They're trying to censor The Great Global Warming Swindle
Discussion
The Guardian, 25 April 2007
http://environment.guardian.co.uk/cli
David Adam, environment correspondent
Dozens of climate scientists are trying to block the DVD release of a controversial Channel 4 programme that claimed global warming is nothing to do with human greenhouse gas emissions.
Sir John Houghton, former head of the Met Office, and Bob May, former president of the Royal Society, are among 37 experts who have called for the DVD to be heavily edited or removed from sale. The film, the Great Global Warming Swindle, was first shown on March 8, and was criticised by scientists as distorted and misleading.
In an open letter to Martin Durkin, head of Wag TV, the independent production company that made the film, the scientists say: "We believe that the misrepresentation of facts and views, both of which occur in your programme, are so serious that repeat broadcasts of the programme, without amendment, are not in the public interest ... In fact, so serious and fundamental are the misrepresentations that the distribution of the DVD of the programme without their removal amounts to nothing more than an exercise in misleading the public."
Myles Allen, a climate scientist at the University of Oxford who signed the letter, said the programme "took a very cavalier attitude to science. There are important issues around climate change that the public should be discussing, but all this programme did was rehash debates that were had and finished in the scientific community 15 years ago."
The programme featured scientists known as climate sceptics, such as Richard Lindzen at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) and Phillip Stott, emeritus professor at the University of London. It argued that mainstream researchers ignore evidence that counters the consensus that most recent warming is down to human activity. It said there were problems with the computer models that predict future climate change and that solar activity, not greenhouse gas emissions, is to blame for recent warming. Wag TV called the programme a "definitive response to Al Gore's An Inconvenient Truth". Scientists complained that the programme makers distorted evidence, and made elementary mistakes such as claiming that volcanoes produce more carbon dioxide than human activities, when in fact they produce less than 2% of that caused by the burning of fossil fuels.
Dr Allen said: "What Martin Durkin and Channel 4 don't understand is the way science works. Science is about the arguments, not the people who make them."
Carl Wunsch, professor of physical oceanography at MIT, and another signatory to the letter, was featured in the film and subsequently said his views had been misrepresented. He called the programme "as close to pure propaganda as anything since world war two" and has complained to Ofcom, the broadcasting regulator, about his treatment.
Ofcom said it had received 246 complaints, and was investigating. The letter was coordinated by Bob Ward, a former press officer with the Royal Society. He said: "This isn't about censorship, it's a question of quality control. We have no objection to the DVD being distributed if all the errors are corrected, but if they correct all the errors then the whole premise of the program will fall to pieces."
Mr Durkin said: "This contemptible attempt at gagging won't work. The reason they want to suppress The Great Global Warming Swindle is because the science has stung them. By comparison look at the mountains of absurd nonsense pedalled in the name of 'manmade climate change'. Too many scientists have staked their reputations and built their careers on global warming. There's a lot riding on this ridiculous theory. The DVD will be on sale shortly at a shop near you."
http://environment.guardian.co.uk/cli
David Adam, environment correspondent
Dozens of climate scientists are trying to block the DVD release of a controversial Channel 4 programme that claimed global warming is nothing to do with human greenhouse gas emissions.
Sir John Houghton, former head of the Met Office, and Bob May, former president of the Royal Society, are among 37 experts who have called for the DVD to be heavily edited or removed from sale. The film, the Great Global Warming Swindle, was first shown on March 8, and was criticised by scientists as distorted and misleading.
In an open letter to Martin Durkin, head of Wag TV, the independent production company that made the film, the scientists say: "We believe that the misrepresentation of facts and views, both of which occur in your programme, are so serious that repeat broadcasts of the programme, without amendment, are not in the public interest ... In fact, so serious and fundamental are the misrepresentations that the distribution of the DVD of the programme without their removal amounts to nothing more than an exercise in misleading the public."
Myles Allen, a climate scientist at the University of Oxford who signed the letter, said the programme "took a very cavalier attitude to science. There are important issues around climate change that the public should be discussing, but all this programme did was rehash debates that were had and finished in the scientific community 15 years ago."
The programme featured scientists known as climate sceptics, such as Richard Lindzen at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) and Phillip Stott, emeritus professor at the University of London. It argued that mainstream researchers ignore evidence that counters the consensus that most recent warming is down to human activity. It said there were problems with the computer models that predict future climate change and that solar activity, not greenhouse gas emissions, is to blame for recent warming. Wag TV called the programme a "definitive response to Al Gore's An Inconvenient Truth". Scientists complained that the programme makers distorted evidence, and made elementary mistakes such as claiming that volcanoes produce more carbon dioxide than human activities, when in fact they produce less than 2% of that caused by the burning of fossil fuels.
Dr Allen said: "What Martin Durkin and Channel 4 don't understand is the way science works. Science is about the arguments, not the people who make them."
Carl Wunsch, professor of physical oceanography at MIT, and another signatory to the letter, was featured in the film and subsequently said his views had been misrepresented. He called the programme "as close to pure propaganda as anything since world war two" and has complained to Ofcom, the broadcasting regulator, about his treatment.
Ofcom said it had received 246 complaints, and was investigating. The letter was coordinated by Bob Ward, a former press officer with the Royal Society. He said: "This isn't about censorship, it's a question of quality control. We have no objection to the DVD being distributed if all the errors are corrected, but if they correct all the errors then the whole premise of the program will fall to pieces."
Mr Durkin said: "This contemptible attempt at gagging won't work. The reason they want to suppress The Great Global Warming Swindle is because the science has stung them. By comparison look at the mountains of absurd nonsense pedalled in the name of 'manmade climate change'. Too many scientists have staked their reputations and built their careers on global warming. There's a lot riding on this ridiculous theory. The DVD will be on sale shortly at a shop near you."
Bing o said:
Will tehy do the same to "An Inconvenient Truth"?
Nope.
That's going to be sent to schools by Miliband.
Send your messages of support for TGGWS here:
post@WagTV.com
Send your messages of protest at this grotesque development here:
dga@atm.ox.ac.uk cc climate@conted.ox.ac.uk (fao Myles Allen)
www.royalsoc.ac.uk/contactus.asp (fao Houghton, May)
turbobloke said:
Carl Wunsch, professor of physical oceanography at MIT, and another signatory to the letter, was featured in the film and subsequently said his views had been misrepresented. He called the programme "as close to pure propaganda as anything since world war two" and has complained to Ofcom, the broadcasting regulator, about his treatment.
Both myself & my wife really enjoyed this program, close minded relatives have not been so receptive however. Does anyone know what Carl Wunsch is upset about? Could have a damaging effect if one of the contributors changes his mind, it all seemed simple in the program, can't see how you could misrepresent what he was saying?
turbobloke said:
The Guardian, 25 April 2007
http://environment.guardian.co.uk/cli
Myles Allen, a climate scientist at the University of Oxford who signed the letter, said the programme "took a very cavalier attitude to science. There are important issues around climate change that the public should be discussing, but all this programme did was rehash debates that were had and finished in the scientific community 15 years ago."
http://environment.guardian.co.uk/cli
Myles Allen, a climate scientist at the University of Oxford who signed the letter, said the programme "took a very cavalier attitude to science. There are important issues around climate change that the public should be discussing, but all this programme did was rehash debates that were had and finished in the scientific community 15 years ago."
So old views should not be challanged, that will help science and understanding progress wont it....
When we breath out arent we contributing to Co2? I can think of some I would like culled.
Timberwolf said:
The actions of the man-made climate change advocates have done more to damage my readiness to accept their theories than any of the science from the natural climate change advocates has done.
I fully agree and feel the same.
Someone spouting questionable science will get a few raised eyebrows, but someone spouting questionable science and attempting to curtail and censor all other theories for 'the public interest' just comes over as a nutter of the first degree with hidden motives and much to lose.
superlightr said:
turbobloke said:
The Guardian, 25 April 2007
http://environment.guardian.co.uk/cli
Myles Allen, a climate scientist at the University of Oxford who signed the letter, said the programme "took a very cavalier attitude to science. There are important issues around climate change that the public should be discussing, but all this programme did was rehash debates that were had and finished in the scientific community 15 years ago."
http://environment.guardian.co.uk/cli
Myles Allen, a climate scientist at the University of Oxford who signed the letter, said the programme "took a very cavalier attitude to science. There are important issues around climate change that the public should be discussing, but all this programme did was rehash debates that were had and finished in the scientific community 15 years ago."
So old views should not be challanged, that will help science and understanding progress wont it....
When we breath out arent we contributing to Co2? I can think of some I would like culled.
He's not telling it as it is, it's not finished.
What was stated (by Allen) is just another phrasing of "the science is settled" nonsense.
What a bunch of hypocrites these True Believers are....
I, too, shall buy the DVD, even though I recorded one myself...
Technical note...
Peddled, Mr Durkin, peddled....no bikes here, please.
TB, get on the case before they send the spelling police round to arrest him...
I, too, shall buy the DVD, even though I recorded one myself...
Technical note...
Mr Durkin said:
look at the mountains of absurd nonsense pedalled
Peddled, Mr Durkin, peddled....no bikes here, please.
TB, get on the case before they send the spelling police round to arrest him...
Reminder of contact details slightly updated, do absolutely send these people your views:
Send messages of support for TGGWS here:
post@WagTV.com
Send your messages of protest at this grotesque development here:
dga@atm.ox.ac.uk cc climate@conted.ox.ac.uk (fao Myles Allen)
www.royalsoc.ac.uk/contactus.asp (fao Houghton, May)
david.miliband@defra.gsi.gov.uk (over the Al Gore quackumentary)
MBH, Durkin may have given his reply over the phone and a Grauniad hack mis-spelt it.
Probably.
Send messages of support for TGGWS here:
post@WagTV.com
Send your messages of protest at this grotesque development here:
dga@atm.ox.ac.uk cc climate@conted.ox.ac.uk (fao Myles Allen)
www.royalsoc.ac.uk/contactus.asp (fao Houghton, May)
david.miliband@defra.gsi.gov.uk (over the Al Gore quackumentary)
MBH, Durkin may have given his reply over the phone and a Grauniad hack mis-spelt it.
Probably.
Alan Davies (Jonathan Creek) was on Radio 2 the other day and gave TGGWS a favourable mention saying he now doesn't believe the CO2 stuff, only for the host (can't remember his name now, arrgh!) to quickly respond that "that's not the majority view though is it?".
At least it got a mention.
At least it got a mention.
So we transition from Science by Concensus to Science by Suppression.
I guess next is Science by Oppression, though with taxes, they are most of the way there...
More disturbingly, this really detracts from true ecological issues of deforestation, rape mining of non-renewabl;e resources, population growth etc, all of which have far wider consequences than Mrs Fahfahfah in her 4x4...
I guess next is Science by Oppression, though with taxes, they are most of the way there...
More disturbingly, this really detracts from true ecological issues of deforestation, rape mining of non-renewabl;e resources, population growth etc, all of which have far wider consequences than Mrs Fahfahfah in her 4x4...
so what - we're not allowed to have differing opinions presented to us?
methinks the Climate Change lobby have realised that some people just don't completely buy into the accuracy and validity of their data and opinions re CO2 and climate change and are actually questioning what they may have previously believed to be right?
i didn't realise that Labour had introduced thoughtcrime on to the statue books just yet.....
methinks the Climate Change lobby have realised that some people just don't completely buy into the accuracy and validity of their data and opinions re CO2 and climate change and are actually questioning what they may have previously believed to be right?
i didn't realise that Labour had introduced thoughtcrime on to the statue books just yet.....
Gassing Station | The Pie & Piston Archive | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




