Internet Forum Libel Case.
Internet Forum Libel Case.
Author
Discussion

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

85 months

Thursday 23rd March 2006
quotequote all
Sorry if it's been done before,

www.guardian.co.uk/law/story/0,,1737445,00.html

news article said:
Legal experts said the case should be taken as a warning to the millions of people in the UK debating contentious issues on message boards, in chatrooms and on their own blogs that the laws of libel applied just as they would if the comments were published in a leaflet or newsletter.

Hirich

3,337 posts

293 months

Thursday 23rd March 2006
quotequote all
I don't see a problem. Saying it on the interent is the same as libel & slander. From what seems to have been said about the plaintiff he had every right to sue. the core rules are pretty easy to establish:
- Contributors sign up by agreeing to certain standards of behaviour. The contributor must bear primary responsibility for the remarks they author
- Forums should be moderated reasonably so any issues can be corrected or expunged. The host bears some respnsibility as the publisher (the libel laws for books and magazines have the publisher liable as well as the author)
- A reasonable complaints procedure. The internet has the facility to easily withdraw remarks, unlike a published book.
- The fair comment defence is well proven.

If you're going to call someone a child molestor, you better be able to back it up.

The libel laws have always had a hole for the vengeful & bullying litigant and the same applies on the net. Until someone finds a way to resolve that in law, you have to trust in getting a reasonable judge. So basically nothing has changed except furhter verification that the lible laws do extend to the internet. How can that be a problem?

The only question I have in this case is whether this was a (permanently recorded) forum, or a (transient) chatroom?

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

85 months

Thursday 23rd March 2006
quotequote all
Hirich said:
I don't see a problem. Saying it on the interent is the same as libel & slander.


True, I'd never really thought about it before.

voyds9

8,490 posts

314 months

Thursday 23rd March 2006
quotequote all
I'm sure with a bit of effort she could have proved that most MPs have trouble with some mental processes.

polus

4,343 posts

256 months

Thursday 23rd March 2006
quotequote all
That kind of 'conversation' goes on all the time on IRC networks.

People take things too far...

Parrot of doom

23,075 posts

265 months

Thursday 23rd March 2006
quotequote all
Bet the person in court was called "Spindrift".......

robdickinson

31,343 posts

285 months

Thursday 23rd March 2006
quotequote all
Thats why theres a rule on this forum of no naming companies that give bad service, you write it, but Ted publishes it and it leaves him open to legalities.

sadako

7,080 posts

269 months

Thursday 23rd March 2006
quotequote all
Ah, the infamous Godwin's law coming in to play. This is why it is preferable to not include enough information in your profile to allow people to work out who you are. This is also why there are advantages to message boards with no profiles and anonymous posting

littlegreenfairy

10,134 posts

252 months

Thursday 23rd March 2006
quotequote all
I got shafted by expressing my displeasure on a forum - queue a quick post grovelling - seemed to do the trick (even tho I wasn't in the wrong to start with)

vixpy1

42,699 posts

295 months

Thursday 23rd March 2006
quotequote all
littlegreenfairy said:
I got shafted by expressing my displeasure on a forum


tinman0

18,231 posts

271 months

Friday 24th March 2006
quotequote all
sadako said:
Ah, the infamous Godwin's law coming in to play. This is why it is preferable to not include enough information in your profile to allow people to work out who you are. This is also why there are advantages to message boards with no profiles and anonymous posting


your ip address from your postings can be tracked to your login address at an isp within seconds. there is no such thing as anonymous postings. dream on.

tinman0

18,231 posts

271 months

Friday 24th March 2006
quotequote all
robdickinson said:
Thats why theres a rule on this forum of no naming companies that give bad service, you write it, but Ted publishes it and it leaves him open to legalities.


nope.

if someone was slagging off a supplier, then they could approach ted to remove the article from the forum. if he refuses then he becomes complicit but not liable.

the reason for the no name and shame policy is to give ted a quiet life.



6 pinyds. i neeed to passs out.

nonegreen

7,803 posts

301 months

Friday 24th March 2006
quotequote all
Great lets start a fund and sue the clowns who called us speedophiles.

scorp

8,783 posts

260 months

Friday 24th March 2006
quotequote all
nonegreen said:
Great lets start a fund and sue the clowns who called us speedophiles.

Considering the number of posts in SP&L advocating and/or admittingn to the breaking of posted limits, i don't think labelling 'us' speedophiles is a libel.

>> Edited by scorp on Friday 24th March 01:19

nonegreen

7,803 posts

301 months

Friday 24th March 2006
quotequote all
scorp said:
nonegreen said:
Great lets start a fund and sue the clowns who called us speedophiles.

Considering the number of posts in SP&L advocating and/or admittingn to the breaking of posted limits, i don't think labelling 'us' speedophiles is a libel.

>> Edited by scorp on Friday 24th March 01:19


Speeders yes, I freel admit to smashing the speed limit daily, however implicit in the term speedophile is the implication that we like shagging children. Now thats libel, the filthy green scum should be made to pay.

scorp

8,783 posts

260 months

Friday 24th March 2006
quotequote all
nonegreen said:
Speeders yes, I freel admit to smashing the speed limit daily, however implicit in the term speedophile is the implication that we like shagging children. Now thats libel, the filthy green scum should be made to pay.

wow, you really hate those greenies don't you... i agree with what you say btw..

CommanderJameson

22,096 posts

257 months

Friday 24th March 2006
quotequote all
tinman0 said:
sadako said:
Ah, the infamous Godwin's law coming in to play. This is why it is preferable to not include enough information in your profile to allow people to work out who you are. This is also why there are advantages to message boards with no profiles and anonymous posting


your ip address from your postings can be tracked to your login address at an isp within seconds. there is no such thing as anonymous postings. dream on.

Actually, there are such things as anonymous proxies which relay your web traffic, discarding your IP address. It only knows what your IP address is while you're connected to it. Disconnect, and it's as if you were never there.

iaint

10,040 posts

269 months

Friday 24th March 2006
quotequote all
tinman0 said:
sadako said:
Ah, the infamous Godwin's law coming in to play. This is why it is preferable to not include enough information in your profile to allow people to work out who you are. This is also why there are advantages to message boards with no profiles and anonymous posting


your ip address from your postings can be tracked to your login address at an isp within seconds. there is no such thing as anonymous postings. dream on.


Only if the forum/bb software stores that info in a database...

Mr E

23,110 posts

290 months

Friday 24th March 2006
quotequote all
The only issue is, a magazine or newspaper can edit the comments before posting. In this case, the comments are viewed instantly, and only (possibly) edited when a moderator sees them.

tinman0 said:

your ip address from your postings can be tracked to your login address at an isp within seconds. there is no such thing as anonymous postings. dream on.


Want a bet?

Don

28,378 posts

315 months

Friday 24th March 2006
quotequote all
iaint said:
tinman0 said:
sadako said:
Ah, the infamous Godwin's law coming in to play. This is why it is preferable to not include enough information in your profile to allow people to work out who you are. This is also why there are advantages to message boards with no profiles and anonymous posting


your ip address from your postings can be tracked to your login address at an isp within seconds. there is no such thing as anonymous postings. dream on.


Only if the forum/bb software stores that info in a database...


Nearly all *do* even they don't show it to you. If you want to really be anonymous you need to use an anonymous proxy as has been said before. Sure its not easy tracking down an IP that *might* well be changeable due to DHCP - and I know someone who got the knock likely due to that.

Personally I think this is a good thing. People should be responsible for what they say. We can still all debate contentious issues. What we cannot do is commit libel and defamation of character. Calling someone a paedophile, for example, when you have no proof certainly deserves to be brought to account...