Question Time - Should it run for a longer duration?
Discussion
I wish they would lengthen the show to 2 hours.
To my mind, the present duration never seems to be adequate enough to cover the topics asked by the audience. Is it perhaps the case that the format is presented in such a way that the panel is obliged to give relatively short, sometimes snappy answers to quite often, very serious issues. I'm thinking in particular about panellists that could get seriously grilled/compromised/exposed by a question from the audience that puts them very much on the 'topical spot' relative to 'the day's' main news story/government cock-up/cover-up/exposure. I don't think 1 hour shared between 5 speakers is adequate, they get approx 10 minutes each; if you exclude Dimbles stewardship, etc. Does anyone think the Beeb deliberately set a relatively short duration for this programme for that reason?; or do the beeb still think the viewers are becoming dummer, and cannot take in two hours of worthy debate? When you think about it; apart from writing futile letters to MP's and an every fourth year tick on a ballot box, we don't really get much opportunity to let our rulers know what is on our mind, do we?; it is hardly representative democracy is it?
To my mind, the present duration never seems to be adequate enough to cover the topics asked by the audience. Is it perhaps the case that the format is presented in such a way that the panel is obliged to give relatively short, sometimes snappy answers to quite often, very serious issues. I'm thinking in particular about panellists that could get seriously grilled/compromised/exposed by a question from the audience that puts them very much on the 'topical spot' relative to 'the day's' main news story/government cock-up/cover-up/exposure. I don't think 1 hour shared between 5 speakers is adequate, they get approx 10 minutes each; if you exclude Dimbles stewardship, etc. Does anyone think the Beeb deliberately set a relatively short duration for this programme for that reason?; or do the beeb still think the viewers are becoming dummer, and cannot take in two hours of worthy debate? When you think about it; apart from writing futile letters to MP's and an every fourth year tick on a ballot box, we don't really get much opportunity to let our rulers know what is on our mind, do we?; it is hardly representative democracy is it?
Parrot of Doom said:
90 minutes would probably be the longest time that I would watch it. I think the standard of debate is very good, mostly because the audience have a chance to cross-examine anything that the panellists say. They can't get away with the usual claptrap on this programme IMO.
yes, 90 minutes would probably be about right. If over time it worked, then perhaps it may stretch to 2hrs. I wonder if the prog in Moscow next week will be longer, i suspect it will, thought Dimbles will close on the hour for us here in the UK, and carry on after.
I think it would be a different programme if it was two hours, as mentioned the style of answers would be different. To be fair those programs allready exist on other channels (allthough maybe not with such esteemed guests?)
Boris & Tony last night
Don't usually watch it but had to for those pair! That woman from Liberty had some interesting things to say too, she looks like a serious treehugger but didnt come accross that way at all in her answers. Boris didnt get to speak enough IMO Tony Benn was allways cutting him off!
Boris & Tony last night
Don't usually watch it but had to for those pair! That woman from Liberty had some interesting things to say too, she looks like a serious treehugger but didnt come accross that way at all in her answers. Boris didnt get to speak enough IMO Tony Benn was allways cutting him off!I think they should allow full "personal" contact between the audience and the slags up in the hot seats with Dimbleby shouting "foul" for dramatic or comic effect.
I bet we'd get a better show and the liars would be exposed as they came clean while begging for mercy.........." and on this weeks show we have Ken Livingstone"......
Hey, you know its a good idea too!
I bet we'd get a better show and the liars would be exposed as they came clean while begging for mercy.........." and on this weeks show we have Ken Livingstone"......
Hey, you know its a good idea too!

Gassing Station | The Pie & Piston Archive | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


