GP refuses to refer patient for private consultation
GP refuses to refer patient for private consultation
Author
Discussion

Tafia

Original Poster:

2,658 posts

279 months

Thursday 17th July 2008
quotequote all
Brother in Law has what appears to be serious damage to his spine . X ray shows a displaced vertebra. It happened at work whilst driving a large earth mover on a Midlands road building project.

Ambulance was called and paramedics offered morphine for the pain. A & E staff gave strong pain killers and advised him to get to his GP ASAP. As he left they said: "good luck".

He then saw a GP (locum) was told there was a 22 week wait to see a consultant. "Can I see a consultant privately?" he asked.

"Go home and rest. I do not believe in going private to jump the queue"

Pain increased, could not sleep, went to A & E in N Wales and was told:
"you are in the system, we must follow procedure; wait for consultant appointment"

Now he is losing the use of a leg and is in constant pain. Locum still refuses to refer him and it appears consultants do not see anyone unless they are referred!

I have told him to ring another consultant to see if they have a GP who will refer him. Anyone suggest what to do next?

Racefan_uk

2,935 posts

287 months

Thursday 17th July 2008
quotequote all
Ask at his practice for a second opinion? If he's not happy with the service he's getting from his doctor (especially a Locum) he is within his rights to see another one from the practice, I believe, could be wrong though.

andygo

7,422 posts

286 months

Thursday 17th July 2008
quotequote all
See a different GP at the practice (should be easy as it seems impossible to se the same doctor twice at most surgeries!)

Go to casualty at the weekend and be very assertive that your condition is getting worse.

Get the GMC involved.

As it happened st work, get companies occupational health/ insurance company involved.

Loads of crappy ads for injury at work solicitors.

Edited by andygo on Thursday 17th July 20:33

Percy Flage

1,770 posts

253 months

Thursday 17th July 2008
quotequote all
There is absolutely nothing to prevent him from making his own, private appointment. He may be asked to prove ability to pay.....

amir_j

3,579 posts

232 months

Thursday 17th July 2008
quotequote all
Percy Flage said:
There is absolutely nothing to prevent him from making his own, private appointment. He may be asked to prove ability to pay.....
As the OP said, many private consultants will not see you without a gp referral as I found out a month ago...

Maybe an idea to find private GP though and see if he is more willing to refer.

Rebuker

5,006 posts

253 months

Thursday 17th July 2008
quotequote all
Any private consultant should see you without an appointment. They PREFER to have a GP referral but if ytou explain that your GP has a problem with the private system as a whole, they should make an exception.

BOR

5,154 posts

286 months

Thursday 17th July 2008
quotequote all
Would it be possible to contact the other people on the list and ask them if he can go first ?

Millionair

77 posts

220 months

Thursday 17th July 2008
quotequote all
Why hasn't anybody blamed Gordon Brown, Environmentalists, speed cameras or the unions yet? confused

rich1231

17,340 posts

291 months

Thursday 17th July 2008
quotequote all
No offense but there is no reason for the GP not to refer him. Is there more to this tale than being told.

gopher

5,160 posts

290 months

Thursday 17th July 2008
quotequote all
rich1231 said:
No offense but there is no reason for the GP not to refer him. Is there more to this tale than being told.
I was thinking similar, me and the wife are covered by private medical insurance through my work and neither of us have had issues getting a private consultation, in fact my GP always seems pleased, I suppose I'm less likely to come back to him for extra treatment.

bigdods

7,175 posts

258 months

Thursday 17th July 2008
quotequote all
You dont need a referral - they do prefer it but remember Doctors are in it for the money (arent we all), wave cash at them they will see you tomorrow. My son needed a professional examination for a problem and the GP was less than helpful - 10 week waiting list and told me that no one in the UK offered this as a private consultation. I spent about an hour on google and found lots of specialists. I picked the one that seemd top of his field, got his number and called his PA. Got an appointment for the same week.


TheCarpetCleaner

7,294 posts

233 months

Thursday 17th July 2008
quotequote all
gopher said:
rich1231 said:
No offense but there is no reason for the GP not to refer him. Is there more to this tale than being told.
I was thinking similar, me and the wife are covered by private medical insurance through my work and neither of us have had issues getting a private consultation, in fact my GP always seems pleased, I suppose I'm less likely to come back to him for extra treatment.
yes I am currently going through the process for a small issue I am dealing with, on the first appointment with the GP he practically jumped up and down to send me to a specialist on my private healthcare hehe

Could have been an ahole I guess, not sure what his issue would be with "jumping the queue" - this is what I pay a great deal of money for...

jessica

6,321 posts

283 months

Thursday 17th July 2008
quotequote all
if you have private healthcare then insist on an appointment with a specialist ASAP.
if you dont they trip to A and E. tell them no bowel or/and bladder movement they will see you ASAP.......
the system is crap atm.

quyen

592 posts

225 months

Thursday 17th July 2008
quotequote all
Tafia said:
Brother in Law has what appears to be serious damage to his spine . X ray shows a displaced vertebra. It happened at work whilst driving a large earth mover on a Midlands road building project.

Ambulance was called and paramedics offered morphine for the pain. A & E staff gave strong pain killers and advised him to get to his GP ASAP. As he left they said: "good luck".
OK, so it has been established that the back pain is not caused by something that requires immediate admission and treatment (at least on that particular day, it may change if his signs and symptoms changes). It is something that can be dealed with electively as an outpatient.

Tafia said:

He then saw a GP (locum) was told there was a 22 week wait to see a consultant. "Can I see a consultant privately?" he asked.

"Go home and rest. I do not believe in going private to jump the queue"
I can't believe this is a direct quote! Even doctors who are opposed to abortions are duty bound to refer their patients to a colleague who is not opposed such services.

Is this a single handed practice? Is there no other GP that your brother in law can see within the practice? How long will the locum be working there? Is s/he covering a holiday/an illness/a maternity leave?

Tafia said:
Pain increased, could not sleep, went to A & E in N Wales and was told:
"you are in the system, we must follow procedure; wait for consultant appointment"
I used to work in A&E and saw a lot of patients who tried (out of pain and desperation) to by-pass the system by going to A&E. Unfortunately, A&E can only deal with emergency cases (e.g spinal compression) where immediate admission and operation are necessary. In 18 months of A&E work, I only saw 1 case of spinal compression presenting as back pain. I was really surprised when I found the patient had the text book signs of complete sensation loss in the back passage and a full to bursting bladder. Of course, the patient was accepted by the surgical team immediately.

Tafia said:
Now he is losing the use of a leg and is in constant pain. Locum still refuses to refer him and it appears consultants do not see anyone unless they are referred!
What do you mean by "losing the use of a leg"? Do you mean he has no power in it? Has he lost sensation in his leg? If this is the case your brother-in-law needs to get down to A&E immediately and the Locum GP will be in a lot of trouble. However, if the Locum GP has had any medical training then I am sure this can't be right.

Do go and see another GP, I am sure your brother-in-law will get that private referral letter without any problem.



quyen

592 posts

225 months

Thursday 17th July 2008
quotequote all
jessica said:
if you dont they trip to A and E. tell them no bowel or/and bladder movement they will see you ASAP.......
Only do this if it is true because your brother-in-law will have a finger up his bum and a catheter up his willy. Unless he is a very good at faking medical signs, he will be going through a lot of unpleasants examinations and will not get what he wants.

Get the private referral, at least then you'll see a specialist rather than an A&E doctor who is only trained to deal with emergency, not chronic back pain.

SteA

251 posts

257 months

Friday 18th July 2008
quotequote all
quyen said:
What do you mean by "losing the use of a leg"? Do you mean he has no power in it? Has he lost sensation in his leg? If this is the case your brother-in-law needs to get down to A&E immediately and the Locum GP will be in a lot of trouble. However, if the Locum GP has had any medical training then I am sure this can't be right.

Do go and see another GP, I am sure your brother-in-law will get that private referral letter without any problem.
It does sound like completely bizarre behaviour from a GP......

Re the leg, you dont think conditions can deteriorate? And my next comment, please dont take the wrong way as I know a lot of fantastic GP's, I've also seen a lot of conditions missed and mismanaged by GP's that leaves me almost speechless at times, all guys with medical training. I would hope. A GP's job is not an easy one though and the majority deserve a lot more credit than they get.


Edited by SteA on Friday 18th July 00:10

Simpo Two

93,126 posts

296 months

Friday 18th July 2008
quotequote all
Just ring up your nearest private hospital and get a consultation, and go from there. You don't need insurance; you may need a loan if you don't have many savings.

I suggest you report the very unhelpful GP to the General Medical Council too, for preaching politics. Does he not see that if you get out of the queue, the next hapless wretch gets seen quicker? Would he wait 22 weeks? I doubt it.

mybrainhurts

90,809 posts

286 months

Friday 18th July 2008
quotequote all
wavey Tafia...

When this is sorted, find out if you can sue the arse off the locum, then do it if you can...

IforB

9,840 posts

260 months

Friday 18th July 2008
quotequote all
If he is losing feeling in his leg, then there is something wrong and he needs it seen to asap.

The GP is being a c*ck, it isn't up to him to decide if the patient goes private or not.

Second opinion or if it was me, into A&E first thing in the morning and not leaving until you get a satisfactory conclusion.

A friend of my father in law went through something similar, except he couldn't even get through the receptionist. He had a major problem with his spine. How did he know. He is a retired GP himself.....

So he short circuited it, rang a mate who specialises in backs who listened to him over the phone, was horrified and had him on the table in under 24 hours. He can now walk properly.

I cannot stress how potentially serious damage to the back and then loss of feeling can be. The chances are that it is just sciatica caused by a herniated disc, but it needs to be diagnosed and treated properly.

Edited by IforB on Friday 18th July 01:38

rich1231

17,340 posts

291 months

Friday 18th July 2008
quotequote all
mybrainhurts said:
wavey Tafia...

When this is sorted, find out if you can sue the arse off the locum, then do it if you can...
What a pathetic summing up of society.

You dont know if the OP is telling the full story, how can anyone then say legal action should be taken beggers belief.