Is there a Liz with more character than an S1 160?
Is there a Liz with more character than an S1 160?
Author
Discussion

hahithestevieboy

Original Poster:

845 posts

245 months

Wednesday 6th September 2006
quotequote all
I has one of these a few years ago, and have found no car i have driven since had so much character and soul of a real sports car. Boxters are just not on the map. Even the S2 exige with a stage 2 exhaust on it seemed little faster (in a straight line up to 100mph)and seemed to have less character and sense of occasion. Getting the 160 on the cam and listening to it scream was like nothing else. (I have not driven a caterfield or S190 by the way). I am thinking of getting an S2 exige next but i know that i will still miss the visceral scream of my old 160. Anyone got any thoughts as to what can be done to an exige to make it more like that?

gooby

9,269 posts

265 months

Wednesday 6th September 2006
quotequote all
The S1 S160 has bundles of character and is just awesome - is it the kind of character you would invite to dinner?. Not so much the split personality of the R, just plain psycotic, axe weilding nut job of a personality.

You are right there is very little like it - dont turn your back on one!

TIPPER

2,955 posts

250 months

Wednesday 6th September 2006
quotequote all
I couldn't live with the 160 as I use my car daily but it is a real character in a spiteful, snarling sort of way. To get that character you really need to be looking at another S1 and all its bangs and clangs with a tuned K. Would seem like another 160 is the way to go....

GTRene

22,802 posts

255 months

Wednesday 6th September 2006
quotequote all
Or the S1 190 motorsport version can be the car for you

My choise would be best of both worlds the S2 with a Honda R engine in it and a hardtop as a extra option
GTRene

hahithestevieboy

Original Poster:

845 posts

245 months

Wednesday 6th September 2006
quotequote all
Yeah S190..... Very naughty. But even an S2 190 isnt exactly available now is it. I dont know if i could live with the potential reliabiltiy problems of a VHPD engine though. Just had a look at the new exige S at JCT600 brooklands. Very very nice but laghably expensive. I was wondering what an S2 exige would be like if it had direct to head throttle boddies, perhapse a livlier cam shaft, emerald ecu and a larini exhaust. Or even perhaps a turbo charged one (rather than supercharged) as i could perhaps fit that to a nice second hand example. I do like the idea of having ABS and air conditioning which would not be possible (at reasonable cost) with a honda elise i think. I very much like the better build quality and different suspension geometry of the S2

S works

10,166 posts

281 months

Wednesday 6th September 2006
quotequote all
Having recently gone from a Sport 160 to a Honda'd S2, and having driven a Honda'd S1 I can honestly say that it's the leap that will make the most sense to you as an ex-160 owner.

The Sport 190 will explode.
The 111R will frustrate.
The Exige 220S will cost too much, and is slower.

Try one, you'll love it.

GTRene

22,802 posts

255 months

Wednesday 6th September 2006
quotequote all
well spoken yes
GTRene

piooly

1,176 posts

256 months

Wednesday 6th September 2006
quotequote all
TIPPER said:
I couldn't live with the 160 as I use my car daily but it is a real character in a spiteful, snarling sort of way. To get that character you really need to be looking at another S1 and all its bangs and clangs with a tuned K. Would seem like another 160 is the way to go....


It always surprises me when people say they cant live with a sport 160 as a daily driver. I have for nearly 3 years and have loved every bit of it. Sure sometimes you think why cant it just be smooth and civilised but then give it some welly and you fall in love with it again....

S works

10,166 posts

281 months

Wednesday 6th September 2006
quotequote all
Me too - could have lived with mine if I'd have had to. Angry little bugger that it was

simonk

908 posts

256 months

Thursday 7th September 2006
quotequote all
hahithestevieboy said:
Anyone got any thoughts as to what can be done to an exige to make it more like that?


Induction kit will certainly help

Simon

toxic frog

3,227 posts

298 months

Thursday 7th September 2006
quotequote all
i used mine as a daily driver, but recently it has decided to stall all the time (i probably need to clean out the air/idle valve thingy...)... it's blatantly complaining about not being driven properly in a while (stroppy little bastard!)...

friday's burger run should sort that out though :-)

hahithestevieboy

Original Poster:

845 posts

245 months

Thursday 7th September 2006
quotequote all
I used mine as a daily driver (4 mile commute), stroppy little madam that she was, evil on part throttle at anything below 40mph and tought me a thing or two about fine throttle control. At the time i always said that the "right" engine for this car was the civic type r which would have had pretty much all the advantages with none of the dissadvantages of the 160 and a good bit more pace to boot. Open the trottle though and i would be grinning from ear to ear every time. I agree that the honda elise would probably be the way to go. Thing is that what i really want is an S2 exige but the toyota and honda engines are fairly similar and i dont know if i could justify the 10K+ for the conversion, especially since a supercharged one would probably cost 15K+ if i wanted a large performance gain. I would have thought that you could do a fair amount with the existing 'yota engine for 10K hense my question about N/A tuning or turbocharging.

toxic frog

3,227 posts

298 months

Thursday 7th September 2006
quotequote all
for the ultimate is snatchy throttle, try sticking on a 160TB on a SVA 160 (with no verniers)... great fun!

S works

10,166 posts

281 months

Thursday 7th September 2006
quotequote all
hahithestevieboy said:
Thing is that what i really want is an S2 exige but the toyota and honda engines are fairly similar and i dont know if i could justify the 10K+ for the conversion, especially since a supercharged one would probably cost 15K+ if i wanted a large performance gain. I would have thought that you could do a fair amount with the existing 'yota engine for 10K hense my question about N/A tuning or turbocharging.

I disagree on that point.

They may have some similarities but the way the power is delivered is totally different. The Exige S is more like the NA Honda but nowhere near as viscereal or 'immediate'. It's a great car, very quick, but just isn't as quick because it's lugging around about 100kg more than you're average Honda'd Elise. Compared to the Exige (again, a pretty quick car) the Honda delivers the power earlier, with a much wider spread. It's way more useable.

The main issue with the regular Exige is the fact that you can't (yet) adjust the map, and hence you're stuck with a (comparatively) small upper power band on the 2nd cam which one either loves or hates - I've not met anyone who's not in one of the two camps.

Sure you could spend 10k or so on the Bemani SC kit for an Exige but then your outlay is going to be somewhere near the £33k mark. With that budget and a keen eye, you could get an S2 Elise get the Honda SC conversion, all the bits, and potentially even re-clam it to look like an Exige, and come to a simliar number BUT have 300bhp rather than 265.

Before I made my choice I tried all variants of the Exige to be 100% sure that the money I spent was in the right direction for me (and I was of a mindset where I really fell in love with the S2 Exige, rather like yourself). I tried the Exige, the Exige S, the Cup 240, an NA Honda'd Elise S1, an NA Honda'd Elise S2 and I'd pax'd in an SC Honda'd Exige S1.

By far the SC Exige S1 was the most planted, fastest car, seconded by the Cup 240 and very closely 3rd came the NA Honda'd S2 Elise (which I bought).

The Cup 240 was a fabulous car, but at £38k was simply too much for me to consider.

The Honda'd S2 Elise was perfect for what I want, and for another £3,500 at some point in the future I can send it back to the lads at Maidstone Sports Cars and have the SC bolted on... I can't see that happening for a long time, it's very quick as it is.

Sorry, I'm waffling.

TBH if I were you and I REALLY wanted an Exige, at the moment I'd be looking for a used Cup240 or 240R. Either of which you should be able to find (if you're patient) around the mid £30k's now, which is somewhere near what you'll pay for a new Exige S... but you'll have more grunt, and probably more toys.

The Bemani is a nice kit, but it's expensive, and I'd want to see more cars, longer term with it before I committed to see how it lasts.

bogie

17,108 posts

303 months

Thursday 7th September 2006
quotequote all
"Sure you could spend 10k or so on the Bemani SC kit for an Exige but then your outlay is going to be somewhere near the £33k mark. With that budget and a keen eye, you could get an S2 Elise get the Honda SC conversion, all the bits, and potentially even re-clam it to look like an Exige, and come to a simliar number BUT have 300bhp rather than 265. "

AND 100Kg less weight

..agree with everything else of course....thats my kind of logic

...if you want the ultimate in performance/price ratio in an Elise derivative then buying the latest factory car is 100% not the option to go for....youd need other reasons like maybe:

1.ease (choice) of insurers on a std factory car
2. the "new" car feel...you may just want the new model...some people do..especially if you dont intend to keep it for many years
3. Aircon - for a daily drive it would be nice
4. electrickery - TC, ABS, central locking, lecky windows etc
5. long factory warranty rather than 1 year warranty on engine conversion
6. you dont have the cash, so need some low rate finance deal and a trade in to fund an upgrade

if you are not bothered about 1-6 and all you want is character, performance, reliability, good-resale (personally I dont mind paying for tangible goods and benefits...I detest depreciation for no reason!) then go for an engine conversion and a refresh of the car you already own

hahithestevieboy

Original Poster:

845 posts

245 months

Thursday 7th September 2006
quotequote all
I was thinking more along the lines of a second hand S2 exige with some of the toys like aircon and fancy dampers and then putting something along the lines of a Force Fed turbo charger kit, which can give over 300bhp. I agree that it will not be as linear power delivery as an SC honda but maybe cheaper??

S works

10,166 posts

281 months

Friday 8th September 2006
quotequote all
Go for it thumbup