Flywheel
Author
Discussion

gooby

Original Poster:

9,269 posts

265 months

Thursday 10th August 2006
quotequote all
The engine is being seperated from the chassis. While it is out, shall I replace the flywheel with a lightened one?

What are the pros / cons?

Sam_68

9,939 posts

276 months

Thursday 10th August 2006
quotequote all
Pros:
More responsive when you rev the engine under no load; engine therefore feels and sounds a bit racier.
Marginal improvement in acceleration, due to the reduced inertia of rotating masses.

Cons:
Idling won't be as smooth, particularly if you fit performance camshafts.
Easier to stall.
Ideally, you ought to be dynamically balancing the whole crankshaft/flyweel assembly; fitting a lightened flywheel on its own, you have no idea of engine balance.
It costs money.

gooby

Original Poster:

9,269 posts

265 months

Thursday 10th August 2006
quotequote all
I have been told the main drawbacks are that the emissions will be messed up and the ECU may not be able to cope.

There are many negatives - is it worth it?

Sam_68

9,939 posts

276 months

Thursday 10th August 2006
quotequote all
gooby said:
I have been told the main drawbacks are that the emissions will be messed up and the ECU may not be able to cope.

Quite possibly - I don't know enough about the K-series engine management to comment. My post was based on the typical pros and cons for any engine.
gooby said:
There are many negatives - is it worth it?

Unless you have a very specific reason for doing it, a lightened flywheel would be fairly well down my list of priorities for a modded car.

tuscan_thunder

1,763 posts

277 months

Friday 11th August 2006
quotequote all
I'd be more interested in getting a balanced flywheel than a lightened one. If you can get one taken to a machine shop and blueprinted, on a K (I think you've a K?) that'd have more of an effect than a lightened fly unless you're running a tuned VHPD

mr_c

2,508 posts

260 months

Friday 11th August 2006
quotequote all
He's got a Toyota.

gooby

Original Poster:

9,269 posts

265 months

Friday 11th August 2006
quotequote all
mr_c said:
He's got a Toyota.


Yep - it is a Toyota (Yamaha) engine out of the 111R.

Lightened flywheel would be down the list of desired mods but while the engine is out I thought "why not". Tha main reason is that it seems that it is not just an "engine out" but also an engine strip down in order to get a dynamic balance with the crank. At the moment there is too much work happening - a engine strip would mean a wait or weeks.

Not worth it.

grinzzz

566 posts

248 months

Friday 11th August 2006
quotequote all
Induction Kit

gooby

Original Poster:

9,269 posts

265 months

Friday 11th August 2006
quotequote all
www.eliseparts.com/shop/index.php?main_page=product_info&cPath=157&products_id=374

These are being delivered on monday - when my baby is being re-assembled, these will be fitted. The oem disks have a huge lip and need changing. Will I have to order more pads? There is still a hell of a lot of meat on my Pagids.

nellie116

34 posts

250 months

Friday 11th August 2006
quotequote all
Hi gooby

Was in the same situation a while back with my k engined S2. Whilst the engine was out it was suggested by my brilliant indie (tipton garage by budleigh salterton) to fit a lightweight flywheel he had lying around.
The intitial engine response is definately crisper due to less inertia. Any other benefits are marginal.Was also difficult to tell cause i had pistons rods and crank balanced at the same time. The idle is much weaker though which made it easier to stall at first until you get used to it. Sometimes stalls when hot and revs drop to idle at junctions but i'm sure the yota management is slick enough to prevent this. No problem now apart from people thinking you are just showing off when pulling away with staccato revs.
I wouldn't get one on it's own but if the flywheels accessible then it's £100 odd well spent.
Hope this helps, Nellie

Janitor

2,372 posts

250 months

Saturday 12th August 2006
quotequote all
gooby said:

Very nice mate

Don't see why your meaty pagids should't see there time out either

speedyellow

2,533 posts

258 months

Saturday 12th August 2006
quotequote all
If the engine is out and taking into account the mileage you've done I'd get the clutch replaced, parts are cheap compared to the labour. For road use I wouldn't fit a lightweight flywheel to the car.

S works

10,166 posts

281 months

Saturday 12th August 2006
quotequote all
As above I can't see the point in the LW flywheel to be honest. The upgraded brakes are a good buy, and speedyellow's point about the clutch is sound.

twinpipe

1,396 posts

260 months

Saturday 12th August 2006
quotequote all
It'll make the car harder to downshift (lazy) and the weight difference I think will be negligable compared to having a good poo but it's not been done by anyone I know so it'd be interesting to see. It's not a step back and like you say the engines out anyway. Why not.

Sam_68

9,939 posts

276 months

Saturday 12th August 2006
quotequote all
twinpipe said:
the weight difference I think will be negligable compared to having a good poo

Reduction in overall vehicle weight isn't the objective. Lightweight flywheels are intended to reduce the rotational inertia of the engine (ie. to let it increase and decrease revs more quickly, beacuse there's less mass to spin up and down).
twinpipe said:
...It's not a step back and like you say the engines out anyway. Why not.

It could well be a step backwards, unless you have the engine balanced along with the new flywheel.
I would imagine that Yota engines designed to rev to 8K rpm are balanced to pretty fine tolerances when they leave the factory. Bolting on a lighter flywheel at random is not a good idea!

GTRene

22,798 posts

255 months

Saturday 12th August 2006
quotequote all
Sam_68 said:
It could well be a step backwards, unless you have the engine balanced along with the new flywheel.
I would imagine that Yota engines designed to rev to 8K rpm are balanced to pretty fine tolerances when they leave the factory. Bolting on a lighter flywheel at random is not a good idea!

the flywheel is not a balance as...and the tolerance of the yota engine is huge, remember every one has to get a drive in it...so it can handle that lightweight flywheel easely me thinks, it only is not bin done from the factory because most people can't drive a car so it owuld stalk and people complain...but when yor a sporty driver there is no problem, only happy revs and ofcorse when you take of you need a bit more revs because of the less mass in the engine, but hey when you know that you don't stop just rev
Do it gooby a better chance you don't get...but whats next on your list here are some idea's that would welcome your lightweight flywheel
www.komo-tec.com/index.php/cPath/128_135
GTRene

Sam_68

9,939 posts

276 months

Saturday 12th August 2006
quotequote all
GTRene said:
the tolerance of the yota engine is huge...so it can handle that lightweight flywheel easely me think

What are the factory figures for tolerance +/- on balance, Rene?

I know of no competent engine builder who would suggest replacement of the flywheel on an engine that revs to 8K rpm, without full balance of the crank/flywheel assembly, etc. For the marginal increase in responsiveness that you'd get from a lightened flywheel, it just isn't worth the risk.

Edited by Sam_68 on Saturday 12th August 15:09

hbaumhardt

950 posts

310 months

Saturday 12th August 2006
quotequote all
GTRene, please give it a rest now. You clearly dont understand the fundamentals of physics or mechanics, and looking stuff up on the internet does not seem to be a substitute.

cej

961 posts

253 months

Saturday 12th August 2006
quotequote all
I had a light flywheel on my Civic and it reveed to 9k happily (and still does to this day) .

I know of a lot of other cars (even race cars ) with light flywheels without issues. Can't see why all of a sudden it would be a problem on a Yota engined elise ?

I was one of the best mods I did to my Civic and as soon as I need to take my gearbox of my Elise I'll put on a light flywheel.

Haven't had any problems stalling either. It's not as bad as some people make it seem.

AlexT

565 posts

267 months

Sunday 13th August 2006
quotequote all
I am not sure of the Elise standard flywheel weight. I wager that it is fairly light. So going lighter might not reap the same benefits as other cars, and in fact introduce some problems for day to day driving (idle, take off etc). I had a 9lb aluminium flywheel fitted to my '01 MX5 and that gave a lovely increase to response and a noticeable increase to acceleration in 1st and 2nd gear. No idle issues etc. Stock flywheel weight was 18lb I think.