Need Convincing
Author
Discussion

ALE 111s

Original Poster:

218 posts

245 months

Wednesday 30th August 2006
quotequote all
I'm changing jobs soon and my commute will change from a 30 mile round trip on A roads and through city centre to 50 miles on a motorway. I'm thinking of changing the Elise to a Boxster.......discuss !!!

confused confused confused

handbag

584 posts

247 months

Wednesday 30th August 2006
quotequote all
If after owning your car for such a short time you need convincing to keep the Elise, you're definitely a typical Boxster driver in the making

S works

10,166 posts

281 months

Wednesday 30th August 2006
quotequote all
Don't be ridiculous. You can close the thread now. thumbup

Mrs Trackside

9,299 posts

264 months

Wednesday 30th August 2006
quotequote all
ALE 111s said:
I'm thinking of changing the Elise to a Boxster.......discuss !!!

confused confused confused


Are you a hairdresser?

espresso

177 posts

243 months

Wednesday 30th August 2006
quotequote all
I've had a Boxster and an Elise (I've currently got a TVR T350)

Boxsters are very competent, well made and ultimately completely dull
Yes, they are a dependable every day drive, but then so is a Toyota Avensis.

The Elise is a different world.
You do have to make a few compromises, but anything fun has downsides.
If you really need more practicality (and for the journey described, I doubt it) maybe you should look at stretching to the new Europa.
I saw it at the motor show and it's pretty fantastic.

emenel

891 posts

250 months

Wednesday 30th August 2006
quotequote all
DON'T DO IT! I made this mistake with my first Elise and missed it soooooo much. 2 years and 3 boring(ish) cars later and I'm back in a Lotus. It was an expensive way to find out that I had the right car in the first place.

bogie

17,108 posts

303 months

Wednesday 30th August 2006
quotequote all
eh - in my first 2 years of Elise ownership I used it daily for business and covered 25K miles a year ....usual commute could involve 150miles on the M25 or 300 miles + to the NE or Scotland with a bootful of kit ...cant see the problem myself - its car...drive it.

...or maybe get yourself a motorbike ...run that for a year through winter every day....that will toughen you up and the Elise will feel like a limo in comparison...I mean its got a roof and a heater - what more do you want !?

TIPPER

2,955 posts

250 months

Wednesday 30th August 2006
quotequote all
50 miles - that's about 45 mins on the motorway! Don't be so soft. Keep the car, buy some decent ICE, and you've still got it for B road blats.


Edited by TIPPER on Wednesday 30th August 23:12

ALE 111s

Original Poster:

218 posts

245 months

Wednesday 30th August 2006
quotequote all
I'm certainly no hairdresser and this being my second Elise I think I know what they're about !!!

Just thought I'd ask the question....maybe I should upgrade the second car...any suggestions ?

bogie

17,108 posts

303 months

Thursday 31st August 2006
quotequote all
you already have an S2 so thats more comfy for daily use than most derivatives ....one thing I had early on was a decent sound system - cures the boredom on motorways/long journeys ..Probax seats are good too

..I think the Elise is actually a great commuter - fuel economy is fantastic, and on a summers evening you can always take the long way home

Edited to add: the only reason I got a 2nd car 2 years ago was that I got a job which required a more kit, and lots of airport runs with luggage ...otherwise Id probably still have the Elise alone.

Now the Europa is coming out, if I didnt do track days, and wanted the Elise type experience on the road, but with more practicality/comfort Id definately be getting a Europa

Edited by bogie on Thursday 31st August 00:13

sp60

524 posts

290 months

Thursday 31st August 2006
quotequote all
Boxster will certainly be more comfortable, but you will be doubling your fuel costs and on that kind of mileage that is significant. On the other hand if you don't pay for your fuel, this is a not an issue (unless you consider the environmental affect). Tax liability and and road tax will be much less in the elise. I do a similar journey at the moment, 48miles each way and the elise is just fine to me. I do have a second car, but that's mainly just to keep the mileage down on the elise and for the extreme weather days...having said that I've never let the weather decide which car I drive to work.
Oh...and personally I think the elise has a much better image....or rather the boxster has an image I'd rather not be associated with, but that's just my opinion and not a dig at boxter drivers.

GTRene

22,802 posts

255 months

Thursday 31st August 2006
quotequote all
Buy an M coupe they drive realy best they look great and not standard BMW they are very rare specialy the S54 M coupe RHD only about 168 are made I believe 2001<>2002 they feel special and the drive specialy with 19inch is geat!! it was the driver car of the year in 2002 top gear I believ also! look at M coupe under BMW in classifieds...
when you step out the Elise and then in the M coupe you will also know what I mean
its a great car for daily use! and much faster then a boxter! and more man
Black is best(to me) but I have a rare colour phoenixyellow because they where hard to find the S54 see if it has the new bettered engine in it(there where some changes needed in the 2001<>early 2003 engines...I have a 2004 engine in it

GTRene

Chrome Orange

140 posts

288 months

Thursday 31st August 2006
quotequote all
Keep the Elise and get a Smart 4Two for the commute.

This is what I did anyway.

The Lotus/Poxster/Bimmo will die in value if you heap the miles on them (not to mention the accelerated costs associated with having to service the thing ever more often).

The Smart will turn in 65mpg, costs buttons to run, is waaaaaay more reliable than most cars, it a cinch to drive in traffic with the semi-auto transmission, and is COOL.

I've piled 65,000 miles on my Smart in 2.5 years and it's never been anything other than a great little car.

jb111s

393 posts

249 months

Thursday 31st August 2006
quotequote all
The boxster is a very nice car for cruising & I see your point in wanting more of a grand tourer. However, the image that goes with it these days is awful. There are so many on the road these days & second hand ones are now quite affordable (10-16k) so a lot of "hairdresser sorts" are buying them. Have a look around & all the older models have private plates (again the sign of a t@sser!!) with people buying them on the cheap trying to look flash. They always forget to upgrade the indicators from the old orange ones, or put an S badge on the back despite it being a 2.5 litre! It is a wannabe's car these days.

Your average elise owner is someone who respects a good fun car with great sporting heritage & is applauded by the man in the street. Your average boxster owner is seen as a flash wannabe who couldn't afford a proper porsche

My mates got a boxster & gets nothing but abuse, he is know contemplating a europa.

Get a decent little 2nd hand hatchback for your commute (alfa's & golfs are cheap) & keep your elise for weekend fun.

ALE 111s

Original Poster:

218 posts

245 months

Thursday 31st August 2006
quotequote all
jb111s said:
The boxster is a very nice car for cruising & I see your point in wanting more of a grand tourer. However, the image that goes with it these days is awful. There are so many on the road these days & second hand ones are now quite affordable (10-16k) so a lot of "hairdresser sorts" are buying them. Have a look around & all the older models have private plates (again the sign of a t@sser!!) with people buying them on the cheap trying to look flash. They always forget to upgrade the indicators from the old orange ones, or put an S badge on the back despite it being a 2.5 litre! It is a wannabe's car these days.

Your average elise owner is someone who respects a good fun car with great sporting heritage & is applauded by the man in the street. Your average boxster owner is seen as a flash wannabe who couldn't afford a proper porsche

My mates got a boxster & gets nothing but abuse, he is know contemplating a europa.

Get a decent little 2nd hand hatchback for your commute (alfa's & golfs are cheap) & keep your elise for weekend fun.


jb111s

That's it I'm convinced.....thank you, actually I decided last night reading the other comments but you certainly convinced me not to get a "hairdressermobile". Was thinking of a Golf GT Tdi as a second car, 54mpg and a bit more safe on the motorway.

Thanks to all....now should I get a Hurrcane induction kit.....?????

jb111s

393 posts

249 months

Thursday 31st August 2006
quotequote all
Ha ha, pleasure. Sounds like a good idea with a diesel golf, cheap to get from a to b & even in the elise motorway driving would be boring. In the winter months or pissing rain you'd be a lot safer in a solid runaround. Definitely invest in a decent 'xaust. Nothing beats giving it a good rev when going in a tunnel or under a bridge!!

For all others contemplating a coxster, read this Clarkson article. Had me in stitches...

http://driving.timesonline.co.uk/arti

sp60

524 posts

290 months

Friday 1st September 2006
quotequote all
>Was thinking of a Golf GT Tdi as a second car, 54mpg and a bit more safe on the motorway.

Good choice. Get a second hand ex-repmobile with FSH and it will go on forever. I had the 1.8T ex repmobile that I drove up to 140k miles with very few problems. It was fine when I sold it...wish i never had now!

boggy

4,603 posts

266 months

Friday 1st September 2006
quotequote all
Hi all,

I have a Piper Cross induction kit £299.95 this is also a recommended part fitted by most Lotus Dealer'shehe It also sound's wicked on my R when the 2nd Cam comes inears I'm sure it will sound Fab on your S

Boggy
www.pipercross.net/newsletters/lotus_1104/

Edited by boggy on Friday 1st September 12:55

sramdeen

416 posts

251 months

Friday 1st September 2006
quotequote all
jb111s said:
The boxster is a very nice car for cruising & I see your point in wanting more of a grand tourer. However, the image that goes with it these days is awful. There are so many on the road these days & second hand ones are now quite affordable (10-16k) so a lot of "hairdresser sorts" are buying them. Have a look around & all the older models have private plates (again the sign of a t@sser!!) with people buying them on the cheap trying to look flash. They always forget to upgrade the indicators from the old orange ones, or put an S badge on the back despite it being a 2.5 litre! It is a wannabe's car these days.

Your average elise owner is someone who respects a good fun car with great sporting heritage & is applauded by the man in the street. Your average boxster owner is seen as a flash wannabe who couldn't afford a proper porsche

My mates got a boxster & gets nothing but abuse, he is know contemplating a europa.

Get a decent little 2nd hand hatchback for your commute (alfa's & golfs are cheap) & keep your elise for weekend fun.


That's it. jb111s for Prime Minister!

boobles

15,251 posts

246 months

Saturday 2nd September 2006
quotequote all
nono nono nono dont do it... I do like the boxter, but come on, it has no comparison to an elise! Theres a couple of them round my way & the amount of respect i get everytime they see me in my elise is unbalievable, its like deep down they know who has the better car.