All this guff about America having a crap health care system
All this guff about America having a crap health care system
Author
Discussion

King Herald

Original Poster:

23,501 posts

247 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
Like most people, I've always believed the stories that if you don't have expensive and comprehensive health insurance you are just about $hit of luck if you have an accident or health problem in the USA.

yes

Until now!

The mum in law has been over there for the last four months visiting her sister and other relatives. About a week ago she fell in the bath and twisted her knee pretty badly. Her sister took her to a local 'charity' hospital, as she has no cover, and she has been in there a week now. She has her own room, has had X rays, MRI's, physiotherapy, examinations, a knee immobiliser fitted, has had blood tests for her diabetes and has had a dietitian visiting her to help sort out her diet, to improve her health living with diabetes.

So far it has cost her $31, as she even got discount for being an OAP. biggrin

Next time I get sick or need an op I'm going to make sure it happens over there!!

Just thought, they might hand her the bill when she leaves?

thehawk

9,335 posts

238 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
I'm pretty certain that the US has the best health care system in the world, there was never any question over treatment you receive - it's just whether you would be bankrupted by your experience or not.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
The flip side - a member of my family took very ill on holiday in USA and required paramedic assistance to come to our villa, they took her to the nearest available hospital as you'd expect when it's an emergency, turned out it was a new private hospital. Over 6 weeks of care the total bill was approx $90,000, care was excellent I have to say, private room with en-suite etc. We were very, very lucky we had good travel insurance cover, and that there was no problems getting them to settle the bill (otherwise the house was getting remortgaged!) and would recommend you don't risk going abroad without travel insurance on the premise that someone somewhere will look after you if you're ill.

Dupont666

22,967 posts

223 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
King Herald said:
Like most people, I've always believed the stories that if you don't have expensive and comprehensive health insurance you are just about $hit of luck if you have an accident or health problem in the USA.

yes

Until now!

The mum in law has been over there for the last four months visiting her sister and other relatives. About a week ago she fell in the bath and twisted her knee pretty badly. Her sister took her to a local 'charity' hospital, as she has no cover, and she has been in there a week now. She has her own room, has had X rays, MRI's, physiotherapy, examinations, a knee immobiliser fitted, has had blood tests for her diabetes and has had a dietitian visiting her to help sort out her diet, to improve her health living with diabetes.

So far it has cost her $31, as she even got discount for being an OAP. biggrin

Next time I get sick or need an op I'm going to make sure it happens over there!!

Just thought, they might hand her the bill when she leaves?
Didnt she have holiday insurance to cover stuff like that?

Timmy35

13,014 posts

229 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
Why do you think cancer survival rates are so much higher in the USA than the UK?

All that crap about healthcare in the USA being poor is just propaganda to convince us that the NHS is something of a cross between Jesus and Mother Teresa.....we should be grovelling grateful for it's existence and would all die painfully tomorrow id it didn't exist.

King Herald

Original Poster:

23,501 posts

247 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
Dupont666 said:
King Herald said:
Like most people, I've always believed the stories that if you don't have expensive and comprehensive health insurance you are just about $hit of luck if you have an accident or health problem in the USA.

yes

Until now!

The mum in law has been over there for the last four months visiting her sister and other relatives. About a week ago she fell in the bath and twisted her knee pretty badly. Her sister took her to a local 'charity' hospital, as she has no cover, and she has been in there a week now. She has her own room, has had X rays, MRI's, physiotherapy, examinations, a knee immobiliser fitted, has had blood tests for her diabetes and has had a dietitian visiting her to help sort out her diet, to improve her health living with diabetes.

So far it has cost her $31, as she even got discount for being an OAP. biggrin

Next time I get sick or need an op I'm going to make sure it happens over there!!

Just thought, they might hand her the bill when she leaves?
Didnt she have holiday insurance to cover stuff like that?
She couldn't get it, as she is over 65, diabetic and has some other existing ongoing illness or other. Her in NY sister told us not to bother as she knew she would be able to go to the charity hospital if she got ill, so I bundled the responsibility for it into her hands.

randomman

2,215 posts

220 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
I would far rather pay health insurance and recieve private care, then pay national insurance and line Gordon's pockets while he bum loves me

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
Private hospitals in the USA ARE excellent. The doctors I spoke to told me their hospital gets all of the latest new machines, equipment, technology etc without so much as a thought about cost, as soon as it's released, however this isn't free. The staff actually have little handheld mini-laptops and everything (I mean everything) is billed and accounted for. e.g. you complain of a headache, in NHS you get some paracetamol pretty much straight away without question, in USA they email pharmacy, a little box of paracetamol is sent up to your room with your name on it and a barcode label, barcode is scanned and the whole experience is charged to your account!

It all boils down to money, you get what you pay for.

Timmy35

13,014 posts

229 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
yellowbentines said:
It all boils down to money, you get what you pay for.
Problem is WE don't. We as a nation all fork out about £1500 a head per year for the NHS and get feck all in return.

sidewayz

2,681 posts

272 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
I think I am right in saying the NHS is the third largest employer in the world-it comes after the chinese army.There was a leage table somewhere.....



ah,no I was wrong.Its on the NHS website

http://www.nhsemployers.org/pay-conditions/pay-con...



Edited to add link and correct spelin


Edited by sidewayz on Tuesday 29th July 11:21

Plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
yellowbentines said:
It all boils down to money, you get what you pay for.
And overall, you pay less in the US.

Tony*T3

20,911 posts

278 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
King Herald said:
Like most people, I've always believed the stories that if you don't have expensive and comprehensive health insurance you are just about $hit of luck if you have an accident or health problem in the USA.

yes

Until now!

The mum in law has been over there for the last four months visiting her sister and other relatives. About a week ago she fell in the bath and twisted her knee pretty badly. Her sister took her to a local 'charity' hospital, as she has no cover, and she has been in there a week now. She has her own room, has had X rays, MRI's, physiotherapy, examinations, a knee immobiliser fitted, has had blood tests for her diabetes and has had a dietitian visiting her to help sort out her diet, to improve her health living with diabetes.

So far it has cost her $31, as she even got discount for being an OAP. biggrin

Next time I get sick or need an op I'm going to make sure it happens over there!!

Just thought, they might hand her the bill when she leaves?
Hm, pretty sure that if she turned up at a US hospital for a non emergency treatment thatn the story would be different. For example, hip replacement or cataract surgery....?

branflakes

2,039 posts

269 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
Timmy35 said:
Why do you think cancer survival rates are so much higher in the USA than the UK?
Assuming you have insurance in the first place. I know someone (without insurance and in a low paying job) who chose to die from her cancer rather than burden her children (also in low paying jobs) with a SEVEN figure medical bill. I also know someone with insurance who was kept deliberately ill by her doctor because he was scamming her insurance company.

In the UK you have two choices - private medical care or the NHS. In the US you also have two choices - private medical care or fk all. I know which system I prefer.

King Herald

Original Poster:

23,501 posts

247 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
Timmy35 said:
yellowbentines said:
It all boils down to money, you get what you pay for.
Problem is WE don't. We as a nation all fork out about £1500 a head per year for the NHS and get feck all in return.
So, you've never been to hospital? Your family has never been to hospital?

As people have already mentioned, in the USA you pay a massive amount for treatment if you have insurance. Work out how much a simple broken leg would cost you in the USA, then divide that by £1500 a year.......

As for forking out £1500 a year for feck all, where does the money come from to pay the 30% of UK citizens who draw on the social welfare system? That boils my p1$$ more than paying for an NHS that I might never use.

tinman0

18,231 posts

271 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
Tony*T3 said:
Hm, pretty sure that if she turned up at a US hospital for a non emergency treatment thatn the story would be different. For example, hip replacement or cataract surgery....?
Not so sure, many low income earners are covered under Medicaid, and Medicaid in some respects is better than standard health insurance.

scotal

8,751 posts

310 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
King Herald said:
She couldn't get it, as she is over 65, diabetic and has some other existing ongoing illness or other.
Dunno about the age thing or the other existing condition, but BUPA travel insurance will cover diabetics (bit late for you in this case I know)

tinman0

18,231 posts

271 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
branflakes said:
I also know someone with insurance who was kept deliberately ill by her doctor because he was scamming her insurance company.
Thats called malpractice and I hope they took him to the cleaners.


Timmy35

13,014 posts

229 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
King Herald said:
Timmy35 said:
yellowbentines said:
It all boils down to money, you get what you pay for.
Problem is WE don't. We as a nation all fork out about £1500 a head per year for the NHS and get feck all in return.
So, you've never been to hospital? Your family has never been to hospital?

As people have already mentioned, in the USA you pay a massive amount for treatment if you have insurance. Work out how much a simple broken leg would cost you in the USA, then divide that by £1500 a year.......

As for forking out £1500 a year for feck all, where does the money come from to pay the 30% of UK citizens who draw on the social welfare system? That boils my p1$$ more than paying for an NHS that I might never use.
Oh yes.

Private dentist, private hospital.

My Gran did go into the NHS though with a minor hip fracture.....she contracted MRSA and died a few days later.

So you're right we do get something from the NHS an early death.

tinman0

18,231 posts

271 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
Plotloss said:
yellowbentines said:
It all boils down to money, you get what you pay for.
And overall, you pay less in the US.
And if you need emergency treatment in the US, a hospital cannot refuse to give it, just make sure you say "I'm indigent" before you pass out. And that way you don't get a bill when you wake upwink

Edited by tinman0 on Tuesday 29th July 16:03

Mikeyboy

5,018 posts

266 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
I think the charity hospital sector in the US depends very largely on the area they are in. If you are in LA, Chicago etc then you'll get good treatment. If its Bushwackerville Kentucky its less likey the standards would be what you'd expect.

Oh and Cancer is a frighteningly expensive business there. If you have any doubts about value for money in the NHS think of my friend who was getting bills of $15,000 per treatment for cancer (just for the drugs not the actual nursing etc). Thats 30k a month for 9 months. Good thing his insurance picked up 90% of it!
what do we pay again Tim? £1500 a year? and it doesn't matter what the treatment costs.