Hello all, I need an Elise which one?
Hello all, I need an Elise which one?
Author
Discussion

rustyveedub

Original Poster:

107 posts

243 months

Sunday 27th August 2006
quotequote all
Hi all this is my first post.
SpeedYellow who i beleive uses this forum has just brought my Land rover XD. The money from that was meant to go on a new house but after seeing Kurt's 240r i decided i couldn't live without an Elise. He pointed me in the direction of this forum.
I am looking at buying an elise and would like your opinions on which model to buy. I have 10k up to 15k for a very good car. I have a company car that i use 99% of the time but the Elise would need to be used for 1% of the time all year round. I would like to go away camping etc.. in it, so boot space would be a consideration. I would be using it as an occasional run around, using it for good road blasts and occasional track days.
Thanks for your advice in advance.

S works

10,166 posts

281 months

Sunday 27th August 2006
quotequote all
S1 111S or Sport 160 or if you haggle and can get a deal, an S2 135 Sport or 111S thumbup

rustyveedub

Original Poster:

107 posts

243 months

Sunday 27th August 2006
quotequote all
Could you let me know what the difference between the models are? or where i can see them listed? and why you have chosen those models?

Edited by rustyveedub on Sunday 27th August 13:24

andy_s

19,857 posts

290 months

Sunday 27th August 2006
quotequote all
S works said:
S1 111S or Sport 160 or if you haggle and can get a deal, an S2 135 Sport or 111S thumbup


Ditto - go check them out in real life as camping may be a squeeze though...

Check out the 2nd thread down, 'Buyers Guide' for some good links regarding the differences.



Edited by andy_s on Sunday 27th August 13:33

S works

10,166 posts

281 months

Sunday 27th August 2006
quotequote all
rustyveedub said:
Could you let me know what the difference between the models are? or where i can see them listed? and why you have chosen those models?

Check out the links in the buyers guide from the forum: www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?t=284992&f=15&h=0

elises.co.uk lists all the models.

Why did I pick them?

S1 111S - best 'allrounder' of the S1's
S1 Sport 160 - track-biased, most powerful S1 (great 2nd car)

S2 Sport 135 & 111S - best 'allrounders' of the S2 world.

rustyveedub

Original Poster:

107 posts

243 months

Sunday 27th August 2006
quotequote all
When i say camping i don't mean real hardcore camping, just going to a pub or somewhere with a tent and sleeping bag for a night. I have been told a S2 has a larger boot than a S1 is this true?

S works

10,166 posts

281 months

Sunday 27th August 2006
quotequote all
Yep

rustyveedub

Original Poster:

107 posts

243 months

Sunday 27th August 2006
quotequote all
So a S2 it is then.

Hollywood Wheels

3,689 posts

261 months

Sunday 27th August 2006
quotequote all

Don't write off the S1, you can squeeze quite a bit in there if you use every inch of space. Don't let luggage room dictate which Elise you buy, that factor is waaaaay down the list. Personally, on your budget and with it not needing to be an everyday car, I would be looking at an S1. You'll get a quality one for that price, it will have been looked after, and you can get something a bit more 'special', such as a Sport 160 (not that I'm biased or anything! hehe)

piooly

1,176 posts

256 months

Sunday 27th August 2006
quotequote all
S works said:
Yep


I'd say no to this. So S2's have the battery in the boot and this takes up a fair bit of space. The S1 boot is meant to be the biggest....

I'd get a S1 sport 160 for sure. If its going to be a second car, then dont bother with the S2, get a very sorted S1 instead. They are a bit more raw than the S2 and I think it would suit your circumstances better.

piooly

1,176 posts

256 months

Sunday 27th August 2006
quotequote all
actually, maybe even push the boat out and get an S1 sport 190. That has to be the ultimate elise but they are very rare...

toxic frog

3,227 posts

298 months

Sunday 27th August 2006
quotequote all
You'd probably want a S2 as they can be bought with in a colour similar to the 'interesting' shade of your old LR (I saw it earlier this week)

But in all seriousness, I can't really comment on S2's as I've never owned one, can't comment on Exiges (coz Westovers evidently don't think I'm wealthy enough for one), but I have owned a standard S1, S1 111S & S160 (my current stead).

My pick would be a lightly modded S1 111S... with decent tyres, better brake pads, ubiquitous sports zorst and induction kit and a set of S2 suspension (better yet, Nitrons), the 111S would be close to the ultimate (imho of course!).

The S160 requires a little more of a unhealthy love affair.. It'll get under your skin as when it's not sending you to heaven and back (you haven't lived until you've changed up at 7,250rpm in a Sport 160), it's a complete and utter bitch... Grp20 insurance and 6k services intervals completes the picture.

I'm mad enough to run a S160 as a daily driver (a S2 would be a much better choice), but it has Sooooooooooooooooooooooo much character (whereas a standard S1 111S has very little... positively verging on a porsche-esqe clinical feel).

Maybe I'm going round in circles here... so maybe the best thing to say is that coming out of a LR, whatever you buy will be absolutely fantastic... these cars are quite cheap to modify with drastic differences in feel, character and performance available for relatively little outlay... you can always make an Elise into what you want given enough time, money and knowledge.

Good luck...

oh, by the way,,, they don't like offroad driving!

rustyveedub

Original Poster:

107 posts

243 months

Sunday 27th August 2006
quotequote all
To be quite honest i am looking at an Elise for the raw driving experience. So i am not worried about the extras like electric windows etc. but from what i have seen air con would be very useful. If the boot is bigger on a S2 and it is a better all round car i can justify the extra cash to the other half by telling her we would be able to go away in it for longer. How would an Exige measure up as road car and run around to the Elise?

rustyveedub

Original Poster:

107 posts

243 months

Sunday 27th August 2006
quotequote all
toxic frog said:
My pick would be a lightly modded S1 111S... with decent tyres, better brake pads, ubiquitous sports zorst and induction kit and a set of S2 suspension (better yet, Nitrons), the 111S would be close to the ultimate (imho of course!).!

I have been doing my homework and visted Paul matty sports car a week or so ago and spoke to somebody there who advised against the 111s, Due to the complicated heads getting old now and causing problems?

toxic frog said:

Maybe I'm going round in circles here... so maybe the best thing to say is that coming out of a LR, whatever you buy will be absolutely fantastic... !

I only drove the XD for 1% of my total driving time and it was very good at what it was made for. You cant really compaire them.
Thanks for the advice.

turnamere

315 posts

266 months

Monday 28th August 2006
quotequote all
rustyveedub said:
When i say camping i don't mean real hardcore camping, just going to a pub or somewhere with a tent and sleeping bag for a night. I have been told a S2 has a larger boot than a S1 is this true?

Can't comment on the size of the S2 boot but you can fit a surprising amount in an S1. We arrived back home in the p!ss!ng rain after the British GP this year and unpacked the car straight into the lounge in a hurry, was amazed how much kit came out of such a small car; squashy bags are your friend. If you aren't too tall a two man tent and the roof will both fit behind the drivers seat leaving the boot, the little shelf, the footwell and the passengers lap free for other stuff!!

rustyveedub

Original Poster:

107 posts

243 months

Monday 28th August 2006
quotequote all
So for my needs would i be better off with a late special S1 or an early standard S2?

Hollywood Wheels

3,689 posts

261 months

Monday 28th August 2006
quotequote all

A late S1!!! driving

Paul RN

1,168 posts

245 months

Monday 28th August 2006
quotequote all
Hollywood Wheels said:

A late S1!!! driving


I'd also agree. All you'll get a base standard model S2 for that kind of money which is "refined" which would be fine for a everyday car.

Get a good spec S1 and you've got something with raw appeal. Unless you can find an S135R but I think thats above your budget.

Mark Benson

8,264 posts

300 months

Tuesday 29th August 2006
quotequote all
S works said:


S1 Sport 160 - track-biased, most powerful S1 (great 2nd car)


Apart from the S1 Sport 190.....

S Works

10,166 posts

281 months

Tuesday 29th August 2006
quotequote all
Mark Benson said:
S works said:


S1 Sport 160 - track-biased, most powerful S1 (great 2nd car)


Apart from the S1 Sport 190.....

Oops, you're right of course.