how much better is a 111r to an 111s
how much better is a 111r to an 111s
Author
Discussion

tonner_notts

Original Poster:

114 posts

254 months

Thursday 6th July 2006
quotequote all
it seems the prices of the r are droppin pretty quick. ive now seen some for sale at a similar price as i brought my 111s for, paid 19k for it a month ago and ive even seen 111r's for slightly less than this private.
have i made a big mistake?

Tam

135 posts

270 months

Thursday 6th July 2006
quotequote all
Possibly. It depends what you want - 111s has better low down torque, 111r has better high end oomph. And a more reliable engine, which is why lots of people buy them. If you've got one of the later 111s's then the build quality should be about the same

tonner_notts

Original Poster:

114 posts

254 months

Thursday 6th July 2006
quotequote all
its a june 04 car,
so is the exige the same at low down revs also?

shangani

3,069 posts

268 months

Thursday 6th July 2006
quotequote all
Exige has the same engine as the 111r - so it will feel the same, though it actually weighs a bit more. Get out there an enjoy your car - I haven't found much difference between an R and an S on the track.

RobM77

35,349 posts

265 months

Thursday 6th July 2006
quotequote all
I had the money for an R or an S when I bought back in March and bought the S simply as I preferred it - nothing to do with the price difference. I drove both and made a choice. I believe it is a better car for me. Everyone has their own tastes of course, but I didn't like the servo brakes in the R, or the increased weight, which seemed to dullen the tip-toe feeling of the K engined Elises I had driven. The extra power in the R was nice, but it came in very high up the rev range so I'd barely ever use it on my shortish journeys. For me, the lower weight and lack of servo brakes on the S won it over for me. Also, the fuel economy and emissions are in a different league on the S (I get 40-50mpg easily - more on the motorway, put out the same emissions as a 1 litre Micra and pay very little road tax). Once I'd driven a few Elises, it was a no brainer for me which was the better car. I feel the same way about Caterhams - I wouldn't want the new CSR with the Ford engine - I prefer the lighter original 7.

philz

107 posts

274 months

Thursday 6th July 2006
quotequote all
When I was looking for my Elise I weighed up the pro's and con's of each. I had also heard that the S had more low down power but when I overlaid the graphs it didn't at all, it had roughly the same power curve right up to 6200rpm and from then on the R just has an extra boost of power.

www.dyno-plot.co.uk/dyno/dynoplot/id%3D289_210%26sort%3Drec%26but_sea%3Dqs%26sea_simple%3Dexige/index.htm

In the end I went for the R as the sound of the exhaust when on 2nd cam is immense. The very real possibility of head gasket failure bothered me so went down the nice safe Toyota route.

I don't regret my decision at all.

shangani

3,069 posts

268 months

Thursday 6th July 2006
quotequote all
Same power, same torque, but in real world terms, 10-12% more weight for the 111r which is 860kg with no options whereas the 111s is 806 with all options incl aircon. I agree on the reliability issue though.

RobM77

35,349 posts

265 months

Thursday 6th July 2006
quotequote all
Best thing to do is to drive an R I think. It is definately down to personal preference between the two cars. The only universally accepted downside to the R is that dissapearing brake pedal - utterly ridiculous. But then if you are one of the lucky people who have the right feet and ankles to heel and toe in an early 111R (I find it impossible) this may not bother you too much!

jb111s

393 posts

249 months

Thursday 6th July 2006
quotequote all
I had the exact same decision a few months ago when buying my S. Despite all the ciriticism everyone gives the k series vvc it is a fantastic engine, great torque & fuel economy is excellent. I had the same one in my MGF before getting the liz & did 40k without any problems. As long as you drive sensibly & let the engine warm up sufficiently before thrashing it you won't get hgf. It really is a shame it gets such a bad press.

The 'yota engine is also a litte ripper though, lots of power, but adds extra weight & hasn't got the fuel economy. Upto individual choice really. I prefer the S as I get lots of low down grunt & don't like revving the engine hard to get the performance. Although for long journeys I would love the 6th gear & extra grunt on the motorway the R gives..

RobM77

35,349 posts

265 months

Thursday 6th July 2006
quotequote all
I've taken sample values off that torque and power curve that Phil posted and put them into Excel, and come up with these two graphs:



Sorry that it is very small, I don't have much time! Basically, this explains the comments people make about the R vs the S. The graph on the left is my version of the dyno plot, and it shows the 111R to be stronger on torque than the 111S, and similar on power up to 6,200 where the R goes mental and surges ahead. The interesting bit is bringing weight into the equation. The weights I used were 806kg for a standard 111S (as most are), and 879kg for a standard 111R (as few are - this doesn't include carpets, air con, touring pack etc - just amplify the effects for an average 111R).

So, performance wise:

2,000rpm - 4,000rpm identical in power/weight and torque/weight
4,000rpm - 6,500rpm 111S is stronger in power/weight and torque/weight
6,500rpm - redline 111R is stronger in power/weight and torque/weight

The percentage that each car is stronger in the latter two segments is identical at between 5 and 10%.

If anyone had guessed that I was a maths geek, then they now know that I am

kevin ritson

3,423 posts

258 months

Thursday 6th July 2006
quotequote all
For goodness sake man, stop buying cars!!!! You'll buy an R and wish you had an Exige S or a Honda conversion!

Personally, the two engines are completely different in their characteristics, the 'yota is too peaky for my tastes and as for reliability, I've heard as many stories on oil starvation on the track and downshift problems as I would have done HGF issues had there been Elise forums in the first two years of it's existance. If you look after it, it looks after your wallet, there's no such thing as a bulletproof engine...

Tam

135 posts

270 months

Thursday 6th July 2006
quotequote all
If you can't decide which you want just do the obvious thing and buy both - like me

philz

107 posts

274 months

Thursday 6th July 2006
quotequote all
Rob, I'm not sure where you got those weights from as the Lotus brochure shows the 111S to be 842kg and the 111R to be 860kg.

[URL=http://imageshack.us][/URL]

If you've still got your spreadsheet handy could you put the new weights in, I'd be interested to see the difference it makes. (also bare in mind that the 111S in my example is making a few more BHP over stock and the 111R is making a few BHP less than stock - probably down to the rollers I guess but I'd be interested in seeing an 842kg 156BHP S compared to a 860kg 189BHP R)

Edited by philz on Thursday 6th July 20:55

shangani

3,069 posts

268 months

Thursday 6th July 2006
quotequote all
Lotus must be making them heavier recently - mine (03 model) weighs in at 795 kg with fluids etc on a weighbridge. It does have lighter brake discs and a lighter exhaust, but add to that the weight of the harness bar. BTW the engine and gearbox of the 111r alone weighs 50+ kgs more than the k series.

Tim Freeman's 111s with a honda engine is 820kg from what Alex the previous owner posted.

bher

786 posts

301 months

Thursday 6th July 2006
quotequote all
just my 2 pcs:

My 111R weight at the nurburgring was exactly 862 kg with 2/3 full tank, touring pack without aircon, exige wheels and yokohama, stage 1 exhaust and ITG.

Now I put an harness and the bar behind the seats so it will be a little more at colmar berg for the next regularity race. I will follow the weights of the elise variants there and post them...

Thanks for the graph. This is a very interesting topic and I hope we will be able to clear that question.

Edited by bher on Thursday 6th July 21:08

shangani

3,069 posts

268 months

Thursday 6th July 2006
quotequote all
From Sandmuseum:

www.sandsmuseum.com/cars/elise/thecar/performance/performance.html

These are measured weights with oild / fluids / fuel. BTW Ben - remember you are also saving a fair bit of weight with the wheels you have on. (if you had them on at the time)

philz

107 posts

274 months

Thursday 6th July 2006
quotequote all
shangani said:
Lotus must be making them heavier recently - mine (03 model) weighs in at 795 kg with fluids etc on a weighbridge.


As we all know, Lotus like to change specs every other week so it's only fair to compare like for like (ie. both the 111S and 111R above are 04 models).

As the Lotus brochure shows, the 111R is 220BHP per tonne and the 111S is only 185BHP/tonne. The 111R is also a clear second quicker to 100, you can't argue with those figures.

Lotusnick S2

251 posts

261 months

Thursday 6th July 2006
quotequote all
tonner_notts, this must be the 3 elise you bought in 12 months.
Why didnt you test drive all of them before deciding?

This has been discussed so many times.
A friend has weighted in his 111s with AC and all the extras, and it was 816kg with 1/3rd tank of petrol.
Why doesnt someone weight a 111r with touring pack and AC and tell us how much it is?
I bet it is a minimum of 880kg.

Quoting Autocars figures:

____________________111s___________111r
0-60mph_____________5.0secs________5.1secs
0-100mph____________14.5secs_______13secs
30-70mph____________5.2secs________4.9secs
Using all gears
50-70_______________6.3secs________7.8secs
in top gear
60-0mph braking_____2.6secs_______2.8secs
mpg Test/Touring____29/42_________17/38

What do the above mean?
Nothing!!!

Both seem equally fast and so are in rear life (track days), but who cares?
That is not what the Elise is about anyway.
If you want real straight line performance drive a SC Honda and shit yourself.

I have a 111s and I love it and would not change it for a 111r
Equally I understand why 111r owners love them and prefer them.

Nikos








Edited by Lotusnick S2 on Thursday 6th July 21:21

shangani

3,069 posts

268 months

Thursday 6th July 2006
quotequote all
Never seen that weight for the 111s quoted ever before - I take it that is from the lotus leasing site - It is different to the figures lotus published when they were selling the 111s. Also note that the 111r is without any options - all of which are standard on the 111s. So it's not really a fair comparison - add those in and it starts even out again.

Have you ever seen a 111s on a track vs a 111r? - there is absolutely nothing in it in acceleration / top end etc in real terms. Ask anyone who has on track experience of both. 111s handles marginally better on a track on the tighter corners.

I agree re reliability etc, but couldn't bring myself to really like the buzzy nature of the toyota engine.

RobM77

35,349 posts

265 months

Thursday 6th July 2006
quotequote all
I got the weights here:

[url]www.sandsmuseum.com/cars/elise/thecar/performance/performance.html[/url]

I'm not sure where I got them from, but those were the weights that I had remembered from the launches of both cars. We must also remember that most 111Ss are actually the quoted weight, because they're fully loaded with 'touring' options already, yet most 111Rs are heavier than the standard weight because people add touring packs etc.

I've put the new weights from the brochure into my spreadsheet and get the following results:

2,000 - 4,500rpm - 111R is about 5-10% stronger in torque/weight and 3% stronger in power/weight
4,500 - 6,000rpm - 111S is about 5% stronger in torque/weight and identical / slightly stronger in power/weight.
6,000 - redline - 111R is about 15% stronger in torque/weight and power/weight.

As another thought, I don't know what the 111R touring pack weighs, but in comparing the 111S with the standard car, I would have guessed about 40kg?

So, a 111S vs a 111R with the TP: (assuming the TP is 40kg)

2,000 - 4,500rpm - 111S is about the same in torque/weight and power/weight
4,500 - 6,000rpm - 111S is about 15% stronger in torque/weight and 20% stronger in power/weight.
6,000 - redline - 111S is about the same in torque/weight and power/weight.

Whilst I do of course find this new perspective on the cars' straight line performance interesting, I will stress again that the cars just have different characters, and you need to try one to figure out which you prefer. I've met an equal number of people who prefer the R to the S.