Are Qantas starting a trend?
Are Qantas starting a trend?
Author
Discussion

TheCarpetCleaner

Original Poster:

7,294 posts

233 months

Monday 28th July 2008
quotequote all
Now another one...Fault forces Qantas plane to land

A Qantas passenger plane has been forced to make an emergency landing in Adelaide, Australia, due to a mechanical fault.

Local news reports say the pilot told passengers there was a problem with one of the landing gear doors.

A Qantas spokeswoman said there was no risk to passengers' safety at any time.

The incident comes three days after a Qantas plane made an emergency landing in the Philippines after a large hole appeared in its fuselage.

A Qantas spokeswoman told The Canberra Times website that a Melbourne-bound Boeing 737-800 returned to Adelaide shortly after take-off on Monday night because it was believed one of the landing gear doors had failed to retract.


Source - http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/asia-pacific/7529...


Tad worrying? Or just really unfortunate co-incidence?

randomman

2,215 posts

220 months

Monday 28th July 2008
quotequote all
Is it true that they are the only airline of their size/age that have never had a fatality?

lazyitus

19,931 posts

297 months

Monday 28th July 2008
quotequote all
To be fair, this sort of thing isn't that uncommon. It's hit the headlines because of the incident the other day.

If that hadn't happened, you'd never know about this unless you were on the plane.

cronk-flakes

3,480 posts

284 months

Monday 28th July 2008
quotequote all
randomman said:
Is it true that they are the only airline of their size/age that have never had a fatality?
They have a blemish-free record AFAIK. But staff/passengers could die in other ways while flying. hehe

mackie1

8,169 posts

264 months

Monday 28th July 2008
quotequote all
Yup, for example did anyone hear about the plane that got tipped on it's tale at Mallaga airport a week ago? Not unless you're on pprune you didn't.


gazza_3

6,442 posts

239 months

Monday 28th July 2008
quotequote all
A nose door being stuck open, wouldn't cause an emergency landing.

Deva Link

26,934 posts

276 months

Monday 28th July 2008
quotequote all
cronk-flakes said:
randomman said:
Is it true that they are the only airline of their size/age that have never had a fatality?
They have a blemish-free record AFAIK. But staff/passengers could die in other ways while flying. hehe
Only on jets - note the jet bit is always stressed, as they loads in the early days.

Eric Mc

125,934 posts

296 months

Monday 28th July 2008
quotequote all
NO trend.

What happens is that once a main story breaks, the media then hops on every vaguely related story. Expect loads of reports of bits fallinmg off aeroplanes for the next week or so.

No different to "dangerous dogs" or "stabbing" stories. The media is one giant bandwagon and will only stop reporting a parcticular "story" when they themselves get bored with it.

TheCarpetCleaner

Original Poster:

7,294 posts

233 months

Monday 28th July 2008
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
NO trend.

What happens is that once a main story breaks, the media then hops on every vaguely related story. Expect loads of reports of bits fallinmg off aeroplanes for the next week or so.

No different to "dangerous dogs" or "stabbing" stories. The media is one giant bandwagon and will only stop reporting a parcticular "story" when they themselves get bored with it.
I agree, however it is a bit of a co-incidence that two of the same companies planes go wrong within a very short time - unlike the random stabbing or dog stories which are not company specific.

If it was a American Airlines flight or something I would be inclined to agree.

Eric Mc

125,934 posts

296 months

Monday 28th July 2008
quotequote all
There may have been other "bits falling off plane" incidents but perhaps the media have just highlighted the Qantas one - for obvious reasons?

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 28th July 2008
quotequote all
"Emergency landing" due to gear doors not closing. What complete rubbish.

Loads of U.K. airlines have diverted due to technical problems this week and none of it is reported.

signia

479 posts

255 months

Monday 28th July 2008
quotequote all
I believe Qantas and Singapore Airlines have the best records. Can't remember the exact stats off hand, but I think SIA are actually just ahead of Qantas in the "incident" stakes. There is a difference in how "accidents" and "incidents" are recorded.

The alleged oxy cylinder sounds like a bit of a fluke to me. There are thousands of these things flying around in aircraft. They are regularly sent for testing / refilling. I wouldn't be suprised if it's happened before on board an aircraft with less drastic results.

As someone else said - the landing gear door isn't even worth commenting on - other than the fact that it's another Qantas related story. Stuff fails on aircraft all the time and most of the time you wouldn't know. There's so much redundancy built into most of the aircraft, if something fails, there's usually an auxiliary which kicks in. The aircraft doesn't need that much of what it has to fly/land safely either.

thehawk

9,335 posts

238 months

Monday 28th July 2008
quotequote all
signia said:
I believe Qantas and Singapore Airlines have the best records. Can't remember the exact stats off hand, but I think SIA are actually just ahead of Qantas in the "incident" stakes. There is a difference in how "accidents" and "incidents" are recorded.
Singapore have had a couple of accidents.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Singapore_Airlines_Fl...
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SilkAir_Flight_185





Edited by thehawk on Monday 28th July 19:04

Flintstone

8,644 posts

278 months

Monday 28th July 2008
quotequote all
cronk-flakes said:
randomman said:
Is it true that they are the only airline of their size/age that have never had a fatality?
They have a blemish-free record AFAIK. But staff/passengers could die in other ways while flying. hehe
No no no. This bl00dy myth keeps popping up. I blame that window licker Dustin Hoffman mad

While it is true that QANTAS has never lost a jet they had their fair share of hull losses and deaths in the early days the last one being (I think) a flying boat in the 50's.

matchmaker

9,091 posts

231 months

Monday 28th July 2008
quotequote all
Flintstone said:
cronk-flakes said:
randomman said:
Is it true that they are the only airline of their size/age that have never had a fatality?
They have a blemish-free record AFAIK. But staff/passengers could die in other ways while flying. hehe
No no no. This bl00dy myth keeps popping up. I blame that window licker Dustin Hoffman mad

While it is true that QANTAS has never lost a jet they had their fair share of hull losses and deaths in the early days the last one being (I think) a flying boat in the 50's.
Aren't Quantas the oldest airline in the world?

Flintstone

8,644 posts

278 months

Monday 28th July 2008
quotequote all
KLM I believe.

Flintstone

8,644 posts

278 months

Monday 28th July 2008
quotequote all
matchmaker said:
Flintstone said:
cronk-flakes said:
randomman said:
Is it true that they are the only airline of their size/age that have never had a fatality?
They have a blemish-free record AFAIK. But staff/passengers could die in other ways while flying. hehe
No no no. This bl00dy myth keeps popping up. I blame that window licker Dustin Hoffman mad

While it is true that QANTAS has never lost a jet they had their fair share of hull losses and deaths in the early days the last one being (I think) a flying boat in the 50's.
Aren't Quantas the oldest airline in the world?
Edit: The flying boat was in the 40's. Last recorded fatality was a Drover in 1951.

signia

479 posts

255 months

Monday 28th July 2008
quotequote all
thehawk said:
Yes, after SIA's crash in 2000, Qantas are ahead of SIA in the "fatal accident" count. I don't think they've ever lost an aircraft in an accident, but not sure about the fatalities mentioned about 50 years ago. See here. http://aviation-safety.net/database/operator/airli... Doesn't look like they were on passenger aircraft?

I think SIA manage to not include the SilkAir one in their own stats smile

Incidents are different. I think SIA have had fewer per x/ million flying miles or something. Could probably find the stats at work.




Flintstone

8,644 posts

278 months

Monday 28th July 2008
quotequote all

signia

479 posts

255 months

Monday 28th July 2008
quotequote all
Flintstone said:
Ah, that will be because they seem to only report jet airliners now. I guess that's more relevant to the modern aircraft age.

However, both SIA's and Qantas' records are outstanding. They have very specific maintenance requirements which often go above the norm. For example, neither Qantas nor SIA allow the use of 3rd party components in their repairs by default. They've both been known to pay extra / wait longer to have their own unit returned rather than one from a "pool" which could have been from another airline. They don't allow certain repairs to be carried out, which I know other airlines accept.

Not saying whether that's good/bad/related to incidents/etc. And they could save a lot of money by adopting some cheaper repairs on their components. They are also very particular as to who touches their units as far as repairs / exchanges etc go.