A/V system - rear speakers
A/V system - rear speakers
Author
Discussion

David A

Original Poster:

3,727 posts

282 months

Sunday 13th July 2008
quotequote all
Have got a home a/v system with a yamaha dspax759se amp feeding 602.5 S3 fronts (floorstanders) and the LCR60 S3 center, theres also a 12" sub and for good measure an 8" rel too. At the mo I have mission floorstanders for the rear speakers but the impending redecoration of the living room I want to get rid of these and replace with either little speakers - the sort on thin poles/legs or perhaps even mount some speakers in the corners of room just below the ceiling. So 2 questions:

1. Are the little speakers any good - if so which ones?
2. If I did mount speakers high up (small bookshelf type) would it sound crap due to them being high up?

I'll be getting the room re-plastered so will be able to chase cables etc up the wall.

Thanks

Dave

Edited by David A on Sunday 13th July 22:05

threesixty

2,068 posts

234 months

Sunday 13th July 2008
quotequote all
Getting the ceiling done too?

I can highly reccomend our b&w ceiling units. No clutter and the quality and soundstage is great.

David A

Original Poster:

3,727 posts

282 months

Sunday 13th July 2008
quotequote all
threesixty said:
Getting the ceiling done too?

I can highly reccomend our b&w ceiling units. No clutter and the quality and soundstage is great.
Yup skimmed - which units are they? Do they work ok as rears - thinking would it sound wierd with the sound being "above".

Cheers

threesixty

2,068 posts

234 months

Sunday 13th July 2008
quotequote all
Can't remember the exact models.

We have them as part of a 7.1 system doing side and rear. Fronts are 704s andthey are a decent match.

Their positioning is only noticeable when listening to music in 7.1 either from a stereo source or SACD/DVDA. But thats not something we really do.

Edited by threesixty on Sunday 13th July 22:30

David A

Original Poster:

3,727 posts

282 months

Monday 14th July 2008
quotequote all
Ok, thanks - do you know if they are secured into the beams etc or can they just attach to the plasterboard?

Cheers

Dave

Plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Monday 14th July 2008
quotequote all
Ceiling speakers are alright for rears but not ideal.

Also its a commonly held misconception that rear speakers should be behind the listener, strictly speaking they shouldnt, they should be either side of the cash seat in a 5.1 array.

In an EX (7.2) array the dipoles should be either side of the cash seat and the rears effects are then actually rears.

Goochie

5,804 posts

250 months

Monday 14th July 2008
quotequote all
You may want to consider face plates with speaker connections behind each of the rear speakers. These are available in a range of plastic and metal finishes that can match your switches and sockets - and they're available at a very good price via a friendly PH memberwink

They can be seen in profile at the far end of this shot:


The connection module looks like this:


and allows bare wire connections to be clamped securely onto gold-plated terminals on the front and rear.



David A

Original Poster:

3,727 posts

282 months

Monday 14th July 2008
quotequote all
Goochie said:
You may want to consider face plates with speaker connections behind each of the rear speakers. These are available in a range of plastic and metal finishes that can match your switches and sockets - and they're available at a very good price via a friendly PH memberwink

They can be seen in profile at the far end of this shot:


The connection module looks like this:


and allows bare wire connections to be clamped securely onto gold-plated terminals on the front and rear.
Hmm yess will need those for the other parts of the lounge redecoration smile wait for the call.

David A

Original Poster:

3,727 posts

282 months

Monday 14th July 2008
quotequote all
Plotloss said:
Ceiling speakers are alright for rears but not ideal.

Also its a commonly held misconception that rear speakers should be behind the listener, strictly speaking they shouldnt, they should be either side of the cash seat in a 5.1 array.

In an EX (7.2) array the dipoles should be either side of the cash seat and the rears effects are then actually rears.
Was hoping you'd appear! The system isn't meant to be super special just OK for my ears really. They would on the ceiling either side of the sofa - so I guess align with the seats/where ears would be?

I was thinking overnight if I did do this I could also put a center rear in too? Worth it do you think?

Also any thoughts on securing them - I guess they aren't meant to do any low frequencies to securing them to plaster board should be ok?

Also while I'm waiting for good ole Der to check with his minions - do you know if you you can wall mount a Hitachi 55pd9700 ?

Cheers

Dave

Plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Monday 14th July 2008
quotequote all
Goochie, do you make those then?

Or do you work in the AV game?

Plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Monday 14th July 2008
quotequote all
David A said:
Plotloss said:
Ceiling speakers are alright for rears but not ideal.

Also its a commonly held misconception that rear speakers should be behind the listener, strictly speaking they shouldnt, they should be either side of the cash seat in a 5.1 array.

In an EX (7.2) array the dipoles should be either side of the cash seat and the rears effects are then actually rears.
Was hoping you'd appear! The system isn't meant to be super special just OK for my ears really. They would on the ceiling either side of the sofa - so I guess align with the seats/where ears would be?

I was thinking overnight if I did do this I could also put a center rear in too? Worth it do you think?

Also any thoughts on securing them - I guess they aren't meant to do any low frequencies to securing them to plaster board should be ok?

Also while I'm waiting for good ole Der to check with his minions - do you know if you you can wall mount a Hitachi 55pd9700 ?

Cheers

Dave
55PD9700, if its on the James Bond stand, just drop that off (4 Bolts) and then there are wall mount screw holes on the rear.

If you want to use ceiling speakers for the front effects then you need ceiling speakers that will put the soundstage in the correct place via the use of angled drivers. They're quite good but as a result they arent cheap, at all, for the same money you'll get a far superior set of wall mount speakers.

Goochie

5,804 posts

250 months

Monday 14th July 2008
quotequote all
Plotloss said:
Goochie, do you make those then?

Or do you work in the AV game?
We have them as part of our electrical accessory range.

Switches, sockets, media distribution outlets, pretty much anything that you'd need in a house. We dont normally sell directly to the public and hence, I cant give you a simple link to the company website (the products arent' shown on there).

Here is a link to one of our customers - That should give you a good idea of the range (only the "Click" stuff is ours)


Edited by Goochie on Monday 14th July 12:39


Edited by Goochie on Monday 14th July 12:41

David A

Original Poster:

3,727 posts

282 months

Monday 14th July 2008
quotequote all
Plotloss said:
David A said:
Plotloss said:
Ceiling speakers are alright for rears but not ideal.

Also its a commonly held misconception that rear speakers should be behind the listener, strictly speaking they shouldnt, they should be either side of the cash seat in a 5.1 array.

In an EX (7.2) array the dipoles should be either side of the cash seat and the rears effects are then actually rears.
Was hoping you'd appear! The system isn't meant to be super special just OK for my ears really. They would on the ceiling either side of the sofa - so I guess align with the seats/where ears would be?

I was thinking overnight if I did do this I could also put a center rear in too? Worth it do you think?

Also any thoughts on securing them - I guess they aren't meant to do any low frequencies to securing them to plaster board should be ok?

Also while I'm waiting for good ole Der to check with his minions - do you know if you you can wall mount a Hitachi 55pd9700 ?

Cheers

Dave
55PD9700, if its on the James Bond stand, just drop that off (4 Bolts) and then there are wall mount screw holes on the rear.

If you want to use ceiling speakers for the front effects then you need ceiling speakers that will put the soundstage in the correct place via the use of angled drivers. They're quite good but as a result they arent cheap, at all, for the same money you'll get a far superior set of wall mount speakers.
Have b&w 602.5s and a b&w center at the front plus sub - its just the rears I'm on about.

Plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Monday 14th July 2008
quotequote all
Goochie said:
Plotloss said:
Goochie, do you make those then?

Or do you work in the AV game?
We have them as part of our electrical accessory range.

Switches, sockets, media distribution outlets, pretty much anything that you'd need in a house.
Any chance you could bang me over a price list of all the euromods you carry?

I get through hundreds of the bloody things, some I can get at relatively cheap prices, some not so cheap and I'll always give preference to a PHer.

Plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Monday 14th July 2008
quotequote all
David A said:
Plotloss said:
David A said:
Plotloss said:
Ceiling speakers are alright for rears but not ideal.

Also its a commonly held misconception that rear speakers should be behind the listener, strictly speaking they shouldnt, they should be either side of the cash seat in a 5.1 array.

In an EX (7.2) array the dipoles should be either side of the cash seat and the rears effects are then actually rears.
Was hoping you'd appear! The system isn't meant to be super special just OK for my ears really. They would on the ceiling either side of the sofa - so I guess align with the seats/where ears would be?

I was thinking overnight if I did do this I could also put a center rear in too? Worth it do you think?

Also any thoughts on securing them - I guess they aren't meant to do any low frequencies to securing them to plaster board should be ok?

Also while I'm waiting for good ole Der to check with his minions - do you know if you you can wall mount a Hitachi 55pd9700 ?

Cheers

Dave
55PD9700, if its on the James Bond stand, just drop that off (4 Bolts) and then there are wall mount screw holes on the rear.

If you want to use ceiling speakers for the front effects then you need ceiling speakers that will put the soundstage in the correct place via the use of angled drivers. They're quite good but as a result they arent cheap, at all, for the same money you'll get a far superior set of wall mount speakers.
Have b&w 602.5s and a b&w center at the front plus sub - its just the rears I'm on about.
Ahh, a centre rear I see, sorry.

If you're opening up the ceiling anyway I'd run the wire for 5.1, 6.1 and 7.1 (in both standard and ASA configurations)

6.1 uses a matrixed rear centre channel, like pro-logic. Its alright but slightly compromised as it doesnt give you the steerage effect that 7.2 does.

Goochie

5,804 posts

250 months

Monday 14th July 2008
quotequote all
Plotloss said:
Goochie said:
Plotloss said:
Goochie, do you make those then?

Or do you work in the AV game?
We have them as part of our electrical accessory range.

Switches, sockets, media distribution outlets, pretty much anything that you'd need in a house.
Any chance you could bang me over a price list of all the euromods you carry?

I get through hundreds of the bloody things, some I can get at relatively cheap prices, some not so cheap and I'll always give preference to a PHer.
You have an emailwink

David A

Original Poster:

3,727 posts

282 months

Monday 14th July 2008
quotequote all
David A said:
Goochie said:
You may want to consider face plates with speaker connections behind each of the rear speakers. These are available in a range of plastic and metal finishes that can match your switches and sockets - and they're available at a very good price via a friendly PH memberwink

They can be seen in profile at the far end of this shot:


The connection module looks like this:


and allows bare wire connections to be clamped securely onto gold-plated terminals on the front and rear.
Hmm yess will need those for the other parts of the lounge redecoration smile wait for the call.
Can you email me a rough guide to price on those - do you also do rca ones (for the sub). Do they fit in standard wall socket casing things or need their own?

Cheers

Dave

Plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Monday 14th July 2008
quotequote all
They're 25x50 modules that fit in a standard Euromod plate.

So depending on where you're getting the rest of your wall furniture there could be a complimentary euromod frame.

David A

Original Poster:

3,727 posts

282 months

Monday 14th July 2008
quotequote all
Plotloss said:
They're 25x50 modules that fit in a standard Euromod plate.

So depending on where you're getting the rest of your wall furniture there could be a complimentary euromod frame.
So normal casings for the wall and a euromod face plate that these just clip into? Cool.

Plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Monday 14th July 2008
quotequote all
Ideally go with a 47mm box if you're putting new ones in, may seem like overkill but it makes things a lot easier when you come to terminate.