Treatment of POWs
Author
Discussion

armynick

Original Poster:

631 posts

292 months

Sunday 27th July 2008
quotequote all
Not allowed to hood POWs or put them into stress positions? How pathetic, whatever next?

"Hands up, would you like a cup of tea, like to see our maps? Maybe you'd like some compensation and by the way sorry to have ruined your day, in fact have a passport with your cake"

fking bks! We were always taught to put a hood (blindfold) on etc etc. There's a very good reason. They are prisoners of war! It'll be against the law to take prisoners next. "Arwfully sorry old chap, just turn around and go home".

In fact when will they make it against human rights to shoot people? Better still, just don't take prisoners, shoot them on the spot, then there will be no arguing about putting a hood over their heads or making them sit in uncomfortable positions. Poor dears.

Get a grip.

drivin_me_nuts

17,949 posts

242 months

Sunday 27th July 2008
quotequote all
armynick said:
Not allowed to hood POWs or put them into stress positions? How pathetic, whatever next?

"Hands up, would you like a cup of tea, like to see our maps? Maybe you'd like some compensation and by the way sorry to have ruined your day, in fact have a passport with your cake"

fking bks! We were always taught to put a hood (blindfold) on etc etc. There's a very good reason. They are prisoners of war! It'll be against the law to take prisoners next. "Arwfully sorry old chap, just turn around and go home".

In fact when will they make it against human rights to shoot people? Better still, just don't take prisoners, shoot them on the spot, then there will be no arguing about putting a hood over their heads or making them sit in uncomfortable positions. Poor dears.

Get a grip.
needless to say, you would be the first to squeal like a stuck pig when there was some picture in the Wail of one of 'our boys' (or girls come to that) in a similar position.

MarkK

667 posts

310 months

Sunday 27th July 2008
quotequote all
armynick said:
Not allowed to hood POWs or put them into stress positions? How pathetic, whatever next?

"Hands up, would you like a cup of tea, like to see our maps? Maybe you'd like some compensation and by the way sorry to have ruined your day, in fact have a passport with your cake"

fking bks! We were always taught to put a hood (blindfold) on etc etc. There's a very good reason. They are prisoners of war! It'll be against the law to take prisoners next. "Arwfully sorry old chap, just turn around and go home".

In fact when will they make it against human rights to shoot people? Better still, just don't take prisoners, shoot them on the spot, then there will be no arguing about putting a hood over their heads or making them sit in uncomfortable positions. Poor dears.

Get a grip.
It's called the Geneva convention and it ensures our POWs welfare as much as the oppositions.

hugoagogo

23,438 posts

264 months

Sunday 27th July 2008
quotequote all
are there actually any 'proper wars' going on anywhere? with official government troops on both sides?

Battenburg Bob

8,857 posts

223 months

Sunday 27th July 2008
quotequote all
I don't think putting someone in an orange suit and beheading them falls under the Geneva Convention.

Edited by Battenburg Bob on Sunday 27th July 13:29

armynick

Original Poster:

631 posts

292 months

Sunday 27th July 2008
quotequote all
drivin_me_nuts said:
armynick said:
Not allowed to hood POWs or put them into stress positions? How pathetic, whatever next?

"Hands up, would you like a cup of tea, like to see our maps? Maybe you'd like some compensation and by the way sorry to have ruined your day, in fact have a passport with your cake"

fking bks! We were always taught to put a hood (blindfold) on etc etc. There's a very good reason. They are prisoners of war! It'll be against the law to take prisoners next. "Arwfully sorry old chap, just turn around and go home".

In fact when will they make it against human rights to shoot people? Better still, just don't take prisoners, shoot them on the spot, then there will be no arguing about putting a hood over their heads or making them sit in uncomfortable positions. Poor dears.

Get a grip.
needless to say, you would be the first to squeal like a stuck pig when there was some picture in the Wail of one of 'our boys' (or girls come to that) in a similar position.
No I wouldn't. You sign up, you go to war, you know the risk involved. It's not nice but it's reality. You're put through a certain amount of training in the forces to expect this kind of training. being hooded and roughed up, is all part of the norm.

Also how can you say I would squeal about it when you don't even know me? It's like me saying you're a spineless desk jocky who's never been in the military and talks st.

armynick

Original Poster:

631 posts

292 months

Sunday 27th July 2008
quotequote all
And it's not against the geneva convention.....look it up!

drivin_me_nuts

17,949 posts

242 months

Sunday 27th July 2008
quotequote all
armynick said:
drivin_me_nuts said:
armynick said:
Not allowed to hood POWs or put them into stress positions? How pathetic, whatever next?

"Hands up, would you like a cup of tea, like to see our maps? Maybe you'd like some compensation and by the way sorry to have ruined your day, in fact have a passport with your cake"

fking bks! We were always taught to put a hood (blindfold) on etc etc. There's a very good reason. They are prisoners of war! It'll be against the law to take prisoners next. "Arwfully sorry old chap, just turn around and go home".

In fact when will they make it against human rights to shoot people? Better still, just don't take prisoners, shoot them on the spot, then there will be no arguing about putting a hood over their heads or making them sit in uncomfortable positions. Poor dears.

Get a grip.
needless to say, you would be the first to squeal like a stuck pig when there was some picture in the Wail of one of 'our boys' (or girls come to that) in a similar position.
No I wouldn't. You sign up, you go to war, you know the risk involved. It's not nice but it's reality. You're put through a certain amount of training in the forces to expect this kind of training. being hooded and roughed up, is all part of the norm.

Also how can you say I would squeal about it when you don't even know me? It's like me saying you're a spineless desk jocky who's never been in the military and talks st.
... which in some part might well be true. No offence meant, it was a figure of speech that went too far, so apologies for that.

But even in war there must be some protocol to follow otherwise there would just be the return to group massacres and general butchery on a grand scale. There has to be limit in what is deemed acceptable - even in war and that limit changes from time to time.

Timsta

2,779 posts

277 months

Sunday 27th July 2008
quotequote all
armynick said:
And it's not against the geneva convention.....look it up!
I did...


Geneva Convention Article 17 said:
...
No physical or mental torture, nor any other form of coercion, may be inflicted on prisoners of war to secure from them information of any kind whatever. Prisoners of war who refuse to answer may not be threatened, insulted, or exposed to any unpleasant or disadvantageous treatment of any kind.
...

groucho

12,134 posts

277 months

Sunday 27th July 2008
quotequote all
Timsta said:
I did...


Geneva Convention Article 17 said:
...
No physical or mental torture, nor any other form of coercion, may be inflicted on prisoners of war to secure from them information of any kind whatever. Prisoners of war who refuse to answer may not be threatened, insulted, or exposed to any unpleasant or disadvantageous treatment of any kind.
...
What a load of st! War is nasty.

paoloh

8,617 posts

235 months

Sunday 27th July 2008
quotequote all
Timsta said:
armynick said:
And it's not against the geneva convention.....look it up!
I did...


Geneva Convention Article 17 said:
...
No physical or mental torture, nor any other form of coercion, may be inflicted on prisoners of war to secure from them information of any kind whatever. Prisoners of war who refuse to answer may not be threatened, insulted, or exposed to any unpleasant or disadvantageous treatment of any kind.
...
Please tell me where the bomb is? NO. Ok, off you go...... It's war and it's them or us.

We put a hood on smoeone, who gives a fk, they behead our prisoners.

Semi hemi

1,801 posts

229 months

Sunday 27th July 2008
quotequote all
groucho said:
Timsta said:
I did...


Geneva Convention Article 17 said:
...
No physical or mental torture, nor any other form of coercion, may be inflicted on prisoners of war to secure from them information of any kind whatever. Prisoners of war who refuse to answer may not be threatened, insulted, or exposed to any unpleasant or disadvantageous treatment of any kind.
...
What a load of st! War is nasty.
of course war is "nasty" but genocide is totally unacceptable, Just look at whenever the military get to run the show and basic human rights go out the window.
the dissapeared in South/Central America, the massacares in Ruwanda, Bosnia, Martial law is brutal and I for one would not be happy living under it. I guess it would be different if you were the ones in charge, bit of rape and pillage whenever the fancy takes you and if anyone disagrees, you just kill them.

groucho

12,134 posts

277 months

Sunday 27th July 2008
quotequote all
A bit of a leap from a hood to genocide.

biglepton

5,042 posts

232 months

Sunday 27th July 2008
quotequote all
armynick said:
Not allowed to hood POWs or put them into stress positions? How pathetic, whatever next?

"Hands up, would you like a cup of tea, like to see our maps? Maybe you'd like some compensation and by the way sorry to have ruined your day, in fact have a passport with your cake"

fking bks! We were always taught to put a hood (blindfold) on etc etc. There's a very good reason. They are prisoners of war! It'll be against the law to take prisoners next. "Arwfully sorry old chap, just turn around and go home".

In fact when will they make it against human rights to shoot people? Better still, just don't take prisoners, shoot them on the spot, then there will be no arguing about putting a hood over their heads or making them sit in uncomfortable positions. Poor dears.

Get a grip.
I've also served my country and as you have, I'm surprised you don't understand the status quo. Squaddies have to stick to the rules when it comes to treatment of prisoners so the government of the day can take the moral high ground and if there is any dirty work to do with regards to prisoners they are given to the spooks who are not governed by such rules. The remfs back home may not understand the sharp end of fighting, but they do understand that Islamic nutters are not your common or garden variety prisoners.

r1ot

733 posts

239 months

Sunday 27th July 2008
quotequote all
The geneva convention only applies if you are a legal combatant fighting under a countries flag. A terrorist is a mercenary and they are not protected under the geneva convention, only basic human rights.

besides fk 'em they have no respect for human life in general and if they get caught it's their own look out, at least we don't cut their heads off with a bread knife and post it on the internet.

armynick

Original Poster:

631 posts

292 months

Sunday 27th July 2008
quotequote all
No worries old chap, no offence taken.

The practice of Hooding is primarly a simple method of blindfolding someone in order that they can't see the layout of our military camps, what troops and equipment are around them and obviously to prevent them from spotting an escape exit etc.

The stress positions are designed to prevent them from jumping up and running off. Most of the stress positions are designed so that you can't just "run off" as you would have to make one or two movements of your body to get into a position in order to move i.e stand up or unwrap your legs etc.

Both also have the bonus that they can confuse and disorientate the prisoner which aids in keeping him subdued or when it comes to questioning.

Is this classed as physical or mental torure? Is shouting at someone? Pointing a gun at them? Grabbing them by the scruff of the neck? Locking them up in a cell? Taking them prisoner in the first place?

You have to draw the line. It's not against the Geneva convention to hood or blindfold prisoners. The British Army, as have all the others, have always taught it and it's normal procedure. It's not torture.

Giving them a kicking while all this is going on is a different matter.

Fittster

20,120 posts

244 months

Sunday 27th July 2008
quotequote all
armynick said:
Not allowed to hood POWs or put them into stress positions? How pathetic, whatever next?
What people are allowed to do and what they actually do are different matters. It's not as if anyone in the British army is going to be found guilty if they ignore the rules.

It only seems logical that we should treat prisoners in the same way as we would want our troops treated if captured.

paoloh

8,617 posts

235 months

Sunday 27th July 2008
quotequote all
Fittster said:
armynick said:
Not allowed to hood POWs or put them into stress positions? How pathetic, whatever next?
What people are allowed to do and what they actually do are different matters. It's not as if anyone in the British army is going to be found guilty if they ignore the rules.

It only seems logical that we should treat prisoners in the same way as we would want our troops treated if captured.
Have you not watched the News for the past 10 years???

Fittster

20,120 posts

244 months

Sunday 27th July 2008
quotequote all
paoloh said:
Fittster said:
armynick said:
Not allowed to hood POWs or put them into stress positions? How pathetic, whatever next?
What people are allowed to do and what they actually do are different matters. It's not as if anyone in the British army is going to be found guilty if they ignore the rules.

It only seems logical that we should treat prisoners in the same way as we would want our troops treated if captured.
Have you not watched the News for the past 10 years???
Please point to a case where a soldiers has been found guilty of an offence.

Breadbasket

Prisoners beaten, forced to strip and simulate sex in May 2003. Subject of damages claim by 11 of the victims.

Abu Naji

Twenty Iraqi civilians allegedly executed at British base in Abu Naji in May 2004. Five survivors bringing a claim for damages.

Jabbir Hmoud Kammash

70-year-old tribal leader is bringing action over claims he was hooded and beaten during a raid at his home in Basra in April last year.

Ahmer Jabbar Kareem and Ayad Salim Hanoon

Teenagers forced to swim a canal, resulting in the drowning of Kareem, 15. Kareem's father and Hanoon are pursuing a claim for damages.

Hassan's statement: 'They enjoyed abusing us'

At 7am my friends convinced me to head towards Camp Breadbasket in order to steal dried milk cartons in order to sell them on the black market. The hangars were surrounded by a high fence, though there was an opening in the fence. Next to the fence there was a road, then a river.

When we tried to leave the hangars via the opening in the fence British soldiers chased us. We tried to run away but were caught. Some Iraqis managed to escape arrest. I believe some may have drowned as they were trying to escape the British.

British soldiers caught me and started beating me and others using their vehicle's aerials. They were beating us very harshly. We were led inside the hangars while still being beaten all the way. The beating became stronger when we were inside the camp. I was kept in a hangar along with four other Iraqis.

They ordered us to take off our clothes by gesturing to us to do so. When we refused they continued beating us, so we had to follow their orders. They made us sit on each other's laps. I was with one of the detainees, while another two detainees were made to do the same thing, as in the photos. They were enjoying humiliating and abusing us. I wished I was dead at this moment. Then they made me sit with Tariq as in the other photo, where I was forced to put Tariq's penis in my mouth. The other two were made to do the same.

They locked the hangar while we were inside and left us there with no food or drink till the afternoon of the day after, when they opened the hangar and let us go. Since then I fled Basra altogether as I cannot see Tariq again after what had happened, despite the fact that we were close friends.

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/bri...

If people aren't breaking the rules why are we paying compensation??

paoloh

8,617 posts

235 months

Sunday 27th July 2008
quotequote all
Fittster said:
paoloh said:
Fittster said:
armynick said:
Not allowed to hood POWs or put them into stress positions? How pathetic, whatever next?
What people are allowed to do and what they actually do are different matters. It's not as if anyone in the British army is going to be found guilty if they ignore the rules.

It only seems logical that we should treat prisoners in the same way as we would want our troops treated if captured.
Have you not watched the News for the past 10 years???
Please point to a case where a soldiers has been found guilty of an offence.

Breadbasket

Prisoners beaten, forced to strip and simulate sex in May 2003. Subject of damages claim by 11 of the victims.

Abu Naji

Twenty Iraqi civilians allegedly executed at British base in Abu Naji in May 2004. Five survivors bringing a claim for damages.

Jabbir Hmoud Kammash

70-year-old tribal leader is bringing action over claims he was hooded and beaten during a raid at his home in Basra in April last year.

Ahmer Jabbar Kareem and Ayad Salim Hanoon

Teenagers forced to swim a canal, resulting in the drowning of Kareem, 15. Kareem's father and Hanoon are pursuing a claim for damages.

Hassan's statement: 'They enjoyed abusing us'

At 7am my friends convinced me to head towards Camp Breadbasket in order to steal dried milk cartons in order to sell them on the black market. The hangars were surrounded by a high fence, though there was an opening in the fence. Next to the fence there was a road, then a river.

When we tried to leave the hangars via the opening in the fence British soldiers chased us. We tried to run away but were caught. Some Iraqis managed to escape arrest. I believe some may have drowned as they were trying to escape the British.

British soldiers caught me and started beating me and others using their vehicle's aerials. They were beating us very harshly. We were led inside the hangars while still being beaten all the way. The beating became stronger when we were inside the camp. I was kept in a hangar along with four other Iraqis.

They ordered us to take off our clothes by gesturing to us to do so. When we refused they continued beating us, so we had to follow their orders. They made us sit on each other's laps. I was with one of the detainees, while another two detainees were made to do the same thing, as in the photos. They were enjoying humiliating and abusing us. I wished I was dead at this moment. Then they made me sit with Tariq as in the other photo, where I was forced to put Tariq's penis in my mouth. The other two were made to do the same.

They locked the hangar while we were inside and left us there with no food or drink till the afternoon of the day after, when they opened the hangar and let us go. Since then I fled Basra altogether as I cannot see Tariq again after what had happened, despite the fact that we were close friends.

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/bri...

If people aren't breaking the rules why are we paying compensation??
And who compensates our boys and civilians???