carrying a knife for a purpose?
carrying a knife for a purpose?
Author
Discussion

pugwash4x4

Original Poster:

7,684 posts

252 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
Anyone know the laws about carrying knives legally?

I have a Kukri which i use for skinning and boning meat- i have a firearms license and spend time deer hunting on a local landowners estate. The knife is used to dispatch the carcass (if necessary), and to draw and skin the carcass if not being hung for a long period.

So what happens if i'm caught with this thing? it's always packed away (usually in the rifle cabinet which is bolted and locked to the vehicle) but is razor sharp and probably 18 inches long!

More disturbingly for me i usually spend 2-3 weeks a year abroad rough camping and living wild- a knife is an essential tool which i will use very many times per day. Again it is often locked in the gun cabinet when in transit but it wouldn't surprise me if one day we (i go away in convoy with 2-3 other vehicles) get stopped and searched.

If i can't carry my knife, do i also have to get rid of my hand axe and bow saw?


randomman

2,215 posts

220 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
I'm fairly certain that will stand up as an acceptable purpose.

In which case you are allowed to with no restrictions

redgriff500

28,982 posts

294 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
Same as having an axe or chainsaw....

Fine in the right circunstances...

but not in the pub !

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
Wonder how he manages?


oldskool

317 posts

261 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
randomman said:
I'm fairly certain that will stand up as an acceptable purpose.

In which case you are allowed to with no restrictions
What he said... otherwise for everyday carry, eg. walking around a busy city centre going about your daily business, on public transport etc. knives must be under 3 inches and non-locking (i.e. slip-joint folders such as swiss army knives are fine)

dan1981

18,129 posts

230 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
you are Ray Mears AICMFP

Olf

11,978 posts

249 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
Can I come with you? Sounds bloody great.

King Herald

23,501 posts

247 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all

They believe are trying to push a law through to make knife carrying a compulsory five year jail term, yet a local prick recently got 'four years youth custody' for actually stabbing a bounced in the back with a knife, inside a night club.

That sends out a real strong message I guess.....

Davi

17,153 posts

251 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
Was pondering on this myself at the weekend. Whilst working on the extension I realised I was short on Damp Proof, so just jumped in the car to pick some up. Getting to the till to pay, when I put my hand in my pocket to pull out some change I discovered I had my lockable folding Stanley knife in my pocket (I'd been cutting the shrink wrap off the delivery when I discovered I'd miscalculating).

What would have happened if I'd been pulled and searched en route?

redgriff500

28,982 posts

294 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
The ones who carry them on a Friday night have a purpose too


To stab people.


getmecoat

Kaelic

2,723 posts

232 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
pugwash4x4 said:
Anyone know the laws about carrying knives legally?

I have a Kukri which i use for skinning and boning meat- i have a firearms license and spend time deer hunting on a local landowners estate. The knife is used to dispatch the carcass (if necessary), and to draw and skin the carcass if not being hung for a long period.

So what happens if i'm caught with this thing? it's always packed away (usually in the rifle cabinet which is bolted and locked to the vehicle) but is razor sharp and probably 18 inches long!

More disturbingly for me i usually spend 2-3 weeks a year abroad rough camping and living wild- a knife is an essential tool which i will use very many times per day. Again it is often locked in the gun cabinet when in transit but it wouldn't surprise me if one day we (i go away in convoy with 2-3 other vehicles) get stopped and searched.

If i can't carry my knife, do i also have to get rid of my hand axe and bow saw?
Great choice of blade!

I am sure the police would use their discression and not do anything about you. But if you were walking around the local precinct with it hidden under your tracksuit then thats a different story... I would hope anyways biggrin

chris_w666

22,655 posts

230 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
I carry a knife at work occasionally, and so do a lot of our staff.

The knives we carry are all quite sharp and are carried usually concealed in the buoyancy aid we are wearing when working on watersports activities. It is however necesarry for this kit to be moved between venues sometimes in vehicles and sometimes when walking.

I would not want to think that just for having this essential piece of kit in my bag on the way to work I was going to be arrested.

Actually making those carrying them for no 'GOOD' reason feel like they have a reason to be fearful of the consequences is a hard task.

Mattygooner

5,304 posts

235 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
Unless you are hunting in Saff London, i don't see that there is a problem. If however it turns out that you are hunting cub scouts and skinning them and wearing them as trophies [Universal Soldier Dolph]I am all ears!![Universal Soldier Dolph] then they may want to question the blade in question.

Do you really need 18 inches (not a question for the women!

On a side note, Is that why Deer stalker hats came back in to fashion with the Yoof? so they could try and say they were actually going hunting?

Edited by Mattygooner on Tuesday 29th July 12:56

stew-S160

8,021 posts

269 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all

Keithp

299 posts

256 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
I believe there is guidance on this on BASC and BDS websites , there is a gray area when traveling to and from , you ground , i used to put all my kit on my belt when i left home to make sure i did not forget anything , to be sure now i leave the knife in the case with the rifle .

Where you would be on sticky ground is if you stopped for fuel or something to eat and were away form your car and i a public place with a knife in your possesion, you are not actualy stalking so are then in a public place with a knife and do not have good reason in the eyes of the law. If you leave it in the car with you rifle it is part of your equipmet and that apparantly is ok.

Thats how it was explained to me when i did my level 1 some years ago.

Keith


Keithp

299 posts

256 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
Just re-read you post, wtf do you need something that big to skin with , no need i use two knives biggest is 6 inches long and i only use that on fallow and red even that is to big on small roe.

Keith

[AJ]

3,079 posts

229 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
I always used to carry a knife. One like this Kershaw:



I had it in it's pouch on my belt almost everywhere I went. I would put it on as part of my normal attire. Kind of like a watch. The only time it wouldn't go on my belt was if I was wearing a suit! But then I lived out in the hills and used it a lot. It was a tool. I don't carry them about with me any more though unless I'm off camping etc. It's a shame really that a few idiots have to make life difficult for everyone else.

Mr Trophy

6,811 posts

234 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
redgriff500 said:
The ones who carry them on a Friday night have a purpose too. To stab people.getmecoat
I've always wondered about this. When the person that carring his knife, does he do a check, "Right ok got my wallet, hairs done, got my phones, keys, oh yeah and my knife!"

pugwash4x4

Original Poster:

7,684 posts

252 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
Keithp said:
Just re-read you post, wtf do you need something that big to skin with , no need i use two knives biggest is 6 inches long and i only use that on fallow and red even that is to big on small roe.

Keith
It's possibly not 18"- having never managed it i don't actually know- it's just a kukri- but it has both a sharpening and paring knife in the sheaf- so it can be used for everything. I have always found it easier to wrk with a big knife- don't know why!

I had the understanding that you did from trainin- BUT the laws seems to be changing at the moment so i thought i would ask again to see what other people thought.

King Herald

23,501 posts

247 months

Tuesday 29th July 2008
quotequote all
stew-S160 said:
Good god, that woman gives me the horn.