'Other' suspension options
'Other' suspension options
Author
Discussion

enjybenjy

Original Poster:

928 posts

284 months

Thursday 24th August 2006
quotequote all
Has anyone tried the other manufacturers (other than Nitron or Ohlins) for uprated suspension?
Gaz, Spax etc?
I know they're like 1/2 the price, but how do they compare?

cuzza

2,042 posts

284 months

Thursday 24th August 2006
quotequote all
I think "you get what you pay for" seem to be the bywords here.

Those who have Nitrons say Gaz and Spax are crap, those who have them say they're an improvement but that could just be the fact that the car has new dampers rather than old and rolls less due to beefed up springs.

There's no doubt that the Nitron and Ohlins kits are developed and valved for the car and this shows.

If I were you, I'd stick to a new set of Bilsteins (whether you be in an S1 or S2) if you can't afford the higher end stuff.

enjybenjy

Original Poster:

928 posts

284 months

Thursday 24th August 2006
quotequote all
Might try and get some s/h LSS (from a 135R or the like). Getting Exige wheels and tyres soon, got a very annoying clunking from my right front still (I have an S2), hoping I can kill 2 birds with one stone here. Plus I wouldn't mind doing the odd track day - albeit I have a VERY noisy car!

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Thursday 24th August 2006
quotequote all
Save your money for Nitrons or Ohlins if you want adjustables - the Bilsteins you have will be better than Spax or Gaz.

Lotus are famed for their ride and handling, and it's a known that monotube dampers work better on the Elise, which is why Lotus specced them so.

Edited by S Works on Thursday 24th August 09:45

enjybenjy

Original Poster:

928 posts

284 months

Thursday 24th August 2006
quotequote all
so, if i COULD get s/h LSS (there's no way I can justify a grand or more for Nitrons or Ohlins) this would be a good compromise between standard and high end equipment?

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Thursday 24th August 2006
quotequote all
I wouldn't bother personally. The LSS set-up is still somewhat compromised leading to a hard ride on road - for all-round driving you're probably better off sticking with the standard set-up and adjusting the geo if you want it a bit more aggressively set-up.

piooly

1,176 posts

256 months

Thursday 24th August 2006
quotequote all
S Works said:
I wouldn't bother personally. The LSS set-up is still somewhat compromised leading to a hard ride on road - for all-round driving you're probably better off sticking with the standard set-up and adjusting the geo if you want it a bit more aggressively set-up.


I am in the same posistion. I am looking to get some new shocks andf springs but not sure what. I personnally think the LSS is a bit too soft. I'd like it harder. I dont want to spend a £1,000 or so so the other options are Spax, Gaz etc. I want them to be ride height adjustable and I want to be able to adjust the dampers. The bilsteins ride to high so I dont want them. I could get a new set of LSS but I thing they would cost a stack against the other. Spax are renowned for their suspension, I would have thought they must be good enough? As the gaz, at £300 they are very cheap. The company offers anyone to visit their factory to see how they are made and to such a high standard....... Might be worth a visit. I would be interested in how they have deceided on the spring rates etc....

simonk

908 posts

256 months

Thursday 24th August 2006
quotequote all
I put new original spec suspension on an old porsche 911 and the difference was amazing. So i do wonder if some of the cheaper things feel an improvement simply because old vs new is being compared.

Simon

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Thursday 24th August 2006
quotequote all
piooly said:
S Works said:
I wouldn't bother personally. The LSS set-up is still somewhat compromised leading to a hard ride on road - for all-round driving you're probably better off sticking with the standard set-up and adjusting the geo if you want it a bit more aggressively set-up.


I am in the same posistion. I am looking to get some new shocks andf springs but not sure what. I personnally think the LSS is a bit too soft. I'd like it harder. I dont want to spend a £1,000 or so so the other options are Spax, Gaz etc. I want them to be ride height adjustable and I want to be able to adjust the dampers. The bilsteins ride to high so I dont want them. I could get a new set of LSS but I thing they would cost a stack against the other. Spax are renowned for their suspension, I would have thought they must be good enough? As the gaz, at £300 they are very cheap. The company offers anyone to visit their factory to see how they are made and to such a high standard....... Might be worth a visit. I would be interested in how they have deceided on the spring rates etc....

Oly, if you buy the right kit (for instance from Steve Butts on SELOC) the Bilstein's can be set with a ride height of your choice, so if you want them lower that can be accommodated. This would be my choice were you not going down the route of new LSS, or new/used Ohlins or Nitrons.

If I were you I'd tread very carefully if you're going to change from a monotube damper to something else. I would not buy until I'd had a chance to try the kit on an Elise and drive it on roads which you are familiar with so you have something for comparison.

piooly

1,176 posts

256 months

Thursday 24th August 2006
quotequote all
What is a monotube damper? I assume they are all like that?? is it the internals?

cuzza

2,042 posts

284 months

Thursday 24th August 2006
quotequote all
piooly said:
What is a monotube damper? I assume they are all like that?? is it the internals?


Something Tim's read about on SELOC FWIW Gaz and Spax are almost certainly twin tube - apparently they are more crashy than a monotube and will get hotter as they can't dissapate the heat as well - some good info here if you're interested www.monroe.com/tech_support/tec_shockabsorbers.asp

If you want to go harder than LSS, then the Bilsteins are out as the spring rates are almost identical (although as mentioned, they can be adjusted height wise via brackets) and you're looking at something like Nitrons/Ohlins who will supply any spring rate you desire. Why do you want the car harder?

Edited by cuzza on Thursday 24th August 13:58

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Thursday 24th August 2006
quotequote all
Well done for spotting my lack of engineering knowledge - good link by the way which explains the basics.

My take at its very simplest is this - Lotus are renowned experts in the field of vehicle handling and dynamics. Who do big companies go to when they want help to sort that aspects of their cars out? Lotus.

So if Lotus specifies a particular sort of damper on it's most sucessful, most critically acclaimed model, and if several very well respected companies products are used at the upper echelons of motorsports involving variants of that model, why would you go against that grain unless you know better?

You pays your money, you makes yer choice thumbup

Edited by S Works on Thursday 24th August 15:50

cuzza

2,042 posts

284 months

Thursday 24th August 2006
quotequote all
S Works said:
My take at its very simplest is this - Lotus are renowned experts in the field of vehicle handling and dynamics. Who do big companies go to when they want help to sort that aspects of their cars out? Lotus.

So if Lotus specifies a particular sort of damper on it's most sucessful, most critically acclaimed model, and if several very well respected companies products are used at the upper echelons of motorsports involving variants of that model, why would you go against that grain unless you know better?


Spot on - only playing BTW

Unless you're doing lots of track days the Bilstein S2 kit is the best option, otherwise take it to the next level with Nitrons. I used my S1 with the S2 setup on track and it was absolutely superb and made a collossal difference on the road too thumbup

On the S2 front I think fresh units on each corner will do wonders as I and Simon have already said. If you're going for 48s tyre-wise then they can overload the std units and you could end up on the bumpstops (v.bad) but I know at least one PHer who has used 48s on track with std suspension and was fine.

enjybenjy

Original Poster:

928 posts

284 months

Thursday 24th August 2006
quotequote all
S Works said:

On the S2 front I think fresh units on each corner will do wonders as I and Simon have already said. If you're going for 48s tyre-wise then they can overload the std units and you could end up on the bumpstops (v.bad) but I know at least one PHer who has used 48s on track with std suspension and was fine.


But he was probably only going round bends at 20mph!
Seriously though, if I'm really Ok with standard shocks, then I should be OK running 48s for a while until maybe i change to 'normal' tyres. I'm not going to anything up by doing this? I still think that if a set of S2 LSS came up for £250 odd then I'd snap this up and they'd be fine for coping with harder use with this wheel/tyre combo. Am I right?

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Thursday 24th August 2006
quotequote all
enjybenjy said:
cuzza said:
<- ahem
On the S2 front I think fresh units on each corner will do wonders as I and Simon have already said. If you're going for 48s tyre-wise then they can overload the std units and you could end up on the bumpstops (v.bad) but I know at least one PHer who has used 48s on track with std suspension and was fine.


But he was probably only going round bends at 20mph!
Seriously though, if I'm really Ok with standard shocks, then I should be OK running 48s for a while until maybe i change to 'normal' tyres. I'm not going to anything up by doing this? I still think that if a set of S2 LSS came up for £250 odd then I'd snap this up and they'd be fine for coping with harder use with this wheel/tyre combo. Am I right?

Yep, bang on.

Hollywood Wheels

3,689 posts

261 months

Thursday 24th August 2006
quotequote all

Only just spotted this thread. When I was at N Weald, Andy mentioned that the suspension was okay but felt a little worn. I'd like to treat the car to some S2 suspension as I really can't justify Nitrons because of the type of stuff I use the car for. I have the 160 very low, 100/110 I think, and Steve B on Seloc states that this is the lowest setting he can provide for his S2 kits. Is it worth upgrading to these? Certainly having done a search on here and Seloc the consensus seems to be that S2 suspension is worth it, even as a replacement for S1 LSS such as mine. Any opinions welcomed.....

cuzza

2,042 posts

284 months

Friday 25th August 2006
quotequote all
OK, let's try and sum this up.......

S1 first. The red Konis are quite soft sprung and can get noisy after a while. Replacemnet options are the S2 kit or Nitrons/Ohlins. The S2 Bilstein kit has almost identical spring rates to S1 LSS (an adjustable Koni) but the damper is better if not adjustable in any way, however the ride height can be changed by altering the platforms (Steve B on SELOC can supply them ready done) cots is around £550 plus fitting. IMO these are the cheapest option worth considering, they will be fine with track days on road tyres. Nitrons/Ohlins are one way adjustable dampers (two and three way are available at a price) and you can alter the ride height - springs are to your spec but are normally around the 375-450 mark and the cost is just over £1k plus fitting. Depending on spring rates, these dampers will cope with semi slick track day tyres or even full slicks if you want to run them.

On the S2 the Konis are not an option as the car comes as std with Bilsteins but the options are pretty much the same apart from the LSS option which is an adjustable Bilstein damper with increased spring rates. The main gripe people seem to have with this setup is that it's too hard for crappy road surfaces but not really hard enough for track use with tyres such as A048Rs (I have never driven a car with this setup though).

As far as sticky tyres go - if you're running them on track, you need something like a Nitron/Ohlin to avoid hitting the bumpstops as the tyres provide so much grip the springs won't cope and you'll bottom the damper out, you will also need to upgrade the rear toe links as they can fail under the increased load. If you're running sticky tyres on a pure road car, you have too much money


Edited by cuzza on Friday 25th August 09:36

enjybenjy

Original Poster:

928 posts

284 months

Friday 25th August 2006
quotequote all
Ta Cuzza, that sort of sums it up. I haven't got 'tto much money' though, so I'm going to suck it and see cool