Monarchy or Republic - the poll
Poll: Monarchy or Republic - the poll
Total Members Polled: 169
Discussion
My appallingly socialist view: at least cut her down by one palace.
Chuck her out to Windsor; take Buck House off her and convert it to luxury flats and sell at an outrageous price; use resulting cash to build both affordable (joint-ownership) housing for 'key workers' (AKA those we depend on but don't pay enough to) and a load of hostels for the homeless.
Chuck her out to Windsor; take Buck House off her and convert it to luxury flats and sell at an outrageous price; use resulting cash to build both affordable (joint-ownership) housing for 'key workers' (AKA those we depend on but don't pay enough to) and a load of hostels for the homeless.
claypigeon60 said:
... a load of hostels for the homeless.
Then who will sell the Big Issue? The magazine will go bust putting people out of work and on the streets because the hostels are all full of the homeless YOU put there.That's the trouble with you lot. Never think things through.
;)
escargot said:
Monarchy for sure.
Despite the (minimal) cost for the tax payer, it's part of our heritage and that in itself is worth preserving. From a financial point of view, the revenue they bring in to the economy from tourism alone probably eclipses any cost to us.
What e said.Despite the (minimal) cost for the tax payer, it's part of our heritage and that in itself is worth preserving. From a financial point of view, the revenue they bring in to the economy from tourism alone probably eclipses any cost to us.
keep good old Queenie (and no I'm not talking about Mr. Barrowman, Slikk).
As a cultural/historical thing it may have its place and admirers.
On the other hand, in the year 2008 in a modern world of democracy and equality, is it really acceptable that one family is to be worshipped solely for the sake of being of royal ancestry?
In what meaning are they worth any more, or less, than you or me?
On the other hand, in the year 2008 in a modern world of democracy and equality, is it really acceptable that one family is to be worshipped solely for the sake of being of royal ancestry?
In what meaning are they worth any more, or less, than you or me?
escargot said:
Monarchy for sure.
Despite the (minimal) cost for the tax payer, it's part of our heritage and that in itself is worth preserving. From a financial point of view, the revenue they bring in to the economy from tourism alone probably eclipses any cost to us.
Well it's the common argument from Royalists; but the common counter-argument is that no-one has stopped visiting France because they got rid of their royalty.Despite the (minimal) cost for the tax payer, it's part of our heritage and that in itself is worth preserving. From a financial point of view, the revenue they bring in to the economy from tourism alone probably eclipses any cost to us.
Let's be honest, we're talking about Americans here - for the most part they think we all live in castles. It makes me cringe how some US films portray the UK (seen Three Men and a Little Lady?)
Finlandia said:
As a cultural/historical thing it may have its place and admirers.
On the other hand, in the year 2008 in a modern world of democracy and equality, is it really acceptable that one family is to be worshipped solely for the sake of being of royal ancestry?
In what meaning are they worth any more, or less, than you or me?
Its the institution rather than the family. Forget the personalities for a moment, the monarch is merely the personification of the crown.On the other hand, in the year 2008 in a modern world of democracy and equality, is it really acceptable that one family is to be worshipped solely for the sake of being of royal ancestry?
In what meaning are they worth any more, or less, than you or me?
Finlandia said:
As a cultural/historical thing it may have its place and admirers.
On the other hand, in the year 2008 in a modern world of democracy and equality, is it really acceptable that one family is to be worshipped solely for the sake of being of royal ancestry?
In what meaning are they worth any more, or less, than you or me?
I am all for the Monarchy.On the other hand, in the year 2008 in a modern world of democracy and equality, is it really acceptable that one family is to be worshipped solely for the sake of being of royal ancestry?
In what meaning are they worth any more, or less, than you or me?
They are probably more relevant today than yesteryear, simply by the fact that they occupy a position that otherwise a politician would occupy. They uphold a very successful limbo.
Who worships the royal family !? I dont, i think most are planks. I have no idea, on a personal level, who the Queen is and neither do i care, so long as she acts in the impeccable public manner that she has done for the last near-60 years on the throne.
Who says they are worth any more !? I dont.
s2art said:
Finlandia said:
As a cultural/historical thing it may have its place and admirers.
On the other hand, in the year 2008 in a modern world of democracy and equality, is it really acceptable that one family is to be worshipped solely for the sake of being of royal ancestry?
In what meaning are they worth any more, or less, than you or me?
Its the institution rather than the family. Forget the personalities for a moment, the monarch is merely the personification of the crown.On the other hand, in the year 2008 in a modern world of democracy and equality, is it really acceptable that one family is to be worshipped solely for the sake of being of royal ancestry?
In what meaning are they worth any more, or less, than you or me?
Gassing Station | The Pie & Piston Archive | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff





