Poirot, dodgy insurance man and a broken Liz!
Poirot, dodgy insurance man and a broken Liz!
Author
Discussion

midas029

Original Poster:

184 posts

253 months

Thursday 3rd August 2006
quotequote all
I was on the M25 on last sat, not moving as ususal! Some guy on his way back to Belgium has crashed into the back of me, His excuse was “ I just lost concentration” I thought the damage was going to be a lot worse, The rear clam is spit and fractured and the grill above the rear diffuser is all twisted. He hit us quite hard so I was expecting worse; still I was mortified with the damage done.
Then came the concerns about his insurance with him being foreign etc, anyway that all seems to be legit, what is bothering me is my insurance.
I told them that I want my car to be repaired by Lotus, seems logical; they said that they can only repair through lotus if they agree costs. My point was the cost shouldn’t matter as they are claiming off the third party who can hardly contest liability as I wasn’t even moving.
The guy at the insurance company said that I would have to go through their repair centre if they couldn’t agree costs with Lotus, My point to him and my question is that if the repairs aren’t done by Lotus will my vehicle be worth less when it is time to sell or P/X. If the vehicle is worth less because of this I’m out of pocket, if I go through Lotus I may have to make the difference up out of my own money again leaving me out of pocket!
The insurance company said to me if your car was repaired by someone other than Lotus don’t tell the person I sell it too. When I pointed out to him that more than likely it would be P/X with the dealer who are currently preparing a quote for repair he said nothing.
If anyone has any ideas of what to do your advice would be greatly appreciated.
Will the repair of my vehicle be inferior to that of Lotus if someone else does it?
Do I stand to loose money on a resale because of someone else repairing?

Some moron not looking where he was going has caused this, while he carries on tottering around in his Volvo estate, incidentally it didn’t get a scratch, I’m left to pick up the pieces and a potential argument with my insurance company over repair and future repercussions. Anyone else had a situation like this?

John

cuzza

2,042 posts

284 months

Thursday 3rd August 2006
quotequote all
There's a guy on here (I think called anniesdad) who sorts this sort of thing out for a living - worth dropping him a mail, he always seems very helpful.

AFAIK you have the right to get the car fixed by whoever you want.

zebra

4,555 posts

245 months

Thursday 3rd August 2006
quotequote all
I had a bit of knock in my old 111s and my insurance company wanted me to go to one of their approved repairers. This happened to be some sh*t ford dealer. My concern was over potential variations between panels aswell as potential parts that might niot be new (some garages allegedly use any old bits). Phoned the Lotus garage where I got the car (Formula One, Newcastle) and they told me that it was my right to have the car fixed where I wanted fixed. So sure enough I do that, take the car in and the garage looked after the rest. My arguement to the insurance company was that as a specialist car, I wanted a specialist garage to carry out the work. Having said all that, check the small print on your insurance details, the worst case scenario is that you need a comparison quote to demonstrate the viability and economy of having your repairs carried out by a garage potentially unkown to your insurance provider; they always want the cheapest work while you want the best work to restore your liz to her former glory.

Hope that helps, but there's bound to be someone on here who can give you more detail.

Sorry to hear of the accident, it'l soon be right.

Zebra

TonyHetherington

32,091 posts

281 months

Thursday 3rd August 2006
quotequote all
Anniesdad (top bloke, by the way) is indeed the guy you're thinking of. However I don't think he's needed at the moment.

Simply put, you can have your car repaired by whoever you wish - but the insurance company of course need to agree costs. You couldn't say "my mate" will fix it and it will cost £50k.

So, get a written quote from Lotus and then send it to your insurance company. They will then have a surveyor come to look at your car (preferably at the dealership) and discuss the quotation. Once agreed, it can go ahead.

They're just trying to make you go with their 'approved repairers'. Don't get me wrong - they're approved repairers are probably as good, if not better, than Lotus. I once had my Lexus fixed by an ins companies approved repairer and it was a first class job. HOWEVER, this is your Lotus, your pride and joy, and when you come to sell it you can say it was repared by Lotus. This is important to you and to the buyer.

Just be firm, get the quote, and make them talk to your Lotus dealer.

Tony

jez o

353 posts

257 months

Thursday 3rd August 2006
quotequote all
I wouldn't worry too much- I used to work for an insurance company and their approved repairers were only used to dealing with Mondeos, Astras etc and would run a mile from anything specialist. The vast majority of approved repairers are generally not equipped/skilled enough for fibreglass etc, and if they make a mess of them, the insurer will insists it gets rectified at the expense of the repairer, usually by getting a specialist to do it!

Try and get two different quotes from somewhere you're happy to go, and make them aware you're getting more than their quote- that is supposed to ensure they give a competitive/fair quote.

Hope this helps!

midas029

Original Poster:

184 posts

253 months

Thursday 3rd August 2006
quotequote all
Lotus are picking the car up next wednesday to carry out a small amount of warranty work and provide photo`s and qoute for insuarnce. i`ll let you know what happens, I`ll stay true to my beliefs of Lotus repairing and see what transpires!


Thanks

JOhn

TonyHetherington

32,091 posts

281 months

Thursday 3rd August 2006
quotequote all
Nice one, John

sp60

524 posts

290 months

Thursday 3rd August 2006
quotequote all
midas029 said:
Lotus are picking the car up next wednesday to carry out a small amount of warranty work and provide photo`s and qoute for insuarnce. i`ll let you know what happens, I`ll stay true to my beliefs of Lotus repairing and see what transpires!


Thanks

JOhn


I had this problem with an accident in my old lotus. Because it was my fault and i needed a courtesy car, I agreed to go with their approved garage ( a Ford dealership based body shop! ). They had it in for 3 days whilst they tried to find a fibreglass specialist and price up the parts. In the end they gave up and shipped it out to a lotus specialist. On examination the specialists wrote it off due to damage to the tub. The approved bodyshop didn't even know how to check the tub, just assuming they could fix the fibreglass, bolt on new suspension parts and it would be sorted. It's well worth getting it to a specialist, but if the insurance company insist it goes to their approved dealer, go along with it, but tell them that it needs special checks and a specialist inspector to check the damage due to it's unique construction. My ins co were pretty good in the respect that they listened to what I said and took it on board.

rapid rental

477 posts

253 months

Thursday 3rd August 2006
quotequote all
midas029

Sorry to hear about your accident, legally you are entitled to have your car repaired wherever you like. I certainly would`nt go thru your own ins company, it will stuff your NCD temporarily whilst its being sorted out. If you need a replacement Lotus for the duration of repairs on your`s, then drop me an email, i may be able to help, its also possible we could pay for the repairs as well.

Non fault accidents are my speciality!

If i knew how to post photos i could show you the last few Lotus claims i have dealt with!.

Regards

MJK 24

5,679 posts

267 months

Thursday 3rd August 2006
quotequote all
It's your right to have it repaired wherever you want.

However, your insurance co. may be awkward and refuse you a courtesy car etc.

jondude

2,441 posts

248 months

Thursday 3rd August 2006
quotequote all
Or why not meet them halfway and let an independent specialist get involved, like Sinclaires, Fibreglass Services?

Although having said that, it is not so much Lotus approved they object to, it is the outrageous way many, if not all repairers, up their bills when ' the insurance pays '.

Their approved repairers spend thousands dining the board to get on the list - it means an almost never ending supply of work. Naturally, they are expected to charge less.

Your best bet is to explain this to your preferred repairer. They are fully aware what a fair(er) price is. Get a written estimate, if possible.

It won't feel this way to you, but the insurers are trying to keep everyone happy here. If they keep accepting silly repair costs from greedy garages, our premiums will rocket.

The insurance companies never have, and never will pay our repair costs. They act as credit cards, and simply send us ALL the bill at renewal.

I agree that when all is said and done, they may have to use a fibreglass/Lotus specialist anyhow.

If you can get some good estimates in the meantime, that will swing it.

midas029

Original Poster:

184 posts

253 months

Friday 4th August 2006
quotequote all
this is the email i have recieved from the insurance company. Not quite sure what it means? Any suggestions?

Following conversation with claims department. I have been advised that if you seek indemnity under the terms of your policy. We will seek to agree cost with your lotus dealer. If we are unable to do so we can direct you to a recommended repairer or settle your claim with an amount equal to the loss or damage.

Approaching the third party insurers direct to see if they would authorise direct with the lotus dealer, would not be seeking indemnity through your policy. We would not normally get involved with these negotiations.

Regards, Paul Loveridge

zippee

14,155 posts

265 months

Friday 4th August 2006
quotequote all
jez o said:
I wouldn't worry too much- I used to work for an insurance company and their approved repairers were only used to dealing with Mondeos, Astras etc and would run a mile from anything specialist. The vast majority of approved repairers are generally not equipped/skilled enough for fibreglass etc, and if they make a mess of them, the insurer will insists it gets rectified at the expense of the repairer, usually by getting a specialist to do it!


Agree with this, when my TVR was reversed into my insurers tried to insist on me using a particular garage for repairs despite my protest. On ringing the garage myself and telling them it was a fibreglass repair they instantly said they couldn't do it. Relayed this back to the ins company and they still tried to insist I take it there.
This is one of the main reasons I used Anniesdad (Steve Greensmith - www.europaconsultants.co.uk) as he actually knew what he was talking about, got my car repairs authorised within a couple of days and booked into where I wanted along with a like for like hire car for the duration of the repair.
I've recommended him to several PHers and can't recommend him enough.....

s55shh

523 posts

243 months

Friday 4th August 2006
quotequote all
Definately sounds like a viable credit repair / credit hire job to me.

midas029

Original Poster:

184 posts

253 months

Friday 4th August 2006
quotequote all
Thanks for the advice on anniesdad, looking at the website now. Hopefully all will go well.

midas029

Original Poster:

184 posts

253 months

Tuesday 8th August 2006
quotequote all
Zippee,

thanks for the limk, I spoke to Steve Yesterday and i feel a lot happier about the situation now. Appears in have people who are actually intersted in my car being repaired.

Thanks again

John

zippee

14,155 posts

265 months

Tuesday 8th August 2006
quotequote all
midas029 said:
Zippee,

thanks for the limk, I spoke to Steve Yesterday and i feel a lot happier about the situation now. Appears in have people who are actually intersted in my car being repaired.

Thanks again

John


No problem John,

Spoke to Steve yesterday on an unrelated matter and he mentioned you had called. Your car will be in the best hands with him.
Hope all goes well

Tony

S works

10,166 posts

281 months

Tuesday 8th August 2006
quotequote all
Another vote for Steve here

boggy

4,603 posts

266 months

Tuesday 8th August 2006
quotequote all
Here to very helpful and professional service

Boggy