Should having Dyslexia mean easier exams?
Should having Dyslexia mean easier exams?
Author
Discussion

Smiler.

Original Poster:

11,752 posts

261 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
Er, a bit worrying I think.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/7530159.stm

I would question whether a dyslexic should be in the medical profession.

thehawk

9,335 posts

238 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
Couldn't they just use numbers?

Olf

11,978 posts

249 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
The young lady in question was on Radio 4 this morning saying that a patient does not present a GP with a list of problems and then ask the Dr which one is the right answer (for answer, read 'diagnosis').

Funny that - I thought that was exactly what patients did do!

Whilst I have no objection to a dyslexic Doctor, they should be capable of logical reasoning in a variety different scenarios. Clearly, no two patients present their symptoms in the same way. If a Dr does not have the ability to diagnose through this variety of presentation then they have no place as a GP or medical practitioner.

IMO.


Edited by Olf on Tuesday 29th July 08:50

AngryS3Owner

15,855 posts

260 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
What a load of garbage, you can still read the question and choose the appropriate answer. As in most cases Dyslexics have been given extra time in written exams (as I was in the past) which I think is fair, however that just seems stupid.

Munter

31,331 posts

272 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
I'd have thought a full written paper was worse if her level of dyslexia was bad enough that she cant see 4 or 5 roundels in a row and get them in the correct order.

Don

28,378 posts

315 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
PC st. I hope it gets buried quickly. I'm not sure I want a Doctor treating me that can't read the godamned prescription they just wrote.

Oh. That's all of them. Oops.





For the record. I have mild Dyslexia. And I program your computers. evil

zcacogp

11,239 posts

275 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
No, it fvcking shouldn't. Exams should test real-world ability, and if the doctor in question (who was indeed on R4 this morning) cannot perform as well in the real world (which she admitted she couldn't, on account of her dyslexia) then they shouldn't be allowed any leeway in the exams.

Picture the scene. Your child is in a hospital bed, in desperate need of the best possible medical care. Dyslexic Doc comes up, mis-treats your child on account of his/her dyslexia and child dies. But this is perfectly OK because they had the exams system fiddled to allow them to pass and thus become a doctor.


Oli.

plasticpig

12,932 posts

256 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
Don said:
For the record. I have mild Dyslexia. And I program your computers. evil
Ha I am severely dyslexic and am in the same line of work. I am not sure what her problem is. If she has problems reading the questions then she would have problems reading any exam question. The simple answer would be for the questions and answers to be done verbally with an individual invigilator. I was allowed to use a word processor to do exams twenty years ago. I would have thought things would have moved on by now so its common practice.

randomman

2,215 posts

220 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
I thought dyslexia had a very broad range of severity, its going to be difficult to justify a flat out easier exam for everyone, surely?

Look at the mess they've just had with the SATs when everyone had the same exam, lets not confuse matters till they are fixed!

Geronimo

626 posts

223 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
What a ridiculous woman. I honestly believe that if her dyslexia is so bad as to cause exam issues then she has no right to enter a profession which can quite literally be life or death.

Mr Will

13,719 posts

237 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
A multiple choice exam is 99% reading, 1% ticking the correct box. An essay exam is 5% reading, 95% writing an answer. I can see how this could cause problems for someone who struggles with reading.

Surely there has to be a better answer than changing the whole exam though. Maybe get someone to read the questions out for her?

97octane

2,203 posts

254 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
The knowledge base required for medicine is enormous. MCQs have long been considered the only effective way to test a candidate's factual knowledge. You can't throw out an entire system because it discriminates against one person.
Aside from that, and the point above about prescribing errors, how is she going to keep up to date if she is unable to read fast & effectively?

I accept that dyslexia does not equal thick, and she is probably highly intelligent, but some people get dealt a bad hand in life, so live with it!

Edited by 97octane on Tuesday 29th July 10:30

Engineer1

10,486 posts

240 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
I suppose it depends on if it is a multiple choice exam where you write on the question sheet or on one of those horrid computer readable answer sheets as i can see the problem with finding the correct row and column to put your mark in

97octane

2,203 posts

254 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
However, they have recently got rid of negative marking in MCQs as it discriminates against women, who don't (apparently/allegedly) do as well as men with negative marking systems.
Must have something to do with changing their minds!wink

crofty1984

17,064 posts

235 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
Should the questions on the exams be easier? Absolutely not.

Exams should test
A) The amount of knowledge a person has
B) The person's ability to apply that knowledge

and to a lesser extent, if it's a vocational/work entrace exam, the person's ability to do the job.

Dyslexia shouldn't affect the first two, so the exams shouldn't be made easier. It will impact the person's ability to take the exam itself, so I have no problems with them getting extra help/time/being allowed to take the exam orally etc.

I think if the latter is affected than, no that person shouldn't have that job. You'd not want a surgeon with shaky hands.
If it makes their job more difficult, but they are able to perform it (eg, they have to do homework for twice as long, because the reading's harder)then that's OK with me.

jollygreen

21,599 posts

233 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
No.

Should exams be made easier for stupid people? Of course not.

I'm not saying that deyslexis (ahem) people are stupid but just that there has to be a line drawn so that comparisons can be made on a like-for-like basis.

I'm st at Art - I can't draw or paint or sculpt. I don't have that ability or the proper brain-eye-hand co-ordination. So should the school exam (when I was 15) have been made easier because I can't do it? I got a poor grade, accepted it, moved on and don't paint/draw/sculpt.



Edited by jollygreen on Tuesday 29th July 12:24