Is it fair? The disability thread
Is it fair? The disability thread
Author
Discussion

raf_gti

Original Poster:

4,258 posts

237 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
First of all may I apologise to who ever this thread may offend, I'm well aware it may be a sensitive subject for some.

Anyway

If you had the choice would you let your future child be born with a disability? I am by no means a perfect physical specimen but I am thankful for the way I am, life can be tough enough as it is without the added pressure of being disabled. When I see people who are confined to a wheelchair for life and need permanent care I do often wonder is there much point for them, I certainly can't imagine them or their carer getting much joy out of life.

If we did have the right to choose pre-birth where would the line be drawn? I'm sure there are plenty of people out there who would choose to get rid of a baby for the most minor of affliction's.


Trommel

20,661 posts

290 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
If it was going to be ginger, then obviously it would have to go.

Bringing a ginger into the world is horrendously unfair on both parents and child.

spikeyhead

20,652 posts

228 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
raf_gti said:
If you had the choice would you let your future child be born with a disability? I am by no means a perfect physical specimen but I am thankful for the way I am, life can be tough enough as it is without the added pressure of being disabled. When I see people who are confined to a wheelchair for life and need permanent care I do often wonder is there much point for them, I certainly can't imagine them or their carer getting much joy out of life.

If we did have the right to choose pre-birth where would the line be drawn? I'm sure there are plenty of people out there who would choose to get rid of a baby for the most minor of affliction's.
Why not ask Stephen Hawking?

rich1231

17,340 posts

291 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
spikeyhead said:
raf_gti said:
If you had the choice would you let your future child be born with a disability? I am by no means a perfect physical specimen but I am thankful for the way I am, life can be tough enough as it is without the added pressure of being disabled. When I see people who are confined to a wheelchair for life and need permanent care I do often wonder is there much point for them, I certainly can't imagine them or their carer getting much joy out of life.

If we did have the right to choose pre-birth where would the line be drawn? I'm sure there are plenty of people out there who would choose to get rid of a baby for the most minor of affliction's.
Why not ask Stephen Hawking?
He wasnt born with a disability.

Simpo Two

93,104 posts

296 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
It depends on the degree of disability.

Having said that rational decisions don't apply, because whilst at present it's easy for me to say 'I don't want a Down's baby' if it was mine and I saw it I might love it anyway.

panhandle

48 posts

220 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
i dont know that i could. i know that sounds really really awful, but it's just...my opinion.

Marf

22,907 posts

272 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
rich1231 said:
spikeyhead said:
raf_gti said:
If you had the choice would you let your future child be born with a disability? I am by no means a perfect physical specimen but I am thankful for the way I am, life can be tough enough as it is without the added pressure of being disabled. When I see people who are confined to a wheelchair for life and need permanent care I do often wonder is there much point for them, I certainly can't imagine them or their carer getting much joy out of life.

If we did have the right to choose pre-birth where would the line be drawn? I'm sure there are plenty of people out there who would choose to get rid of a baby for the most minor of affliction's.
Why not ask Stephen Hawking?
He wasnt born with a disability.
errr you dont catch motor neurone disease rich like you would a cold...

Don

28,378 posts

315 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
If you could screen the foetus and detect birth defects early enough for an abortion?

Of course many would take the option.

But what a horrid choice.

neil_bolton

17,113 posts

295 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
[whistles]

Blimey. This'll turn into a bun fight I can tell you.

I remain undecided on this decision, having not yet been in a position whereupon I may have to make a choice. Therefore I cannot say whether or not my head may rule over my heart; this, I feel, being the key here.

The head says that you should consider the quality of life for the child, however the heart says that the child has a right to life.

Its a tricky one, and like I said, one that I cannot decide until in that situation, and I hope to god myself, nor anyone here has to encounter it.

Heskey

4,048 posts

224 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
Myself and my partner are physically healthy, if by some anomaly (should we stay together long enough to think about kids) our child would be born with some deficiency (Not including minor things, both mental and physical) I probably wouldn't want to bare it.

Call me cruel but it's not to early to say 'no', and given my good health, I wouldn't want to bare the responsibility of raising a disabled child.

I may feel different if this was actually happening, but I do have to say if I fore-knew my child would be born with severe disability, I wouldn't go through with it.

There's no quality of life for such children, and definately ends the parents lives early.

Swilly

9,699 posts

305 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
raf_gti said:
If you had the choice would you let your future child be born with a disability?
Thats a very emotive way to put it.

You are in effect placing the persons thoughts in a future position where they then have to look back to make a decision whether to abort or not the present child.

You could have phrased the question:

If you had the choice would you abort an abnormal foetus !?

Yes i would (dependent on the type and degree of course) !!

Would i allow say a foetus with Downs to develop and be born !?

No i wouldnt. It wouldnt rob anyone of a chance of life, because at that stage there is no one.

... and this decision doesnt devalue those Downs people who are alive today either. They have value BECAUSE they are alive.

FiveStar

760 posts

235 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
There are so many varying degrees of disability that I would really have to know what disability it is first. Something simple like not having a leg/arm and I dont belive with the technology and adaptations available the child would suffer/ have a "different" life that much.


MentalSarcasm

6,083 posts

242 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
Marf said:
rich1231 said:
spikeyhead said:
raf_gti said:
If you had the choice would you let your future child be born with a disability? I am by no means a perfect physical specimen but I am thankful for the way I am, life can be tough enough as it is without the added pressure of being disabled. When I see people who are confined to a wheelchair for life and need permanent care I do often wonder is there much point for them, I certainly can't imagine them or their carer getting much joy out of life.

If we did have the right to choose pre-birth where would the line be drawn? I'm sure there are plenty of people out there who would choose to get rid of a baby for the most minor of affliction's.
Why not ask Stephen Hawking?
He wasnt born with a disability.
errr you dont catch motor neurone disease rich like you would a cold...
True, but at the moment it cannot be detected. It can't even be properly diagnosed in any decent amount of time, they just cross possible things off a list until they to MND.

MND is a bh but early development of the disease is very rare, most sufferers are in their 50's before they start to get symptoms of it. And while it may be caused by a defective gene no one is really sure what the trigger that stars the disease progressing is. Or why it can take years to kill person or months to kill another. My Grandad was dignosed when he was 77, he was gone 14 months later.

In fact the amount that is known about MND is very little, the amount spent on research is even less, somthing which pisses me off greatly as it is a nasty disease, one of the nastiest around. But of course, finding a cure, or even decent treatment, isn't "financially viable" so very few companes actually give a toss.

Sorry, yes, disabilities. I'm not sure, depends on the disease, or when my child would develop it. If my child was going to be born with severe disabilities then I'd probably opt for not having it, as I believe in quality of life over quantity.

Very thought-provoking question for a Wednesday afternoon.

smutbag

1,705 posts

221 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
I think each and every case where there was a decision to be made is indiviual.

The type and severity of disability would most likely have a major impact on the decision to be made. For example some parents to be are told, your child would have no quality of life and not make it past the age of 1, then you could understand the rational behind a decision to abort. It would however likely be the most heartbraking and difficult decision any parent is likely to make.

There are on the other hand those who know their child will have downs (for example) and go ahead with the birth, changing their own, their family's and their childs lives forever. This too is an incredibly brave decision and one you can only have complete admiration for.

No person takes any decision like this lightly and those who judge people in these types of situations disgust me.

Edited by smutbag on Wednesday 23 July 16:26

Prof Beard

6,669 posts

258 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
A very difficult question.

Mrs B and I had our two sons in our late 30s and hence Mrs B had additional tests to check for various detectable disabilities.

I didn't know at the time how I'd react if there was a problem. As it turned out both lads are "normal" (or as normal as anyone who got half their genes from me can be). In hindsight, I still don't know.

voyds9

8,490 posts

314 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
spikeyhead said:
raf_gti said:
If you had the choice would you let your future child be born with a disability? I am by no means a perfect physical specimen but I am thankful for the way I am, life can be tough enough as it is without the added pressure of being disabled. When I see people who are confined to a wheelchair for life and need permanent care I do often wonder is there much point for them, I certainly can't imagine them or their carer getting much joy out of life.

If we did have the right to choose pre-birth where would the line be drawn? I'm sure there are plenty of people out there who would choose to get rid of a baby for the most minor of affliction's.
Why not ask Stephen Hawking?
or Joey Deacon if his two friends are alive you might even get a reply.

Seriously I think some disabilities you could live with others I wouldn't want to. Good mind, bad body I could live with. Good body, bad mind put me down please.

Don

28,378 posts

315 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
Speaking from personal experience neither is great.

I have a nephew who is tall and strong but blind and mentally will never be capable of looking after himself in any way.

I have another nephew who is bright as a button but has half a heart.

One out of three nephews came out right.

Neither of the two disabled kids would have been spotted early in pregnancy.

It's no wonder I don't have kids.

Edited by Don on Wednesday 23 July 17:03

The Excession

11,669 posts

281 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
Prof Beard said:
A very difficult question.

Mrs B and I had our two sons in our late 30s and hence Mrs B had additional tests to check for various detectable disabilities.

I didn't know at the time how I'd react if there was a problem. As it turned out both lads are "normal" (or as normal as anyone who got half their genes from me can be). In hindsight, I still don't know.
Likewise with myself and the Mrs, both late thirties, tried for two years to conceive. We had all sorts of problems early on in the pregnancy.

Once the foetus was developed enough we pushed for an amniocentesis, they weren't common practice at the time here in Ireland and we were very fortunate that there was a Canadian doctor at the Limerick Hospital that was here training staff how to perform the procedure.

It was a hell of a worry, I seem to remember it was done at around 17 weeks...
We then had to wait a few more weeks for the cultures to be grown and tested before we got any results.

We talked about it alot at the time leading upto the results, we really didn't think we could cope with a handicapped child, but having to make that call would have been utterly heart wrenching.

Fortunately everything was OK, I really don't know what we would have done had there been a problem. Given that we were seeing pictures like this on the ultrasound during the procedure. (Infact, that's a picture of 13 week foetus) During our test procedure we were clearly able to see he was a boy. (with a very big willy hehe )



I guess we got lucky.




Sheets Tabuer

21,563 posts

246 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
It's a tough one, my son is alright mentally, well more than alright he's a little genius. It's just his body doesn't work.

In fact I really can't answer that as I feel it too hard to comprehend.

Now we know the Mrs has this genetic fault we decided not to have any more but that is out of her guilt for what she sees as "inflicting" on him an incurable illness.

pgilc1

40,169 posts

228 months

Wednesday 23rd July 2008
quotequote all
Marf said:
rich1231 said:
spikeyhead said:
raf_gti said:
If you had the choice would you let your future child be born with a disability? I am by no means a perfect physical specimen but I am thankful for the way I am, life can be tough enough as it is without the added pressure of being disabled. When I see people who are confined to a wheelchair for life and need permanent care I do often wonder is there much point for them, I certainly can't imagine them or their carer getting much joy out of life.

If we did have the right to choose pre-birth where would the line be drawn? I'm sure there are plenty of people out there who would choose to get rid of a baby for the most minor of affliction's.
Why not ask Stephen Hawking?
He wasnt born with a disability.
errr you dont catch motor neurone disease rich like you would a cold...
No, but you're not born with it either. No more than someone is born with cancer