Brown and pensions?
Discussion
Up until 1998, monies credited into pension funds in the form of dividends were allowed to be invested "tax free". At that time, companies paid dividends to shareholders with 20% already deducted at source and this tax was paid directly to the Revenue by the company issuing the dividend. Pension funds receiving these dividends could ask the Revenue to refund the tax collected from the dividends back into the pension fund. It was a deliberate tax policy by previous governments to ensure that pensions gave good returns and grew much more rapidly compared to more mundane, taxed, investments. This was to encourage people to invest in pensions.
Gordon changed the whole way dividends are taxed in 1998. First of all, the 20% tax deducted at source was actually abolished and replaced with a "Notional" or pretend deduction of 10%. The weird element to this is that this "Notional" 10% tax is never actually deducted from the dividend at all - and therefore is never paid to the Revenue. Obviously, if it has never been paid to the Revenue, they are not in a position to "refund" it to the pension fund.
I think Gordon expected that companies would now be in a position to pay bigger dividends into the funds now that he wasn't actually asking them to really deduct any tax on them. However, it didn't quite work out that way.
At one fell swoop he undermined the whole pension industry - and, since a lot of pension funds were invested in the stock market, his actions had a massively detrimental effect on stocks and shares. The poor performance of the stock market from early 2000 was not entirely due the bursting of the "dot-com" bubble. Gordon had a serious hand in it too -although you will never see or hear him admitting it.
Gordon changed the whole way dividends are taxed in 1998. First of all, the 20% tax deducted at source was actually abolished and replaced with a "Notional" or pretend deduction of 10%. The weird element to this is that this "Notional" 10% tax is never actually deducted from the dividend at all - and therefore is never paid to the Revenue. Obviously, if it has never been paid to the Revenue, they are not in a position to "refund" it to the pension fund.
I think Gordon expected that companies would now be in a position to pay bigger dividends into the funds now that he wasn't actually asking them to really deduct any tax on them. However, it didn't quite work out that way.
At one fell swoop he undermined the whole pension industry - and, since a lot of pension funds were invested in the stock market, his actions had a massively detrimental effect on stocks and shares. The poor performance of the stock market from early 2000 was not entirely due the bursting of the "dot-com" bubble. Gordon had a serious hand in it too -although you will never see or hear him admitting it.
JoolzB said:
BROWN AND PENSIONS?
It's the colour your pants go when you read how much pension you're gonna be getting. I wonder if Gordy will get a pension, now that's a tricky question?
Umm, well he's an MP, so he gets a final salary pension, which accrues at the rate of 1/40th of his final salary per year served up to a maximum of 2/3 of his final salary.
And yes that has to be a candidate for the most generous pension scheme in existence.
To be fair they do contribute a massive 10% of their pay to it ...

Eric Mc said:
This is how Snatcher Brown killed private pensions
Quite right...
In the 80's, my employer had a medium sized pension scheme. Part of my job was to prepare the scheme's accounts.
Every year I reclaimed about £1 million of tax credits on investment income, which was then re-invested in the scheme.
This stopped dead when Gordon stuck his nose in. Having left that company many years ago, I'm still in the scheme and it's almost died a death.
I remember Gordon's budget speech, during which he claimed to have closed an anomaly, saying individuals can't reclaim tax credits on dividends received, so why should pension schemes have preferential treatment...?
Do you get it now, Mr Brown, or is your bloody glass eye still bothering you...?
AS I said earlier, the refund of tax credits was a deliberate ploy by earlier chancellors, both Labour and Conservative, to MAKE pension schemes more attractive to investors. Those chancellors had a bit of foresight and knew the demographic timebomb waiting ahead of us regarding an ageing population. Gordon could not care a jot for this line of thought. All he wanted was his hands on the money.
Belatedly, he has realised that he almost destroyed the pension industry overnight and is now introducing his "baby", the SIPP. However, being a Gordon inspired project (like Stakeholder Schemes" ), it will be a complicated fiasco and will not achieve its intended aims. The last thing Gordon ever wants to do is admit that he may have got something wrong and then reverse his original bad decision.
>> Edited by Eric Mc on Wednesday 22 March 08:05
Belatedly, he has realised that he almost destroyed the pension industry overnight and is now introducing his "baby", the SIPP. However, being a Gordon inspired project (like Stakeholder Schemes" ), it will be a complicated fiasco and will not achieve its intended aims. The last thing Gordon ever wants to do is admit that he may have got something wrong and then reverse his original bad decision.
>> Edited by Eric Mc on Wednesday 22 March 08:05
So If I understand correctly, Gordon was totally responsible for the collapse in pension funds, but then expects us to have to bail ourselves out of the mess he created by saving more for our futures, which we can't do because taxes are rising and new taxes are being introduced, meaning less funds available to save.
I hope that the %50 percent of the populace able to vote who didn't now realise what they've done and will make an effort to get to poll booths next time, even if its to vote for an independant.
The most worrying thing is this incompetant moron will soon be running the country (may god have mercy on us all).
I hope that the %50 percent of the populace able to vote who didn't now realise what they've done and will make an effort to get to poll booths next time, even if its to vote for an independant.
The most worrying thing is this incompetant moron will soon be running the country (may god have mercy on us all).
www.telegraph.co.uk/htmlContent.jhtml?html=/archive/1997/07/03/nbb203.html
article from 1997 - have a look at the predictions.
article from 1997 - have a look at the predictions.
Ballistic Banana said:
In laymans terms.. You wont be getting one timr to flea this god forsaken country...sadley
I won't be getting one as I fled the country in '89 and haven't paid a cent into anything since then. I'm now living back here, paying seamans tax, which means I don't pay any, or national insurance. Which means I can't actually pay into a pension.
'They' tell me I have to just save up myself, but if ever I need to claim from the government they will tell me to live off my savings. Unless I piss it all up the wall then tell them I am skint, and then they will look after me like a king.
The less you are prepared to do for yourself in this country, the more the social will do for you
Try to succeed and you are treated like a criminal

Eric Mc said:
AS I said earlier, the refund of tax credits was a deliberate ploy by earlier chancellors, both Labour and Conservative, to MAKE pension schemes more attractive to investors. Those chancellors had a bit of foresight and knew the demographic timebomb waiting ahead of us regarding an ageing population. Gordon could not care a jot for this line of thought. All he wanted was his hands on the money.
Well said Eric
Gordon spends much time blathering on about being 'prudent' and 'investing for the future' and yet he is partially responsible for destroying private sector pension funds.
Not to mention as pointed out above, not only does HIS and every other MP's pension accrue in 1/40th of pensionable salary meaning they get full pension after 27 years, things are also guaranteed AND inflation proofed.
This is a very bitter pill to swallow when one considers the utter horlicks made of things by Brown.
Some of us as pension trustees a few years ago were in the position of managing a fund with considerable surplus. So much so that one arm of HMG (the Revenue) came along and said unless you do something about this we will consider you as overfunded and tax you to take the surplus off you as HMG can put that money to much better use.
So we improved benefits, company took benefit of reduced payments so funding was now at a level acceptable to Johnny Revenue.
Another arm of HMG in shape of Gordon Dick Turpin Brown with his trusty assistant Johnny Revenue comes along and demands "Stand and Deliver" as well described above by Eric MC.
Pensions industry goes tits up.
HMG goes into Pontius Pilate mode coupled with a bit of Nero fiddling away.
Gordon Brown should get the bullet.
And you can put what you want into that you nosey little lot in Cheltenham.....
>> Edited by Flat in Fifth on Wednesday 22 March 14:08
This is a very bitter pill to swallow when one considers the utter horlicks made of things by Brown.
Some of us as pension trustees a few years ago were in the position of managing a fund with considerable surplus. So much so that one arm of HMG (the Revenue) came along and said unless you do something about this we will consider you as overfunded and tax you to take the surplus off you as HMG can put that money to much better use.
So we improved benefits, company took benefit of reduced payments so funding was now at a level acceptable to Johnny Revenue.
Another arm of HMG in shape of Gordon Dick Turpin Brown with his trusty assistant Johnny Revenue comes along and demands "Stand and Deliver" as well described above by Eric MC.
Pensions industry goes tits up.
HMG goes into Pontius Pilate mode coupled with a bit of Nero fiddling away.
Gordon Brown should get the bullet.
And you can put what you want into that you nosey little lot in Cheltenham.....
>> Edited by Flat in Fifth on Wednesday 22 March 14:08
Gassing Station | The Pie & Piston Archive | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



timr to flea this god forsaken country...sadley



hope not.