exige, 111r, 111s??? help please!!!
exige, 111r, 111s??? help please!!!
Author
Discussion

rjr

Original Poster:

150 posts

273 months

Thursday 13th July 2006
quotequote all
Hi there im in need of some help... im in the fortuneate position of deciding between buying an s2 exige, 111r or 111s. i have had numerous s1 elise's, and i bought a new exige s2 a couple of years back, but it had to go when i moved house... But now i have the money to get something again im really not sure what to get, i guess its really between the 111r and the 111s, as i've already had an exige... would really appreciate some guidance from some experienced owners!!

shangani

3,069 posts

268 months

Thursday 13th July 2006
quotequote all


Really it is all down to personal choice. For taking the car on the track, get an exige S2. For pure road - depends what you like. There would be about a 5K saving on an S vs an R.

Have you test driven an exige s yet?

rjr

Original Poster:

150 posts

273 months

Thursday 13th July 2006
quotequote all
I have'nt driven an s yet, but to be honest they're out of mt price range at the mo... im looking to get a second hand car... up to 24k

shangani

3,069 posts

268 months

Thursday 13th July 2006
quotequote all
Do you track the car? If not and it would be your daily driver, get a 111r and enjoy roofless motoring. If you are sold on another exige, the consider a soft top kit. Also bear in mind the cost of tyres for the exige (new set every 5000 miles) and how poor they are in the wet (the 048's).

bher

786 posts

301 months

Thursday 13th July 2006
quotequote all
Tell us what you plan to do with the car and your driving expectations, we will be able to be more precise.
Both cars are great... one more than the other but do not know which for you.

Edited by bher on Thursday 13th July 10:06


Edited by bher on Thursday 13th July 10:07

hbaumhardt

950 posts

310 months

Thursday 13th July 2006
quotequote all
As a major incentive dont forget that if you were to correctly select the 111S with VVC power (being of sound mind and free will) you would benefit from membership of our exclusive VVC club, and avoid the significant humiliation of scrota mota(R) ownership.

Benefit list: More Torque, better MPG, scheduled optimisation opportunities (known as "HGF", its British, all the properly cool people here have one*, only costs £500 for a whole new replacment (e.g. if it gets dirty) ...

* kevin's beard excepted

Esprit

6,373 posts

314 months

Thursday 13th July 2006
quotequote all
hbaumhardt said:
As a major incentive dont forget that if you were to correctly select the 111S with VVC power (being of sound mind and free will) you would benefit from membership of our exclusive VVC club, and avoid the significant humiliation of scrota mota(R) ownership.

Benefit list: More Torque, better MPG, scheduled optimisation opportunities (known as "HGF", its British, all the properly cool people here have one*, only costs £500 for a whole new replacment (e.g. if it gets dirty) ...

* kevin's beard excepted


Mr Tea, meet Mr Keyboard!

mr_c

2,508 posts

260 months

Thursday 13th July 2006
quotequote all
I was waiting for Hans to come along and invite you to his exclusive club!

you didn't dissapoint mate

shangani

3,069 posts

268 months

Thursday 13th July 2006
quotequote all
Esprit - PMSL - only it was coffee meets monitor!

rjr

Original Poster:

150 posts

273 months

Thursday 13th July 2006
quotequote all
Its not gonna be an everyday car, more the kind of thing to take out at weekends etc... i won't be taking it to a track either, neither do i want to end up with a car thats been on a track! just want something to have abit of fun in... the way i see it , i could go and buy a nice 111s for around 17k ish, but is thata a bad move as for an extra 5k i could prob get a newer car, a 111r or even another exige... gotta say i still absolutely love the look of the exige!!!

shangani

3,069 posts

268 months

Thursday 13th July 2006
quotequote all
rjr said:
Its not gonna be an everyday car, more the kind of thing to take out at weekends etc... i won't be taking it to a track either, neither do i want to end up with a car thats been on a track! just want something to have abit of fun in... the way i see it , i could go and buy a nice 111s for around 17k ish, but is thata a bad move as for an extra 5k i could prob get a newer car, a 111r or even another exige... gotta say i still absolutely love the look of the exige!!!


Personally I would wonder about the logic of owning an exige that didn't go on the track - you will not get beyong 60% of the capability of the car on the road. As for cars that have been on track - they usually get looked after with a lot more attention to detail than road cars that get looked at on their annual service. Ironically most of the cars on Seloc that have done major mileage have been used on the track. It is all about whether they have been looked after.

Exige as road only car? What is the point? - it is designed primarily as a race car. Bottom line - you need to make the choice based on what is important to you - noone can help you with that aspect of the decision.

hbaumhardt

950 posts

310 months

Thursday 13th July 2006
quotequote all
I must agree with you on this non VVC related matter.

It seems an odd proposition that the exige coming as standard on A048 cut slick track biased tyres (which cost a lot and dont last long) to be used only on the road. OK if you have heaps of cash, but then being the slowest car on the motorway in the rain constantly on standby to aquaplane ??? Yup I have been sideways up the M25 at 40mph in standing water with A048s on the way to a track, and frankly bollox to that.

Edit to say: appologies to current S2 Exige drivers, no offence ment but running around the road on 48s and premium LTS badged ones at that just seems mad.

Edited by hbaumhardt on Thursday 13th July 15:15

kelk

955 posts

244 months

Thursday 13th July 2006
quotequote all
Been through the same situation myself - which Elise or Exige?

I have to say I settled on the 111R elise, the Exige S was good, don'tr get me wrong, but i'm definitely after the grin fatcor and the Exige didn't offer that as much as the Elise did. Of course this is only personal opinion.

The great thing about the Exige S is the supercharger, sounds like you're flying a tie fighter above 3000 rpm.

rjr

Original Poster:

150 posts

273 months

Thursday 13th July 2006
quotequote all
Well looks like i've got some thinking to do... thanks a lot for your help, think im swaying toward the R, but will keep you posted, thanks again. Rob

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Thursday 13th July 2006
quotequote all
If it's only going to be an occasional car and you're not going to track it, then why not wait for the new Elise S and get that. You'll probably be able to get a deal on it as IIRC they will be £23,995 rrp

jago

247 posts

250 months

Thursday 13th July 2006
quotequote all
an R with a stage2 above 6400 is something special, despite the relative merits of the S.

Dave_s2_111s

246 posts

259 months

Thursday 13th July 2006
quotequote all
Ive just brought a 2003 111s s2 (2004 spec) and im over the moon. I owned the 111s s1 4 years ago and loved it, then after that an esprit gt3. My new car lives up to every expectation. Its a newer car but still has the ripped ou rawness of an older car.
Cant really comment on the 111r but if its a fun occasional car you want do you really want abs etc:?
No id say! The 111s has everything you need.
I managed to get the 2004 spec model that has lecy windows, remote cl and updated interior etc: which is a bonus.
I use mine as a toy as well but not on the track, just sunday blasts and trips to the pub etc:

Go drive thats the best thing.
Suppose mainly depends were you like your torque band? Hi up the rev range, get the 111r, low down then get the 111s.

There both as reliable as one another i think if your talking under 3 years old.

Best of luck.

drac

369 posts

254 months

Friday 14th July 2006
quotequote all
111GRRRRRRRRRRR.
Hear the roar!

RRRRRRRRRRRRRR all the way.

boggy

4,603 posts

266 months

Friday 14th July 2006
quotequote all
No disrespect to the S I'm sure it's going to be a Great Entry level Car, the R is itself a completely different animal if you want high end power & speed then go for the R if you want a cheaper alternative then buy the S, you must take into consideration thou it's cheaper for a reason. I love my R Quicksilver Pipe & induction kit you should hear it & see it go

Boggy

bobcorb

44 posts

260 months

Friday 14th July 2006
quotequote all
I've just moved over from a Caterham R400 to an Exige. I was looking for a 111r simply because I didn't want another K series but the Exige used values have taken such a kicking recently that I found a high Spec Exige for less than the equivalent 111r. I love it, use it all the time. I use normal road tyes on it just now which are fine but I'll put the A048s back on a second set of rims when I find some. I'll use Yoko AD07s for my next set of road tyres.

I took the roof off a while back but didn't like it so much so its staying on, but thats just my preference.

BC