Out with Elise S2 in with Exige S2
Out with Elise S2 in with Exige S2
Author
Discussion

L888DER

Original Poster:

523 posts

243 months

Tuesday 22nd August 2006
quotequote all
Morning, Just after some advice really. this is my first post onto Piston heads and would like some friendly Lotus advice. With my redundancy looming at work i have decided to blow the cash very sesinbly on an exige as i love my S2 elise and want to take a step up. Not interested in the 111R as want the sheer brutality from the exige. Any hints as will be buying second hand, hopefully only about 6 months old? looking at around £28K GREAT ONE ON here for sale actually at dream machines. Test drove the S at the weekend aswell but i dont think its worth the extra cash as they were only released in April. Your thoughts? L888DER

gooby

9,269 posts

265 months

Tuesday 22nd August 2006
quotequote all
Road or Track use?

L888DER

Original Poster:

523 posts

243 months

Tuesday 22nd August 2006
quotequote all
Will be used at weekends to be honest as missus just bought a cooper, untill now was using elise everyday but have moved in with her now so can walk to station. Exige will be garaged and used at leisure i hope!

scotte

372 posts

265 months

Tuesday 22nd August 2006
quotequote all
corerct me if i am wrong but dont the exige tyres (yoko 0048s) need to be replaced every 4,000 miles ?

i would prefer a Exige S2 over 111R but i think there is a differece in running cost which is putting me off a a bit - might be marginal however.

just a thought
Scott

L888DER

Original Poster:

523 posts

243 months

Tuesday 22nd August 2006
quotequote all
tyres come with 5m tread on and apparenly last 5000 miles, but then to be fair you dont buy an exige to drive slow? But then again new tyres every 500 miles is a lot cheaper for this performance than that of a TVR, was looking at the T350 and warrenty for a year, plus insurance and service would be 3500 a year ish. NO THANKS? I have considered Boxster S but dont think its for me. EXIGE ALL THE WAY

L888DER

Original Poster:

523 posts

243 months

Tuesday 22nd August 2006
quotequote all
Also going to add the Stage 2 exhaust and indiction kit, Armour fend and snap off steering wheel. Any suggestions for or against?

kevin ritson

3,423 posts

258 months

Tuesday 22nd August 2006
quotequote all
Welcome to job club! Looking to maximise my redundancy too but will wait and see what I'm earning next...

Bear in mind that Exige prices will have taken a hit now that the S has been released. Might even be worth waiting until the S starts to appear on the secondhand market, won't be long til it does. You may have a bit more money to spend then as well.

L888DER

Original Poster:

523 posts

243 months

Tuesday 22nd August 2006
quotequote all
I drove both at the weekend, and i dont know if it was because the S's exhaust was standard but really didnt like the sound appossed to that of the standards exige with the stage 2 and indiction. I think fir what i want it for the normal exige will more than suffice. You thinking of buying an exige too?

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Tuesday 22nd August 2006
quotequote all
Standard Exige will be no quicker than a 111R, and IMvHO you'd be mad to buy one at £28k now given that the used S's will probably be on the market within 12 months.

If you want a really quick car, you should get your S2 a Honda or Audi engine conversion.

The price to change will probably be similar or less. Before you commit, I strongly suggest a trip to Maidstone Sports Cars in Headcorn (open day this Saturday BTW) to try their Honda Powered Elise and Exige.

pennpromo

121 posts

287 months

Tuesday 22nd August 2006
quotequote all
L888DER you could buy mine: www.pistonheads.com/sales/76581.htm
its really great, has a snap off wheel, rare forged alloys, starlight black, Pipercross carbon induction kit, all you would need is an exhaust. Do beware that if you are going to do trackdays a stage 2 will probably be too loud. Even if you don't buy mine take my advice, buy a private one still under warranty and save yourself a fortune for the upgrades- some time with Walshy etc.

scotte

372 posts

265 months

Tuesday 22nd August 2006
quotequote all
L888DER said:
I have considered Boxster S but dont think its for me. EXIGE ALL THE WAY


considering a boxster S too. Heart says lotus, head says boxster S.

L888DER

Original Poster:

523 posts

243 months

Tuesday 22nd August 2006
quotequote all
I know what your saying but i really didt like the sound of the S, nor did it feel differant enough to splash the cash, donmt get me wrong would love one in aspin white but cant see them dropping enough in 6 weeks? as i am looking to buy early october. STUPID timing i know but no way am i gonna wait till MARCH/APRIl for the spring. Boxster S delivers the power smoothly but simply doesnt have the force and grunt of the Exige.

scotte

372 posts

265 months

Tuesday 22nd August 2006
quotequote all
plus the exige looks better

Scott

Davey S2

13,394 posts

285 months

Tuesday 22nd August 2006
quotequote all
S Works said:


If you want a really quick car, you should get your S2 a Honda or Audi engine conversion.



Why have you not mentioned this before Tim?



emenel

891 posts

250 months

Wednesday 23rd August 2006
quotequote all
A bit over budget but well worth a look...www.pistonheads.com/sales/93355.htm

I know this car and the Lady selling it. It is absolutely mint, Aspen White, has a fantastic spec and the bespoke interior is beautiful.

Bada Bing!

959 posts

258 months

Wednesday 23rd August 2006
quotequote all
L888DER said:
Not interested in the 111R as want the sheer brutality from the exige.

confused

They are the same car, aside from some fairly minor differences. None of which I have ever been able to say make a difference when both are driven in anger side by side.

The Exige S is the only real step up for you if you want brutality (and a warranty).

Edited by Bada Bing! on Wednesday 23 August 11:41

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Wednesday 23rd August 2006
quotequote all
Davey S2 said:
S Works said:


If you want a really quick car, you should get your S2 a Honda or Audi engine conversion.



Why have you not mentioned this before Tim?




I know you jest Davey, but I think it's worth considering. The Exige is a quick car, no doubt, but it's a total fallacy to say it's 'quicker' than a 111R because the facts bear out that it's not.

And it's also fair to say that the conversions offer significantly different and more powerful drives than the Lotus out-of-the-box options. If you want a seriously quick and sorted car, I personally can't see why you wouldn't consider the alternatives also.

I have heard countless problems with new Lotus cars of late, and nightmares of people having to ruck with dealers and Lotus just to get warranty claims agreed, let alone actually sorted.

I don't remember hearing so many about Bernard or MSC for instance... food for thought.

bogie

17,108 posts

303 months

Wednesday 23rd August 2006
quotequote all
define "brutality" - you mean the style/appearance of an Exige? ...sure it looks more aggressive...its not really any faster than a 111R in a straight line though

And put A048s and Ohlins/Nitrons on a 111R and it will be just as quick (if not slightly quicker) than an Exige

..sure get an Exige if you want the styling ...but if you want more peformance then keep what youve got and stick an Audi/honda in there ...111R/Exige seem pretty gutless in comparison and have a 100-160Kg weight penalty too ......but then you get aircon and leccy windows which is useful for a daily drive I guess ...horses for courses and all that.

bogie

17,108 posts

303 months

Wednesday 23rd August 2006
quotequote all
ought to add - Im not saying the 111R/Exige are slow - no doubt any car that does 60 in 5 ish and a ton in 13-14 for £30K is in the 'sportscar' category ....but if you *really* want a crap your pants its fast, supercar performance car for sub £30K then you need Honda or Audi power ...sub 4's to 60, sub 9's to a ton, and 170mph in a 800kg car is about as good as it gets without looking at silly track toys or £100K+ supercars......and they are still cheap to run

Davey S2

13,394 posts

285 months

Wednesday 23rd August 2006
quotequote all
S Works said:
Davey S2 said:
S Works said:


If you want a really quick car, you should get your S2 a Honda or Audi engine conversion.



Why have you not mentioned this before Tim?




I know you jest Davey, but I think it's worth considering. The Exige is a quick car, no doubt, but it's a total fallacy to say it's 'quicker' than a 111R because the facts bear out that it's not.

And it's also fair to say that the conversions offer significantly different and more powerful drives than the Lotus out-of-the-box options. If you want a seriously quick and sorted car, I personally can't see why you wouldn't consider the alternatives also.

I have heard countless problems with new Lotus cars of late, and nightmares of people having to ruck with dealers and Lotus just to get warranty claims agreed, let alone actually sorted.

I don't remember hearing so many about Bernard or MSC for instance... food for thought.


I am jesting mate but for the vast majority of owners I would say a Honda / Audi car is complete overkill. 'Standard' cars with a few mods are usually fine for average road use with the odd trackday thrown in. Its only when you start seriously getting into it that conversions come into it.

I am still completely undecided with what to do with mine. I still like the thought of changing to a Noble but I have done 9 trackdays in mine in the last 12 months and that would cost a lot more to do in a Noble.

Converting mine is also a consideration but I also have a hankering for a 340r which wont go away.

Decisions.