Elsie S1 Advice re servicing
Elsie S1 Advice re servicing
Author
Discussion

SpikeOT

Original Poster:

129 posts

244 months

Thursday 10th August 2006
quotequote all
Hello to you all,

I'm new here as I purchased a 1997 Elise S1 a few weeks back and have recently discovered a few slightly un-nerving things I'd like your advice on. The model I bought is a 13000 mile S1 registered in Oct 1997 and it is totally unmodified. Managed to bag it for £9500 which seemed like a good enough deal that I only did an HPI check before saying yes.

The previous (and only) owner had a bad back and has only driven the car 400 miles in the last 2 years. They are a client of mine, and trustworthy, so I trust this is true. It's also backed up by the mileages on the MOT certificates. The car has a full Lotus history, but seems to have missed its last service as the owner figured it didn't need one because it had only done 250 miles since the one before!

I am so unbelievably happy to have got my hands on this car, and just want to get it back in the best possible health. The issues I'm faced with are the following:

1: Red Clutch Hose - I'm on the case with this and will be fitting an Eliseparts.com braided hose ASAP. Any fitting advice gratefully received!

2: Corrosion under floor mats (I have lumpy rubber mats, something apparently indicates corrosion). I haven't lifted them to check in case I make them look worse. The lumps are about the size of 10p pieces. Has anyone on here had this? It seems I'm out of warranty regarding corrosion with Lotus, so may have to pay to rectify this myself. Anyone know what this costs. Is it worth pleading with Lotus warranty care over the fact that I'm 10 months out of warranty and the problem was their fault?

3: Noisy suspension - The suspension feels great most of the time, but makes some quite loud squeaks and makes a loud crashing noise over potholes etc. I've checked tyre pressures so it can't be them. Don't expect it to ride like a Jag, but this seems very crashy indeed to me. Dampers seem fine when you push the car down while parked and handling is excellent. Is there a part that cushions the blow when the suspension runs out of travel? If so I think this/ these may be dead.

4: Hard Top: The car came with no hard top. Do I need one of these when it seems my soft top is watertight? Does the hard top make the car more refined? IT doesn't sound like it from what I have read... I'm going to refurb the soft top and see how I get on I think.

5: Servicing: I haven’t got m hands on the service history yet as the previous owner is sending it to me when they get back from hols in 2 weeks. Would you recommend I go for the full ‘C’ Service with cambelt change if the car has been sitting around for essentially 2 years? I’m just nervous of writing off a relatively young K-Series engine. Also, how does everyone feel about full Lotus histories? I’m in Balham and getting to my nearest dealer is pain the backside. Was thinking I might let a classic car dealership do the work, but nervous about letting someone that doesn’t normally look after Elises do the work...

Any help you guys can offer would be much appreciated and if you think I should go somewhere else to ask this, please let me know.

James

DSS123

351 posts

267 months

Thursday 10th August 2006
quotequote all
Hi James,

Sounds like you have a little jem there.

I'll offer a few pointers if I can.

1: Red Clutch Hose - Yup, get that one sorted as soon as poss. Also well worth fitting braided brake lines as well. Not expensive and really improves pedal feel (along with new pads and a full bleed)

2: Corrosion under floor mats - Happens to most I am afraid, mine included. I have heard of some people being lucky and getting a dealer to do the work FOC even out of warranty. Maybe you could offer to pay half. Either way, get the mats up ASAP and clean and dry everything to prevent it getting worse. Very often the lumps in the mats are caused by acummulated gunk.

3: Noisy suspension - They all do that mate, S1 sus is very crashy. Should be good for 30k miles but worth replacing with S2 when they do give up the ghost. Costs about £600 with a geo.

4: Hard Top: In my opinion - not needed. Bit more secure, bit quieter but that's not why I bought my Elise!

5: Servicing: I would get a full C, regardless of miles. It's the years that matter for the cam belt and if it hasn't had one, it's long overdue! Get it done ASAP. (about £300-£400 non dealer prices)

Also I don't think a dealer service history is of any value really. Many of the specialists are more highly regarded than most dealers.

Hope it helps


Dunc


Jimbo2005

33 posts

250 months

Thursday 10th August 2006
quotequote all
Hello!
1, Clutch hose is a pain to do, not too difficult but very fiddly. However it means taking many bits off which I found really interesting as you will learn/see loads about the car. Search the forums here and seloc.org for tips etc but basically leave a whole weekend, get hold of an Eezibleed kit (Halfords) to make life easier and make sure you reuse the insulation to stop the braid chafing.

2, The lumps may be just glue from the floor covering, mine were so have a look but not a worry, i think most kind dealers can be persuaded to sort it for free..

3, I learned to love it, especcially combined with damper noises as the fluid moves, reminds me of mountain bike suspension working away...

4, Do it! If not for any other reason than the depression of winter setting in being overcome by how the car actually looks better with a coloured roof..

5, Yup, and get the C done asap at a local specialist.

6, Increase the mileage at once. Go nowhere at least once a week for a few hours.


Edited by Jimbo2005 on Thursday 10th August 14:19

Ruxpin

324 posts

276 months

Thursday 10th August 2006
quotequote all
Congrats on the purchase - just in time for some summer motoring

Some answers to your questions....

1. Red Hose. Don't know as doesn't affect me - don't think it is too difficult through

2: Corrosion under floor mats - i'd definitely have a go with lotus - they have acknowledged the problem so IMHO shoud rectify it. However if you have to do it yourself and it is only the minor repair i don't think it would be too difficult - it doesn't take lotus very long and they only appear to clean the corrosion off and refit some super thin mats - i wore through them in a few weeks!

3: Noisy suspension - They all do that. If it bothers you / when the original suspension fails fit either the S2 suspension kit or upgrade to nitrons/ohlins if you track the car lots

4: Hard Top - Its noisier with my hardtop. Still leaks with the hardtop. However is more secure

5: Servicing - its quite an old car. IMHO i think you'd be throwing money away taking it to a Lotus main dealer. In 2 services you'd save enough money going to a indi to pay for the S2 suspension upgrade. Its only a rover engine so can be serviced by anyone who can pick a spanner up. Suspension is worth getting set up by a good indi. Not having a full Lotus history will but some people off when it comes to sell (Wrongly IMHO having sampled Lotus servicing and customer care) but you'll save more in the long run.

All i would say is get some proper tyres on it if they are the originals. Having stuck by P-Zeros for several years waiting for them to wear out, the change to yokohama advans is huge - definitely worth the extra spend.

Get out and put some miles on it

SpikeOT

Original Poster:

129 posts

244 months

Thursday 10th August 2006
quotequote all
Thanks for the advice guys - I thought a C service was probably wise. Also not surprised the genral concensus is that dealer service history is not required for an 8 yr old car.

Suspension I can easily live with, I just wanted to check it was a case of them all doing that.

Driving the car everywhere, whether I need to or not at the moment - I am also on the waiting list for the Goodwood Road Racing Club thanks to my girlfriend, so will be giving it a healthy outingat that track (which I love) as soonas I can. I've only driven a '63 E-Type round it so far, so will be very interested to compare that experience with something that has brakes and traction! Anyone tried an MMC disc car on a track? I hear the discs aren't really made for track use...

Also pleasantly surprised that you can get a week's food shopping in the boot no trouble, although hot yoghurt doesn't taste as good as cold, I have recently discovered.

Thanks for mentioning tyres Ruxpin, meant to ask about them too. I am on the P-Zeros which seem good, if a little understeery at the front. On the standard 185s and 205s - will try Advans next time round - what sizes do you run Ruxpin?

Thanks,

James

purpleheadedcerb

1,143 posts

253 months

Friday 11th August 2006
quotequote all
I did a track day a couple of weeks ago at Rockingham which is very hard on brakes.

I've got the original MMC set up and P Zeros. I did 120 track miles in all and didn't experience any fade. I did however treat them kindly, you can feel the effectiveness going away slightly after say 10 minutes of hard use, I would then do 5 mins of moderate use and then a cool down lap. The P zeros were rubbish, no confidence in them at all in long corners at 80 mph. You will experince a few corners like that at Goodwood and will see what I'm getting at.

Haven't driven Goodwood for a few years but its still runs a close favourite to Cadwell for me.

Scott

TIPPER

2,955 posts

250 months

Friday 11th August 2006
quotequote all
HiSpike. Sounds like a really nice car. Deffo get the C service done and change those P- Zeros. Advans are the way to go for the S1. Only available from Lotus dealers. They must have a LTS suffix for the Elise. Don't believe any tyre outfit that says they don't.
Other options for the S1 are BF Goodrich G force Profilers or Toyo T1Rs.
I recently chucked away my p-zeroas and fitted the Goodrichs - massive improvement. Piooly on here haws the Toyos and rates them highly.

S works

10,166 posts

281 months

Saturday 12th August 2006
quotequote all
SpikeOT said:
Thanks for the advice guys - I thought a C service was probably wise. Also not surprised the genral concensus is that dealer service history is not required for an 8 yr old car.

Hi James, welcome to the nuthouse and congrats on your purchase!

I echo everyone's advice above on Q's 1-4.

Regarding service history - it's not 'dealer' servicing that people look for on an Elise, it's more 'who has done the servicing' and 'was it done on time'.

Re: Who? Speak to 1,000 Elise/Exige/340R owners and ask them who they get their cars serviced with and I'd wager that the vast majority would tell you the name of a good local independent NOT a main dealer. Why? Cost is one factor, ability (or percieved lack thereof) will likely be the other.

Re: Was it done on time? This is particularly important with the K-series around the schedules for changing the cam and alternator belts. One of these fails and you'll have a large and unwelcome bill, far in excess of the cost of the service to replace them. For peace of mind, get it done.

SpikeOT said:
Suspension I can easily live with, I just wanted to check it was a case of them all doing that.

Driving the car everywhere, whether I need to or not at the moment - I am also on the waiting list for the Goodwood Road Racing Club thanks to my girlfriend, so will be giving it a healthy outingat that track (which I love) as soonas I can. I've only driven a '63 E-Type round it so far, so will be very interested to compare that experience with something that has brakes and traction! Anyone tried an MMC disc car on a track? I hear the discs aren't really made for track use...


Re: the suspension - yes you can learn to live with it, but to be honest, if you have the ££'s, the conversion to S2 Bilsteins and Eibach springs from the Koni's will be a revalation. If you want to go the whole hog and get Ohlins or Nitron's it will be nothing short of a quantum leap forwards.

RE: Goodwood, I'm sure you know the track and will take care, but do take it easy with the Elise there. I've heard it has some tricky sections and little opportunity to sort things out before the armco if you lose it!

SpikeOT said:

Thanks for mentioning tyres Ruxpin, meant to ask about them too. I am on the P-Zeros which seem good, if a little understeery at the front. On the standard 185s and 205s - will try Advans next time round - what sizes do you run Ruxpin?

As above, the weapon of choice is the Yokohama Advan Neova LTS tyre, available only from main dealers, good specialists or Eliseparts.com

They are by far and away the best road and track combo tyre for the S1. BF Goodrich G-Force Profilers come 2nd, and Toyo Proxes T1-R's a close 3rd.