Is oil a fossil fuel?
Author
Discussion

Spokey

Original Poster:

2,246 posts

240 months

Friday 18th July 2008
quotequote all
I am very confused by this article:

In broad strokes:

CFP said:
We all grew up believing that oil is a fossil fuel, and just about every day this ‘fact’ is mentioned in newspapers and on TV. However, let us not forget what Lenin said – “A lie told often enough becomes truth.” It was in 1757 that the great Russian scholar Mikhailo V. Lomonosov enunciated the hypothesis that oil might originate from biological detritus. The scientists who first rejected Lomonsov’s hypothesis, at the beginning of the nineteenth century, were the famous German naturalist and geologist Alexander von Humboldt and the French chemist and thermodynamicist Louis Joseph Gay-Lussac, who together enunciated the proposition that oil is a primordial material erupted from great depth, and is unconnected with any biological matter near the surface of the Earth.
Apparently, there is no biological constituent in petroleum?

CFP said:
The great French chemist Marcellin Berthelot particularly scorned the hypothesis of a biological origin for petroleum. Berthelot first carried out experiments involving, among others, a series of what are now referred to as Kolbe reactions and demonstrated the generation of petroleum by dissolving steel in strong acid. He produced the suite of n-alkanes and made it plain that such were generated in total absence of any “biological” molecule or process. Berthelot’s investigations were later extended and refined by other scientists, including Biasson and Sokolov, all of whom observed similar phenomena and likewise concluded that petroleum was unconnected to biological matter.
It has been assessed further by geologists:

CFP said:
During the first decade of its existence, the modern theory of petroleum origins was the subject of great contention and controversy. Between the years 1951 and 1965, with the leadership of Kudryavtsev and Porfir’yev, increasing numbers of geologists published articles demonstrating the failures and inconsistencies inherent in the old “biogenic origin” hypothesis. With the passing of the first decade of the modern theory, the failure of Lomonosov’s eighteenth century hypothesis of an origin of petroleum from biological detritus in the near-surface sediments had been thoroughly demonstrated, the hypothesis discredited, and the modern theory firmly established.
It all sounded fairly plausible, until I got here:

CFP said:
By contrast, the practice of mainstream, predictive modern science, particularly physics and chemistry, involves a minimum of observation or data, and applies only a minimum of physical law, inevitably expressed with formal mathematics, and argued by compulsion. Such predictive proof of the geologists’ assertions for the modern Russian-Ukrainian theory of deep, abiotic petroleum origins had to wait almost a half century, for such required the development not only of modern quantum statistical mechanics, but also that of the techniques of many-body theory and the application of statistical geometry to the analysis of dense fluids, designated scaled particle theory.
This paragraph just sounds like a crock of st to me, especially the bit I put in italics.

If oil is abiotic, it changes perspectives a lot. I'm not entirely convinced by the article, though.

What is the wisdom of the PH massive on this one?

Timmy35

13,014 posts

229 months

Friday 18th July 2008
quotequote all
Utter internet bks.

mechsympathy

58,948 posts

286 months

Friday 18th July 2008
quotequote all
CFP said:
Berthelot first carried out experiments involving, among others, a series of what are now referred to as Kolbe reactions and demonstrated the generation of petroleum by dissolving steel in strong acid.
If this is correct then petroleum should contain iron compounds.

Kolbe reactions are organic, but have nothing to do with petroleum...

It's amazing what bks you can find on the interweb.

mattikake

5,119 posts

230 months

Friday 18th July 2008
quotequote all
They are just rejecting Biogenic theory in the same way creationists reject evolution.

They haven't seen it happen in their life-time, therefore it doesn't happen. That the world is static, despite all the other evidence and action of fluidity we see around us.

Doesn't stop the theory being of sound reason. It will take millions of years for organic matter to break down into individual molecules and then toward atomisation and become oil. It's only for this reason we haven't been able to recreate it in a lab.

Numb nuttery. rolleyes

Spokey

Original Poster:

2,246 posts

240 months

Friday 18th July 2008
quotequote all
Thanks ... I'm glad my bullst detectors aren't entirely broken, then. nuts

rev-erend

21,624 posts

315 months

Friday 18th July 2008
quotequote all
If it's not a fosil fuel - then they can't tax it..

Now Mr Brown - about that refund of tax cloud9

jesta1865

3,453 posts

240 months

Friday 18th July 2008
quotequote all
if oil is dinosaur bones, surely they are organic, and in the next 65million years more and more gubbins has been on it's way down there. or did someone say 'no that's the last dinosaur no more stuff to be made into oil'.

or am i missing something about stuff rotting into the ground etc, and other theories?

off_again

13,917 posts

265 months

Friday 18th July 2008
quotequote all
Ooo, someone posted something on the internet - It must be true, right?

Simpo Two

93,127 posts

296 months

Friday 18th July 2008
quotequote all
Burning fossil fuels merely recycles the CO2 back to where it came from. Recycling is good biggrin

Dr Jekyll

23,820 posts

292 months

Friday 18th July 2008
quotequote all
Maybe not QUITE as ludicrous as all that, it was once a respectable if minority theory.

http://www.straightdope.com/columns/060512.html

TheCaseAce

700 posts

242 months

Friday 18th July 2008
quotequote all
jesta1865 said:
if oil is dinosaur bones, surely they are organic, and in the next 65million years more and more gubbins has been on it's way down there. or did someone say 'no that's the last dinosaur no more stuff to be made into oil'.

or am i missing something about stuff rotting into the ground etc, and other theories?
You are missing the fact that 200 million years ago, the dinosaurs weren't pumping around 26.7 billion barrels of it out of the ground every year.

It is getting topped up, but not quite quick enough...