hmmm service time already! eeeek!
Discussion
ho hum.
I seem to have done 5500 miles in 7 weeks of ownership of my S1...
I believe it now needs an 'A' service for which I have been quoted £265 which seems reasonable (from the main dealer in Newcastle) but I fear that I need some new discs and therefore pads...which I was quoted £100 per disc and £100 for a set of pads!!!
is this the going rate? they are not MMC or whatever the special fancy brakes are (I can see that they are rusty round the edges and so far as I can tell aluminium doesn't rust).
does anyone have any advice?
is it worth going to a main dealer (the car has been serviced there all it's life) or shall I take it to a specialist? I plan to keep the car for years and years as I love it dearly so I don't really mind about resale value losses (unless they're going to be massive
)
thanks for your help!
Tom
I seem to have done 5500 miles in 7 weeks of ownership of my S1...
I believe it now needs an 'A' service for which I have been quoted £265 which seems reasonable (from the main dealer in Newcastle) but I fear that I need some new discs and therefore pads...which I was quoted £100 per disc and £100 for a set of pads!!!
is this the going rate? they are not MMC or whatever the special fancy brakes are (I can see that they are rusty round the edges and so far as I can tell aluminium doesn't rust).
does anyone have any advice?
is it worth going to a main dealer (the car has been serviced there all it's life) or shall I take it to a specialist? I plan to keep the car for years and years as I love it dearly so I don't really mind about resale value losses (unless they're going to be massive
) thanks for your help!
Tom
Well considering from other Lotus Authorised dealers an A service (basically an oil change) you can get for £120 (Miles @ Fibreglass Services). I'd suggest you're better off looking at specialists, not sure of the best one up North but just to give you an idea of prices in the South:
Maidstone Sports Cars A Service £185.00
Plans Motorsport A Service £179.00
Fibreglass Service A Service approx. £120.00 (Lotus Dealer Stamp)
Dreammachine A Service A service £195.00
Disc Prices (£99 to £245 per pair)
www.eliseparts.com/shop/index.php?main_page=index&cPath=114
Gives you a good idea of the disc prices
Pads Prices (£40-£129)
www.eliseparts.com/shop/index.php?main_page=index&cPath=113
Don't forget the labour to fit at around £45 per hour.
*edit* damn you Sam
Maidstone Sports Cars A Service £185.00
Plans Motorsport A Service £179.00
Fibreglass Service A Service approx. £120.00 (Lotus Dealer Stamp)
Dreammachine A Service A service £195.00
Disc Prices (£99 to £245 per pair)
www.eliseparts.com/shop/index.php?main_page=index&cPath=114
Gives you a good idea of the disc prices
Pads Prices (£40-£129)
www.eliseparts.com/shop/index.php?main_page=index&cPath=113
Don't forget the labour to fit at around £45 per hour.
*edit* damn you Sam
Edited by Paul RN on Wednesday 30th August 18:37
Paul RN said:
Well considering from other Lotus Authorised dealers an A service (basically an oil change) you can get for £120 (Miles @ Fibreglass Services). I'd suggest you're better off looking at specialists, not sure of the best one up North but just to give you an idea of prices in the South:
Maidstone Sports Cars A Service £185.00
Plans Motorsport A Service £179.00
Fibreglass Service A Service approx. £120.00 (Lotus Dealer Stamp)
Dreammachine A Service A service £195.00
Disc Prices (£99 to £245 per pair)
www.eliseparts.com/shop/index.php?main_page=index&cPath=114
Gives you a good idea of the disc prices
Pads Prices (£40-£129)
www.eliseparts.com/shop/index.php?main_page=index&cPath=113
Don't forget the labour to fit at around £45 per hour.
Maidstone Sports Cars A Service £185.00
Plans Motorsport A Service £179.00
Fibreglass Service A Service approx. £120.00 (Lotus Dealer Stamp)
Dreammachine A Service A service £195.00
Disc Prices (£99 to £245 per pair)
www.eliseparts.com/shop/index.php?main_page=index&cPath=114
Gives you a good idea of the disc prices
Pads Prices (£40-£129)
www.eliseparts.com/shop/index.php?main_page=index&cPath=113
Don't forget the labour to fit at around £45 per hour.
thank you paul and sam, I hadn't heard of eliseparts before...
...couple of questions occur though - why are greenstuff pads cheaper than the mintex ones? I thought greenstuff were track-biased pads (they certainly were for my mini) and as such, upgrades? for hard road use are the mintex ones better? it wears mintex ones at the moment...
and the discs...is there really any benefit from the 'turbo' discs? they obviously look a lot cooler but I can't see the difference other than that...
...I mean, the grooves surely offer less surface area for the pads to grip to and so surely less effective stopping power? or am I arse about face?
re: servicing costs, I cannot believe how us northern lotus owners get stiffed! £90 more for the service and a whopping £140 more for the discs and pads!

Sam_68 said:
Edited by Sam_68 on Wednesday 30th August 18:36
don't know, depends how hard it is to do it!
I fitted pads to my mini a year or so ago, but that was a matter of a split pin removal and a hammer
and I wouldn't know how to change a disc...anyone who lives near who would like some beer tokens to help me out is welcome to offer!

Grooved discs help to remove dirt and gases from the face of the disc and pad resulting in more consistent performance and cross drilled discs offer improved feel/bite.
Greenstuff are track bias pads (with less dust!) and the Mintex 1144 are as you say more road bias (better from cold). Pricewise might just be the price that Geary at Eliseparts can get them for (more people want greenstuff so he buys more get s abigger discount etc), plenty of other websites to cross check pricing on. Check the "Buyers Guide" sticky at the top of the forum as theres a whole list of em.
On fitment personally I get someone else to do it. Brakes are important and its the last thing personally I want to touch. Although you've done the right thing if you get someone to help you'll be fine.
Greenstuff are track bias pads (with less dust!) and the Mintex 1144 are as you say more road bias (better from cold). Pricewise might just be the price that Geary at Eliseparts can get them for (more people want greenstuff so he buys more get s abigger discount etc), plenty of other websites to cross check pricing on. Check the "Buyers Guide" sticky at the top of the forum as theres a whole list of em.
On fitment personally I get someone else to do it. Brakes are important and its the last thing personally I want to touch. Although you've done the right thing if you get someone to help you'll be fine.
Edited by Paul RN on Wednesday 30th August 18:53
minimax said:
don't know, depends how hard it is to do it!
I fitted pads to my mini a year or so ago, but that was a matter of a split pin removal and a hammer
and I wouldn't know how to change a disc...anyone who lives near who would like some beer tokens to help me out is welcome to offer!
I fitted pads to my mini a year or so ago, but that was a matter of a split pin removal and a hammer
and I wouldn't know how to change a disc...anyone who lives near who would like some beer tokens to help me out is welcome to offer!

It's trained Chimp stuff...no, come to think of it, that's an insult to quite a bright primate. Kwik Fit trainees can be taught to change discs and pads!
The front pads are the same as your Mini - remove split pins, withdraw pad retaining pins, remove pads.
Rear pads require a special tool to retract the pistons, but still not rocket science.
Discs you just unbolt the calipers (front) or remove the pads (rear), unbolt the discs, make sure the hub face is spotlessly clean, then bolt on the new discs. You need to keep an eye on fluid level (see this thread), but otherwise completely straightforward.
Download one of the free PDF copies of the workshop manual that are floating around on the web, and you'll have detailed instructions.

Get in touch with Dan @ Jude Performance www.judeperformance.co.uk/
He's a regular poster on here, gets good feedback from clients and will no doubt be way more competitive on price.
Don't get Greenstuff pads, they're no good on an Elise. Go for Mintex or Pagids. I've been advised to avoid drilled discs as they are prone to cracking under hard use. That said, the EBC Turbogroove ones are a decent budget buy.
He's a regular poster on here, gets good feedback from clients and will no doubt be way more competitive on price.
Don't get Greenstuff pads, they're no good on an Elise. Go for Mintex or Pagids. I've been advised to avoid drilled discs as they are prone to cracking under hard use. That said, the EBC Turbogroove ones are a decent budget buy.
Edited by S works on Wednesday 30th August 20:15
Stopping properly on that combination?
Didn't work so well for me as I tried to advance my braking point way to far on the 2nd straight:
http://media.putfile.com/Outbrake
Didn't work so well for me as I tried to advance my braking point way to far on the 2nd straight:
http://media.putfile.com/Outbrake
shangani said:
Stopping properly on that combination?
Didn't work so well for me as I tried to advance my braking point way to far on the 2nd straight:
http://media.putfile.com/Outbrake
Didn't work so well for me as I tried to advance my braking point way to far on the 2nd straight:
http://media.putfile.com/Outbrake
Staying out too long and boiling the brakes?. Crazy old sod, did you get hair in your eyes?
No, actually I went into the chicane at nearly 100 mph, ended up exiting to the right of the right hand cone (ie turning it into a straight) and making very high velocity into the hairpin. Not enough time to slow down form the increased speed. I chose the conservative option. Oh and yes, my brakes were fading. I had pushed the car pretty near its limits by late afternoon - the instructor said I might find another 0.4 seconds a lap by braking later, otherwise he had no other suggestions.
So I gave it a try.
So I gave it a try.
carlymart said:
you don't say how far north you are but I have heard ver good thing about jude performance in gateshead I think also have you tried calling other local lotus dealers just as a price comparison
I would be quite interested in prices for when I service my elise
I would be quite interested in prices for when I service my elise
i'm in newcastle so that's not too far for me
looks like i'm going to have to do some serious shopping around!
only thing i'm worried about (presuming specialist servicing does not completely bugger the resale) is the quality of oils etc these cheaper garages might put in...I know it's only a cooking engine but I still would like castrol or similar

Paul RN said:
Grooved discs help to remove dirt and gases from the face of the disc and pad resulting in more consistent performance and cross drilled discs offer improved feel/bite.
Greenstuff are track bias pads (with less dust!) and the Mintex 1144 are as you say more road bias (better from cold). Pricewise might just be the price that Geary at Eliseparts can get them for (more people want greenstuff so he buys more get s abigger discount etc), plenty of other websites to cross check pricing on. Check the "Buyers Guide" sticky at the top of the forum as theres a whole list of em.
On fitment personally I get someone else to do it. Brakes are important and its the last thing personally I want to touch. Although you've done the right thing if you get someone to help you'll be fine.
Greenstuff are track bias pads (with less dust!) and the Mintex 1144 are as you say more road bias (better from cold). Pricewise might just be the price that Geary at Eliseparts can get them for (more people want greenstuff so he buys more get s abigger discount etc), plenty of other websites to cross check pricing on. Check the "Buyers Guide" sticky at the top of the forum as theres a whole list of em.
On fitment personally I get someone else to do it. Brakes are important and its the last thing personally I want to touch. Although you've done the right thing if you get someone to help you'll be fine.
Edited by Paul RN on Wednesday 30th August 18:53
gotcha.
..and it's this reason why I don't do a lot of maintenance work - I don't trust myself!
Sam_68 said:
minimax said:
don't know, depends how hard it is to do it!
I fitted pads to my mini a year or so ago, but that was a matter of a split pin removal and a hammer
and I wouldn't know how to change a disc...anyone who lives near who would like some beer tokens to help me out is welcome to offer!
I fitted pads to my mini a year or so ago, but that was a matter of a split pin removal and a hammer
and I wouldn't know how to change a disc...anyone who lives near who would like some beer tokens to help me out is welcome to offer!

It's trained Chimp stuff...no, come to think of it, that's an insult to quite a bright primate. Kwik Fit trainees can be taught to change discs and pads!
The front pads are the same as your Mini - remove split pins, withdraw pad retaining pins, remove pads.
Rear pads require a special tool to retract the pistons, but still not rocket science.
Discs you just unbolt the calipers (front) or remove the pads (rear), unbolt the discs, make sure the hub face is spotlessly clean, then bolt on the new discs. You need to keep an eye on fluid level (see this thread), but otherwise completely straightforward.
Download one of the free PDF copies of the workshop manual that are floating around on the web, and you'll have detailed instructions.

well... if it's that easy...

minimax said:
Sam_68 said:
minimax said:
don't know, depends how hard it is to do it!
I fitted pads to my mini a year or so ago, but that was a matter of a split pin removal and a hammer
and I wouldn't know how to change a disc...anyone who lives near who would like some beer tokens to help me out is welcome to offer!
I fitted pads to my mini a year or so ago, but that was a matter of a split pin removal and a hammer
and I wouldn't know how to change a disc...anyone who lives near who would like some beer tokens to help me out is welcome to offer!

It's trained Chimp stuff...no, come to think of it, that's an insult to quite a bright primate. Kwik Fit trainees can be taught to change discs and pads!
Download one of the free PDF copies of the workshop manual that are floating around on the web, and you'll have detailed instructions.

well... if it's that easy...

I'm with you minimax - I had to pluck up courage just to change the front access panel nut things. In terms of me doing anything mechanical, stopping (and getting someone else to do it) is priceless...
Gooby - how did you get on with that combo in the end as compared to the old combo? Thinking of doing the same myself in the near future.
minimax said:
only thing i'm worried about (presuming specialist servicing does not completely bugger the resale) is the quality of oils etc these cheaper garages might put in...I know it's only a cooking engine but I still would like castrol or similar

We use Silkolene fully synthetic or Pro R 15w-50 if you track it a lot. Just cos we're cheaper it doesn't mean we use lower quality parts etc.
As for resale, for anyone who's in the know, my stamp is worth more than the dealers in your book when it come to selling time.
HTH
Dan@JPS
Gassing Station | Elise/Exige/Europa/340R | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



