Plumbing questions - boiler / heating / hot water
Plumbing questions - boiler / heating / hot water
Author
Discussion

dan1981

18,129 posts

230 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
Morning All,

Looking for plumbing advice from you lot!

At present we seem to have an ancient system installed. We've got a hot water tank, and gas powered central heating. Until Saturday we also had an immersion heater that heated hot water for us. The big point here is that we didn't KNOW we had an immersion heater, or that it had been switched on for the last 6 months constantly.

Anyway the thermostat has gone pop so the immersion is no longer a viable option.

So if we now want hot water we have to turn our heating on. We've turned all the radiators off but its still a pain having to do this and then switch them on if we want them back on etc.

The plumber has told us our options are:

1: Stay as we are - using the heating to heat water.
2: Replace the thermostat and go back to using the immersion heater - however the tank may be damaged / unopenable etc which would mean a new tank
3: New tank anyway with new controls etc allowing us to operate heating and hot water seperatly - may require extra pipework - taking up of carpets etc.
4: New system - eg combi boiler.

Its a 3 bed semi, just the two of us, prob two showers (electric) and a bath a day, plus dish washing once a day. Heating is on very rarely - not been on at all for the last few months.

The weird thing is our electricity bills don't seem massivly high to say we've had the immersion heater on constantly for the last 6 months. Nor do our gas bills. We've just been told our monthly direct debit for the two is going down to £60 from £87.

So - any advice?

And any advice on the likely costs involved??

Apologies for the long winded post.

Cheers

Dan

Edited by dan1981 on Wednesday 30th July 09:48




Edited by dan1981 on Wednesday 30th July 09:55

Smart roadster

769 posts

257 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
If you have an old system you are going to have to bite the bullet sometime and get a new system fitted. Better in the summer than during a big freeze in February. New systems don't have to be combis you could go for a new conventional system.
You say your bills aren't high, we live an a 3 bed detached 2 adults and an eight month old so are washing amchine is nearly always going. Are bills are £22 for one and £24 for the other. Can't remember which is which.

dan1981

18,129 posts

230 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
Smart roadster said:
If you have an old system you are going to have to bite the bullet sometime and get a new system fitted. Better in the summer than during a big freeze in February. New systems don't have to be combis you could go for a new conventional system.
You say your bills aren't high, we live an a 3 bed detached 2 adults and an eight month old so are washing amchine is nearly always going. Are bills are £22 for one and £24 for the other. Can't remember which is which.
hmmm maybe our bills arn't quite as reasonable as I thought then?

dan1981

18,129 posts

230 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
Sorry to bump this up again guys.

Just a few further points.... if any can help.....

If we did go for a boiler change would a combi be a good change? or are we better sticking with our tank - really not sure on the pros and cons of both systems.


Deva Link

26,934 posts

276 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
You'll find filling a bath a very frustrating experience with a combi as it'll take ages.

The advantage of a combi is the hot water is unlimited, and it does away with the cylinder (although you then need to heat your airing cupboard). It's also said that it's less wasteful, as you haven't got a cylinder full of hot water sitting there going cold.

I'd go with option 3 on your list. It's exactly what we've got, and we can have either ch or hw separately (or both together of course).

You might not *need* a new hw cylinder, if yours is an indirect cylinder and if it can be well insulated. However if you need to change it then you could go for a fast recovery cylinder which will get hot very quickly.


There are other solutions - heat stores etc, but I'm not very familiar with them. Maybe others can advise.

Edited by Deva Link on Wednesday 30th July 12:19

cjs

11,718 posts

282 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all

Combi Plus points are:

Instant HW
Save space. No HW Tank. No CW tank in Loft.
Great Showers off mains pressure ( you could do away with your electric shower)
Cheaper to run as you only heat water you need ( This is questionable)

Negatives:

If your in the shower and someone switches on a tap/washing machine/flushes toilet your shower stops/goes cold/goes too hot.
If the boiler goes down you have no HW (no immersion heater)


Edited to add. I have a Combi in my Bungalow, it works well for me and has freed up loads of space. BTW my bath takes less than 10 mins to fill, not too bad.

Edited by cjs on Wednesday 30th July 17:34

King Herald

23,501 posts

247 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
We're planning to get a combi boiler fitted in the very near future, to replace our ancient old conventional boiler and water tank. It'll be firing the central heating and washing up water, as that is pretty much all we use hot water for. Maybe the occasional bath, but we have an electric shower that is usually used instead.

Three bedroomed semi, boiler in the attached garage, what would be the best combi boiler make and size to use? I want something reliable, obviously, and I don't want to wait three hours to fill a bath.

I await the usual precise and accurate PH opinions. biggrin

moles

1,860 posts

275 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
If you get a combi get a Vaillant Ecotec +837 will do 16 litres/min which will fill a bath nearly as quick as a normal tank fed cylinder. Vaillant are one of the most expensive boiler on the market but if you plan on staying in the property for a few years it's worth it. Only downside with a combi is if (as has already been said) you use 2 taps at once the pressure drops, but with a bigger KW boiler this is less of an issue. I work on all types of boilers and the Vaillant Eco-tec series has been out for 3 years and I have yet to visit a single one on a repair visit. (Go to any plumbers merchant and ask what they recommend and I bet they all say Vaillant) If 16l/min isn't enough you can add a tank on the boiler (made by Vaillant) which will do 20 litres/min but it makes the boiler pretty big and is overkill for most situations.

Edited by moles on Wednesday 30th July 18:45

moles

1,860 posts

275 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
King Herald you may as well get the smallest combi if you don't want it for much DHW, Eco-tec +824 9.5litres/min or they do a 831 which is 31kw/13litres/min or the biggest 837 @ 16/20litres/min.
http://www.vaillant.co.uk/homeowners/heating-solut...

Edited by moles on Wednesday 30th July 18:41


Edited by moles on Wednesday 30th July 18:46

condor

8,837 posts

279 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
I used to have an immersion tank and the element would go every 2 years ( hard water area) - it wasn't that difficult to change and spares were approx £25. To change thermostat is very easy and a new one costs about £5.
Mine lasted about 20 years in total, and then I changed to a Megaflo system.
This gives hot water at mains pressure so no need for electric shower pumps, which I like.

dan1981

18,129 posts

230 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
oooh evening activity!

So any advice on my origional conundrum?

I dunno why but i'm edging back toward putting a new immersion in and using that. Willing to listen though!

Cheers

Dan

B17NNS

18,506 posts

278 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
King Herald, give this man a shout http://www.pistonheads.co.uk/gassing/profile.asp?m...

Bernie is a top chap (with a rather nice red Noble) who installs boilers by the bucket load.

His preference is usually Worcester-Bosch.

Edited by B17NNS on Wednesday 30th July 19:30

moles

1,860 posts

275 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
If you don't use the CH much and use electric showers then you may as well stick with the immersion heater but as the plumber said until you start to get the immersion out you don't know if the tank will split or not cylinder's are a normally £200 ish depending on size £10 for new immersion heater then labour on top so will be a lot cheaper than a new boiler.

dan1981 said:
oooh evening activity!

So any advice on my origional conundrum?

I dunno why but i'm edging back toward putting a new immersion in and using that. Willing to listen though!

Cheers

Dan

King Herald

23,501 posts

247 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
B17NNS said:
King Herald, give this man a shout http://www.pistonheads.co.uk/gassing/profile.asp?m...

Bernie is a top chap (with a rather nice red Noble) who installs boilers by the bucket load.

His preference is usually Worcester-Bosch.
Is he the guy in Eccleshall? I remember getting his details and stashing them somewhere safe a while back... :embarrassed:

B17NNS

18,506 posts

278 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
King Herald said:
Is he the guy in Eccleshall?
Yep thats the fella.

Gas Service Lower Farm, Fair Oak, Eccleshall, Stafford, Staffordshire, ST21 6PW Tel: 01630 620222

King Herald

23,501 posts

247 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
B17NNS said:
King Herald said:
Is he the guy in Eccleshall?
Yep thats the fella.

Gas Service Lower Farm, Fair Oak, Eccleshall, Stafford, Staffordshire, ST21 6PW Tel: 01630 620222
Cheers, I'll call him in the very near future.

I can't afford gas bills in the £1000's a month when our price freeze finishes in two years. frown

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
I would recommend going Worcester Bosch if you need a new boiler. They give very little problems and good warranties.

I've spent quite a while doing some consultancy work for a friend who runs a decent size heating company and he wouldn't recommend anything else.

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
King Herald said:
We're planning to get a combi boiler fitted in the very near future, to replace our ancient old conventional boiler and water tank. It'll be firing the central heating and washing up water, as that is pretty much all we use hot water for. Maybe the occasional bath, but we have an electric shower that is usually used instead.
i was told that if you switch to a combi system you are not allowed to retain your electric shower, is this right? Not that I want to, just wondered if this was correct

AndrewTait

1,849 posts

225 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
In the last 2 houses I've had, both have had combi boilers and electric showers. I suspect that this comes from the water pressure issue, in that the shower heating element gets rather hot if a lot of water is run off while the shower is on.

I had 2 in 8 years in my first house because of this.

King Herald

23,501 posts

247 months

Thursday 31st July 2008
quotequote all
MRSNEAK said:
King Herald said:
We're planning to get a combi boiler fitted in the very near future, to replace our ancient old conventional boiler and water tank. It'll be firing the central heating and washing up water, as that is pretty much all we use hot water for. Maybe the occasional bath, but we have an electric shower that is usually used instead.
i was told that if you switch to a combi system you are not allowed to retain your electric shower, is this right? Not that I want to, just wondered if this was correct
I can see no logical reason whatsoever for this. confused Some pointless 'green' legislation perhaps?

The whole reasoning behind getting the combi boiler is because we HAVE an electric shower and don't need loads of tanked up, hot all day, heated for no reason, water.