Trees a sign of climate change?
Trees a sign of climate change?
Author
Discussion

mattikake

Original Poster:

5,119 posts

230 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
First they start budding months early, are they not shedding leaves early too?

Driving to work the other day, and I noticed all the Horse Chestnut trees on my way in had brown/browning leaves. It's July not September! Are these trees more sensitive to climate changes than others?

Anyone else noticed similar where they are?

panhandle

48 posts

220 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
this can happen. trees lose their leaves at different times.

not directly a result of climate change.

xiphias

5,889 posts

258 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
It snowed in July when I was 3. Climate change wasn't even invented then.

fatboy b

9,666 posts

247 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
mattikake said:
First they start budding months early, are they not shedding leaves early too?

Driving to work the other day, and I noticed all the Horse Chestnut trees on my way in had brown/browning leaves. It's July not September! Are these trees more sensitive to climate changes than others?

Anyone else noticed similar where they are?
fk off you tt

Hedders

24,460 posts

278 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
mattikake said:
First they start budding months early, are they not shedding leaves early too?

Driving to work the other day, and I noticed all the Horse Chestnut trees on my way in had brown/browning leaves. It's July not September! Are these trees more sensitive to climate changes than others?

Anyone else noticed similar where they are?
Not being funny mate, you probably have good intentions and all that but you really are trying to preach to the wrong people!


Neil_Sc

2,258 posts

238 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
mattikake said:
Anyone else noticed similar where they are?
No

mavester

54 posts

249 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
So spring and autumn are early and summer seems to have been skipped all together (which reminds me of a scene in Monty Python and the Holy Grail...). Maybe all the calendars are broken....I do hope this doesn't mean that Christmas is the week after next smile

HRG

72,863 posts

270 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all

Hyperion

16,952 posts

231 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
The Horse Chestnut trees you're seeing have been infected by the Horse Chestnut Leaf Miner larvae. Nothing to do with 'global warming'.
More info here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Horse-chestnut_leaf_m...

Edited by Hyperion on Wednesday 23 July 11:30

ludo

5,308 posts

235 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
ludo said:
mattikake said:
First they start budding months early, are they not shedding leaves early too?

Driving to work the other day, and I noticed all the Horse Chestnut trees on my way in had brown/browning leaves. It's July not September! Are these trees more sensitive to climate changes than others?

Anyone else noticed similar where they are?
Climate is about long term changes, short term changes are just weather. If you have some results showing a long term trend in leaves budding earlier each year you might have a point regarding the climate. If on the other hand you have noticed them budding early this year, you have an observation about this years weather, not the climate. Don't make the mistake of confusing weather with climate (as many are doing by claiming there is global cooling on the basis of 18 months of cool weather due to ENSO)
P.S. the horse chestnut trees are browning here as well, but according to the villages tree czar (sorry can't remember the proper designation) it is caused by some sort of blight and the trees will not be seriously harmed by it.

billynomates

2,101 posts

267 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
ludo said:
ludo said:
mattikake said:
First they start budding months early, are they not shedding leaves early too?

Driving to work the other day, and I noticed all the Horse Chestnut trees on my way in had brown/browning leaves. It's July not September! Are these trees more sensitive to climate changes than others?

Anyone else noticed similar where they are?
Climate is about long term changes, short term changes are just weather. If you have some results showing a long term trend in leaves budding earlier each year you might have a point regarding the climate. If on the other hand you have noticed them budding early this year, you have an observation about this years weather, not the climate. Don't make the mistake of confusing weather with climate (as many are doing by claiming there is global cooling on the basis of 18 months of cool weather due to ENSO)
P.S. the horse chestnut trees are browning here as well, but according to the villages tree czar (sorry can't remember the proper designation) it is caused by some sort of blight and the trees will not be seriously harmed by it.
It's Guignardia aesculi. I have 3 trees heavily infected this year some of the leaves are completely brown.

Shifty Scott

108 posts

249 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
If you examine the leaves you will probably find that it is caused by a parasitic fungus (Guignardia aesculi) or the larvae of the leaf mining moth (Cameraria ohridella). Neither should cause the tree any serious harm but does make it look like autumn has come early.

mattikake

Original Poster:

5,119 posts

230 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
ludo said:
ludo said:
mattikake said:
First they start budding months early, are they not shedding leaves early too?

Driving to work the other day, and I noticed all the Horse Chestnut trees on my way in had brown/browning leaves. It's July not September! Are these trees more sensitive to climate changes than others?

Anyone else noticed similar where they are?
Climate is about long term changes, short term changes are just weather. If you have some results showing a long term trend in leaves budding earlier each year you might have a point regarding the climate. If on the other hand you have noticed them budding early this year, you have an observation about this years weather, not the climate. Don't make the mistake of confusing weather with climate (as many are doing by claiming there is global cooling on the basis of 18 months of cool weather due to ENSO)
P.S. the horse chestnut trees are browning here as well, but according to the villages tree czar (sorry can't remember the proper designation) it is caused by some sort of blight and the trees will not be seriously harmed by it.
Just wondered if the trees were detecting an onset of autumn before anything else or if it was a local disease or something.

btw, I am very well aware that weather varies year on year and that one unusual year does not = climate change(d). However, a few years on the trot or a pattern over more often than not over a 10 or 20 year period could indicate this.

Edited by mattikake on Wednesday 23 July 11:36

Davi

17,153 posts

251 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
Neil_Sc said:
mattikake said:
Anyone else noticed similar where they are?
No
actually I noticed a very large pile of leaves on my drive in mid July last year.

It may have been because I chopped down a fking huge 200 year old tree to make space to park my third car, but I'm not sure - could have been MMGW afterall.

Bing o

15,184 posts

250 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
mattikake said:
First they start budding months early, are they not shedding leaves early too?

Driving to work the other day, and I noticed all the Horse Chestnut trees on my way in had brown/browning leaves. It's July not September! Are these trees more sensitive to climate changes than others?

Anyone else noticed similar where they are?
Seriously, last month you are on about Fuel Protests (surely petrol prices going up is good for you lentilists?), this month you want to buy a mincers 2.0 Z3, and start talking bks about climate change - why don't you take the hint and fk off.

ludo

5,308 posts

235 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
mattikake said:
ludo said:
ludo said:
mattikake said:
First they start budding months early, are they not shedding leaves early too?

Driving to work the other day, and I noticed all the Horse Chestnut trees on my way in had brown/browning leaves. It's July not September! Are these trees more sensitive to climate changes than others?

Anyone else noticed similar where they are?
Climate is about long term changes, short term changes are just weather. If you have some results showing a long term trend in leaves budding earlier each year you might have a point regarding the climate. If on the other hand you have noticed them budding early this year, you have an observation about this years weather, not the climate. Don't make the mistake of confusing weather with climate (as many are doing by claiming there is global cooling on the basis of 18 months of cool weather due to ENSO)
P.S. the horse chestnut trees are browning here as well, but according to the villages tree czar (sorry can't remember the proper designation) it is caused by some sort of blight and the trees will not be seriously harmed by it.
Just wondered if the trees were detecting an onset of autumn before anything else or if it was a local disease or something.
Questioned answered then (more accurately by some others, rather than me, but then I was fielding at long-on whilst discussing the horse-chestnut trees (just beyond the boundary) with the tree czar, so she didin't have my undivided attention). ETA thanks for the identifying the culprit billy, shifty and hyperion.

Edited by ludo on Wednesday 23 July 11:37

mattikake

Original Poster:

5,119 posts

230 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
Bing o said:
mattikake said:
First they start budding months early, are they not shedding leaves early too?

Driving to work the other day, and I noticed all the Horse Chestnut trees on my way in had brown/browning leaves. It's July not September! Are these trees more sensitive to climate changes than others?

Anyone else noticed similar where they are?
Seriously, last month you are on about Fuel Protests (surely petrol prices going up is good for you lentilists?), this month you want to buy a mincers 2.0 Z3, and start talking bks about climate change - why don't you take the hint and fk off.
Eh? Is it against the forum to have an opinion, discussion or something? Look-up the origin of the word "forum". At least I'm not offensive/abusive about stepping into your cliquey domain, unlike some...

Instead, be constructive and use this as an opportunity to practice counter-arguments or something.

FYI, I've since decided against a Z3 purely on the emissions which are pretty pants for a simple 2.0 litre. As I remember something like 220-223g/km!

Edited by mattikake on Wednesday 23 July 11:43

Fume troll

4,389 posts

243 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
Seems to me that trees have been holding their leaves longer than normal these past few years - I'd have thought that was more likely to indicate warmer weather (note short term term!) than them dropping earlier.

Cheers,

FT.

Cara Van Man

29,977 posts

282 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
mattikake said:
Bing o said:
mattikake said:
First they start budding months early, are they not shedding leaves early too?

Driving to work the other day, and I noticed all the Horse Chestnut trees on my way in had brown/browning leaves. It's July not September! Are these trees more sensitive to climate changes than others?

Anyone else noticed similar where they are?
Seriously, last month you are on about Fuel Protests (surely petrol prices going up is good for you lentilists?), this month you want to buy a mincers 2.0 Z3, and start talking bks about climate change - why don't you take the hint and fk off.
Eh? Is it against the forum to have an opinion, discussion or something? Look-up the origin of the word "forum". At least I'm not offensive/abusive about stepping into your cliquey domain, unlike some...

Instead, be constructive and use this as an opportunity to practice counter-arguments or something.

FYI, I've since decided against a Z3 purely on the emissions which are pretty pants for a simple 2.0 litre. As I remember something like 220-223g/km!

Edited by mattikake on Wednesday 23 July 11:43
You are Milligan AICMFP

mattikake

Original Poster:

5,119 posts

230 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
Fume troll said:
Seems to me that trees have been holding their leaves longer than normal these past few years - I'd have thought that was more likely to indicate warmer weather (note short term term!) than them dropping earlier.

Cheers,

FT.
:Yes:

Well I had a (playful) theory about deciduous trees being a natural CO2/climate regulator by keeping their leaves longer and prolonging their photosynthesis period, automatically correcting any surplus.

Too easy though.