Exige S against hardtop Elise 250S from komotec, report...
Exige S against hardtop Elise 250S from komotec, report...
Author
Discussion

GTRene

Original Poster:

22,798 posts

255 months

Thursday 3rd August 2006
quotequote all
Lotus Exige S duel against the hardtop Lotus Elise 250S from komotec(261ps), all in German because its from a german carmagazine you realy must see the difference from 0 to 200km/h the 250S is more then 4 sec faster! there are some beautiful pictures though, and a nice testresult! also the price seems to be good...;the tuning cost 9.900,-euro included the exhaust! so thats not that bad, ofcorse you could buy some more options like brakes and wheels all up to you, see their list

www.komo-tec.com/media/products/0043378001150721335.pdf

the rest you can find on their website;

www.komo-tec.com/product_info.php/products_id/437/language/en

GTRene


Edited by GTRene on Friday 4th August 00:00

Phil-CH

1,132 posts

295 months

Tuesday 8th August 2006
quotequote all
Nice info. Amusingly, after looking at the specs and the time results, the similarities to the Bemani S/C conversion are quite striking: Same torque, same output power - even the cooling method seems to be identical. Heck even the price is identical (9900 Euro)...

I wouldn't be surprised if the the Komo-Tec Elise is in fact an nigh identical to the Bemani conversion.

A Bemani Exige would be a bit slower at higher speeds than the Komo-Tec Elise (or Bemani Elise) because of the downforce...

GTRene

Original Poster:

22,798 posts

255 months

Tuesday 8th August 2006
quotequote all
Yep I thought so too...but they never talk about bemani...so I think they have the same supplier from the SC and make their own installations to make all work, thats why they don't have to name it a bemani kit?
Anyway it looks oke, its closer to most of us and the price is ok! and best, its fast too
GTRene

Phil-CH

1,132 posts

295 months

Tuesday 8th August 2006
quotequote all
GTRene said:
Yep I thought so too...but they never talk about bemani...so I think they have the same supplier from the SC and make their own installations to make all work, thats why they don't have to name it a bemani kit?
Anyway it looks oke, its closer to most of us and the price is ok! and best, its fast too
GTRene


Maybe... although Red-Motorsports sells them without any mention of Bemani either. It could very well be a more or less identical package Komo-Tec is selling (but assembling on their own). The super-charger Bemani uses is also a Roots-type (a slightly larger one than the one used in the Exige-S / 240R).

From the magazine I have that tested a Bemani Exige (in Winter), the performance figures speak for themselves:

0-100km/h (62mph) in 4.3s (komo-tec Elise in 4.2)
0-160km/h in 9.7s (komo-tec Elise in 9.5)
0-200km/h in 16.5s (komo-tec Elise in 15.3)

Keep in mind though that the Elise would be slightly lighter and doesn't have the extra downforce that the Exige has to carry with it. Also, the above figures were taken at 3°C - which surely would have had an impact on the grip of the summer tires. All in all, I'd say the Komo-Tec Elise is pretty much what I'd expect a Bemani Elise to reach.

Also the figures...
80-120kmh in 5th gear in 5.9s (komo-tec Elise in 6.2) (Std. Exige in 8.8s)
80-120kmh in 6th gear in 7.5s (komo-tec Elise in 7.6) (Std. Exige in 11.2s)

...are very similar.

All in all, very good figures and good to see Komo-Tec offering a kit that seems to be as thought-through as the Bemani solution...

GTRene

Original Poster:

22,798 posts

255 months

Tuesday 8th August 2006
quotequote all
Yep, so I think its all around the "same" system and they use some parts from the same builder of that SC?? sure the maker is not bemani on that SC maybe those SC are made in the UK? only the provide the bemani compleet kit...
That could explain those almost the same results? and maybe all have there own ECU settings? and own plumbing?

Anyway, I nice list you came up with and 3degrees temp is a very good temp! not for tires(below 7 is bad) but for air into the engine, more cold air! better performance

Indeed the Elise is a bit lighter too, and have a better cw drag for topspeeds...specialy with hardtop me thinks...

Also very glad Komo-tech offering sort like a kit as the bemani...its much closer to me if I would deside to buy a 111R and put a SC on it, those kits I like way more better then the high mounted intercooler systems of the 240 exige's and those not lotus kits are useble for exige and elise and have more better power too what more do you need...euhm more cash

But what about Rotrex chargers, they do a fantastic 360hp kit for a honda conversion, how about the Rotrex system for the 111R and Exige anyone have info about that??

GTRene

Phil-CH

1,132 posts

295 months

Tuesday 8th August 2006
quotequote all
GTRene,

From what I know is, both the Exige-S/240R and the Bemani Exige/Elise use Eaton-Superchargers. The only difference is that Bemani uses a slightly larger one than Lotus chose. I would think that Komo-Tec also went with a Eaton-Supercharger, possibly even the same size as Bemani chose given the same power output and identical cooling method.

About ECU remaps; from what I heard from Bemani, doing ECU remaps isn't easy. I won't be able to remap my MY05 to the lower cam-change solely because there would be other changes required to optimize performance as was done with the newer models. All MY06 models that are Bemani supercharged however, have the lower cam change...

I would think that Komo-Tec faces a similar situation - can't really be sure though.

GTRene said:
Anyway, I nice list you came up with and 3degrees temp is a very good temp! not for tires(below 7 is bad) but for air into the engine, more cold air! better performance


Yep, 3 degrees is better for the engine, but after speaking to Bemani, I'm very confident that the Exige can reach the 4.2s barrier in summer thanks to the water-cooling which is pretty much flawless, even after hard tracking from what I heard without any drop in performance.

Edited by Phil-CH on Tuesday 8th August 15:44

GTRene

Original Poster:

22,798 posts

255 months

Tuesday 8th August 2006
quotequote all
yeah, that is also what I like about the bemani setup and I believe the same komo-tech en Red-motorsport set up, and ofcorse the fact they can be put in the 111R and the Exige and have more power, and the weight lower mounted

At Komo-tech they also offer upgrade's from 1.8 to 2.0L and around 30hp more and 40nm! see their website list.

www.komo-tec.com/index.php/cPath/128_135

They also deliver some chips for better torgue, maybe they also have some good things for the 05 models?
GTRene

zebra

4,555 posts

245 months

Tuesday 8th August 2006
quotequote all
GTRene said:
yeah, that is also what I like about the bemani setup and I believe the same komo-tech en Red-motorsport set up, and ofcorse the fact they can be put in the 111R and the Exige and have more power, and the weight lower mounted

At Komo-tech they also offer upgrade's from 1.8 to 2.0L and around 30hp more and 40nm! see their website list.

www.komo-tec.com/index.php/cPath/128_135

They also deliver some chips for better torgue, maybe they also have some good things for the 05 models?
GTRene


There's some good stuff on that site mate, very interested.

Zebra