Which is worst - Too fat or too skinny?

[V8S]

The extremes of weight can be equally repulsive. Someone who looks or is anorexic and someone who is obese for whatever reason both draw critics, rightly or wrongly.

What about the middle ground? Much much more is made of people who are a stone too heavy than a stone too light. Skinny people tend to come under the radar most of the time - i.e. most won't make a comment about someone who is a bit boney - whereas a girl with a muffin top is derided for daring to show her ample flesh.

So is it better to be too skinny for your body shape than too fat? Why?

[ypauly]

fat bird are far more grateful
give me a porker anytime

[Nicol@]

This skinny girl votes fat.

[SS HSV]

Skinny birds are more 'chuckable' you can't do bedroom olympics with fatties it just don't happen

[trumpet600]

Both bad.

[grumbledoak]

Bones aren't that attractive, but ripples are far worse.

[Penny-lope]

SS HSV said:

Skinny birds are more 'chuckable' you can't do bedroom olympics with fatties it just don't happen

You want a bet

And can I just ask...By too skinny, or too fat, what are we talking???

7 stone vs 17 stone

[driverrob]

There's a limit to how much weight a woman can lose - before she's hospitalised.
There seems to be no limit to how fat they can get!

[Miguel38]

SS HSV said:

Skinny birds are more 'chuckable' you can't do bedroom olympics with fatties it just don't happen

Agreed - at least with a skinny bird if you throw them around they just kinda float - where as a fatty would put a hole in the floor.

also skinny girls can get to a wider verity of positions even if they do look like there 10yr old boys....

[Hedders]

trumpet600 said:

Both bad.

One stone either way of 'normal' will do just fine for me, If i had to choose though it would be one stone underweight.

[rude-boy]

Both bad but if I had to chose I would have to leave the skinny one single for fear of getting halfway through and then having to call out “Fetch me another girl, I’ve broken this one!”

[Simond001]

Too fat could be anything from a size 14 to size 34.

Too skinny is under size 6 down to a zero (do we even have a zero?)

[Incorrigible]

Another question

Granny grabber or chubby chaser ??

[mybrainhurts]

Slightly fat and extremely skinny are on a par with badiddity....

Consequently, I was unable to vote....

[V8S]

If you see a skinny person in the street, what do you think instinctively?

When you see an overweight person in the street, what do you think instinctively?

There is quite a disparity for me, in that I'll see a skinny person and maybe think they need to eat more. I see an overweight person and I castigate them for failing to have personal control. One is sympathy or at worst apathy about them, the other is almost always a poor judgement on their mental strength and health.

I am not necessarily talking about our partners here. Just people in general. People you come into contact with.

[Murcielago_Boy]

You tend to equate Fat People with GREED... and to some extent that's true.....

[V8S]

Murcielago_Boy said:

You tend to equate Fat People with GREED... and to some extent that's true.....

Yes, gluttony. Taking too much which equates to a kind of selfishness.

[Timmy35]

From a practical point of view fat birds are worse because you have more trouble locating their 'true fagina' as opposed to the many 'false faginas' created by rolls of sweaty fat.

[Swilly]

I imagine it would be best to be less judgemental !!

[V8S]

Let's leave aside the sexual angle...

What do non-gay blokes think when they see a skinny bloke? And a fat bloke?

What do non-gay girls think when they a skinny girl? And a fat girl?