Is it now economically sensible to reopen British Coal Pits?
Is it now economically sensible to reopen British Coal Pits?
Author
Discussion

minimax

Original Poster:

11,985 posts

287 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
I've been reading about EDF putting up energy prices by 22% or so, and quoting that coal (amongst other things) has increased in price by 70% in the the last year alone..

now, I seem to remember that the pits were closed by maggie because quite apart from the strawbs-loving commies not working efficiently, the price of coal was awful thus not profitable.

so.. even though our coal is supposedly high in sulphur and therefore less valuable, at what point does it become financially viable to reopen, re-equip and start digging again?

..and also, wouldn't it reduce energy costs if the coal for power stations was delivered from the local area?

just musing.. smile

s2art

18,942 posts

284 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
minimax said:
I've been reading about EDF putting up energy prices by 22% or so, and quoting that coal (amongst other things) has increased in price by 70% in the the last year alone..

now, I seem to remember that the pits were closed by maggie because quite apart from the strawbs-loving commies not working efficiently, the price of coal was awful thus not profitable.

so.. even though our coal is supposedly high in sulphur and therefore less valuable, at what point does it become financially viable to reopen, re-equip and start digging again?

..and also, wouldn't it reduce energy costs if the coal for power stations was delivered from the local area?

just musing.. smile
Yup. Coal is cheap relatively speaking. And its being looked at.

Yertis

19,741 posts

297 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
How expensive would oil have to become before steam locomotion once again becomes viable? Not having a car would be slightly compensated by having steam trains and traction engines charging all over the place.

Wacky Racer

41,418 posts

278 months

minimax

Original Poster:

11,985 posts

287 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
Yertis said:
How expensive would oil have to become before steam locomotion once again becomes viable? Not having a car would be slightly compensated by having steam trains and traction engines charging all over the place.
I refer to the fuelling of power stations, not throwing cars away.. this is a suggestion for the mitigation of high oil prices ..

jamiebae

6,245 posts

242 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
At the moment we ship coal from Poland (I think?) so given the increase in wages there, plus fuel prices rocketing it's probably not far off being viable to re-open mines here.

esselte

14,626 posts

298 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
jamiebae said:
At the moment we ship coal from Poland (I think?) so given the increase in wages there, plus fuel prices rocketing it's probably not far off being viable to re-open mines here.
It's not just a case of reopening though,most mines have been totally demolished and built over.I think it would mean starting from scratch.

cloggy

4,959 posts

240 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
Don't they have new technologies whereby they can liquidise coal to pump it up instead of mining it ?

Yertis

19,741 posts

297 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
minimax said:
Yertis said:
How expensive would oil have to become before steam locomotion once again becomes viable? Not having a car would be slightly compensated by having steam trains and traction engines charging all over the place.
I refer to the fuelling of power stations, not throwing cars away.. this is a suggestion for the mitigation of high oil prices ..
I know but one leads inevitably to the other. At some point a steam locomotive becomes cheaper to run than a diesel.

prand

6,246 posts

227 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
Please please please do this! This country has such a pathetically small primary industrial base, that we are now totally at the mercy of global economics and oil prices. Surely new, lean burn efficient power stations can be built which don't pollute as much and convert more of the raw material into power?

Who knows, opening up coal mines might make other heavy industries more viable in the UK too. How bizarre, a second coal based industrial revolution.



Timmy35

13,014 posts

229 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
minimax said:
now, I seem to remember that the pits were closed by maggie because quite apart from the strawbs-loving commies not working efficiently, the price of coal was awful thus not profitable.
Yes but closing the pits wasn't ever about economics it was about breaking the Unions.

Problem is all those shafts are flooded now. And alot of the skills required to mine have been lost, it was a father to son industry, that's all gone now. All South Wales and the Northern Coal towns have is several generations on the dole.


prand

6,246 posts

227 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
Although I guess the new mines will be owned by French/Indian/Spanish companies so the UK won't see the profit sit makes....

Munter

31,331 posts

272 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
prand said:
Please please please do this! This country has such a pathetically small primary industrial base, that we are now totally at the mercy of global economics and oil prices. Surely new, lean burn efficient power stations can be built which don't pollute as much and convert more of the raw material into power?

Who knows, opening up coal mines might make other heavy industries more viable in the UK too. How bizarre, a second coal based industrial revolution.
Depends a little on the Coal your feeding it, but yes they can be quite clean.

We can also turn the coal into oil and stick it in cars.....wink

minimax

Original Poster:

11,985 posts

287 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
Yertis said:
minimax said:
Yertis said:
How expensive would oil have to become before steam locomotion once again becomes viable? Not having a car would be slightly compensated by having steam trains and traction engines charging all over the place.
I refer to the fuelling of power stations, not throwing cars away.. this is a suggestion for the mitigation of high oil prices ..
I know but one leads inevitably to the other. At some point a steam locomotive becomes cheaper to run than a diesel.
ah! idea sorry, thought you were being a d!ckhead for some reason, seems the friday deadline stress has affected me.. steam engines would be cool! and would make train travel a bit more interesting smile


pugwash4x4

7,684 posts

252 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
Timmy35 said:
minimax said:
now, I seem to remember that the pits were closed by maggie because quite apart from the strawbs-loving commies not working efficiently, the price of coal was awful thus not profitable.
Yes but closing the pits wasn't ever about economics it was about breaking the Unions.
Not strictly true that statement though- subsidies were a wonderful thing!

Wouldn't it make sense to use up all our neighbours natural resources until we were truly desperate and then start using our own- at least then we would have some reserves in case of conflict!

minimax

Original Poster:

11,985 posts

287 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
esselte said:
jamiebae said:
At the moment we ship coal from Poland (I think?) so given the increase in wages there, plus fuel prices rocketing it's probably not far off being viable to re-open mines here.
It's not just a case of reopening though,most mines have been totally demolished and built over.I think it would mean starting from scratch.
aren't there still quite a few (20+) coal mines in Britain? i'm sure there are at least 2 in my beautiful homeland (northumberland biggrin) par example..

sleep envy

62,260 posts

280 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
Timmy35 said:
Problem is all those shafts are flooded now
that's what I though made it economically unviable - would cost more to pump them than the profit generated from the sale of mined coal

esselte

14,626 posts

298 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
minimax said:
esselte said:
jamiebae said:
At the moment we ship coal from Poland (I think?) so given the increase in wages there, plus fuel prices rocketing it's probably not far off being viable to re-open mines here.
It's not just a case of reopening though,most mines have been totally demolished and built over.I think it would mean starting from scratch.
aren't there still quite a few (20+) coal mines in Britain? i'm sure there are at least 2 in my beautiful homeland (northumberland biggrin) par example..
I think UK Coal has about 6 mines, who has the rest?

Gimlet

328 posts

313 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
It will not be viable to reopen the vast majority of UK Pits.
My father was involved in several closures during the 80's and millions of £'s worth of equipment and machines were left underground as it was considered too costly to retrieve them, this included pumping equipment.
At the time the Pits were then closed the pumps were just switched off so any old workings that have not collapsed are likely to be flooded.
At one Pit in Warwickshire water was actually sold back to Severn Trent.

Many shafts were filled in, as were many tunnels.
Those tunnels not filled in will have collapsed, and anyone who remembers the "dips" on the M6 between Corley Services and the M42 from 4/5 years a go will know of the effect on the surface.

However, this said, there is no reason why new Pits cannot be sunk and coal mined.
There are vast reserves of coal still to be mined in this country, one of the largest seams being on the Oxfordshire/Warwickshire border.

s2art

18,942 posts

284 months

Friday 25th July 2008
quotequote all
sleep envy said:
Timmy35 said:
Problem is all those shafts are flooded now
that's what I though made it economically unviable - would cost more to pump them than the profit generated from the sale of mined coal
Thay may not be true any more. Depends how much oil and gas cost.