induction v. warranty
induction v. warranty
Author
Discussion

zebra

Original Poster:

4,555 posts

245 months

Wednesday 16th August 2006
quotequote all
I'm thinking about a hurricane induction kit but have a few questions.

1. How is the warranty affected? (the car is only a six months old 111r)

2. Has anybody suffered from the engine light coming on for no reason when they've had a kit fitted (something mentioned by the garage)

Cheers in advance

Zebra

philz

107 posts

274 months

Wednesday 16th August 2006
quotequote all
Not sure if Lotus would try to wriggle out of a claim but assuming that you put the standard airbox back on I can't see how they'd even know.

I've got an ITG on mine and no problems with the MIL light.

Tina K

22,029 posts

243 months

Wednesday 16th August 2006
quotequote all
I have the Hurricane on my MY05 111R which is still within warranty, and have had no problems with it.

I have been told that you can't fit it to the MY06 111R though because of the drive-by-wire throttle.

zebra

Original Poster:

4,555 posts

245 months

Thursday 17th August 2006
quotequote all
Tina K said:


I have been told that you can't fit it to the MY06 111R though because of the drive-by-wire throttle.


Why's that?

Zebra

bing

1,946 posts

269 months

Thursday 17th August 2006
quotequote all
I've been told by Lotus HQ that the induction itself and any 'problems' caused by it would not be covered as a warranty claim, i.e. if they found that the induction blew up your engine that would not be covered (this hardly likely to happen though), a gearbox failure for example is still covered. Having said that Lotus main dealers are still selling them as an option and giving you the usual manufacturers warranty (I don't know how that works)....

I've got one on mine and love it to bits, car still in warranty...

Hope this helps..........

Edited by bing on Thursday 17th August 09:58

zebra

Original Poster:

4,555 posts

245 months

Thursday 17th August 2006
quotequote all
bing said:
I've been told by Lotus HQ that the induction itself and any 'problems' caused by it would not be covered as a warranty claim, i.e. if they found that the induction blew up your engine that would not be covered (this hardly likely to happen though), a gearbox failure for example is still covered. Having said that Lotus main dealers are still selling them as an option and giving you the usual manufacturers warranty (I don't know how that works)....

I've got one on mine and love it to bits, car still in warranty...

Hope this helps..........

Edited by bing on Thursday 17th August 09:58


Cheers.

Following on from previous post _ is yours 05 or 06?

Zebra

jago

247 posts

250 months

Thursday 17th August 2006
quotequote all
zebra said:
Tina K said:


I have been told that you can't fit it to the MY06 111R though because of the drive-by-wire throttle.


Why's that?

Zebra


Also - what's the difference between 06 and 05 111Rs with respect to being able to lower the cam change over point in the event a 3rd party or otherwise supercharger coming on the market? Or have just misread some threads in the past?

Edited by jago on Thursday 17th August 11:04

bing

1,946 posts

269 months

Thursday 17th August 2006
quotequote all
mine is an 05

simonk

908 posts

256 months

Thursday 17th August 2006
quotequote all
Mines an 06 with DBW and no probs with pipercross induction.

Believe the ecu is still locked and encoded or whatever though so no remapping.

Simon

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Thursday 17th August 2006
quotequote all
There are people who have had wrangles with Lotus over problems with their cars and aftermarket induction/exhausts. Search for boggy and MIL light and you'll find his woes for an example. All sorted out now but he was banging his head against a wall for a fair few weeks.

Re: the ECU remap, as Simon notes, it's locked and everything I've heard is that Lotus would prefer it to stay that way - there are people who are trying to get around it, but I've heard of nothing successful to-date.

I wouldn't hold my breath expecting a factory supercharger option for the R anytime soon either. Look at the way the brand is moving to differentiate it's cars, as answered to a question I posed on SELOC last week...

Heathcliffe Robertshaw - General Manager Lotus Cars UK and Ireland said:

Hi Tim

It's a simple naming strategy as I'm sure your dealers will be able to explain to you all- here it is.

BHP doesn't work in the States so we needed a global answer

There's the Elise - currently sold in Japan which is the Rover engine car out there. There's the Elise S - the new one just launched and an Elise R - the renamed 111R.

There's the Exige (190), the Exige S (220) and then potentially the Exige R - (don't even go there, no plans but offers us future scope should we decide to do something)

Then there's the Europa (there currently isn't one, but we have the opportunity in the future - again no current plans) you have the new Europa S out in September and then again the possibility for the Europa R.

The caveat is that there's no point hypothesising about what could and couldn't be, it's just a simple naming strategy that allows flexibility for the future.

Not only does it allow flexibility, Lotus are clearly defining each car with a purpose. Elise, everyman's sports car.
Exige, the 'extreme' model.
Europa, 'business class' GT.

Talk to your dealer - they have been told explicitly NOT to talk about track use and the Europa together, despite the fact that those who've driven it think it will make an excellent track car with some suspension tweaks, and that the engine is ripe for some serious tuning.

Sorry for the thread-drift, but you get my point?

Edited by S Works on Thursday 17th August 17:03

philz

107 posts

274 months

Thursday 17th August 2006
quotequote all
S Works said:
Re: the ECU remap, as Simon notes, it's locked and everything I've heard is that Lotus would prefer it to stay that way - there are people who are trying to get around it, but I've heard of nothing successful to-date.


Have you seen this yet?

www.elisetalk.com/forums/showthread.php?t=21256

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Thursday 17th August 2006
quotequote all
No I hadn't actually, but I'm not surprised someone has tried a different approach. Until there are dyno-plots to see what it does I'd remain somewhat sceptical though - I'm a big fan of the phrase "what don't talk, don't lie", and the proof of the pudding will be when consistent data is in the public domain.

FWIW, I can't see many owners running to grab this until then, and I also would imagine that most R and Exige owners would prefer to see something direct from Lotus rather than take the risk.

kevin ritson

3,423 posts

258 months

Thursday 17th August 2006
quotequote all
I can see there being a lucrative market in chipping 111Rs - I for one would welcome such an option, especially since a changeover at 4,000rpm works well with Honda K20s. Similar engine-protecting measures a la Honda would be good, too. It would save a lot of people who would otherwise supercharge to get a similar result on power delivery a bomb, too.

philz

107 posts

274 months

Thursday 17th August 2006
quotequote all
How about Ragnorak Racing?

www.ragnorakracing.com/page/page/2337807.htm

They offer various packages for the 111R with up to 230BHP obtainable without needing a supercharger. They seem to offer an ECU reflash as part of their packages too.

jago

247 posts

250 months

Thursday 17th August 2006
quotequote all
well it all looks very promising. it does look possible that in 6 months or so, there will be a tried and tested 'standard' solution.
i'd jump at it, so long as none of the excitement is taken away. the sudden kick in the back at change over is fun.

Edited by jago on Thursday 17th August 23:41

Ollyd

1,917 posts

250 months

Wednesday 23rd August 2006
quotequote all
Hi Zebra,

I have an 06 111R Sports Racer with a Pipercross Viper Industion kit and have had numerous issue with the MIL light. The car has even gone in to safe mode a few times which leaves you stuck at 25mph (and this is no fun at all on a motorway). The cure is to stop the car, lock it, and stand there for 10 minutes whilst the car resets itself. The whole standing around waiting for the car to reset itself make you feel like you are helping to perpetuate the sterotype!

My car is back in the shop yet again for this right now. There seems to be a growing feeling that the induction kit may be the underlying cause for this but no one is sure. The kit I had fitted (by the Lotus dealer) was the one they recommend so its all being looked at (again) under warranty.

For what it is worth having lived with the induction kit for some time now (even ignoring the MIL issue) with hind sight I would probably not go for one on the 111R - I'd spend my dosh on a sports exhaust instead. I find my induction kit just a bit too unsubtle with the radical cam change on the 111R. Its provides a goodish but fairly restrained noise below the cam change, which admitedly does sound a lot better the standard poor effort, but then you get total aural mayhem when the cam switches. You get a dramatic increase in noise for not much extra throttle. Given that the cam change often happens while you are overtaking you often feel that those you are overtaking must think you are taking the p*ss or showing off; you know the boy racer reving his engine at the lights type effect. I'd prefer a louder, lower exhaust note across the board I think so I am thinking of switching for a new exhaust instead. Who knows though, I might put both on for a while and see how that sounds!

On the plus side I did find a small improvement in low end torque from the induction kit (as advertised) but not enough to buy it just for that. I'm a bit of a torque fan myself and my planned remedy for this is a TVR! (I guess I had better get used to standing by the side of the road perpetuating a stereotype!)

Cheers
Ollyd

zebra

Original Poster:

4,555 posts

245 months

Wednesday 23rd August 2006
quotequote all
Cheers mate, that's solid information.

GRL

252 posts

255 months

Wednesday 23rd August 2006
quotequote all
Olly - I'll get this in before Joe does hehe

shout 2Bular

probably the best exhaust for an Elise in the world

zebra

Original Poster:

4,555 posts

245 months

Wednesday 23rd August 2006
quotequote all
GRL said:
Olly - I'll get this in before Joe does hehe

shout 2Bular

probably the best exhaust for an Elise in the world


You needed to be in earlier than that mate, I already have a stage II fitted.

Zebra

zebra

Original Poster:

4,555 posts

245 months

Thursday 24th August 2006
quotequote all
GRL said:
Olly - I'll get this in before Joe does hehe

shout 2Bular

probably the best exhaust for an Elise in the world


Although I've got a stage II, what makes the 2bular ones so good and how much are they? I'm always tempted to change if its worthwhile.

Zebra