someone didn't see my parked S2!
someone didn't see my parked S2!
Author
Discussion

sheetstabuer

Original Poster:

21,555 posts

246 months

Saturday 19th August 2006
quotequote all
Some idiot has just smacked in to my baby in a car park, he was parked next to me and while reversing put his lock on too soon, bang! I now have a 3 inch crack on the rear wheel arch.

Luckily I saw him do it and stopped him, he had offered to pay for it to be fixed until I explained that it would need a whole rear clam. Then after picking him up off the floor I explained he had hit a lotus and not a fiesta

What can I expect insurance wise, I'm not going to settle for a repair or anything less than a new clam so should I expect a fight with them over this?

Thanks

bogie

17,108 posts

303 months

Saturday 19th August 2006
quotequote all
make sure it goes to a Lotus specialist bodyshop ....will be a £3K job at insurance rates, but I wouldnt have thought there would be any hassle.

TIPPER

2,955 posts

250 months

Saturday 19th August 2006
quotequote all
Sorry to hear about this and hope you get it sorted soonest.

4pot

481 posts

255 months

Saturday 19th August 2006
quotequote all
If you have legal expenses cover, claim on that if you have problems with the other guys insurance company. Basically they should give you a like for like vehicle etc.

The only issues with this one is that car parks are not the public highway and there are sometimes one or two issues with this from an insurance point of view.

jondude

2,441 posts

248 months

Saturday 19th August 2006
quotequote all
If you put it through your insurers then they decide if it needs a new clam or not, I'm afraid.

If the damage can be repaired, which is likely, they will not entertain the price of a new clam. Think about this in reverse - would you, if you had promised to pay for damage caused by you to another car, be happy if you were sent a £2,500+ bill instead of £500?

You can sometimes still insist on the clam but then the insurers talk of betterment, and they will ask you to pay the balance above what they expected to pay. Say £2,000.

In a way you have to understand where the insurers are coming from. If they allow us all to demand exaggerated repairs then premiums will go through the roof.

Still, you can certainly insist on the car going to a fibreglass specialist. If he says it needs a clam, they will not argue. If he says it can be done professionally for a few hundred, they will not argue.

It really is as simple as that!

jb111s

393 posts

249 months

Saturday 19th August 2006
quotequote all
You'd be amazed at what some of the fibreglass guys can do. Luckily it sounds like a relatively low speed whack & just a big crack so could probably be repaired with some expensive polyfilla & a bit of a respray. If it were my car I'd feel the same as you though. At least you managed to catch the bugger in the act, else you'd really be out of pocket.

That is my biggest fear, some chelsea tractor being driven by a distracted mum who doesn't see the tiny little 'liz she just plows into. Whenever I go to the supermarket or any kind of public car park I always park it well away from the masses. There's so many prats who just slam their door open into the car next to them (I reckon about 60-70% of cars on the road have dings in their doors). A short walk to the shop is far better than a smashed clam






jondude

2,441 posts

248 months

Sunday 20th August 2006
quotequote all
JB - Quite right. I have extended your logic a little further and decided a nice e-bay special, Ford Sierra at £100, is even better and cheaper than Tesco or shopping car park damage.

Honestly, I would never, ever park an Elise where there are stressed shoppers.

Not only does a week in the Sierra keep the Elise safe, it makes the Elise feel all new and virginal when you take it out again.


Recommended.

as400

161 posts

243 months

Sunday 20th August 2006
quotequote all
So if the guy denies he hit your car, what happens then? Were there any third party independant witnesses?

kevin ritson

3,423 posts

258 months

Monday 21st August 2006
quotequote all
Worth considering an accident management company if it's 100% their fault - this way you don't have to pay an excess or get stung by your insurance company and you get a decent courtesy car (worth it - mine's taken a few weeks and if I'd had a Corsa in August I'd be suicidal by now!).

Don't shy away from a repair - if it's a good fibreglass specialist you have nothing to worry about

RDH S2

4 posts

243 months

Monday 21st August 2006
quotequote all
Similar thing happened to me on my 2nd week of ownership - except no-one saw it and they never left a note!

Rather than bump up my insurance - I got it repaired- it's flawless - no-one can tell it's been repaired! And it only cost me £100 from a local fibreglass specialist!
For a 3 inch crack the insurance company will laugh at the suggestion of a new clam!

Good luck!

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Monday 21st August 2006
quotequote all
kevin ritson said:
Worth considering an accident management company if it's 100% their fault - this way you don't have to pay an excess or get stung by your insurance company and you get a decent courtesy car (worth it - mine's taken a few weeks and if I'd had a Corsa in August I'd be suicidal by now!).

Don't shy away from a repair - if it's a good fibreglass specialist you have nothing to worry about

Agreed.

Talk to Steve Greensmith from Europa Consultants (posts as anniesdad here on PH). Very nice chap, great service.

jb111s

393 posts

249 months

Monday 21st August 2006
quotequote all
jondude said:
JB - Quite right. I have extended your logic a little further and decided a nice e-bay special, Ford Sierra at £100, is even better and cheaper than Tesco or shopping car park damage.

Honestly, I would never, ever park an Elise where there are stressed shoppers.

Not only does a week in the Sierra keep the Elise safe, it makes the Elise feel all new and virginal when you take it out again.


Recommended.


I was thinking about doing the same especially as the weather gets a bit worse. Driving back from silverstone the other week in the pouring rain I nearly pulled off the motorway as was that concerned it would swap ends or aquaplane. I know its a perfectly usable everyday car, but when you need to get somewhere in extreme conditions then it's best to have an old banger to get from a to b, rather than risk the baby.

I used to drive a shed when living abroad. It was great as I was king of the road! The only benefit of driving a bomb is that you are also king of the road, anything that sees you coming will always give way to a battered old heap as they know you're not going to be concerned about adding another to the collection.

I saw an old big audi with power steering 7 months tax & electric windows for 400 quid for sale on my road, might just buy it for the winter months.



midas029

184 posts

253 months

Monday 21st August 2006
quotequote all
I`ve got Steve Greensmith from europa taking care of a claim i have going through for a replacement rear clam replacement, got his details from the guys on here. Can`t recommend him enough!!!