How accurate were thermometers in 1860?
How accurate were thermometers in 1860?
Author
Discussion

thewave

Original Poster:

14,877 posts

240 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
The reason I ask, is because I'm currently sifting through a 74 page document released by the IPCC, and there's a graphical representation of sea surface temperature anomalies which would suggest sea temperature measurements accurate to two decimal places.

Is that right? Were we capable of this in 1860?

Also, how many points across the globe were measured back then? Where were they? Shouldn't we only be accepting data currently collected from those same points?


Fume troll

4,389 posts

243 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
Are they converted units? Or averages?

Thermometers were pretty accurate back then. The first clinical thermometers started appearing around 1870.

Cheers,

FT.

thehawk

9,335 posts

238 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
Presume you are in the toilet because there is only one thing that document is good for.

thewave

Original Poster:

14,877 posts

240 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
Fume troll said:
Are they converted units? Or averages?

Thermometers were pretty accurate back then. The first clinical thermometers started appearing around 1870.

Cheers,

FT.
It says anomolies, and the graph shows the deviation from temperatures in the period 1960-2007, however, when 0.33 of a degree is a pretty fecking big spike on this graph, the data would seem flawed if the measuring device was not as accurate as the range they're indicating.

If, though, as you say, they were pretty accurate, then that's fine. Although i'm still not convinced on the collection of the data.

For example, what's the point in showing data collected in 1860 from say, 50 points across the globe, to 2000 points of collection in 2007? Those 50 points may have all been in colder regions.

Just a thought.

Fume troll

4,389 posts

243 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
thewave said:
Fume troll said:
Are they converted units? Or averages?

Thermometers were pretty accurate back then. The first clinical thermometers started appearing around 1870.

Cheers,

FT.
It says anomolies, and the graph shows the deviation from temperatures in the period 1960-2007, however, when 0.33 of a degree is a pretty fecking big spike on this graph, the data would seem flawed if the measuring device was not as accurate as the range they're indicating.

If, though, as you say, they were pretty accurate, then that's fine. Although i'm still not convinced on the collection of the data.

For example, what's the point in showing data collected in 1860 from say, 50 points across the globe, to 2000 points of collection in 2007? Those 50 points may have all been in colder regions.

Just a thought.
I'd agree, sounds quite sketchy. Thermometers round there were quite precise (as in repeatable), but accurate...well they were getting better around then and certainly in the late 1800's they were a lot better.

Cheers,

FT.

ludo

5,308 posts

235 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
Fume troll said:
thewave said:
Fume troll said:
Are they converted units? Or averages?

Thermometers were pretty accurate back then. The first clinical thermometers started appearing around 1870.

Cheers,

FT.
It says anomolies, and the graph shows the deviation from temperatures in the period 1960-2007, however, when 0.33 of a degree is a pretty fecking big spike on this graph, the data would seem flawed if the measuring device was not as accurate as the range they're indicating.

If, though, as you say, they were pretty accurate, then that's fine. Although i'm still not convinced on the collection of the data.

For example, what's the point in showing data collected in 1860 from say, 50 points across the globe, to 2000 points of collection in 2007? Those 50 points may have all been in colder regions.

Just a thought.
I'd agree, sounds quite sketchy. Thermometers round there were quite precise (as in repeatable), but accurate...well they were getting better around then and certainly in the late 1800's they were a lot better.

Cheers,

FT.
But you have to remember that spatial averaging will cancel out the errors of individual thermometers to an extent (the more stations averaged over, the greater the cancellation of the error).

s2art

18,942 posts

284 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
thewave said:
The reason I ask, is because I'm currently sifting through a 74 page document released by the IPCC, and there's a graphical representation of sea surface temperature anomalies which would suggest sea temperature measurements accurate to two decimal places.

Is that right? Were we capable of this in 1860?

Also, how many points across the globe were measured back then? Where were they? Shouldn't we only be accepting data currently collected from those same points?
I think its worse than just the accuracy of the thermometer. There are all sorts of issues with the method of measurement. In olden days it was via a bucket hauled up, later on some Yank ships measured the temperatures but neglected to take warm water outlets into account.
Basically you cant trust the figures much.

Fume troll

4,389 posts

243 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
ludo said:
But you have to remember that spatial averaging will cancel out the errors of individual thermometers to an extent (the more stations averaged over, the greater the cancellation of the error).
Probably true, but the point made is a good one - the data should be considered in light of the accuracy with which it was collected, and in this case it likely to be measurably different from current methods.

Cheers,

FT.

Cara Van Man

29,977 posts

282 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
Didn't they use some sort of primitive 'Galileo thermometer' or are these just the preserve of gift shops now?

ludo

5,308 posts

235 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
Fume troll said:
ludo said:
But you have to remember that spatial averaging will cancel out the errors of individual thermometers to an extent (the more stations averaged over, the greater the cancellation of the error).
Probably true, but the point made is a good one - the data should be considered in light of the accuracy with which it was collected, and in this case it likely to be measurably different from current methods.
Yes, absolutely, and the climatologists are well aware of such problems, and the error bars generally reflect their estimates of the uncertainties involved. All of the common datasets contain adjustements to deal with known problems, and these are often the subject of some discussion (understatement). As usual you need to make a distinction between the science and the presentation in the media (which normally ignores uncertainty in the interest of controvery, which gets a wider readership).

mat205125

17,790 posts

244 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
ludo said:
Fume troll said:
ludo said:
But you have to remember that spatial averaging will cancel out the errors of individual thermometers to an extent (the more stations averaged over, the greater the cancellation of the error).
Probably true, but the point made is a good one - the data should be considered in light of the accuracy with which it was collected, and in this case it likely to be measurably different from current methods.
Yes, absolutely, and the climatologists are well aware of such problems, and the error bars generally reflect their estimates of the uncertainties involved. All of the common datasets contain adjustements to deal with known problems, and these are often the subject of some discussion (understatement). As usual you need to make a distinction between the science and the presentation in the media (which normally ignores uncertainty in the interest of controvery, which gets a wider readership).
Well summed up.

How many reports and headlines regarding climate change cherry pick the dramatic numbers, yet ignore the accompanying report that should display the accuracy of the data.

dilbert

7,741 posts

262 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
CameraVanMan said:
Didn't they use some sort of primitive 'Galileo thermometer' or are these just the preserve of gift shops now?
Come off it the liverpool and manchester railway opened in 1830. The celcius (centigrade) scale was devised in 1740.

I would say that it is reasonable to assume that a scientific thermometer in those (industrialised) days would be as good as any cheap digital job you would pick up in a hardware shop today.

Perhaps not as good as a properly calibrated thermocouple, but the thing is that they were using mercury as their reference, which has very consistent properties. You would probably find that the mercury is more consistent than the electronic references in a cheap modern digital thermometer.

Edited by dilbert on Monday 21st July 14:54

collateral

7,238 posts

249 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
Very interesting question, and not one I'd thought about before. Especially as the news loves it when it's 'the hottest day since records began'.

Aren't some of these temperatures estimated by tree rings and digging into ice?

Cara Van Man

29,977 posts

282 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
dilbert said:
CameraVanMan said:
Didn't they use some sort of primitive 'Galileo thermometer' or are these just the preserve of gift shops now?
Come off it the liverpool and manchester railway opened in 1830. The celcius (centigrade) scale was devised in 1740.

I would say that it is reasonable to assume that a scientific thermometer in those (industrialised) days would be as good as any cheap digital job you would pick up in a hardware shop today.

Perhaps not as good as a properly calibrated thermocouple, but the thing is that they were using mercury as their reference, which has very consistent properties. You would probably find that the mercury is more consistent than the electronic references in a cheap modern digital thermometer.

Edited by dilbert on Monday 21st July 14:54
rofl

WHOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOSSSSHHHH

Sorry, I seem to have stumbled into some mad scientists thread!!!

I bet your name is Kelvin (absolute zero)


;)

ETA: i can't believe you didn't like my temperature related pun. Tut.

Edited by Cara Van Man on Monday 21st July 15:37

thewave

Original Poster:

14,877 posts

240 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
Well I just want to try and understand these MMGW articles and need to know the facts, where they come from.

Is MMGW bks? I don't know, but I refuse to believe without knowing the facts myself.

PS, who's anti MMGW from a scientific point of view? ie; the equivalent of the antiIPCC?

dilbert

7,741 posts

262 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
Undecided about global warming, but doubtful. Anti, man made global warming.

MilnerR

8,273 posts

289 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
ludo said:
As usual you need to make a distinction between the science and the presentation in the media (which normally ignores uncertainty in the interest of controvery, which gets a wider readership).
Very true, the habit of the media to take the spoken word as the gold standard is also rather a worry. What an egotistical Prof. is willing to say over the phone to a journalist he's trying to impress can often be very different to what he would write in a paper that is going to be peer reviewed.



Simpo Two

93,111 posts

296 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
Slightly OT but the Victorian surveyor Everest (the man after whom Everest was named) surveyed the thing so accurately that the GPS satellites had to be recalibrated - he was right, they were wrong.

The Victorians may not have had hi-tech electronic stuff but they were highly determined, painstaking people. Which probably explains why they managed to achieve so much - they couldn't whine 'sorry, it's the computer...'

collateral

7,238 posts

249 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
thewave said:
Well I just want to try and understand these MMGW articles and need to know the facts, where they come from.

Is MMGW bks? I don't know, but I refuse to believe without knowing the facts myself.

PS, who's anti MMGW from a scientific point of view? ie; the equivalent of the antiIPCC?
FWIW my dad is an organic prof and he's very skeptical.

mr_tony

6,351 posts

300 months

Monday 21st July 2008
quotequote all
MilnerR said:
ludo said:
As usual you need to make a distinction between the science and the presentation in the media (which normally ignores uncertainty in the interest of controvery, which gets a wider readership).
Very true, the habit of the media to take the spoken word as the gold standard is also rather a worry. What an egotistical Prof. is willing to say over the phone to a journalist he's trying to impress can often be very different to what he would write in a paper that is going to be peer reviewed.
err I think ludo is makign the point that journalists will employ selective hearing understanding / use of statistics to make a story out of nothing.....

Relatively innocuous data can easily be turned into a scare story very easily if you use the words WILL instead of MIGHT. See just about any copy of the mail for details...