Getting back to career I originally wanted - trader
Getting back to career I originally wanted - trader
Author
Discussion

elster

Original Poster:

17,517 posts

241 months

Friday 1st August 2008
quotequote all
Well first of all I'm currently an Electrical Engineer, family business.

Due to family reasons I had to drop out of School after first year of my A Levels So I just got my AS Levels (Maths - A, Geography - B, Physics - B and Biology -B) With 5 A's, 4 B's and 2 C's at GCSE.

I am wanting to go back into what I orginally wanted to and that is become a trader on the markets.

What is the best way for me to go forward into it?

The idea I was thinking of was go to college and do A levels, or access course (haven't worked out what that is yet, or if worth it), so can go to Uni and do a degree in something like Economics.

Has anyone got any other suggestions for what I could look into? Or is this looking the way to go forward.

H_Kan

4,942 posts

230 months

Friday 1st August 2008
quotequote all
Probably not the best thing to get into at the minute.

However something like economics, maths, finance etc would be a good starting place for degrees.

Bing o

15,184 posts

250 months

Friday 1st August 2008
quotequote all
H_Kan said:
Probably not the best thing to get into at the minute.

However something like economics, maths, finance etc would be a good starting place for degrees.
Considering that the OP will probably take 4-5 years to graduate, I would expect the markets to be in recovery, if previous cycles are repeated, so would be better placed by then.

My only concern would be age, and the level of competition from others younger than him. Getting a 2.i from an average uni probably won't impress a lot of the top tier banks either, so be prepared to work very very hard.

Also, does the OP have any experience of what trading is like? I've worked in banking for 8 years and have no desire to go down that road.

elster

Original Poster:

17,517 posts

241 months

Friday 1st August 2008
quotequote all
Bing o said:
H_Kan said:
Probably not the best thing to get into at the minute.

However something like economics, maths, finance etc would be a good starting place for degrees.
Considering that the OP will probably take 4-5 years to graduate, I would expect the markets to be in recovery, if previous cycles are repeated, so would be better placed by then.

My only concern would be age, and the level of competition from others younger than him. Getting a 2.i from an average uni probably won't impress a lot of the top tier banks either, so be prepared to work very very hard.

Also, does the OP have any experience of what trading is like? I've worked in banking for 8 years and have no desire to go down that road.
A few of sisters friends work in that area, yes spoken to various people. Always been interested in.

I'm currently 24. So Obviously I'm looking more long term. I would hope the markets are recovering by the time I'm out of schooling.

Economics and maths you say.

Bing o

15,184 posts

250 months

Friday 1st August 2008
quotequote all
elster said:
Bing o said:
H_Kan said:
Probably not the best thing to get into at the minute.

However something like economics, maths, finance etc would be a good starting place for degrees.
Considering that the OP will probably take 4-5 years to graduate, I would expect the markets to be in recovery, if previous cycles are repeated, so would be better placed by then.

My only concern would be age, and the level of competition from others younger than him. Getting a 2.i from an average uni probably won't impress a lot of the top tier banks either, so be prepared to work very very hard.

Also, does the OP have any experience of what trading is like? I've worked in banking for 8 years and have no desire to go down that road.
A few of sisters friends work in that area, yes spoken to various people. Always been interested in.

I'm currently 24. So Obviously I'm looking more long term. I would hope the markets are recovering by the time I'm out of schooling.

Economics and maths you say.
There are traders with degrees in all sorts - engineering, chemistry - anything heavily numerically influenced generally.

I'd check with your sister's mates whether they'd employ a new trader at the age of say 28?

Don't want to piss on your fire, but a lot of desks want 22 year olds that are easier to build up/develop generally, are happy to do the hours with a view to cutting back when they hit 30 - you'd almost be at that age when you graduate. What if you meet someone/have a kid - it's very hard to maintain a relationship doing trading hours generally - I know a lot of divorced traders.

All the best though - I hope that you get what you want.

elster

Original Poster:

17,517 posts

241 months

Friday 1st August 2008
quotequote all
Bing o said:
elster said:
Bing o said:
H_Kan said:
Probably not the best thing to get into at the minute.

However something like economics, maths, finance etc would be a good starting place for degrees.
Considering that the OP will probably take 4-5 years to graduate, I would expect the markets to be in recovery, if previous cycles are repeated, so would be better placed by then.

My only concern would be age, and the level of competition from others younger than him. Getting a 2.i from an average uni probably won't impress a lot of the top tier banks either, so be prepared to work very very hard.

Also, does the OP have any experience of what trading is like? I've worked in banking for 8 years and have no desire to go down that road.
A few of sisters friends work in that area, yes spoken to various people. Always been interested in.

I'm currently 24. So Obviously I'm looking more long term. I would hope the markets are recovering by the time I'm out of schooling.

Economics and maths you say.
There are traders with degrees in all sorts - engineering, chemistry - anything heavily numerically influenced generally.

I'd check with your sister's mates whether they'd employ a new trader at the age of say 28?

Don't want to piss on your fire, but a lot of desks want 22 year olds that are easier to build up/develop generally, are happy to do the hours with a view to cutting back when they hit 30 - you'd almost be at that age when you graduate. What if you meet someone/have a kid - it's very hard to maintain a relationship doing trading hours generally - I know a lot of divorced traders.

All the best though - I hope that you get what you want.
One is in recruitment now, so will ask him what he thinks.

Bing o

15,184 posts

250 months

Friday 1st August 2008
quotequote all
elster said:
One is in recruitment now, so will ask him what he thinks.
Like I say, I don't want to be harsh, but this is often the reality in Investment Banking - not a very soft and cuddly profession smile

All the best.

Glocko

1,813 posts

280 months

Friday 1st August 2008
quotequote all
I thought he meant..

NoelWatson

11,710 posts

273 months

Friday 1st August 2008
quotequote all
elster said:
Well first of all I'm currently an Electrical Engineer, family business.

Due to family reasons I had to drop out of School after first year of my A Levels So I just got my AS Levels (Maths - A, Geography - B, Physics - B and Biology -B) With 5 A's, 4 B's and 2 C's at GCSE.

I am wanting to go back into what I orginally wanted to and that is become a trader on the markets.

What is the best way for me to go forward into it?

The idea I was thinking of was go to college and do A levels, or access course (haven't worked out what that is yet, or if worth it), so can go to Uni and do a degree in something like Economics.

Has anyone got any other suggestions for what I could look into? Or is this looking the way to go forward.
I think it will be pretty difficult. The traders at our place either joined on the graduate scheme or joined at a more senior level with a number of years trading experience behind them. Depending on area, the hours aren't massively bad depending on which area you work in.

zahal

2,719 posts

240 months

Friday 1st August 2008
quotequote all
For me, if I were in your shoes rather than spending 3 years at university and spending all the money that will cost, I'd take my savings and use them to learn how to trade with your own money. Find an arcade that will allow you to trade, and provide you with market quotes, info, etc etc, and off you go. Give yourself enough cash to live for at least 6 months on top of your trading capital, start small and make all the mistakes you want. If you're disciplined and focused enough, eventually you have to pick it up. Just a question of when 'eventually' is.
Spending 3 years at a second rate university to come out with a non first class degree at 28 ish and then compete against top grads from A list universities for a job at an investment bank...you've got no chance. And before you say anything, I totally agree...it doesn't mean you wouldn't have been a better trader than any of them, it's just the way the recruitment process works.

uuf361

3,185 posts

253 months

Friday 1st August 2008
quotequote all
A lot of traders I know have no formal trading related qualifications, and when I was a trader the only qualification I got was the mandatory Series (NASD) licence - and that's only bcos I was in the US and trading certain products - otherwise I would have not got any formal qualifications at all - they woudl not have helped me........

blindswelledrat

25,257 posts

263 months

Friday 1st August 2008
quotequote all
Good thread. I too decided I would like to further explore my original idea to become and Astronaut.
Any suggestions?

Fatboy

8,271 posts

303 months

Friday 1st August 2008
quotequote all
blindswelledrat said:
Good thread. I too decided I would like to further explore my original idea to become and Astronaut.
Any suggestions?
You need a really big metal tube, loads of rocket fuel, and an ability to point it straight up.

That should get you started.

blindswelledrat

25,257 posts

263 months

Friday 1st August 2008
quotequote all
And judging by your username you would need a slightly bigger tube with a load more fuel?

Mutt

1,115 posts

222 months

Friday 1st August 2008
quotequote all
Have you considered applying for a role in trade support? Working with traders, correcting booking errors, learning the business...?

I know a few people who have made the jump from middle office to front office via this route.

Fatboy

8,271 posts

303 months

Friday 1st August 2008
quotequote all
blindswelledrat said:
And judging by your username you would need a slightly bigger tube with a load more fuel?
More than likely - probably need a second stage for the emergency pie support system biggrin

Horse_Apple

3,795 posts

273 months

Friday 1st August 2008
quotequote all
zahal said:
For me, if I were in your shoes rather than spending 3 years at university and spending all the money that will cost, I'd take my savings and use them to learn how to trade with your own money. Find an arcade that will allow you to trade, and provide you with market quotes, info, etc etc, and off you go. Give yourself enough cash to live for at least 6 months on top of your trading capital, start small and make all the mistakes you want. If you're disciplined and focused enough, eventually you have to pick it up. Just a question of when 'eventually' is.
Spending 3 years at a second rate university to come out with a non first class degree at 28 ish and then compete against top grads from A list universities for a job at an investment bank...you've got no chance. And before you say anything, I totally agree...it doesn't mean you wouldn't have been a better trader than any of them, it's just the way the recruitment process works.
I really disagree with this. Putting your own money up is so wrong it's not true.

I do agree that there is absolutely no point in wasting time at anything other than a top Uni if your plan is to work as a trader within a banking environment. You'll spend 3-5 years getting an education that when you finally exit will not be remotely competitive in that environment.

There are two types of traders really, those who started at the bottom and have fought their way up without a Uni education but the City is now far more focused on the second type which is the Oxbridge/Harvard spod.

I think the days of entering the City with no education has been coming to a close very rapidly since the strong emergence of the US and European banks.

At this moment in time Stat Arb seems to eb the Holy Grail of prop desks and is likely to continue. I'd go and get some books on that and if you don't find yourself driving down to Beachy Head then I'd consider paying up for a Masters or MBA.

But, going back to what I said at the beginning, never put your own money up. The % of people who make it is microscopic. The arcades use such people to pay the rent.

Mutt

1,115 posts

222 months

Friday 1st August 2008
quotequote all
Horse_Apple said:
zahal said:
For me, if I were in your shoes rather than spending 3 years at university and spending all the money that will cost, I'd take my savings and use them to learn how to trade with your own money. Find an arcade that will allow you to trade, and provide you with market quotes, info, etc etc, and off you go. Give yourself enough cash to live for at least 6 months on top of your trading capital, start small and make all the mistakes you want. If you're disciplined and focused enough, eventually you have to pick it up. Just a question of when 'eventually' is.
Spending 3 years at a second rate university to come out with a non first class degree at 28 ish and then compete against top grads from A list universities for a job at an investment bank...you've got no chance. And before you say anything, I totally agree...it doesn't mean you wouldn't have been a better trader than any of them, it's just the way the recruitment process works.
I really disagree with this. Putting your own money up is so wrong it's not true.

I do agree that there is absolutely no point in wasting time at anything other than a top Uni if your plan is to work as a trader within a banking environment. You'll spend 3-5 years getting an education that when you finally exit will not be remotely competitive in that environment.

There are two types of traders really, those who started at the bottom and have fought their way up without a Uni education but the City is now far more focused on the second type which is the Oxbridge/Harvard spod.

I think the days of entering the City with no education has been coming to a close very rapidly since the strong emergence of the US and European banks.

At this moment in time Stat Arb seems to eb the Holy Grail of prop desks and is likely to continue. I'd go and get some books on that and if you don't find yourself driving down to Beachy Head then I'd consider paying up for a Masters or MBA.

But, going back to what I said at the beginning, never put your own money up. The % of people who make it is microscopic. The arcades use such people to pay the rent.
You mean sitting in my bedroom, wearing red braces, shouting "BUY SELL" and looking for a 1985 Guards Red 911 in the classifieds won't make me a trader?

Oh.

Jasandjules

72,684 posts

260 months

Friday 1st August 2008
quotequote all
Most dealers come in on Grad schemes at 21/22. The exceptions are usually from back-middle office who then impress a desk, and get a shot.


Horse_Apple

3,795 posts

273 months

Friday 1st August 2008
quotequote all
Mutt said:
Horse_Apple said:
zahal said:
For me, if I were in your shoes rather than spending 3 years at university and spending all the money that will cost, I'd take my savings and use them to learn how to trade with your own money. Find an arcade that will allow you to trade, and provide you with market quotes, info, etc etc, and off you go. Give yourself enough cash to live for at least 6 months on top of your trading capital, start small and make all the mistakes you want. If you're disciplined and focused enough, eventually you have to pick it up. Just a question of when 'eventually' is.
Spending 3 years at a second rate university to come out with a non first class degree at 28 ish and then compete against top grads from A list universities for a job at an investment bank...you've got no chance. And before you say anything, I totally agree...it doesn't mean you wouldn't have been a better trader than any of them, it's just the way the recruitment process works.
I really disagree with this. Putting your own money up is so wrong it's not true.

I do agree that there is absolutely no point in wasting time at anything other than a top Uni if your plan is to work as a trader within a banking environment. You'll spend 3-5 years getting an education that when you finally exit will not be remotely competitive in that environment.

There are two types of traders really, those who started at the bottom and have fought their way up without a Uni education but the City is now far more focused on the second type which is the Oxbridge/Harvard spod.

I think the days of entering the City with no education has been coming to a close very rapidly since the strong emergence of the US and European banks.

At this moment in time Stat Arb seems to eb the Holy Grail of prop desks and is likely to continue. I'd go and get some books on that and if you don't find yourself driving down to Beachy Head then I'd consider paying up for a Masters or MBA.

But, going back to what I said at the beginning, never put your own money up. The % of people who make it is microscopic. The arcades use such people to pay the rent.
You mean sitting in my bedroom, wearing red braces, shouting "BUY SELL" and looking for a 1985 Guards Red 911 in the classifieds won't make me a trader?

Oh.
No, but it'll impress the ladies biggrin