mountain bike advice for a newbie
Discussion
I know there are some serious cycling types in the PH massive so a request for a bit of advice if I may?
Looking to make a bit more of the great outdoors in God's own North Yorkshire so looking for a hardtail bike for about £500 - hopefully enough to get me out of poverty spec.
Going to use it for general cross country and whatever trails I can find - nothing too extreme.
Had a wander round some local shops and for the money have had the Claud Butler Cape Wrath Disc, Dawes Reddle and the Specilized Rockhopper and Trek 6500 recommended. Picking the bones out of the specs is a bit bewildering but my gut feeling so far is the Rockhopper as it seems to have the best frame, which seems to be the best place to start.
Which bike to go for or is there anything else out ther I should be considering??
Looking to make a bit more of the great outdoors in God's own North Yorkshire so looking for a hardtail bike for about £500 - hopefully enough to get me out of poverty spec.
Going to use it for general cross country and whatever trails I can find - nothing too extreme.
Had a wander round some local shops and for the money have had the Claud Butler Cape Wrath Disc, Dawes Reddle and the Specilized Rockhopper and Trek 6500 recommended. Picking the bones out of the specs is a bit bewildering but my gut feeling so far is the Rockhopper as it seems to have the best frame, which seems to be the best place to start.
Which bike to go for or is there anything else out ther I should be considering??
Frame is the king.
Having said that, it can be pretty expensive to upgrade too many bits. I have spent a fortune over the years on my Yeti, to the point where I basically had enough bits for two bikes.
Might be a case of spending more now is worthwhile, so maybe add to the decent frame a decent groupset (XTish spec) some decent forks and wheels.
That will probably push the budget over £500, but will be cheaper overall than upgrading.
Hope that helps.

Having said that, it can be pretty expensive to upgrade too many bits. I have spent a fortune over the years on my Yeti, to the point where I basically had enough bits for two bikes.
Might be a case of spending more now is worthwhile, so maybe add to the decent frame a decent groupset (XTish spec) some decent forks and wheels.
That will probably push the budget over £500, but will be cheaper overall than upgrading.
Hope that helps.

I was faced with the same situation 3 years back - bought the RockHopper Disc Comp in the end - paid around £500. I go out twice a week in all weathers with a group who have Epics, Stumpjumpers, a Trek, a cool Kona and a wierd Jon Whyte...mine is at least half the price of the cheapest, is the only hardtail, but is does the job. It is just getting to the stage where bits nead replacing, but it is does get a hard time...
As Mr MadBadger says, the frame is what really makes the bike - have a look at ebay - some really good bits of kit available - only drawback being you have to make the bike up yourself..
So you can't go wrong with the RockHopper, and remember, the bike is only as good as its rider...!
As Mr MadBadger says, the frame is what really makes the bike - have a look at ebay - some really good bits of kit available - only drawback being you have to make the bike up yourself..
So you can't go wrong with the RockHopper, and remember, the bike is only as good as its rider...!
deckster said:
Might be getting a bit late in the year but you can get some good deals on '05 models as shops get rid of old stock. I picked up last year's Orange P7 for £550 a month ago - £200 quid off list which I thought wasn't bad.
No, there's still a few old stock bikes around so a deal is out there if you look for it.
Try www.paulscycles.co.uk for a start, something like the Giant XtC SX would be one to look at.
As said, the frame is the important bit, you can upgrade the drivetrain and wheels as you wear out the stuff on there and end up with quite a reasonable bike. Specialised are good, I've been quite impressed by what you get for your money with the Claud Butlers but also look at Merlin, they are nice bikes and you can custom spec them up to a degree.
Jay GTI said:
Try www.paulscycles.co.uk for a start, something like the Giant XtC SX would be one to look at.
How do you know what frame size to go for when buying online? I'm after a new bike soon and will probably get a similar bike to 2wheelsonmywagon.
FunkyNige said:
Jay GTI said:
Try www.paulscycles.co.uk for a start, something like the Giant XtC SX would be one to look at.
How do you know what frame size to go for when buying online? I'm after a new bike soon and will probably get a similar bike to 2wheelsonmywagon.
This is the flaw in buying online...no store back up as a local bike store will spend time with you setting the bike up (seat height/position, stem angle and length etc..) Like I said a bike store (a good one, not halfords where you have a lottery whether or not the guy knows anything) will exchange stems and seats during purchase and stems after a few weeks to ensure you are happy. For a first time buyer I would stay off the net and go visit a good store.
WRT frame size length, all the manufacturers have different frame geo's and top tube lengths (more important as seatpost can change frame size easily, but reach cant be sorted without compromising handling with silly Stem lengths..
>> Edited by LRdriver II on Sunday 26th March 12:40
I wouldn't buy a bike online unless you're getting it in component form and building it up. That said, its easy enough to do if you know what you're doing and have teh tools (there are some specialised tools you need) but if you're a newbie I'd recommend 100% a good bike shop.
I use Harry Halls in Manchester, have done for years. 100% trustworthy and some sound advice.
As others have said, the frame is everything. Lightweight and stiff - the stiffer the frame, the less it will flex when pedalling, and the more acceleration you'll get. You can see how stiff a frame generally is by standing astride the bike, one foot on the ground, and the other foot on the pedal - push down hard with the brakes on, and you'll see the crank and pedals move towards your standing foot. The more the frame flexes, the less responsive it will be.
While you're doing this, get measured up for the frame - if you get a frame thats incorrect for your legs/torso/arms, its going to hurt later on.
For £500 I'd stick with a hardtail - but be prepared to upgrade the front forks after a few thousand miles as they'll start failing. If you can afford it, and if you're going to be riding through mucky puddles and mud, get disc brakes - rim brakes are fine, but not many suspension forks have the bosses for them, and they also get very noisy when the rims are muddy.
Make sure you get clipless pedals as well. Stirrups are ok for the road, but offroad you want clipless as stirrups don't release your foot as easily. You'll need shoes with recessed cleats for the clipless pedals.
A cycle computer is a good addition, they're very cheap and it will let you see how many miles/av speed/etc you're doing each ride.
Don't forget to buy some proper clothing as well, you want padded shorts, proper shoes, a good quality top (they have extra material to cover and protect your arse from mud/water) and proper gloves.
Oh, and DON'T FORGET TO OIL THE CHAIN EVERY RIDE!!! And keep the pistons on the forks clear of muck each ride, otherwise the mud will get past the boots and into the seals = broken forks.
>> Edited by Parrot of Doom on Sunday 26th March 14:44
I use Harry Halls in Manchester, have done for years. 100% trustworthy and some sound advice.
As others have said, the frame is everything. Lightweight and stiff - the stiffer the frame, the less it will flex when pedalling, and the more acceleration you'll get. You can see how stiff a frame generally is by standing astride the bike, one foot on the ground, and the other foot on the pedal - push down hard with the brakes on, and you'll see the crank and pedals move towards your standing foot. The more the frame flexes, the less responsive it will be.
While you're doing this, get measured up for the frame - if you get a frame thats incorrect for your legs/torso/arms, its going to hurt later on.
For £500 I'd stick with a hardtail - but be prepared to upgrade the front forks after a few thousand miles as they'll start failing. If you can afford it, and if you're going to be riding through mucky puddles and mud, get disc brakes - rim brakes are fine, but not many suspension forks have the bosses for them, and they also get very noisy when the rims are muddy.
Make sure you get clipless pedals as well. Stirrups are ok for the road, but offroad you want clipless as stirrups don't release your foot as easily. You'll need shoes with recessed cleats for the clipless pedals.
A cycle computer is a good addition, they're very cheap and it will let you see how many miles/av speed/etc you're doing each ride.
Don't forget to buy some proper clothing as well, you want padded shorts, proper shoes, a good quality top (they have extra material to cover and protect your arse from mud/water) and proper gloves.
Oh, and DON'T FORGET TO OIL THE CHAIN EVERY RIDE!!! And keep the pistons on the forks clear of muck each ride, otherwise the mud will get past the boots and into the seals = broken forks.
>> Edited by Parrot of Doom on Sunday 26th March 14:44
Parrot of Doom said:
Everything that needed to be said really
I started off on a basic Rockhopper and really got the bug from there. It's a great sturdy bike that can take a serious hammering (as beginners tend to give a bike
) without complaining. The rockhopper also comes with disc hubs as standard with makes the changeover to a front disc easily done. I did this after a few months and the difference is incredible, no real need to change the rear other than aestetics (sp?). Have since upgraded to an S-Works Epic buying the frame and all the components to my taste and choice from my local bike shop that sold me the Rockhopper. Keep your business local and they reward you with advice, freebies, discounts to beat the band and even the odd free quick repair. Bike shops know the competition is tough from the net. Get to know them and they'll look after you with the right spec to suit your competency and skill.
i just bought a specialized hardrock pro yesterday. i had my heart set on the orange evo6 but couldnt really justify the extra money as i have a few other things i am saving for. the hardrock pro is well specced and should take a good deal of abuse. it feels quite an aggresive bike and the hydraulic disc brakes are not compromised that much by lower spec components.
just to add, bought it from garlands in bristol, very helpful, i was unsure about teh stem as it seemd to short and i was hunched over the front of the bike too much so they swopped it foc for a longer one. you get bargains on line but not the support when buying it.
>> Edited by anonymous-user on Sunday 26th March 17:44
just to add, bought it from garlands in bristol, very helpful, i was unsure about teh stem as it seemd to short and i was hunched over the front of the bike too much so they swopped it foc for a longer one. you get bargains on line but not the support when buying it.
>> Edited by anonymous-user on Sunday 26th March 17:44
Pish, I've bought 3 bikes mail order (2 from pauls cycles) and not had a single problem. Sure, pay full price if you want, but it's wasted money.
To get an idea of frame size, try a few out at your local bike shop. The staff at Pauls are also very good and can give great advice based on a few details about your size and build. If you have to change stem lengths and angles to make a bike fit you, you've bought the wrong bike, because they are specific to a frame's geometry and changing them could leave you with an unridable pig. Yes you can change them to change the handling, but you'd need to know how the bike rides first and how your changes will affect the ride.
I buy all my MTB stuff mail order, saved a fortune so far...
To get an idea of frame size, try a few out at your local bike shop. The staff at Pauls are also very good and can give great advice based on a few details about your size and build. If you have to change stem lengths and angles to make a bike fit you, you've bought the wrong bike, because they are specific to a frame's geometry and changing them could leave you with an unridable pig. Yes you can change them to change the handling, but you'd need to know how the bike rides first and how your changes will affect the ride.
I buy all my MTB stuff mail order, saved a fortune so far...
Jay GTI said:
Pish, I've bought 3 bikes mail order (2 from pauls cycles) and not had a single problem. Sure, pay full price if you want, but it's wasted money.
To get an idea of frame size, try a few out at your local bike shop. The staff at Pauls are also very good and can give great advice based on a few details about your size and build. If you have to change stem lengths and angles to make a bike fit you, you've bought the wrong bike, because they are specific to a frame's geometry and changing them could leave you with an unridable pig. Yes you can change them to change the handling, but you'd need to know how the bike rides first and how your changes will affect the ride.
I buy all my MTB stuff mail order, saved a fortune so far...
Eh?...no denying you save money by mailorder but this is exactly what narks off local stores, some punter showing up , testriding everything and getting stuff of the net. Realities of todays world I guess..
Completely disagree with the change stem comment. Some people are shorter/longer in the body/legs and if you stay within extremes the bike will handle just fine. If you need a loooong stem, then yes, you have a too small size frame. The toptube length will dictate this and you need to try to see what works. Anything appraoching a 150mm stem on a bike means you screwed up somewhere (on XC anyway) Weight distribution will affect handling too so must be considered when you decide what you want the bike for. (XC, trial, jumpy, enduro etc..)
if your looking north yorkshire.
head over to Boneshakers in Harrgate. They did me very well for a couple of bikes a couple of years ago.
have a look out for demo days where you can try different bikes out on the trail with no obligation.
£500 is a good starting point for a Hardtail - look for the likes of specialised, trek, giant, kona, GT, Marin, Orange... have a look in halfords - carrera do ok bikes for halfords.
personally i've been through flats, clips and clipless.. and back to flat pedals, abet ones with a grip level of that of a bear trap (DMR v8s) which i find more comfortable cycling with than being fastened to the bike - it suits my style more.
try different bikes as they all ride slightly different - and the forks they spec can often vary the ride as well - and its how you find it.
at the £500 point i wouldnt worry tooooo much about disk brakes, so long as at least V brakes are fitted, and the frame/forks are disk compatable - then you can upgrade later.
Also look out for the shifters - some are specced with shimano dual control - where theres a flappy brake lever which you lift up and down to change gear - its a love hate thing - you either get on with it or you dont. theres the rapid fire trigger shifter - of which both shimano and sram do a version of, and sram have gripshift.
again it comes down to go into the shop and have a look, chat to the guys in the shop.
head over to Boneshakers in Harrgate. They did me very well for a couple of bikes a couple of years ago.
have a look out for demo days where you can try different bikes out on the trail with no obligation.
£500 is a good starting point for a Hardtail - look for the likes of specialised, trek, giant, kona, GT, Marin, Orange... have a look in halfords - carrera do ok bikes for halfords.
personally i've been through flats, clips and clipless.. and back to flat pedals, abet ones with a grip level of that of a bear trap (DMR v8s) which i find more comfortable cycling with than being fastened to the bike - it suits my style more.
try different bikes as they all ride slightly different - and the forks they spec can often vary the ride as well - and its how you find it.
at the £500 point i wouldnt worry tooooo much about disk brakes, so long as at least V brakes are fitted, and the frame/forks are disk compatable - then you can upgrade later.
Also look out for the shifters - some are specced with shimano dual control - where theres a flappy brake lever which you lift up and down to change gear - its a love hate thing - you either get on with it or you dont. theres the rapid fire trigger shifter - of which both shimano and sram do a version of, and sram have gripshift.
again it comes down to go into the shop and have a look, chat to the guys in the shop.
LRdriver II said:
I second the clipless pedals, but find a nice piece of grass to practise clipping and unclipping and riding slowly so you dont hurt yourself. The favorite screwup is to unclip one foot and tip over the other side..
Out agin today with a friend who just bought shoes/pedals. Refused to mess about and go straight at it. Que numerous falls onto hard rocky things. As LR said above, ride slow and take sharp turns so that you become unstable. Falling on grass is a million times better than rock, and guaranteed, you will fall
.up-the-dubs said:
LRdriver II said:
I second the clipless pedals, but find a nice piece of grass to practise clipping and unclipping and riding slowly so you dont hurt yourself. The favorite screwup is to unclip one foot and tip over the other side..
Out agin today with a friend who just bought shoes/pedals. Refused to mess about and go straight at it. Que numerous falls onto hard rocky things. As LR said above, ride slow and take sharp turns so that you become unstable. Falling on grass is a million times better than rock, and guaranteed, you will fall
.
Without over-egging the clipless pedals thing. When getting use to them, it is a good idea to practice unclipping both left and right pedals alternately. What can happen is that after some time of unclipping, say only the left, it can become difficult to undo the right one without losing balance. After years of using first toe clips and straps, then "Look" cleated pedals, I have great difficulty stopping by unclipping the right foot - the mental and physical process associated with the left foot are so ingrained.
Decathlon were selling off 05 rockrider 8.1's for £400 - superb spec - excellent fork, hydraulic discs, great frame, spd's very light & fast - great value even at original £500. Gives you £100 to spend on helmet, shoes, clothes etc.
www.decathlon.co.uk
If you are a novice I find some local bike shops can offer very good deals & you will get good advice & support too.
www.decathlon.co.uk
If you are a novice I find some local bike shops can offer very good deals & you will get good advice & support too.
minnsy said:
So you can't go wrong with the RockHopper, and remember, the bike is only as good as its rider...!
Decided something similar last year ... quizzed mates who ride regularly, pestered teh bike shops and read on teh internet intill i had information overload ....
All teh advice narrowed it down to a Kona (something or other - it was red) and teh Specialised Rockhopper.
Both were cracking bikes, bought the rockhopper (because it was Blue - nothing more technical than that) and have not regreted it yet!!
Go for
Disk Brakes
Front Forks with a Lock Out
Anything else is personal preferance.
Gassing Station | The Pie & Piston Archive | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


