Build quality getting worse?
Discussion
For a while I've been contemplating changing my TVR T350C for an Exige S (just love the race-car looks and go-kart driving feel)
I've previously had a S2111S and based on my experience of this IMO the build quality was an improvement on most of the TVR's I had been looking at (having said that my 350 does seems a good one and I've not had any probs)
So yesterday went off to my local dealer to have a look at the Exige's and was very suprised by what I saw.
Elise 111S brand new car for official launch in Ardent red:- where the front clam shell meets the vented panel behind the front wheel the panel gap was wider than normal exposing a white un-painted ridge (very noticeable on a red car IMO)Twas the same on both sides.
Next there were 2 Exige's together, an older yellow Exige and a blue 06 'S' demo car.
The yellow car seemed well screwed together but on the blue one the engine cover was standing proud in relation to the rest of the body work and just didn't look right. Also the cowl that's been added to the roof air intake on the 'S' looked like it had been tacked on and could potentially come off at any time.
Now don't get me wrong I'm nor anal about build quality and fully appreciate what your buying into with a Lotus, I was just very suprised about what I saw on new factory fresh cars.
Finally what is it with several people currently advertising Exige 'S' on the Autotrader when the cars are not a genuine 'S'
I've previously had a S2111S and based on my experience of this IMO the build quality was an improvement on most of the TVR's I had been looking at (having said that my 350 does seems a good one and I've not had any probs)
So yesterday went off to my local dealer to have a look at the Exige's and was very suprised by what I saw.
Elise 111S brand new car for official launch in Ardent red:- where the front clam shell meets the vented panel behind the front wheel the panel gap was wider than normal exposing a white un-painted ridge (very noticeable on a red car IMO)Twas the same on both sides.
Next there were 2 Exige's together, an older yellow Exige and a blue 06 'S' demo car.
The yellow car seemed well screwed together but on the blue one the engine cover was standing proud in relation to the rest of the body work and just didn't look right. Also the cowl that's been added to the roof air intake on the 'S' looked like it had been tacked on and could potentially come off at any time.
Now don't get me wrong I'm nor anal about build quality and fully appreciate what your buying into with a Lotus, I was just very suprised about what I saw on new factory fresh cars.
Finally what is it with several people currently advertising Exige 'S' on the Autotrader when the cars are not a genuine 'S'
The panel gaps on the rear hatch of the Exige S are terrible. I've heard some whining (which I believe eminates from either Hethel or dealers, or both) going on about how hard it is to get fibreglass to line up correctly or something half-baked, and that being why there are gaping holes between the rear clam edge and the engine cover.
For what seems to work out as a £40k car it's shoddy at best.
As for Autotrader and misadvertising - well, that's just people isn't it? I once saw a Jag advertised in the prestige cars section under a piccie of a Jacket Potato oven
For what seems to work out as a £40k car it's shoddy at best.
As for Autotrader and misadvertising - well, that's just people isn't it? I once saw a Jag advertised in the prestige cars section under a piccie of a Jacket Potato oven

The panel gap on the Exige S engine cover is indeed noticeable ... at a guess it seems that the lock mechanism is adjusted slightly higher to clear the intercooler gubbins. But overall the build quality seems even better on the demo car than on my 05 111R (which I thought was pretty good in any event)

The Exige engine cover standing proud issue is related to the lifting struts and nothing else. They are simply too powerful and cause the lid to lift at one edge or the other or both. Lotus are apparently working on a solution to sort this out. IMO the solution will be the fitting of less powerful struts.
I went from a 2000 Tuscan to a 111R and part of the reason for that was build quality/spares availability, Lotus`s are not perfect (still get the odd niggle) but they really are oceans apart from TVR in terms of build quality. Gone are the days i used to get into my car wondering what was going to go wrong next with the pod/electrics/sp6 engine etc. The only down side is the performance trade off, however having said that and i can say this because ive had both, there is no way a TVR would get the better of a Lotus unless it was a on a straight. TVR at present can only dream of making a machine as well planted on the road as a Lotus.
I've had three TVR's V8s, Cerbera 4.2 and T350T and without a doubt, the bigger engined TVR's have it on performance. BUT they don't handle as well, and point to point the Lotus wins hands down. As for build quality, mmmnnn I reserve judgement as mine is currently getting rattles/vibrations and an engine management problem sorted with less than 2000 miles on the clock. That bit is no different to TVR. What is different is the lack of excess glue, badly fitted trim etc.....
Build quality has progressively improved - compare an 02 to an 04 and you'll see lots of reasons. Similarly the 06 111R I've been loaned has, for example tighter side windows and just the other day I noticed that they've finally put a plastic cover in the inside of the roll bar.
But on the other hand the dash has a silly rattle when going over large bumps and I've heard stories of wafer-thin paintwork. I think as experience in the factory grows, the bean counters are as much in evidence to rein in other areas.
But on the other hand the dash has a silly rattle when going over large bumps and I've heard stories of wafer-thin paintwork. I think as experience in the factory grows, the bean counters are as much in evidence to rein in other areas.
I think you've hit the nail on the head Kev. In some cases there are considerable improvements, but in others things which have been shown to be fault-prone time and time again (like paint) just don't appear improved.
Still, they are moving on, but I feel that for the brand a keen eye on quality & customer focussed service is a must.
Still, they are moving on, but I feel that for the brand a keen eye on quality & customer focussed service is a must.
I remember during a factory tour back in 2002 watching a video of 2 men spraying all of the panels on a Elise, they start in the middle at one end each working down one side of the car untill they meet again in the middle at the other end, and there didn't appear to be much paint going on to any one part of the car (this procedure may well have changed by now)
ballistic said:
purpleperil said:
I went from an 05 TVR 350c to an 06 111R. The build quality of the Lotus was in a different (better) leauge than the TVR! It was one of my reasons for changing!
How do you find the two compare?
The Elise 111R is a car I may consider.
Well for a start I've had the 111R for longer than the dealer which wasn't the case with the Tiv! Brute force and sound - the Tiv wins hands down but as we live in the real world and twisty roads are more fun than drag strips...then I'm over the moon with my Lotus!
purpleperil said:
ballistic said:
purpleperil said:
I went from an 05 TVR 350c to an 06 111R. The build quality of the Lotus was in a different (better) leauge than the TVR! It was one of my reasons for changing!
How do you find the two compare?
The Elise 111R is a car I may consider.
Well for a start I've had the 111R for longer than the dealer which wasn't the case with the Tiv! Brute force and sound - the Tiv wins hands down but as we live in the real world and twisty roads are more fun than drag strips...then I'm over the moon with my Lotus!
sounds familiar.
exx said:
The Exige engine cover standing proud issue is related to the lifting struts and nothing else. They are simply too powerful and cause the lid to lift at one edge or the other or both. Lotus are apparently working on a solution to sort this out. IMO the solution will be the fitting of less powerful struts.
Thats true, i have removed my struts for this reason and use a short alluminium rod to hold the hatch open until Lotus comes along with some weaker struts. The struts are so strong they raise the hatch by themselves from closed the moment the lever is pulled! I think this is overkill and means there is a huge force pushing up constantly on the outer edges of the hatch.
The air intake on the S is also something Lotus should be ashamed of.
I would say the quality of the cars is getting better overall, i just think Lotus let themselves down a bit with how half baked some of the solutions on all the supercharged cars are.
Gassing Station | Elise/Exige/Europa/340R | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




