How safe are cigars?
Author
Discussion

Mike400

Original Poster:

1,026 posts

260 months

Friday 9th January 2009
quotequote all
Just out of interest, how damaging is the occasional smoking of a cigar?

I want an unbiased answer - the net either throws up the usual no smoking brigade or the pro smoking groups. Nothing really balanced sounding, even the stuff I read on the beeb website reeks of government health agenda.

So whats the truth? (relatively) Harmless to have one now and then, or not?

Just to add that I have only smoked a handful of cigars, all cheap (i.e. not hand rolled!)

Tyre Smoke

23,018 posts

290 months

Friday 9th January 2009
quotequote all
My dad is a pipe smoker and has the occasional cigar. Apparently he is classed as a non-smoker - work that out!

Depends if you inhale I guess.

petrol_penelope

924 posts

215 months

Friday 9th January 2009
quotequote all
Smoking full stop is a danger to anybody weather it just be a puff on one or a full blown smoker.

so i would say NOT good for you.

ps. Im a smoker myself

Justin_Tvr

574 posts

214 months

Friday 9th January 2009
quotequote all
I hear pretty bad as far as mouth cancer.. though nowadays everything is bad for you; life is short if you enjoy them smoke them...

clonmult

10,529 posts

238 months

Friday 9th January 2009
quotequote all
Occasionally smoked cigars years back ... first time I tried one after a few years smoking, wish someone had told me you weren't supposed to inhale. Felt like my throat had been ripped out!

Mike400

Original Poster:

1,026 posts

260 months

Friday 9th January 2009
quotequote all
Just cant see them being that bad if you are only having a handful a year, say every other month or something?

As I said, I have only ever had cheap ones bought in a bar whilst pissed. I quite fancy ordering a couple of proper hand-rolled jobbies just to try so I cant see that doing any harm

Unless I end up liking them....

Can you get addicted to cigars?

camgear

6,941 posts

223 months

Friday 9th January 2009
quotequote all
Mouth cancer claimed my mates dad at a very early age, also caused my (very young) driving instructor a collapsed lung (as he was inhaling them!)

I know ciggies are bad, but the cigars I've smoked actually felt like they were killing me.

TWSTEEL

1,099 posts

218 months

Friday 9th January 2009
quotequote all
They never did Monica Lewinsky any harm wink

uriel

3,244 posts

280 months

Friday 9th January 2009
quotequote all
Mike400 said:
As I said, I have only ever had cheap ones bought in a bar whilst pissed. I quite fancy ordering a couple of proper hand-rolled jobbies just to try so I cant see that doing any harm
I tried this. Ordered a selection of good' ones, they arrived and I selected the biggest, fattest one and by the time I got the the end I felt like I was half drunk, half stoned. It would probably take 12 cans of lager to get me in that state. I was completely out of it and then puked my guts out. Odd because I used to smoke cheapies all the time.

G_T

16,163 posts

219 months

Friday 9th January 2009
quotequote all
Pretty unsafe tbh (and I say this as a smoker of cigars). There are loads of factors; how you smoke, what you smoke, how often you smoke and genetic factors etc. but ultimately there's a really good chance that as a regular smoker you'll die horribly. Be wary of statistics though as these vary greatly at an invidual level because of the factors mentioned e.g. some have very low probabilities and others will see ~100% chance of cancer even in low doses due to genetic predispositions.

As an aside do you know that if you eat a whole cigar you'll die? Isn't science wonderful!

Edited: Corrected piss poor spelling.

Edited by G_T on Friday 9th January 14:57

southendpier

6,205 posts

258 months

Friday 9th January 2009
quotequote all
G_T said:
Pretty unsafe tbh (and I say this as a smoker of cigars). There are loads of factors; how you smoke, what you smoke, how often you smoke and genetic factors etc. but ultimately there's a really good chance that as a regular smoker you'll die horribly. Be wary of statistics though as these vary greatly at an invidual level because of the factors mentioned e.g. some have very low probabilities and others will see ~100% chance of cancer even in low doses due to genetic predispositions.

As an aside do you know that if you eat a whole cigar you'll die? Isn't science wonderful!

Edited: Corrected piss poor spelling.

Edited by G_T on Friday 9th January 14:57
i could never eat a whole one.

loafer123

16,667 posts

244 months

Friday 9th January 2009
quotequote all

The trick is to smoke cigars that are so wince-makingly expensive that you can only afford to do it infrequently.

Works for me.

Crusoe

4,123 posts

260 months

Friday 9th January 2009
quotequote all
just as bad as sitting beside the barbeque/camp fire or eating smoked foods i'd expect. As long as it's not something you do daily then the risks are pretty small i'd say.

SpydieNut

5,956 posts

252 months

Friday 9th January 2009
quotequote all
are cigars dangerous?

just ask mr clinton

Digga

48,061 posts

312 months

Friday 9th January 2009
quotequote all
Used to smoke the odd one a few years back, but my life insurance bills, which my provider insisted it were cheaper to cover totally non-smoking than 'the odd cigar' (I've never smoked anything else) stopped the habit.

There is very little better than sitting outside on a nice, warm summers day, puffing at a hand-rolled ciger thumbup BUT I always had the most dreadful mouth the morning after - like I'd gone to sleep with an old teabag under my tongue, which can't be good for you.

Dolf

487 posts

242 months

Friday 9th January 2009
quotequote all
uriel said:
Mike400 said:
As I said, I have only ever had cheap ones bought in a bar whilst pissed. I quite fancy ordering a couple of proper hand-rolled jobbies just to try so I cant see that doing any harm
I tried this. Ordered a selection of good' ones, they arrived and I selected the biggest, fattest one and by the time I got the the end I felt like I was half drunk, half stoned. It would probably take 12 cans of lager to get me in that state. I was completely out of it and then puked my guts out. Odd because I used to smoke cheapies all the time.
Did you take it out of its plastic sleeve? biggrin

s2art

18,942 posts

282 months

Friday 9th January 2009
quotequote all
Didnr seem to hurt old Winston much. Guess it depends on your genes. The occasional cigar or ciggie isnt going to hurt you.

RDMcG

20,838 posts

236 months

Friday 9th January 2009
quotequote all
Definitely unsafe.Of course it varies with genetics and frequency. I smoke the occasional good cigar,as a former pipe smoker many years ago, but do not inhale. I enjoy it, and have a few cigar smoking mates,but certainly would not suggest its a good idea.

chris watton

22,547 posts

289 months

Friday 9th January 2009
quotequote all
Unsafe - I saw a man's face blown off when lighting his cigar in one CSI episode!
be very careful!

SubRosa

271 posts

225 months

Friday 9th January 2009
quotequote all
I enjoy the odd good quality cigar every now and again, just add it onto the list of things that "might kill me" along with driving, crossing the road, riding bikes and generally getting up in the morning biggrin