Can a company debit your card without your authority?
Can a company debit your card without your authority?
Author
Discussion

maxrider

Original Poster:

2,481 posts

267 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
Just had my renewal for bike insurance.
I normally pay in full over the 'phone by credit card.

This year they've just sent me a letter that says they'll automatically deduct the amount at renewal date using the card details they took last year.

I'm not renewing as their quote is taking the piss, but even after calling them to say I'm not taking them up I'm not convinced I won't have a nasty shock on my statement and will then have all the ensuing hassle.

Surely a company cannot just use card details from a previous transaction to take payments as they see fit. Isn't that tantamount to fraud...?

confused

Fidgits

17,202 posts

260 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
they all do that sirwink

Justayellowbadge

37,057 posts

273 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
maxrider said:
Just had my renewal for bike insurance.
I normally pay in full over the 'phone by credit card.

This year they've just sent me a letter that says they'll automatically deduct the amount at renewal date using the card details they took last year.

I'm not renewing as their quote is taking the piss, but even after calling them to say I'm not taking them up I'm not convinced I won't have a nasty shock on my statement and will then have all the ensuing hassle.

Surely a company cannot just use card details from a previous transaction to take payments as they see fit. Isn't that tantamount to fraud...?

confused
No, it's perfectly standard.

HarryW

16,080 posts

300 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
Justayellowbadge said:
maxrider said:
Just had my renewal for bike insurance.
I normally pay in full over the 'phone by credit card.

This year they've just sent me a letter that says they'll automatically deduct the amount at renewal date using the card details they took last year.

I'm not renewing as their quote is taking the piss, but even after calling them to say I'm not taking them up I'm not convinced I won't have a nasty shock on my statement and will then have all the ensuing hassle.

Surely a company cannot just use card details from a previous transaction to take payments as they see fit. Isn't that tantamount to fraud...?

confused
No, it's perfectly standard.
but is it legal confused
I used to pay for an ISP via a debit card and then changed supplier. They continued to debit the card even though they didn't provide the service. It even got to the point that they were still debiting after the card expired and was updated. It was only then I noticed they'd taken a fair few months of money (small amount don't read ever line of statements, wrong I know). I maintain that was the banks liability post change of card, they disagreed frown.

King Herald

23,501 posts

247 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
HarryW said:
Justayellowbadge said:
maxrider said:
Just had my renewal for bike insurance.
I normally pay in full over the 'phone by credit card.

This year they've just sent me a letter that says they'll automatically deduct the amount at renewal date using the card details they took last year.

I'm not renewing as their quote is taking the piss, but even after calling them to say I'm not taking them up I'm not convinced I won't have a nasty shock on my statement and will then have all the ensuing hassle.

Surely a company cannot just use card details from a previous transaction to take payments as they see fit. Isn't that tantamount to fraud...?

confused
No, it's perfectly standard.
but is it legal confused
I used to pay for an ISP via a debit card and then changed supplier. They continued to debit the card even though they didn't provide the service. It even got to the point that they were still debiting after the card expired and was updated. It was only then I noticed they'd taken a fair few months of money (small amount don't read ever line of statements, wrong I know). I maintain that was the banks liability post change of card, they disagreed frown.
Mcafee virus scan people did that to my dad, kept renewing his subscription every year from his credit card, but the bank were unable to stop the process, told him Mcafee have to do it, and even if he cancels the card they will still chase him for the money. He had canceled his internet subscription, thus needed no virus scan, so had no e mail.

To phone Mcafee meant calling the USA on a pay line, $1.80 a minute and waiting upwards of 20 minutes (according to the message when he tried to call) to speak to someone.

Eventually he asked me and I e mailed them on his behalf telling them to shut it off.

It sounds feckin' ridiculous that you can't just stop someone taking money from your card like that, but the bank, HSBC told him that is the way it works when you have given permission to someone to make a regular charge.

maxrider

Original Poster:

2,481 posts

267 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
King Herald said:
It sounds feckin' ridiculous that you can't just stop someone taking money from your card like that, but the bank, HSBC told him that is the way it works when you have given permission to someone to make a regular charge.
But this isn't a regular charge. It has always been a one-off payment with card details given by 'phone.

I have never signed anything or given permission for them to take regular payments or set up any form of direct debit.

By this logic anyone I've given my card details to can just take whatever, whenever they want?

Toni896

2,188 posts

257 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
for ins, they will say it's in the T&C that you give them permission to renew.

the bit that says "we may renew" and "you should"
and if it's the little red phone people good luck.

sprinter885

11,550 posts

258 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
("Smart People")Budget-BISL did that with me this year. DESPITE the fact that they had rung me to say my card had expired & they couldn't take it. I was a bit slow in shopping round & did it with Prudential-via "Quidco" -SAVED over £100 !
Anyway I did get refund off BISL -less of course "Cancellation charge" but I still think it's wrong but I must have agreed to let them when I took it out.

P.S. NOTE to all -most good Card providers do have a "Disputed Payment" service. It's a bit long winded but should recover all the money if genuine. If I'd used that (didn't wait for them to send me forms) I would not have suffered the cancellation fee... lesson there.

Edited by sprinter885 on Friday 25th July 12:09

King Herald

23,501 posts

247 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
maxrider said:
King Herald said:
It sounds feckin' ridiculous that you can't just stop someone taking money from your card like that, but the bank, HSBC told him that is the way it works when you have given permission to someone to make a regular charge.
But this isn't a regular charge. It has always been a one-off payment with card details given by 'phone.

I have never signed anything or given permission for them to take regular payments or set up any form of direct debit.

By this logic anyone I've given my card details to can just take whatever, whenever they want?
They are just hoping you will not bother going to the trouble of looking elsewhere, and just let them bill you. It is all about sales.

If they take the money just contact the card company and report it has been taken illegally.

robm3

4,930 posts

258 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
I used to get this problem all the time when hiring cars in Ireland. I'd fill the tank up prior to dropping off (at the service station literally right next to the airport) and then they'd charge 20 odd euros on my card about three days later.
I had to argue with them directly at the desk every time I flew in (which was weekly) and in the end took to getting receipts and handing them in when I returned the keys.
It's just so easy to charge against a card when you have the number and there's so little we can do about it!

NWTony

3,011 posts

259 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
No they can't just take the money.

Your contract with them lasted eactly one year, after that you have no contract with them. Saying that "unless we hear differently, we'll take the amount from your card" is illegal, silence can not be inferred to be acceptance.

Or I'd just like to say everyone who reads this has to give me £50 unless you say you don't want to.


onlynik

4,279 posts

224 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
I use my Cahoot account for online stuff

They have a wee appication which generates a card number for you, which I can set the limit, and the expirey date is the end of the next month.

They'll never be able to use it more than once smile

Munter

31,331 posts

272 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
NWTony said:
No they can't just take the money.

Your contract with them lasted eactly one year, after that you have no contract with them. Saying that "unless we hear differently, we'll take the amount from your card" is illegal, silence can not be inferred to be acceptance.

Or I'd just like to say everyone who reads this has to give me £50 unless you say you don't want to.
Unless he said yes to automatic renewals.... Then would it not just be a regular payment open ended contract type thing....

maxrider

Original Poster:

2,481 posts

267 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
Munter said:
Unless he said yes to automatic renewals.... Then would it not just be a regular payment open ended contract type thing....
Nope, just a one-off transaction each year, the same as buying something off t'internet. "I want xxxx and my card details are xxxx" shouldn't give them carte blanche to deduct amounts when they feel like it.

Pigeon

18,535 posts

277 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
This sort of st is why I never use a card if I can send a postal order instead.

SS HSV

9,646 posts

289 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
Pigeon said:
This sort of st is why I live in the dark ages and send a postal order instead.
EFA hehe

Justayellowbadge

37,057 posts

273 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
Pigeon said:
This sort of st is why I never use a card if I can send a postal order instead.
They do cost a few extra shillings, though, the chap from the GPO tells me.