Council Nazis fine bloke for smoking in own vehicle
Discussion
http://uk.news.yahoo.com/pressass/20080725/tuk-han...
Beggars belief. I'm a non smoker but this is just bonkers. Britain really has become a Police state with council jobsworths to the fore, leading the fight to supress all forms of civil liberty. If you went back to 1948 and told George Orwell what personal freedoms have been removed in Browns Britain he would probably tell you to behave yourself and stop exaggerating.
Beggars belief. I'm a non smoker but this is just bonkers. Britain really has become a Police state with council jobsworths to the fore, leading the fight to supress all forms of civil liberty. If you went back to 1948 and told George Orwell what personal freedoms have been removed in Browns Britain he would probably tell you to behave yourself and stop exaggerating.
Edited by anonymous-user on Friday 25th July 11:47
I thought the rules stipluated that if the Vehicle was owned by the company or for commercial use then it was illegal? However from what I can gather the Van was owned by himself and merely used to arrive at his destination of work and therefore it is perfectly legal for him to smoke in his own van.
anonymous said:
[redacted]
I thought there was a getout if all the occupants of the vehicle are smokers (as in this case)Also how does a van beome a workplace? Is it becuase its a van? Becuase its signwritten? Does it depend on the ownership of the van, i.e it its owned by a Ltd company then its a work place, but if its owned by an individual it isnt?
In the unlikely event that I feel the need to by an Astramax and take up smoking, would I be committing an offence to smoke init, even if I wasn't using it as a working vehicle, just a load lugger?
Davi said:
anonymous said:
[redacted]
Just because it's a commercial vehicle doesn't mean it not private - I thought the law states that it's company vehicles where others have access to use?Commercial Vehicle is a term given to a panel van or such like. There is no law saying that a private individual can't use a panel van for personal use.
Actually, they're probably trying to pass that paper through parliament as we speak.


Edited by lazyitus on Friday 25th July 11:58
If he owned the van, then the world's gone loopy.
If the COMPANY owns the van, then whilst I don't agree with what's happened, I do agree he shouldn't be smoking in it.
I for one detest the smell; if I had to use that van the next day with the seats (and then my clothes) smelling, I would not be happy!
If the COMPANY owns the van, then whilst I don't agree with what's happened, I do agree he shouldn't be smoking in it.
I for one detest the smell; if I had to use that van the next day with the seats (and then my clothes) smelling, I would not be happy!
Heskey said:
If he owned the van, then the world's gone loopy.
If the COMPANY owns the van, then whilst I don't agree with what's happened, I do agree he shouldn't be smoking in it.
I for one detest the smell; if I had to use that van the next day with the seats (and then my clothes) smelling, I would not be happy!
What if he owned the company that owned the van and there was only him working for it...?If the COMPANY owns the van, then whilst I don't agree with what's happened, I do agree he shouldn't be smoking in it.
I for one detest the smell; if I had to use that van the next day with the seats (and then my clothes) smelling, I would not be happy!
Heskey said:
If he owned the van, then the world's gone loopy.
If the COMPANY owns the van, then whilst I don't agree with what's happened, I do agree he shouldn't be smoking in it.
I for one detest the smell; if I had to use that van the next day with the seats (and then my clothes) smelling, I would not be happy!
But even then - if the company owns the van, and he IS the company - what then? The ONLY pertinent issue is if anyone else has access to use, not ownership, not designated use, nothing.If the COMPANY owns the van, then whilst I don't agree with what's happened, I do agree he shouldn't be smoking in it.
I for one detest the smell; if I had to use that van the next day with the seats (and then my clothes) smelling, I would not be happy!
Who owns the vehicle doesnt matter - we have some guidance sent round here from time to time as we use our own cars for site visits etc.
If I have a collegue in my own privately owned car for work-purposes (i.e. on way to a site etc) I cant smoke.
Its there to protect non smokers. I dont smoke myself so do appreciate it when in someone elses motor and they dont light up.
However it was never an issue before these stupid laws, as any of the smokers in the office tended to use something called courtesy and not light up when they had someone in the car.
Besides we are requred to have own transport for the job so surely if they have a problem they should just use their own car?
Different kettle of fish if its a company owned vehicle but this wasnt. t
ts.
If I have a collegue in my own privately owned car for work-purposes (i.e. on way to a site etc) I cant smoke.
Its there to protect non smokers. I dont smoke myself so do appreciate it when in someone elses motor and they dont light up.
However it was never an issue before these stupid laws, as any of the smokers in the office tended to use something called courtesy and not light up when they had someone in the car.
Besides we are requred to have own transport for the job so surely if they have a problem they should just use their own car?
Different kettle of fish if its a company owned vehicle but this wasnt. t
ts.I can't get over this.
This is the state of Britain in 2008 !
Listen to us all arguing over something that's so irrelevant and has f
k all to do with any single one of us.
It's a sad state of affairs. We're a f
king pushover in this country. Namby Pamby Jelly Backboned idiots.
What can we do ??????
HELP
This is the state of Britain in 2008 !
Listen to us all arguing over something that's so irrelevant and has f
k all to do with any single one of us.It's a sad state of affairs. We're a f
king pushover in this country. Namby Pamby Jelly Backboned idiots.What can we do ??????
HELP
lazyitus said:
I can't get over this.
This is the state of Britain in 2008 !
Listen to us all arguing over something that's so irrelevant and has f
k all to do with any single one of us.
It's a sad state of affairs. We're a f
king pushover in this country. Namby Pamby Jelly Backboned idiots.
What can we do ??????
HELP
This is the state of Britain in 2008 !
Listen to us all arguing over something that's so irrelevant and has f
k all to do with any single one of us.It's a sad state of affairs. We're a f
king pushover in this country. Namby Pamby Jelly Backboned idiots.What can we do ??????
HELP


Heskey said:
But whether he's the boss or not; if other people are due to drive in it, then he shouldn't.
next question then...why not? Their health isn't going to be affected by a vehicle that has been smoked in previously. The only effect will be it smells.
So? It's his company, his employees. We've got a bloke upstairs that insists on eating Thai food every night. The stench after he's used the toilets is bad enough to make you gag - can I get the government to ban him eating Thai because I don't like the smell? What about the receptionist that likes to spend £3.50 per gallon on cheap nasty perfume that leaves your throat feeling like its had a chemical peel? can we get the gov't to ban that as well please?
Edited by Davi on Friday 25th July 12:20
Gassing Station | The Pie & Piston Archive | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


