Tiredness and hours slept - an experiment...
Tiredness and hours slept - an experiment...
Author
Discussion

Gylen

Original Poster:

10,218 posts

248 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
You know how people (usually women) complain that they are soooooo tired as they only got 5 hours sleep last night due to cat pissing on face/baby crying/car alarm etc? Well, something occurred to me this morning - I think it's just because they know how long they slept for so they know they ought to be tired.

I couldn't sleep last night as I stayed up late watching a film and ended up being awake until 3/3.30 am. When I woke up, I had that sinking feeling which precedes the realisation that one has slept in. Badly. You know the kind of thing, you wake up feeling wide awake and refreshed and that only happens if you've slept for ages! The reason for this was that my phone/alarm clock had been left in the lounge so I hadn't had my usual wake up ring.

Now, here comes the theory part. After springing out of bed in a panic, I found out it was only 8am (I work from home) and I'd only slept in by a small amount. I wasn't tired at all though as although I only had 5 hours or so, I woke up thinking I'd had way more.

My question, if people didn't know how long they'd slept for, would they still be tired? Eg, if you convinced someone they'd been asleep for 10 hours when they'd only slept for 4, would they be wide awake?

I appreciate that there's a bare minimum needed to function but beyond this, I can't help but feel we're conditioned to expect and demand our 7-8 hours and use it as an excuse when we don't get it? Do we really really need it? I rarely get it and do a lot of sport on top of work etc. and usually make it up with a lie in on the weekend every couple of weeks for example...

rhinochopig

17,932 posts

229 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
I think it's more a case of letting your body wake up naturally rather than being dragged from your sleep by an alarm clock. The daylight alarms are supposed to be very good.

Graebob

2,172 posts

238 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
On Fridays I only usually get 4-5 hours in (Friday is beer night, but I have work on Saturday at 5am) and I'm generally fine when I get up. It only sets in later (I get tired around 9pm, as opposed to 10-11pm normally). Interesting thought though.

Edited by Graebob on Tuesday 22 July 12:31

BoRED S2upid

21,144 posts

271 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
You probably only need 5 hours a night. If we didn't have clocks you would sleep when you felt like it and probably wake up when the sun woke you up rather than an alarm waking you up cos you have to go to work.

Dover Nige

1,308 posts

274 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
I think it's an accumulation of a lack of sleep rather than just a one off that hits hardest....

KB_S1

5,967 posts

260 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
I too, find that I am better off with 5 hours continuous sleep.
However, it is nights when I am woken or disturbed at various times that lead to tiredness.
Over the last couple of nights I have not slept well due to stomach pains. I am knackered now.

Neil_H

15,418 posts

282 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
It's the quality of sleep that's important, you can sleep for 8 hours, but if it is disturbed sleep, (you won't always know if it is or not - ie you won't always conciously wake up) you won't feel refreshed. On the other hand, 8 hours of solid, undisturbed deep sleep will have you feeling like you've slept well.

That's my problem, I can sleep for 8 hours and not feel good because I sleep very lightly and so often don't get good quality sleep.

jamesgrrr

3,781 posts

252 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
it was probably more the shock of 'oh damn i've overslept' that made you feel awake

rude-boy

22,227 posts

264 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
Dover Nige said:
I think it's an accumulation of a lack of sleep rather than just a one off that hits hardest....
yes

As a rule I sleep like the dead. It is very rare that i sleep for more than 7 hours. 6 is fairly normal but i can get away with stupidly little sleep for a week or two if i 'stock up' before or after.

mmm-five

12,402 posts

315 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
I can, and have lived on 4 hours of sleep a night for about 6 months.

What I found was it wasn't the amount of sleep, but as has been said previously, it is the quality of sleep and also the timing of those sleeping hours.

I had a set amount of work to do (hourly paid) and I started doing the normal (at the time) 8am-8pm work day, but one of my colleagues went off 'ill' and I had to take up the slack as she was only going to be away for 2 weeks maximum (it ended up being permanent and she was replaced).

With the extra workload, I was regularly working to 3am and then getting back into the office for 8am and having breakfast at the office).

I found that no matter what time I finished work, as long as I got those 4 hours I could easily cope with it. It was only when I was asked to start earlier and finish earlier (i.e. 6am to 6pm plus overtime) that I found myself being woken by the alarm rather than waking up a couple of minutes before the alarm.

With the slightly earlier starts I was more grumpy in the morning and was prone to drowsing in meetings.

Took two weeks to work out it was simply the hours and not a cumulative effect of all those long hours, but I got put back on the 8am-8pm system and was fine working the extra hours.

In my current job I'd be out by 8pm at the latest as I don't get overtime, but in the original one it was double time for any hours after 12, so I was loaded (sorry, it's all been spentwink )

Road_Terrorist

5,591 posts

273 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
dibbers006 said:
You wait till you have had a cup of tea and a sandwich at lunch time... you will feel tired then!wink
That's diet not tiredness

Sandwich = carbs = tiredness
Tea = caffine = short energy burst followed by drowsiness

Also the body keeps itself awake if starved so don't eat lunch and you wont feel tired, you'll be tired AND hungry, but still awake biggrin.

madrob6

3,594 posts

251 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
I have no idea how long I slept last night but I do know that my OH was trying her best to wake up the world with the joy of snoring.

Needless to say I am very tired and grumpy.

Gylen

Original Poster:

10,218 posts

248 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
Hmm, mixed views. I think I may try getting rid of all visible clocks from the bedroom and simply sleeping when I'm tired and waking when I wake, just to see what sort of sleep cycle I naturally fall into. I suspect it would be significantly less than 7-8 a night...

captainzep

13,306 posts

223 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
Grumpy zombie parent here.

Have had a handful (honestly) of decent nights' sleep (5hrs+ unbroken) in the last 6 months following birth of captainzep jnr II. Little fker.

You do get a sort of 'fitness' with long term sleep deprivation. But lets be honest about this, generally you are not as alert, happy, productive, verbally articulate, etc etc. Regular headaches, much shorter temper so arguments can break out over the smallest things. Its pretty horrible at times.

Swilly

9,699 posts

305 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
I imagine it is the duration of quality sleep that matters, not the duration of sleep per se !!

Mars

10,176 posts

245 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
Dover Nige said:
I think it's an accumulation of a lack of sleep rather than just a one off that hits hardest....
Bang on..!! I get about 5 hours a night, often broken due to my children disturbing me, but 5 hours is enough if I can have 9 or 10 hours one night a week. One lie-in per week resets me for another 6 days of minimal sleep.

Zeek

882 posts

235 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
I get 4.5 to 5 hours every day. If I am particuarly knackered, and am going to bed later than usual, I trick myself by pretending it is really early. Half of the problem with knowing you're only going to get 3 hours sleep of the irritation and worry that you'll be knackered, which makes the bit of sleep you will get a waste of time. If it is 2am, (my alarm always goes off at 5:15) then I'll pretend it is 8pm, and then go to sleep!!hehe

Shackleton saved the lives of his crew by tricking them. When they were exhausted, he knew if they slept, they'd die, so he would tell them they could sleep for a couple of hours, and when the last one fell asleep, he'd wake them up and they would believe they had been asleep for a few hours!

Buzz word

2,028 posts

240 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
I think the differance is you woke up with what I like to call 'the fear'. This is a feeling that you have messed up and wont be at work on time and can be motivational, like when you get a new job and you have to be there on time. I find that helps me out the house if I get into that situation. About now I would start to be feeling a bit tiered though.

Geronimo

626 posts

223 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2008
quotequote all
I think the real question here is why, when you work from home, do you make yourself get up at such an early hour. I don't think Jeremy Kyle is even on till mid morning.