S2000 v Elise
Author
Discussion

pattyg

Original Poster:

1,385 posts

258 months

Monday 7th August 2006
quotequote all
I'll keep this brief and to the point-

Used to own a 1997 S1. Recently driven a 2003 S2. Most recently a 1999 S2000.

S2000 soooo much faster and refined. Accelaration from 50mph is in a different league and the engine note is delicious.

BUT

Cabin is tiny, driving position awful (i'm 6'2" though), cheap plastic interior, not as inspiring in the twisties and dull looks all imho.
Overall, I'd take the Elise every time and that is without driving a 111r. Opinions

Edited by pattyg on Monday 7th August 22:23


Edited by pattyg on Monday 7th August 22:24

as400

161 posts

243 months

Monday 7th August 2006
quotequote all
"S2000 soooo much faster and refined. Accelaration from 50mph is in a different league and the engine note is delicious"

"Overall, I'd take the Elise every time and that is without driving a 111r"

So, that's a Honda engine conversion into the Elise for you then.

shangani

3,069 posts

268 months

Monday 7th August 2006
quotequote all
pattyg said:
I'll keep this brief and to the point-
S2000 soooo much faster and refined. Acceleration from 50mph is in a different league and the engine note is delicious.


Faster? My S2 111s murders an S2000 below 100 mph. I also couldn't stand the lack of grunt on the S2000 below 6000 rpm. I agree re refinement and engine note.

S2000 - 0-60 in 6.2 sec (111s = 5.1, 111r 4.9 sec)

Above 100 the S2000 will win hands down, but I never go that fast on roads and the elise is far more fun on track. Also, there are quite a few things that can be done to make an elise faster. The S2000 engine is pretty near the limit out of the box. (great engine, though the K20a is more useable)

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Monday 7th August 2006
quotequote all
I have a Honda engined Elise, and it's superb with the cam change remapped to 4200rpm. To me it makes way more sense than the 111R engine, or the map in the S2000.

The perfect RWD sports car? I think so

Bingoid

15,184 posts

250 months

Tuesday 8th August 2006
quotequote all
S2000 is for Lawyers and retired old men in mid-life crisis, people who think that they would be different and buy a Honda, not a Boxster.....

It says it all when I was parked up the other night and an S2000 driver nearly spun his head round 180 degrees gawping at me...(well the car....). I have never gawped at an S2000....

gooby

9,269 posts

265 months

Tuesday 8th August 2006
quotequote all
I have been a big (HUGE) fan of Honda and I have owned 3 in the past and loved every one. After my first test in an 111R I tried a s2ooo. I have never been so disapointed. I really wanted the s2k to be brilliant. The interior is like a plush office and driving the thing is like doing business, all very nice but not enough fun. There is no sence of occasion, no huge smiles and no adrenalin.

in the first couple of thausand of miles I had my R (before the engine had loosened up) I came across a playful s2k and he mullered me above 90 (Kms, of course). I really do think that it would be a different story now.

The engine in the s2k is just the best 4 pot ever made. I would love one! The layout is lovely (frint engine, rear drive) But the package as a whole leaves me cold. Shame...

kevin ritson

3,423 posts

258 months

Tuesday 8th August 2006
quotequote all
Bingoid said:
S2000 is for Lawyers


Oi, watch it

bing

1,946 posts

269 months

Tuesday 8th August 2006
quotequote all
gooby said:
I have been a big (HUGE) fan of Honda and I have owned 3 in the past and loved every one. After my first test in an 111R I tried a s2ooo. I have never been so disapointed. I really wanted the s2k to be brilliant. The interior is like a plush office and driving the thing is like doing business, all very nice but not enough fun. There is no sence of occasion, no huge smiles and no adrenalin.


I had and still own a type-r before my 111r and I did the same as goob, took the s2k out for a test drive, was kind of impressed, THEN took the 111r out for a test and that BLEW me away hence I got the R....still the s2k is very nice car, I've adviced my sister to get one as she wants a convertible!!!!!

Edited by bing on Tuesday 8th August 10:09

TonyHetherington

32,091 posts

281 months

Tuesday 8th August 2006
quotequote all
I almost bought a new S2000 before I bought my Elise. Had an S2k for a couple of days, all decided what spec, colour etc, just needed to sign. I said I'd wait for a week (which, in fact was a week away on the very original EuroHoon) to mull it over in my head because it was a lot of money.

The car is fantastic, I loved the engine (even though you needed to work it). The car flowed well in the corners and I really liked the look of it.

The thing that changed my mind was the interior. It was awful! Cheap and plasticy and for a £27k car I just don't think it did it justice, considering that's where I'd be spending most of my time.

SOOOoooooo.....I got a £23k Elise (ironically, with no flipping interior hehe!!) and have never looked back. Is the most perfect car for me I can imagine.

gooby

9,269 posts

265 months

Tuesday 8th August 2006
quotequote all
TonyHetherington said:
I almost bought a new S2000 before I bought my Elise. Had an S2k for a couple of days, all decided what spec, colour etc, just needed to sign. I said I'd wait for a week (which, in fact was a week away on the very original EuroHoon) to mull it over in my head because it was a lot of money.

The car is fantastic, I loved the engine (even though you needed to work it). The car flowed well in the corners and I really liked the look of it.

The thing that changed my mind was the interior. It was awful! Cheap and plasticy and for a £27k car I just don't think it did it justice, considering that's where I'd be spending most of my time.

SOOOoooooo.....I got a £23k Elise (ironically, with no flipping interior hehe!!) and have never looked back. Is the most perfect car for me I can imagine.


I have to agree. I found the interior had no sence of occasion, to the point that the best thing was the "start" button. Dont megans have these? The lotus interior does so much more with so much less. You know you are in a sports car in the lotus and you feel fast even if you are in the garage.

I still really want to like the s2k... I just cant. Dynamically it is very good (no elise) but still best in its class it is just the elise has its own class. If I was zapping down to the south of france and sticking to the m-ways, I would probably choose one. Untill I am that dull it will stay with the dealer. God I love that engine...

Bingoid

15,184 posts

250 months

Tuesday 8th August 2006
quotequote all
Go on S2ki.com and see how many spin off the road - scary on-limits handling - owners report that they can swap ends very quickly - the Elise's MR layout is so much better IMO

Esprit

6,373 posts

314 months

Tuesday 8th August 2006
quotequote all
My Elise (basically standard S1) keeps up with S2000s on the back straight at Pukekohe quite easily, except for maybe the lst 100-200, but then I murder them under brakes.... they're not THAT much quicker than an Elise and I maintain that they're not quicker at all until you're over about 90mph (which is nearing the top speed of an Elise anyway).

Down the quarter mile, even a bog standard Elise just pips the S2000 (although by the end the S2000 is hauling back lost ground) and given that the S2000 is not that much quicker in a straight line and it's never going to be anywhere near a Liz in the corners, that basically sums it up.

The S2000 is a better prospect as a genuine sports car than say an MX5 as it's got a fierce punch, but it's not in an Elise's league in most situations..

TonyHetherington

32,091 posts

281 months

Tuesday 8th August 2006
quotequote all
Absolutely agree. I would never say to someone "don't get an S2k", far from it, it was just that interior really ruined it for me. It was going to be my one big purchase, take all of my money, and it just didn't feel "special" where as the Elise in it's "less is more" state really *does* feel special.

boobles

15,251 posts

246 months

Tuesday 8th August 2006
quotequote all
I have to say that i am suprised the s2000 is quicker. I left one for dust few weeks ago, 0 - about 100mph, i left him for dead in my elise.

TonyHetherington

32,091 posts

281 months

Tuesday 8th August 2006
quotequote all
Bingoid said:
Go on S2ki.com and see how many spin off the road - scary on-limits handling - owners report that they can swap ends very quickly - the Elise's MR layout is so much better IMO


Take that comment with a pinch of salt. The early ones were tricky on the limit I'll not deny, but they've addressed this in modern cars.

Lotusnick S2

251 posts

261 months

Tuesday 8th August 2006
quotequote all
One of my best mates had a 2001 S2K and a couple of years ago bought the 2004 model.

The 04 feels improved with better engine response and better ride.
However the steering is still dead and interior feels cramped.

As far as speed is concerned, from a standstill there is no comparison between my 111s and the S2K.
If it is dry the difference up to 110 is just a couple of cars.
If it is raining the S2K just does not have anything like the Elise's traction and just stays behind.

On the Bedford back straight the cars feel equal up to 110+ and then then the S2K is slightly faster.

Lotusnick S2

251 posts

261 months

Tuesday 8th August 2006
quotequote all
Bingoid said:
Go on S2ki.com and see how many spin off the road - scary on-limits handling - owners report that they can swap ends very quickly - the Elise's MR layout is so much better IMO

I dont think its handling is bad.
The steering might be dead and the car might respond less directly than the Elise.
But if driven properly it is quite grippy (not as much as an Elise) helped by its wide (225F 245R) tyres.
I have also found it very easy to drift with its ideal layout of FR and an LSD.

People should stop blaming the car (whether it is the S2K, Elise or Golf) and learn how to drive within their limits.

All in all, I think it is made for different people than the ones that buy Elises.

My friend would never live with the Elise althought he agrees it is far better as a sports car and I could never drive a lifeless car like the S2K after driven the Elise.
Good car it may be, pure sports car it definetely isnt.

Nikos

P.S. They are not 100% reliable as people would expect them to be and if tracked they can get expensive

emenel

891 posts

250 months

Tuesday 8th August 2006
quotequote all
I had an S2000 prior to my current Exige. Fabulous car in almost every way but I agree that it did lack a sense of occassion. In terms of on road performance, I never had a chance to put up against an Elise but I managed to engage in frequent battle with an E46 M3 (always on a private driveway of course) and can honestly say that you could not seperate the two until you got to stupid mph. On paper the M3 should eat it for breakfast but it seemed that once you learn how to keep that incredible vtec 'in the zone' it can punch well above it's weight.

I had the 04 model with revised suspension etc. and it was a very capable car. In the wet, however, it was... errrrr... entertaining!

Exige S is in a different league though! 4,000 miles now and getting better and better.

havoc

33,516 posts

266 months

Tuesday 8th August 2006
quotequote all
Esprit said:
Down the quarter mile, even a bog standard Elise just pips the S2000 (although by the end the S2000 is hauling back lost ground) and given that the S2000 is not that much quicker in a straight line and it's never going to be anywhere near a Liz in the corners, that basically sums it up.

The S2000 is a better prospect as a genuine sports car than say an MX5 as it's got a fierce punch, but it's not in an Elise's league in most situations..
Very dismissive, Esprit. And I'm not convinced about your performance quotes - see below (agreed on E46 M3...have done the same and was surprised!)


I'm going to have to defend the S2000 here...to a degree.


I drove a VX220 and an S2000 within a week of each other, then bought an S2000.
Speed: The S2000, off the line, isn't THAT quick...VTEC and tall-gearing (42mph in 1st) see to that. But once moving and in-VTEC, it's at least as rapid as a 111S, just that first 20-30mph that let it down. In the real-world, it doesn't make much difference...the comparative lack of mid-range is worse if you don't drive with regard to it, same as 111R.

Handling: Never going to match an Elise/VX, but it is very well set-up and has a shed-load of grip. Very sensitive to geometry set-up (FULLY adjustable - camber, castor, toe), but can be set-up to be fairly progressive at the rear, and castor can be adjusted to give enough steering feel (cross-braces improve both further). IMHO the 'original' set-up was agility-optimised but gave insufficient feedback (hence the accidents), while the 'UK revised' was grandad-spec safety-oriented. If you know what you're doing it is quite easy to get a fun set-up and sufficient feedback to enjoy it. Still twitchy in the wet, largely due to dry-optimised tyres (think half-way to a CSL-spec tyre!)...most owners report major improvements from changing tyres.

Interior/space/boot: IMHO very good quality for the type of car, and very good for Honda (not their forte 8 years ago). Miles better than Elise/VX. Won't compare to Z4/Boxster/SLK because they're a lot more expensive for the same performance (and a lot heavier)...think of it as half-way between an Elise and a Z4. As for 'small'...it's clearly bigger than the VX I was in, and in the important areas:-
- VX: Bump elbows with passenger constantly. Decent room by 'outside' elbow. No storage inside. Boot barely adequate (Elise smaller?). Driving position very good, seat not especially comfortable.
- S2000: Tight-ish on 'outside' elbow, plenty of room in the middle. Just about enough storage. Boot is a tardis. Driving position very good, seats pretty comfortable. Far more practical as a car for two people to go away in, and for one person to 'live with' day-to-day (where do you put CDs, glasses cases, atlas...?).


What else?
Sound: S2000 MILES better. Off-cam it's a bit quiet, but on-cam it's glorious. Only Exige or Sport-Elise's are in the same league.
Looks: All look good. S2000 has aged far better than S1 (and still looks among best in class...only SLK better), S2 looks the mutt's - mini-exotic. VX 'challenging' but not unattractive.
Build: S2000 impeccably built, VX felt VERY tinny and rattly. There was no 'interior materials' to speak of.
Ride: Not a lot between them. S2000 feels slightly better 'damped', but VX not as unforgiving as I expected.
Gearbox: No contest - the S2000 has the best in the business. VX 'box was fine, but unexceptional. I understand K-series 'box is worse.
Pedals: S2000 brake pedal needs more feel. Otherwise fine. VX took getting used to but was very rewarding.


Summary: S2000 was designed as a day-to-day sports car, and works very well. Elise/VX designed as a weekend fun car, and works brilliantly. They're too different to compare.
I actually own the S2000 as a second car because the VX wasn't practical enough and didn't feel well-built enough. It isn't perfect, and my old Integra was clearly a more involving car (I'd probably have it over an Elise for a B-road blat...seriously!), but it is teaching me rwd and is a genuinely good car in it's own right.


Apologies for the essay.

bing

1,946 posts

269 months

Tuesday 8th August 2006
quotequote all
Yep agreed with the above as with TonyH, I nearly bought one too as my Type R was soooooo much fun and I was and still am a Honda fan....thing that stopped me was that the s2k didn't feel as raw as my type-r, wasn't worth the extra money as I didn't feel 'alive' in it(25K), didn't feel as fast....I guess if the Elise didn't exist or I didn't get on with the 'lizI would have bought the s2k.....still very capable car though.....not as good as the new Integra type-r (DC5) IMO!!!!!

PS there is also no Honda (except maybe the NSX) that is anywhere near as sexxxxxy as the Elise!!!