Elise replacement for 4
Elise replacement for 4
Author
Discussion

spunagain

Original Poster:

772 posts

289 months

Monday 14th August 2006
quotequote all
Hi All

Well.. next summer it seems I am under pressure to get fun 4 seater car. I drive 40 miles each way to work (which is fine in my Elise) and great as I could drop my daughter off at nursery on the way. Happily I now have 2 (daughters not Elises) and I need to find a 4 seater car that is fun, not provocative (say like a 3 series of a 911) or 'old' like a xk8. I want something with better than 30mpg, no roof and 4 seats. Oh and a <20k budget...

I seem to keep coming back to a Mini cabriolet! I don't think I have any problems with the metrosexual image as I am not bothered if you think I am gay or not and it will have 2 baby seats bolted into it!

Have any Elise owners out there driven both or made such a leap?

I am thinking cooper S or works tune?

Is a Works Mini as much fun as an Elise?

Can a fast Mini replace an Elise? Or would I die of embarassment?

Why doesn't Lotus make a 4 seater any more?

I guess that the only solution is to drive one but I am loath to waste a dealerstime before I have mulled the idea about a bit...

Cheers for your thoughts!

Regards
spunagain

Miles_stylus

332 posts

262 months

Monday 14th August 2006
quotequote all
masserati 3200? maintaining it might be a bit tough but it is an interesting alt to 911 m3 etc

minimax

11,985 posts

287 months

Monday 14th August 2006
quotequote all
storming idea! maser 3200 is a cool car..and the noise is pretty awesome too

spunagain

Original Poster:

772 posts

289 months

Monday 14th August 2006
quotequote all
Hmmm

I thought the 3200 convertible was only a 2 seater tho'

Cheers!

Come to think of it why do the reference guides in car mags never list the number of seats?

Edited by spunagain on Monday 14th August 13:21

S works

10,166 posts

281 months

Monday 14th August 2006
quotequote all
MINI is a great car, but the boot is tiny. No good for taking the trappings that come with 2 small kids around in. Better off stretching to an M3 I'd say.

gooby

9,269 posts

265 months

Monday 14th August 2006
quotequote all
I am looking at a cooper S or a S Works for my wife. We have had a couple of extended test drives and the MINI is superb and nothing else comes close. The only thing better is the 'liz. The MINI chassis can be a little too rigid and the ride a little under damped. A couple of time we have bounced out of a pot hole with no idea which direction the car wants to go in. Overall it is a superb car. I do think they are very ugly as a convertible. With the top up they loose that wonderful roof line and with the roof down it looks like an old materace propped on the back end.

I would go for an older XK8. you will never get 30 to the gallon....

Saab convertible?

spunagain

Original Poster:

772 posts

289 months

Monday 14th August 2006
quotequote all
Hi Gooby

After what you have said I think a mini test drive is in order.

I have tried an XKR and came away thinking lovely - my Dad would love this car. It just wasn't me!

Are you sure I won't get 30mpg from an works or cooper S? (or did you mean the xk?)


Cheers

Spunagain




Edited by spunagain on Monday 14th August 13:41

vx 220

47 posts

247 months

Monday 14th August 2006
quotequote all
You will never get 30mpg from an S Works.

Mine was returning 20-21mpg

gooby

9,269 posts

265 months

Monday 14th August 2006
quotequote all
spunagain said:
Hi Gooby

After what you have said I think a mini test drive is in order.

I have tried an XKR and came away thinking lovely - my Dad would love this car. It just wasn't me!

Are you sure I won't get 30mpg from an works or cooper S? (or did you mean the xk?)


Cheers

Spunagain




Edited by spunagain on Monday 14th August 13:41


They are a special car which you can have a wild time with graphics and colour. I like the interior most. Like the liz, it has a sence of occasion and someone actually designed it. You get in so many cars and the interior is black plastic switches on a black plastic background with black cloth seats and black carpets, or at best a design that your mum would be proud of. I am bored thinking about it. The MINI had so much personality.

There is a new model coming out next month and I am waiting to see what that does to second hand prices.

spunagain

Original Poster:

772 posts

289 months

Monday 14th August 2006
quotequote all
Wow VX220

That milage is worse than my ZT260 with a stone age 4.6 litre v8 (which will also have to go!).

Did your Mini live on the track or is that average milage for "normal use"?

A nicely designed interior is very much a part of a cars specialness.

But.. It looks now like I need to try a more humble Coopers S -(non works) (will look at MPG in car mag when I get home!)

Cheers

Spunagain

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Monday 14th August 2006
quotequote all
There is NO WAY you will get 30mpg from an S or an S Works. Around 25ish I think is apparently good.

jondude

2,441 posts

248 months

Monday 14th August 2006
quotequote all
Be a man.

Get a Ford Sierra off e-bay for a tenner and let the wife drive the kids everywhere.

Sorted.

sramdeen

416 posts

251 months

Monday 14th August 2006
quotequote all
my standard cooper gets 30MPG combined. That's with spirited driving, but definitely not caning it. Motorways are about 35 MPG.

It's the best handling car I've had so far and would have gone for the S if they would have insured me on it :-(

The boot really is TINY though. My friend's Yaris has a bigger boot and that's just plain embarrassing. Go and have a test drive, I'm sure you'll be impressed with its cornering ability and solid build.

If I didn't give a toss about the environment and wanted a big family car, I would have a 5 year old M5 in a flash. That, or a 5 year old E55. ohhhh, the sound. Hard top though, so maybe not for you.

Hey, here's an idea. Why not buy my Mini in December so I can get my Elise!

happy hunting

Stu

Davislove

2,295 posts

277 months

Monday 14th August 2006
quotequote all
spunagain said:
Hi Gooby

After what you have said I think a mini test drive is in order.

I have tried an XKR and came away thinking lovely - my Dad would love this car. It just wasn't me!

Are you sure I won't get 30mpg from an works or cooper S? (or did you mean the xk?)


Cheers

Spunagain






Edited by spunagain on Monday 14th August 13:41



Have a look at my profile, I had a MINI Cooper S Works and it was brilliant and if i'm honest there's lots I miss about it, MPG forget it, I never saw better than 22 in real world driving

cej

961 posts

253 months

Monday 14th August 2006
quotequote all
jondude said:
Be a man.

Get a Ford Sierra off e-bay for a tenner and let the wife drive the kids everywhere.

Sorted.


well said

purpleheadedcerb

1,143 posts

253 months

Monday 14th August 2006
quotequote all
We used to have a Cooper and combined was 27mpg. motorway driving was 32. Quite shocking for a 1.6 really. Nice car though but common as muck now. No longer a head turner and that cabriolet is just ugly. IMO (Sorry if you have one!)
#

spunagain

Original Poster:

772 posts

289 months

Monday 14th August 2006
quotequote all
jondude said:
Be a man.

Get a Ford Sierra off e-bay for a tenner and let the wife drive the kids everywhere.

Sorted.


Spunagain's wife here - just found all the email responses and all I will say about a Sierra that is printable is that they can be good fun on a skidpan being RWD, but I certainly won't be getting one. Grounds for divorce there mate!

TIPPER

2,955 posts

250 months

Monday 14th August 2006
quotequote all
There's really is a gap in the market for a sporting 4 seat convertible that doesn't suffer from the image problem (M3/911/A4/CLK). The Maser is a cracking car but in convertible guise is purely a 2 seater (I've checked). The XK suffers the Dad's car syndrome (maybe the new one will change that but look at the prices!) and is more cruiser than sports car. The Prodrive RX8 looks the part but of course isn't a soft top and suffers with a drink problem.
My favorite come the time to get a four seater sports car will be either a 911 or Maser and forget the soft top (but the liz would have to stay!).
BTW spunagain, what sort of mpg are you getting from your 260ZT. I only get 25mpg from my 160 (with no town work)!

Miles_stylus

332 posts

262 months

Tuesday 15th August 2006
quotequote all
ops - I missed the convertable bit of the spec when talking about the Massa. If you can do without the extended sunroof you could also look at the TVR Cerbera which is on my list when the whole two kids in nursury thing comes up.

Miles

gooby

9,269 posts

265 months

Tuesday 15th August 2006
quotequote all
spunagain said:
jondude said:
Be a man.

Get a Ford Sierra off e-bay for a tenner and let the wife drive the kids everywhere.

Sorted.


Spunagain's wife here - just found all the email responses and all I will say about a Sierra that is printable is that they can be good fun on a skidpan being RWD, but I certainly won't be getting one. Grounds for divorce there mate!


Mrs. spunagain - how about a metro or a rover 25?

run for cover..