just found out my 'liz suffers from red hose syndrome :(
just found out my 'liz suffers from red hose syndrome :(
Author
Discussion

cej

Original Poster:

961 posts

253 months

Sunday 2nd July 2006
quotequote all
A couple of weeks ago I was on a long trip .The weather was extremely hot. gave a friend of mine a ride in the car and all of a sudden I couldn't engage any gears.


We got stuck in the middle of the road until I eventually managed to force it into 1st.

A couple of hours later I drove home and the problem was gone. Didn't experience it until today when I got home after a long trip and suddenly it wouldn't go into any gears again It's also very hot outside today.

So I did a little bit of reading on the net and I discovered this so-called 'red hose syndrome' .

I ran outside to check if I had it in my car..And yes There it is. Bloody red hose

Lotus engineers really messed this one up

How on earth could they even consider strapping a ruber hose to the coolant pipes and not expect it to f*ck up

Ordering a stainless steel clutch hose from eliseparts right now.

Have anyone here had it done to their car ? How much work is required ? I have no idea how to get those sill panels off . Might have to give in and let a lotus dealership to it

greysquirrel

786 posts

258 months

Sunday 2nd July 2006
quotequote all
had this problem last year and asked lotus dealer how much it would be, £70 for a cable £400 to fit apparently as they had to take the clam off.. hmm bit dodgey that as the eliseparts one seems to suggest its quite easy.
Not had the prob until i went to Europe a couple of weeks ago, smack in the centre of Geneva in traffic, no first gear... left it to cool for 30 mins and all ok again. Apparently not a "design fault" i would beg to differ!
heat volatile pile rung directly alongside something hot! nope, no prob with that...

jondude

2,441 posts

248 months

Sunday 2nd July 2006
quotequote all
May well be worth searching sites for help as you can quite easily ( with patience ) fit the hose yourself, apparently. The trick I always use on cables is to leave the original in place and feed the new one along it. If you run into areas where this is impossible. just feed the old cable through gaps with the new one tied to it.

Patience is the key. Allow yourself a weekend to do it.

Even if you then have some trouble bleeding the system, a dealer should not ask more than £20 to do this. Bit better than £400!

( You may as well buy a DIY powerbleeder kit, or just bleed with patience )

greysquirrel

786 posts

258 months

Monday 3rd July 2006
quotequote all
yeah i thought that all you should have to do is attach the old to new and feed through, unless there is some tight spots along the way. Spoke to the service reception guy and not the mechanic to be fair but he said the clam had to be removed etc, probably the easiest way to do it, and most profitable for them but prob not the only way to do it.

Jimbo2005

33 posts

250 months

Monday 3rd July 2006
quotequote all
It's a pain to do, really fiddly job...
But do it, that £400 can be spent elsewhere... As said above, leave yourselff a free weekend for it, get a powerbleeder and don't bother putting the dash top back on until the following weekend as it's the most annoying part!

s7oneyuk

18 posts

247 months

Monday 3rd July 2006
quotequote all
does anyone know if this is limited to a specific variant - or does it affect all liz's (S1 / S2 / exige etc)?

stu hill

147 posts

247 months

Monday 3rd July 2006
quotequote all
It would be nice to know about the problems easy parts as I have this to do at some point in the future.

cej

Original Poster:

961 posts

253 months

Monday 3rd July 2006
quotequote all
thanks for all the suggestions. I had a look in the service manual and they suggest to remove the left hand side dash panel and the left hand sill coin tray. That should be enough Then use the old pipe to pull the new pipe through.

I thought they'd fastened the pipe to the coolant return line, but apparently not

I thought the sill had to come off. If I can do it without removing the sill I'll give it a try. If it's 400GBP at a dealership I'll gladly use a couple of days if that's what it takes

jameshc

50 posts

259 months

Monday 3rd July 2006
quotequote all
400!!!!

I've just had mine replaced at Lakeside and they charged £170...

Wish i'd done it 4 years ago, drove it all weekend and had no problems

greysquirrel

786 posts

258 months

Monday 3rd July 2006
quotequote all
are they a main dealer?
Just booked s1 elise in for a £90 radiator fan change and advised total bill will be £517!
How can lotus get away with making stuff so hard to get to that they can then profit from the overpriced repair bills!
only broke cuz they installed them in a stupid place so water drips onto them, the same as the clutch cable.. amazing how we accept such poor design really, good job it drives so well!

jameshc

50 posts

259 months

Monday 3rd July 2006
quotequote all

Lakeside are a specialist, ex main dealer mechanics. Cant fault them on price and service.

Based just off junction 11 m25.

James

jameshc

50 posts

259 months

Monday 3rd July 2006
quotequote all

Steve williams is probably closer to you and he's just as good..

dave s1

14 posts

245 months

Wednesday 5th July 2006
quotequote all
Exactly the same thing happened to my S1 about a year ago. Misery!

Managed to fit the braided hose off eliseparts myself. It's a bit fiddely but defo worth having a go to save £400! From what I remember you just need to remove the front left part of the dash, and rear floor pannel. There are a couple of cable ties securing the red hose at the front near the dash, and a couple at the back which you can reach from the floor pannel you've removed. Hose runs down the inside of the left sill.

Then it's just a case of strapping the new hose to the old one and dragging it through!

Best of luck!

david@mediacopy

173 posts

252 months

Wednesday 5th July 2006
quotequote all
Hi Guy's,

I seem to remember that this problem is/was subject to a recall and Lotus were fixing it under warrenty. I think it applied to early S1's. I had a R plate car and as far as I remember the dealer sorted it before it became an issue.

Worth checking the assorted recall's for the S1 before spending your own cash :-)



anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 5th July 2006
quotequote all
s7oneyuk said:
does anyone know if this is limited to a specific variant - or does it affect all liz's (S1 / S2 / exige etc)?


S1 Elises only, cars up to early '99 iirc. You can find out recalls for your particular car here www.grouplotus.com/generic/generic.php?section=9&page=12&page_id=35

Hugh72

41 posts

249 months

Wednesday 5th July 2006
quotequote all
Hmmm. So mine's a '98 and shows no recalls outstanding.

I have a red hose. Can't believe someone has had the red hose replaced on warranty and then gone and put another red hose back on.

Can't be a recall item. Should be, though. It's clearly a design fault.

After the last two day's red hose nightmare on the M6, I feel a call to Horizon is on the cards.

andybuk99

312 posts

260 months

Wednesday 5th July 2006
quotequote all
just received mine yesterday and my mechanic was going to fit it but didnt realises it was such a job, even on the instructions from eliseparts they state it is a bit of a pain to fit. the mechanic called elise parts and they agreed it would take 2 mechanics about 4 hours labour! thats £180 i could do without spending!

greysquirrel

786 posts

258 months

Wednesday 5th July 2006
quotequote all
don't see why if enough of us kick up a fuss lotus can't not take this seriously. It is a design fault and can be dangerous, as a car smacks you in the rear as you rev happily in neutral.

greysquirrel

786 posts

258 months

Wednesday 5th July 2006
quotequote all
97 elise and mine shows no recalls, even with a red hose.
Also, if the hose is the same and routed the same way, why would only early models be recalled when they suffer from the same prob?
david@mediacopy said:
Hi Guy's,

I seem to remember that this problem is/was subject to a recall and Lotus were fixing it under warrenty. I think it applied to early S1's. I had a R plate car and as far as I remember the dealer sorted it before it became an issue.

Worth checking the assorted recall's for the S1 before spending your own cash :-)



mr_c

2,508 posts

260 months

Wednesday 5th July 2006
quotequote all
mines got the red hose and it's never really posed any problem. even in 90 degree heat in europe when its showing 99ºC on the display.