Well done BBC. Your no better than dole dossers.
Well done BBC. Your no better than dole dossers.
Author
Discussion

The Ben

Original Poster:

1,623 posts

248 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
ofcom said:
The BBC deceived its audience by faking winners of competitions and deliberately conducting competitions unfairly
Its disgusting, and all involved should be given their P45 and a criminal investigation for theft.

dont they get enough money from the 'unique way the BBC is funded'.. if not, make it fair ofr the other channels and get rid of the communist licence...



Comic Relief (BBC One, March 2007) - £45,000

• Sport Relief (BBC One, July 2006) - £45,000

• Children in Need (BBC One Scotland, November 2005) - £35,000

• TMi (BBC Two and CBBC, September 2006) - £50,000

• Liz Kershaw Show (BBC 6 Music, May 2005 to January 2006) - £115,000

• Jo Whiley Show (BBC Radio 1, 20 April to 12 May 2006) - £75,000

• Russell Brand (BBC 6 Music, April 2006) - £17,500

• Clare McDonnell Show (BBC 6 Music, from September 2006) - £17,500

DWP

1,232 posts

246 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
The Ben said:
ofcom said:
The BBC deceived its audience by faking winners of competitions and deliberately conducting competitions unfairly
Its disgusting, and all involved should be given their P45 and a criminal investigation for theft.

dont they get enough money from the 'unique way the BBC is funded'.. if not, make it fair ofr the other channels and get rid of the communist licence...



Comic Relief (BBC One, March 2007) - £45,000

• Sport Relief (BBC One, July 2006) - £45,000

• Children in Need (BBC One Scotland, November 2005) - £35,000

• TMi (BBC Two and CBBC, September 2006) - £50,000

• Liz Kershaw Show (BBC 6 Music, May 2005 to January 2006) - £115,000

• Jo Whiley Show (BBC Radio 1, 20 April to 12 May 2006) - £75,000

• Russell Brand (BBC 6 Music, April 2006) - £17,500

• Clare McDonnell Show (BBC 6 Music, from September 2006) - £17,500
"Ofcom has recognised that neither the BBC nor any member of staff made any money from these serious editorial lapses"


Sorry to spoil a good rant and accepting there was some very dumb mistakes made, theft was not one of them.




The Ben

Original Poster:

1,623 posts

248 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
though they didnt recognise them, doesnt mean to say that they didnt...


The fact that they let people phone in for supposed live shows when they were pre recorded... Someone made money, surely!!!


Regardless..

SACK SACK SACK

Nick_F

10,598 posts

277 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
Lessons have been learned and certain individuals have lost their jobs.

Having taken part in it myself this afternoon I can also confirm that the BBC has so far put more than 19,000 staff through a training programme entitled 'Safeguarding Trust' as just one of a series of sustantive measures intended to ensure that the mistakes made here are not repeated.

The Ben

Original Poster:

1,623 posts

248 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
the problems being though, that these mistakes seem to be constant... not only in the BEEB but other channels too. How har dis it to run a 'phone in' legally??? if it is so hard, dont bother or get someone who is capable.. How hard is it to run a 'live' competition whilst running a 'live' show, how did they think they could get away with running a pre recorded show with a live competition??? it just seems ludicrous that there are sooo many idiots put in positions of responsibility, and make irrational decisions, which makes everyone look bad!

Im sure presenters like Russell Brand and Jo Whiley had no idea what was going on, and that there shows now look like st. st sticks...

Edited by The Ben on Wednesday 30th July 23:15

esselte

14,626 posts

298 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
Nick_F said:
Lessons have been learned .
How often do we hear this from public bodies?

Emeye

9,781 posts

254 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
Nick_F said:
Lessons have been learned and certain individuals have lost their jobs.

Having taken part in it myself this afternoon I can also confirm that the BBC has so far put more than 19,000 staff through a training programme entitled 'Safeguarding Trust' as just one of a series of sustantive measures intended to ensure that the mistakes made here are not repeated.
Great - another waste of my TV tax money - training BBC staff to be honest.rolleyes Time for adverts at the BBC. fkers.

Tuna

19,930 posts

315 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
The Ben said:
though they didnt recognise them, doesnt mean to say that they didnt...


The fact that they let people phone in for supposed live shows when they were pre recorded... Someone made money, surely!!!


Regardless..

SACK SACK SACK
Not the BBC... these are phone ins where you ring up a normal number to get stuff - not the ITV style premium rate scams.

Given the quality of programming on other channels, the BBC is looking increasingly good value. We're thinking of kicking Sky into touch once the freesat service settles in. BBC news is always open in a browser window, there are podcasts of some great shows to download onto my MP3 player, if we need a recipe we check out the bbc site which is comprehensive and has great search facilities. CBeebies is great for the children and really cannot be rivalled. The list goes on, and compared to the enormous cost of a sky subscription, you get a lot more from the BBC.

The Ben

Original Poster:

1,623 posts

248 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
Tuna said:
The Ben said:
though they didnt recognise them, doesnt mean to say that they didnt...


The fact that they let people phone in for supposed live shows when they were pre recorded... Someone made money, surely!!!


Regardless..

SACK SACK SACK
Not the BBC... these are phone ins where you ring up a normal number to get stuff - not the ITV style premium rate scams.

Given the quality of programming on other channels, the BBC is looking increasingly good value. We're thinking of kicking Sky into touch once the freesat service settles in. BBC news is always open in a browser window, there are podcasts of some great shows to download onto my MP3 player, if we need a recipe we check out the bbc site which is comprehensive and has great search facilities. CBeebies is great for the children and really cannot be rivalled. The list goes on, and compared to the enormous cost of a sky subscription, you get a lot more from the BBC.
Its not the BBC that produces these people who are creative, if it was privatised these people will still be about, they will not siapear into thin air.... Im not saying either that the quality of the progs. are bad, im saying that the style in which it is run is shoddy and just as with any other agency or firm that the govt. runs or managages, it wil be run ineficiently...

Im sure that the amount of money that the beeb wastes, a commercialised tv station could produce an equal quality with the same quality tv makers. I maybe wrong, ITV does produce some crap.

Geronimo

626 posts

223 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
Nick_F said:
Lessons have been learned and certain individuals have lost their jobs.

Having taken part in it myself this afternoon I can also confirm that the BBC has so far put more than 19,000 staff through a training programme entitled 'Safeguarding Trust' as just one of a series of sustantive measures intended to ensure that the mistakes made here are not repeated.
Do people really need to be sent on a fking course to know that getting friends of producers to act as winners of competitions is wrong?

Anyway, at least the Ken Bruce competitions (the Friday Word game) are genuine since I won that a few years back.

Simpo Two

93,083 posts

296 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
It seems that spin and BS are permeating down to all, just as spin and BS put their masters in Government. After all, what better than to copy those in charge?

Fining the BBC is a masterstroke. Almost as stupid as windfall taxes. But so the money-go-round goes round and round, and those at the top get richer, and Joe Taxpayer at the bottom puts more in and gets ever less out.

The Ben

Original Poster:

1,623 posts

248 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
good point, where does this fine go???

srebbe64

13,021 posts

268 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
The Ben said:
ofcom said:
The BBC deceived its audience by faking winners of competitions and deliberately conducting competitions unfairly
Its disgusting, and all involved should be given their P45 and a criminal investigation for theft.

dont they get enough money from the 'unique way the BBC is funded'.. if not, make it fair ofr the other channels and get rid of the communist licence...



Comic Relief (BBC One, March 2007) - £45,000

• Sport Relief (BBC One, July 2006) - £45,000

• Children in Need (BBC One Scotland, November 2005) - £35,000

• TMi (BBC Two and CBBC, September 2006) - £50,000

• Liz Kershaw Show (BBC 6 Music, May 2005 to January 2006) - £115,000

• Jo Whiley Show (BBC Radio 1, 20 April to 12 May 2006) - £75,000

• Russell Brand (BBC 6 Music, April 2006) - £17,500

• Clare McDonnell Show (BBC 6 Music, from September 2006) - £17,500
If you want a proper rant then at least rant about something with some meaningful numbers. Sure the above isn't chicken feed in terms of domestic levels of cash, but in terms of what Government Departments (and that includes the BBC) waste the above is tiny drop in the ocean. I was a consultant for the EU in Brussels for a few years and the money they waste, for NOTHING in return (at least the BBC make programmes) is mind boggling.

The Ben

Original Poster:

1,623 posts

248 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
srebbe64 said:
The Ben said:
ofcom said:
The BBC deceived its audience by faking winners of competitions and deliberately conducting competitions unfairly
Its disgusting, and all involved should be given their P45 and a criminal investigation for theft.

dont they get enough money from the 'unique way the BBC is funded'.. if not, make it fair ofr the other channels and get rid of the communist licence...



Comic Relief (BBC One, March 2007) - £45,000

• Sport Relief (BBC One, July 2006) - £45,000

• Children in Need (BBC One Scotland, November 2005) - £35,000

• TMi (BBC Two and CBBC, September 2006) - £50,000

• Liz Kershaw Show (BBC 6 Music, May 2005 to January 2006) - £115,000

• Jo Whiley Show (BBC Radio 1, 20 April to 12 May 2006) - £75,000

• Russell Brand (BBC 6 Music, April 2006) - £17,500

• Clare McDonnell Show (BBC 6 Music, from September 2006) - £17,500
If you want a proper rant then at least rant about something with some meaningful numbers. Sure the above isn't chicken feed in terms of domestic levels of cash, but in terms of what Government Departments (and that includes the BBC) waste the above is tiny drop in the ocean. I was a consultant for the EU in Brussels for a few years and the money they waste, for NOTHING in return (at least the BBC make programmes) is mind boggling.
Those above figures are not waste, they are the fines they individually recieved... totalling the £400k fined.


And also, no doubt that the EU catastrophically wastes money as does every other political or govt. related agency etc... but that is a different rant!

Sciroccology

29,908 posts

261 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
The Ben said:
Jo Whiley had no idea what was going on
No change there then.


Geronimo said:
Anyway, at least the Ken Bruce competitions (the Friday Word game) are genuine since I won that a few years back.
I came second on Popmaster once.

The Ben

Original Poster:

1,623 posts

248 months

Wednesday 30th July 2008
quotequote all
Sciroccology said:
I came second on Popmaster once.
Ohh if it wasnt rigged, you would have won that;)

Simpo Two

93,083 posts

296 months

Thursday 31st July 2008
quotequote all
srebbe64 said:
I was a consultant for the EU in Brussels for a few years and the money they waste, for NOTHING in return (at least the BBC make programmes) is mind boggling.
Actually, think of this. The money they 'waste' is getting spent somewhere. So whilst the taxpayer may not be getting any return, there must be many people hoovering up this dosh and buying plasma TVs with it, thereby helping retailers etc...?

srebbe64

13,021 posts

268 months

Thursday 31st July 2008
quotequote all
Simpo Two said:
srebbe64 said:
I was a consultant for the EU in Brussels for a few years and the money they waste, for NOTHING in return (at least the BBC make programmes) is mind boggling.
Actually, think of this. The money they 'waste' is getting spent somewhere. So whilst the taxpayer may not be getting any return, there must be many people hoovering up this dosh and buying plasma TVs with it, thereby helping retailers etc...?
By that rationale, we may as well be a 100% Government run state.

Simpo Two

93,083 posts

296 months

Thursday 31st July 2008
quotequote all
srebbe64 said:
By that rationale, we may as well be a 100% Government run state.
Are we not?

DWP

1,232 posts

246 months

Thursday 31st July 2008
quotequote all
The Ben said:
though they didnt recognise them, doesnt mean to say that they didnt...


The fact that they let people phone in for supposed live shows when they were pre recorded... Someone made money, surely!!!


Regardless..

SACK SACK SACK
You have every right to be upset but there were no pre recorded shows used. They were live.