not voting
Author
Discussion

Mike400

Original Poster:

1,026 posts

262 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
This is probably a stupid question but bear with me.

What would happen if NOBODY voted. Impossible situation I know but lets just say it happened, everyone got up on election day and thought "nah i dont fancy any of them"

kambites

71,713 posts

252 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
It'd be a draw, so they'd hold another ballot.

Einion Yrth

19,575 posts

275 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
The politicians all vote, so NOBODY voting is never going to happen. It's a bit like asking what's north of the north pole.

Mike400

Original Poster:

1,026 posts

262 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
Einion Yrth said:
The politicians all vote, so NOBODY voting is never going to happen. It's a bit like asking what's north of the north pole.
I know that, im just asking what if they didnt?

It couldnt keep being a draw forever, someone would have to be put in power?

Simpo Two

93,101 posts

296 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
Haven't they threatened fining people who don't vote?

If they do, it's a sure winner for the Monster Raving Loony Party getting in on protest votes.

But I suppose then they'll fine you for not voting Labour. Which brings us back to Mugabe...

merc_man

1,926 posts

233 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
In the event of a draw the outcome of each contested seat is decided by chance (drawing straws, tossing a coin etc.) If that resulted in a government of no overall control then the head of state decides who will form the next government*.



*probably

fatboy b

9,666 posts

247 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
Einion Yrth said:
The politicians all vote, so NOBODY voting is never going to happen. It's a bit like asking what's north of the north pole.
Depends on which North Pole.

Tony*T3

20,911 posts

278 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
fatboy b said:
Einion Yrth said:
The politicians all vote, so NOBODY voting is never going to happen. It's a bit like asking what's north of the north pole.
Depends on which North Pole.
Abosultly. The North Pole isnt at the top of the world after all....wink (which most people dont understand...)

Simpo Two

93,101 posts

296 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
merc_man said:
In the event of a draw the outcome of each contested seat is decided by chance (drawing straws, tossing a coin etc.) If that resulted in a government of no overall control then the head of state decides who will form the next government*.
How about a pistol duel? Brown presents a bigger target too...

Einion Yrth

19,575 posts

275 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
Tony*T3 said:
fatboy b said:
Einion Yrth said:
The politicians all vote, so NOBODY voting is never going to happen. It's a bit like asking what's north of the north pole.
Depends on which North Pole.
Abosultly. The North Pole isnt at the top of the world after all....wink (which most people dont understand...)
The magnetic one may not be, indeed isn't, but since I was referring to the northern end of the earth's spin axis, you can bite my shiny metal asswink

Skyrat

1,185 posts

221 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
soapbox

I have to admit to having the smallest amount of contempt for people who do not vote. It took long enough for the average man in the street to get the vote and for people to not use it, well it sticks in my throat a little. There are people in certain countries that would love the chance to vote.

That's nothing, mind you, to the contempt I have for people who don't vote, and then sit and moan about the government doing this and that. Simply put, if you don't vote, you should STFU.

[/soapbox]



Edited by Skyrat on Thursday 24th July 13:36

NobleGuy

7,133 posts

246 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
Simpo Two said:
If they do, it's a sure winner for the Monster Raving Loony Party getting in on protest votes.
That would be funny biggrin.

I had a Sociology teacher who thought that people should be forced to vote, if only to spoil their paper. Great idea.... A democracy where you can't vote how you want to.

Mike400

Original Poster:

1,026 posts

262 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
Skyrat said:
soapbox

I have to admit to having the smallest amount of contempt for people who do not vote. It took long enough for the average man in the street to get the vote and for people to not use it, well it sticks in my throat a little. There are people in certain countries that would love the chance to vote.

That's nothing, mind you, to the contempt I have for people who don't vote, and then sit and moan about the government doing this and that. Simply put, if you don't vote, you should STFU.

[/soapbox]



Edited by Skyrat on Thursday 24th July 13:36
I do agree and I have never missed a vote since I was old enough.

However I was just asking "what if".

Would the Queen perhaps take responsibility if a lack of vote would suggest a vote of no confidence in any candidate? dissolving parliment until the situation can be resolved?

Don

28,378 posts

315 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
NobleGuy said:
Simpo Two said:
If they do, it's a sure winner for the Monster Raving Loony Party getting in on protest votes.
That would be funny biggrin.

I had a Sociology teacher who thought that people should be forced to vote, if only to spoil their paper. Great idea.... A democracy where you can't vote how you want to.
If you want to vote "None of the above" go ahead. Write it on the ballot paper and tick next to it. Sure the vote is "spoiled" but if enough people do it it would encourage someone to stand who you might want to vote for.

Either that or go for name recognition voting.

I'm off to form the NONE OF THE ABOVE party. yes I want to be an MEP and live like a king on expenses and feather nest myself a smashing retirement! Yay! In fact - that's my whole manifesto! VOTE NONE OF THE ABOVE!

RedLeicester

6,869 posts

276 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
Skyrat said:
soapbox

I have to admit to having the smallest amount of contempt for people who do not vote. It took long enough for the average man in the street to get the vote and for people to not use it, well it sticks in my throat a little. There are people in certain countries that would love the chance to vote.

That's nothing, mind you, to the contempt I have for people who don't vote, and then sit and moan about the government doing this and that. Simply put, if you don't vote, you should STFU.

[/soapbox]
Couldn't agree more. Curious thing to do, but my parents encouraged me to the belief that it was my duty to vote - what I voted for was immaterial, but that voting was part of the fabric of our society.

Apache

39,731 posts

315 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
I may be one of those you all hold in contempt as I will be spoiling my paper at the next opportunity, although I'm open to suggestions. I just feel that there is no choice the system has become too much of an elected Dictatorship......if push came to shove I'd vote for Dave's gang but it would be purely as the best of a bad bunch scenario as I don't believe in many of their policies. Not a good reason to choose your next ruling party IMO.

And before you flame me, My dear old Dad put his life on the line many a time to defend my right to do so.......and would probably agree were he still alive. wink

branflakes

2,039 posts

269 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
RedLeicester said:
Skyrat said:
soapbox

I have to admit to having the smallest amount of contempt for people who do not vote. It took long enough for the average man in the street to get the vote and for people to not use it, well it sticks in my throat a little. There are people in certain countries that would love the chance to vote.

That's nothing, mind you, to the contempt I have for people who don't vote, and then sit and moan about the government doing this and that. Simply put, if you don't vote, you should STFU.

[/soapbox]
Couldn't agree more. Curious thing to do, but my parents encouraged me to the belief that it was my duty to vote - what I voted for was immaterial, but that voting was part of the fabric of our society.
Couldn't disagree more. Why should I not be allowed to complain about whatever party gets in because I refuse to use my (supposedly important) vote to show support for one of several parties who are all likely to be equally incompetent?

The Ben

1,623 posts

248 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
heaven forbid the monarchy might take over.... eek

Neil_H

15,418 posts

282 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
Mike400 said:
Einion Yrth said:
The politicians all vote, so NOBODY voting is never going to happen. It's a bit like asking what's north of the north pole.
I know that, im just asking what if they didnt?

It couldnt keep being a draw forever, someone would have to be put in power?
It won't and can't happen there is no real answer to the question. I imagine the Queen would get involved through some archaic law. But she wouldn't, because it won't happen.

It's like asking, if blind Aliens landed tonight, what TV channel would they prefer and why? Yes I KNOW they don't have eyes, but WHAT TV channel would they WATCH...

Deltaf01

1,512 posts

228 months

Thursday 24th July 2008
quotequote all
Skyrat said:
soapbox

I have to admit to having the smallest amount of contempt for people who do not vote.
Its known as freedom of choice.

Skyrat said:
It took long enough for the average man in the street to get the vote and for people to not use it, well it sticks in my throat a little.
Yeah okay fine. People using a vote that gets ignored is a fine democratic example.

Skyrat said:
There are people in certain countries that would love the chance to vote.
Well bully for them.

Skyrat said:
That's nothing, mind you, to the contempt I have for people who don't vote, and then sit and moan about the government doing this and that. Simply put, if you don't vote, you should STFU.

[/soapbox]
And that i take issue with.

You with superior ideals go out and vote for something that someone else dosent, because at the time it looked like a good idea to you but turned out not to be.
So who's the one should be held in contempt?
You for voting for a policy that rapes millions or someone who didnt vote because they didnt like THAT choice?

Its not as straight forward as youd like to think.
People who dont vote HAVE THAT RIGHT, and they also have the right to say " I DIDNT VOTE FOR THIS st- YOU DID!!!!"
So now, tell me, what was that you were saying about STFU?