I can't start it!
Author
Discussion

Crapper

Original Poster:

113 posts

250 months

Friday 8th September 2006
quotequote all
Hey people, hoping you might be able to help me. Over the last few days I have had a problem, when I turn the key to start the car the starter motor kicks in but it makes a strange noise then it stops. I then turn ignition off and then back to ignition to start it. Its starts at this point (within a second of turning the key) but the revs vary between 2000 - 1500 RPM. I left this for a minute and it seemed to start settling down to around 1250rpm and as I pull away it starts varying the rpm again. I turned the engine off (for risk that the reving is damaging my cold engine) then restarted and it seems fine. It did it once on Wednesday but initially thought I had caused it but not putting enough pressure on the key when starting but it happened yesterday as well (not every time I go to drive the car though)

Went out to my car this morning and it doesn't want to start at all. I hear the fuel pump cycle for about 2 seconds, wait for most of the lights on the dash to be distinguished (as I normally do) and turn the key. I hear the starter motor briefly but then it makes a clicking noise and both gauges are shaking vigorously. The light in the middle of the rev counter flashes and then the normal three lights that are on at ignition (think they are battery, parking brake and seat belt lights) come back on. I hear clicking noise from the front right side for a further 2 seconds then all goes quiet. I try restarting and does the same thing each time. Check the connecters on the battery and around the engine and everything seems to be OK. I have an S2 111S 04 plate if it helps.

shangani

3,069 posts

268 months

Friday 8th September 2006
quotequote all
Sounds like it might be a flat battery. Either it is not holing a charge, or is not getting charged by the alternator. Try charging the battery and then restarting.

Crapper

Original Poster:

113 posts

250 months

Friday 8th September 2006
quotequote all
OK I'll need to buy a charger, anything I need to look for when buying one?

Dave_s2_111s

246 posts

259 months

Friday 8th September 2006
quotequote all
This maybe a similaf fault to what i have just had.

I am thinking now that it could possibly have been water in and around the HT leads. Although i have got some magnecor leads on order to solve the cap missing of the end of one of my HT leads.

Check for each lead firing etc:

or have a read of my post, there may be something of some help there to you.

http://forums.seloc.org/viewthread.ph

hope you can get it sorted

Dave

Dave_s2_111s

246 posts

259 months

Friday 8th September 2006
quotequote all
The longer you can leave it on charge at a lower charging rate the better.

One with a hi and low charge should do the trick.

If it does work then get your self a trickle charger. I brought a solar powered one and at the moment it seems to work fint. I just leave it plugged in all the time im not using it.

Dont forget when your charging with a battery charger other than a trickle charger to disconnect one of the leads to the battery or you risk damaging your alternator.

I think there has been a few issues with buggered alternators due to how close they are to the zaust manifold but will keep fingers crossed that it is your battery

Dave

S works

10,166 posts

281 months

Friday 8th September 2006
quotequote all
IIRC there are relays in the front service compartment. In the S1 the one which the fuel pump works off is in there (although on the passenger side of the car) and I'm assuming 'right' is as you're sitting in it from your post (so drivers side).

I had water ingress into the relay which controls the fuel pump, and similar symptoms before it failed totally.

Work checking that too as a new one is a cheap fix (£30ish).

cqueen

2,652 posts

251 months

Saturday 9th September 2006
quotequote all
Your engine should be charging your battery and it is not. Before you go and buy a fancy battery charger, go get your alternator checked (you'll need the money for a new one, they aint cheap!).

Edited by cqueen on Saturday 9th September 09:21

shangani

3,069 posts

268 months

Saturday 9th September 2006
quotequote all
shangani said:
Sounds like it might be a flat battery. Either it is not holding a charge, or is not getting charged by the alternator. Try charging the battery and then restarting.


This is what was said right at the beginning. There is no way to be sure it is the alternator rather than the battery with the info given. I had my battery run flat after a few days of not using the car. It produced identical symptoms. A trickle charger cost me just on £10 and has been really helpful if I don't use the car regularly. If it won't start, he still needs to take it to where it can be started to check the alternator. That will cost a lot more than a tenner.

If he has AA then they can charge up the battery and test the alternator current. If the battery is receiving a charge but not retaining it then a new battery is required. If no charge from the alternator, the first thing to check then is the tension in the alternator drive belt - ie is the alternator turning?

If both battery and alternator are OK, then you have a more complex problem and will need to check relays etc. However, from the erratic behaviour, it sounds like not enough battery power to initiate the starter motor.

philygumbo

1,500 posts

280 months

Saturday 9th September 2006
quotequote all
A call came through from Crapper to Gooby at Swanage, "I can't start it".
By the time we ate the burgers and three cars went back up the hill, the RAC had sorted him out. It's a new battery required, and a battery conditioner while in the garage. The run up the hill was worth it though, following Gooby up there is mental, he should be locked up for his own good, and we should be locked up for following.

Crapper

Original Poster:

113 posts

250 months

Saturday 9th September 2006
quotequote all
Just a bit of an update, battery is replaced and the car's great. Going to buy a conditioner to help it out. Thanks for all the help last night I had a great time and looking forward to the next outing.