smoking advert
Author
Discussion

apache

Original Poster:

39,731 posts

315 months

Saturday 25th March 2006
quotequote all
Was shocked to learn that the woman in the ad Trudi, was a teacher at my kids school and one of her daughters was in the same year as my daughters boyfriend. I thought they were actors

motco

17,674 posts

277 months

Saturday 25th March 2006
quotequote all
I believe that's the whole point, they are not actors but real cases. It's a bit mawkish but effective if you're hovering between giving up or not, I'm sure. There's always some who won't be convinced, of course, and that's their priviledge.

polus

4,343 posts

256 months

Saturday 25th March 2006
quotequote all
apache said:
Was shocked to learn that the woman in the ad Trudi, was a teacher at my kids school and one of her daughters was in the same year as my daughters boyfriend. I thought they were actors


Me too!

>> Edited by polus on Saturday 25th March 09:26

soir

2,277 posts

270 months

Saturday 25th March 2006
quotequote all
thing is it actually has the opposite effect - i.e. you tend to smoke more

goverment ads have the same effect as the tobacco firms ads (but tobacco ones are more suggestive, i.e. smoking may lead to amputation hidden in the picture - hence once again you smoke more/quicker

same as no-smoking day, we tend to smoke more.

gvmt have the totally wrong way of approaching it (like dont give up giving up - for gods sake, first very defeatist/pesimistic suggesting you cant, plus suggesting the idea makes you feel your sacrifycing something).

every wondered how much the gvmt earn in cig/tobacco tax? and how much they save in pensions with so many people dying earlier through smoking?

(apologies, recently stopped being a non-smoker and have turned into one of those 'preachers' i used to detest!)

bilko2

1,693 posts

263 months

Saturday 25th March 2006
quotequote all
soir said:
thing is it actually has the opposite effect - i.e. you tend to smoke more

goverment ads have the same effect as the tobacco firms ads (but tobacco ones are more suggestive, i.e. smoking may lead to amputation hidden in the picture - hence once again you smoke more/quicker

same as no-smoking day, we tend to smoke more.

gvmt have the totally wrong way of approaching it (like dont give up giving up - for gods sake, first very defeatist/pesimistic suggesting you cant, plus suggesting the idea makes you feel your sacrifycing something).

every wondered how much the gvmt earn in cig/tobacco tax? and how much they save in pensions with so many people dying earlier through smoking?

(apologies, recently stopped being a non-smoker and have turned into one of those 'preachers' i used to detest!)

exactly!
Usual mixed message /missdirection, wer'e doing the right thing from these people. I desperately want to give up but am finding it so hard to get started. I know...no will power etc. Why do i find it so hard?, i have no idea. It's almost as if i need to be told that I have cancer before i do. Either that or find another fine non smoking woman to give me strength. Well, back on the patches asap i think.
Btw, i think the ads are good for people that don't smoke ( ironicly ) like my 10 year old son.
Is it the same with all government sponsered ads? Take the motorbike one " you see me now " or the run down kid "if you hit me at 20mph i will have an 80% chance of living". Not sure, maybe that's for another thread.

Tuska

961 posts

261 months

Saturday 25th March 2006
quotequote all
I gave up last October (after 25 yrs puffing). Not because any advert said i should nor because of my nagging wife/mother/daughter. I did because i wanted to. Finally.

Smokers never believe illness will happen to them, which is why ads like that, whilst very sad, do nothing to promote quiting.

Anyhow, on the up side, i'm also off booze for lent and am finding myself around 100 quid a WEEK better off. Time for some new golf clubs i think, or maybe a trip to spearmint rhinos.........

Jaglover

46,849 posts

266 months

Saturday 25th March 2006
quotequote all
Tuska said:
or maybe a trip to spearmint rhinos.........


That's more like it

Kinky

39,947 posts

300 months

Saturday 25th March 2006
quotequote all
bilko2 said:
I desperately want to give up but am finding it so hard to get started. I know...no will power etc.


I've given up ..... last night.

So far so good - 9 hours 29 minutes (according to Silkquit).

I've given up a few times - but usually only last a few days - but this time I am truly determined.

It just felt like it was the right time.

K

nwtony

3,011 posts

259 months

Sunday 26th March 2006
quotequote all
Those adverts are better than the old ones which just said that smokers were dirty, nasty, smelly people who should be scorned and despised. Even though these ones use the dirty trick of showing weeping children to make smokers feel guilty at least they dont try and make smokers out to be some sort of social subclass.