Home cinema - beginner's questions
Home cinema - beginner's questions
Author
Discussion

zadumbreion

Original Poster:

1,049 posts

249 months

Tuesday 23rd December 2008
quotequote all
We're fortunate enough to have a largish living room we never use (we all tend to hang out in the much smaller "family room") but it's about time we got some sort of TV in the living room so we could use spend time in it.

Problem is, it's "L" shaped and so I've been racking my brains because the only obvious places for a TV would be in front of the bay window or somehow above the fireplace, where there's already a mirror, mantelpiece etc - neither location particularly suitable for a TV screen.

Then I suddenly thought - maybe we could get a home cinema type jobby with an electric screen that comes down from the ceiling - that way it could go in either of those locations without being an eyesore when not in use.

So - basic question number 1 - are retracting screens like this mainly aimed at gaming and movies - or can the projector handle TV signals perfectly well - in other words, would it be useable for simple TV watching, or is there some reason (projector noise, for example) why screens and projectors aren't a good choice for TV / Sky HD ?

[PS why on earth does my PC beep every time I hold down the shift key and type the letters "TV" ?????]

cw42

976 posts

260 months

Tuesday 23rd December 2008
quotequote all
I've a big electric screen in our lounge, and I must say I rarely use it to watch the tv on.

I'd have thought a decent sized lcd/plasma would be better?

zadumbreion

Original Poster:

1,049 posts

249 months

Tuesday 23rd December 2008
quotequote all
Yeah, but I don't want it there when we're not watching it.... and we can't really put a TV smack in front of the fireplace...

sidicks

25,218 posts

250 months

Tuesday 23rd December 2008
quotequote all
zadumbreion said:
Yeah, but I don't want it there when we're not watching it.... and we can't really put a TV smack in front of the fireplace...
The big problem with Projectors is that they need a very dark room to look their best, so if you just want to watch a TV program in can be a lot of hassle to have to close all the curtains etc to make the room dark.

You can put a Plasma above the fireplace, but it will be 'obvious' which is what you are keen to avoid.

We have a separate cinema room for the projector and have a plasma TV hidden in a bespoke cabinet, which is raised electrically when we want to watch TV - is there anywhere you could put a cabinet of this type? Not cheap though.... :-(

Sidicks

The Moose

23,676 posts

238 months

Tuesday 23rd December 2008
quotequote all
my understanding is that plasmas and the like are not good above the fireplace if it is a real fireplace cause they dont like the heat and the big heat changes

there is no reason you wouldnt be able to watch tv on it, just that as mentioned you would benefit from it being darker in the room!

maybe a good idea to post this in the computer forum??

cheers

the moose

zadumbreion

Original Poster:

1,049 posts

249 months

Tuesday 23rd December 2008
quotequote all
How about "mirror TVs" ? They seem an interesting idea - but they don't seem to be widely available at any sort of sensible money.....

E31Shrew

5,963 posts

221 months

Wednesday 24th December 2008
quotequote all
zadumbreion said:
How about "mirror TVs" ? They seem an interesting idea - but they don't seem to be widely available at any sort of sensible money.....
We build mirror TV's from scratch. Screen sizes up to 40"


zadumbreion

Original Poster:

1,049 posts

249 months

Wednesday 24th December 2008
quotequote all
E31Shrew said:
zadumbreion said:
How about "mirror TVs" ? They seem an interesting idea - but they don't seem to be widely available at any sort of sensible money.....
We build mirror TV's from scratch. Screen sizes up to 40"
What TV "innards" do you use? ie which make of TV?

And are they at sensible money??

Harry Flashman

21,784 posts

271 months

Wednesday 24th December 2008
quotequote all
zadumbreion said:
E31Shrew said:
zadumbreion said:
How about "mirror TVs" ? They seem an interesting idea - but they don't seem to be widely available at any sort of sensible money.....
We build mirror TV's from scratch. Screen sizes up to 40"
What TV "innards" do you use? ie which make of TV?

And are they at sensible money??
+1 - new TV for me in new year, so I'm interested...

Streetrod

6,483 posts

235 months

Wednesday 24th December 2008
quotequote all
You can use a projector system for watching TV and with more and more HD channels coming on line the quality is very good. As has been said before projectors work best in darkened rooms but some of the latest projectors are very bright so can give a reasonable picture in a realativily light room. My screen is above some french doors therefore hidden when not in use.

You also need to consider where and what type of speakers you are going to use as well as a sound system and souce equipment. It you are not carefull it can all start to add up.

One last point, a lot of TV programmes are not designed to be seen on very large screens, soaps are a classic example. Some of those close ups can look scary when the persons face is 3 feet tall.

M400 NBL

3,552 posts

241 months

Wednesday 24th December 2008
quotequote all
I can't specificaly remember any L shaped rooms - but there are a few projector screens (and possible other solutions to your problem) in this thread.