Sunday Times Europa S Review 10/09
Sunday Times Europa S Review 10/09
Author
Discussion

clubsport

Original Poster:

7,420 posts

289 months

Sunday 10th September 2006
quotequote all
Oh Dear, please say Frankel is wrong???

http://driving.timesonline.co.uk/arti

clownfish

153 posts

242 months

Sunday 10th September 2006
quotequote all


The thing is, if they had based it on the VX220, it could have been a half decent car.

God knows what they were thinking of when they built this. Oh well, another nail in the coffin for the fantastic Lotus heritage.


GTRene

22,802 posts

255 months

Sunday 10th September 2006
quotequote all
hm...a bit what I thought about what they use for the drivetrain...(VXT like engine/gearbox/axels and stuff) a bit strange though...I see a VXT Europa S thread coming again...please help ushehe
At least this picture looks stunning I must say!

GTRene

peter450

1,650 posts

264 months

Sunday 10th September 2006
quotequote all
think the guys really missing the point, this is a car for someone who wants the elise experiance, but not in such a track orientated way, of course its not going to match a porsche etc in terms of luxury, but its 90% elise experiance with a lot more user frendlyness, certianly if the posts of the few ppl who have driven one are anything to go by.
An all this nonsense about turbo's not being what lotus are about, has he ever heard of the esprit?

simonk

908 posts

256 months

Sunday 10th September 2006
quotequote all
Yeah one persons good compromise is another persons bad compromise.

As i understand it the vx220 was a subtley different type of elise which tended to get judged on its badge rather than anything else. Will be interesting to see how this does with the lotus badge.

Simon

S works

10,166 posts

281 months

Sunday 10th September 2006
quotequote all
He makes 3 negative points as far as I can make out.

- Doesn't like the looks
- Doesn't like the engine
- Doesn't like the fact that the cabin isn't silent for long range cruising

The comment about a Porka being £175 more is utter bollox, no-one would ever buy one unless it was specced up or you'd never shift it for resale, and that'll soon start nudging the upper end of the £30k's you can be sure.

Check out what he said about the competition...

Model Porsche Boxster £33,170
For: Ride, handling, lovely engine, convertible roof
Against: Bland looks, cramped cabin, miserly standard spec

Model Nissan 350Z £26,495
For: Huge power, great fun to drive, looks great
Against: Cheap-looking cabin, lumpy ride, blue-collar badge

Very little difference in terms of what he likes/dislikes on either of those other than the engine and what it looks like, both of which are totally subject to the individuals preferences.

The Europa is a niche in a niche - for me it looks good, the ride and handling seems to be good, and if the engine is a bit of a let down as standard, there's shedloads of VX tuning options readily available (see Thorney Motorsport) which could be applied cheaply and effectively... http://tinyurl.com/hfl33

It will not take much to make one of these considerably quicker than an Exige S.

Edited by S works on Sunday 10th September 15:11

clubsport

Original Poster:

7,420 posts

289 months

Sunday 10th September 2006
quotequote all
I am confused about comments on the engine.....when I was at the factory talking to lotus engineeers, they were really happy with the power delivery of the Europa engine and felt that was one of it's best features?????
I haven't driven a Europa yet, but we were comparing it to the Exige S at the time confused

S works

10,166 posts

281 months

Sunday 10th September 2006
quotequote all
Speaking to a Dealer last night who's been using a Cup240 as his everyday car for the last few months, and has had the Europa for a week now, he was really happy with the spread of torque from very low down.

For me its not an apples/apples comparison really - it should be judged on its merits/demerits, not vs. the Exige, which is a completely different proposition.

cqueen

2,652 posts

251 months

Sunday 10th September 2006
quotequote all
Thats the problem with newspapers. One person wrote that review.
I personally think porsches are pretty ugly, but what does my opinion matter to anyone else?

clubsport

Original Poster:

7,420 posts

289 months

Sunday 10th September 2006
quotequote all
I guess it is hard to write a definitive review of the car, as far as Lotus models of the last 10years go...it is hardly remarkable and is a sound compliment to the range.
Don't get me wrong I am knocking the car as it certainly has a place in the Lotus range, but it is not as significant as a new Esprit will have to be.

S works

10,166 posts

281 months

Sunday 10th September 2006
quotequote all
Agreed but it's a worthy stablemate of them all.

I await EVO's review with anticipation.

slatess1

437 posts

245 months

Sunday 10th September 2006
quotequote all
Ben at Wilsons Romford took me out yesterday in the Europa S, surprising amount of torque, brilliant car in and out. If you guys havent been out in it yet id definately recomend it!!!!

GTRene

22,802 posts

255 months

Sunday 10th September 2006
quotequote all
S works said:
The Europa is a niche in a niche - for me it looks good, the ride and handling seems to be good, and if the engine is a bit of a let down as standard, there's shedloads of VX tuning options readily available (see Thorney Motorsport) which could be applied cheaply and effectively... http://tinyurl.com/hfl33

It will not take much to make one of these considerably quicker than an Exige S.

Nice clear website about tuning that engine hmmmmm 330hp sounds like a good startyes but to be honest 240hp already is fast in such car for the most of us, when I drove my VXT I remembered the easy power! it only needed a chip and a more sporty sound(VXT)
I think its a nice good car...not a wow or totally new but its a nice compromiseyes
GTRene

clubsport

Original Poster:

7,420 posts

289 months

Sunday 10th September 2006
quotequote all
S works said:
Agreed but it's a worthy stablemate of them all.

I await EVO's review with anticipation.


Sure, please don't get the impression I am against it.....thinking about it if the contract with GM hadn't existed then the Europa would have appeared in the Lotus line up earlier.

TIPPER

2,955 posts

250 months

Sunday 10th September 2006
quotequote all
I think the Times review totally missed the point of the Europa.
The Elise/Exige package in all its varients offers an agressively packaged raw sports car experience where the driver has to work to get the best in terms of performance. The Europa was conceived to offer some of the Elise/Exige experience in a more relaxed manner. Its a compromise car with limited appeal - something Lotus recognise by setting target of just 400 units pa.
I don't know how much Lotus have tinkered with the GM lump but in my extensive test drive of a VX turbo lag was never a problem - I just didn't think the lazy power delivery suited the rest of the car.

gooby

9,269 posts

265 months

Monday 11th September 2006
quotequote all
It is all points that have been discussed on this forum. You can be negative about these points but it is just as easy to be positive.

It is a little more than a VX, it does have a different engine and the interior is different, oh and the body is beautiful. It is basically the same chassis with some lower sills to aid ingress / egress.... Hold on, he doesnt really have a point!

I suppose if you catch anyone on a bad day or the car doesnt "gel" with you then it just doesnt. If you made the mistake of talking to me yesterday, you would really get the point. I have 2 neighbours who wont talk me for a while.

We drive a nieche car with niech design and consequently a neiche of owners / fans, you cant expect everyone to like it. That is probably why I love them.

Overall - it makes sod all difference, the car is sold out for years!

seetim

124 posts

258 months

Monday 11th September 2006
quotequote all
S works said:
Agreed but it's a worthy stablemate of them all.

I await EVO's review with anticipation.


It's be an interesting review as long as EVO don't do a comparison against tbe Boxster. Every time anything comes up against a Porsche in EVO the result is a forgone conclusion - and it's always the Porsche that is a better all round drivers car (qualified in whatever way they can to make it an acceptable decision)

mg511

1,754 posts

272 months

Monday 11th September 2006
quotequote all
It gets a better write up in 'Car' www.carmagazine.co.uk/first_drive.php?sid=151&page=1, though they agree that if you want a Lotus you'd buy an Elise/Exige and if you wanted something more civilised you'd buy a Boxter/Z4.

clownfish

153 posts

242 months

Monday 11th September 2006
quotequote all
[quote=gooby]

It is a little more than a VX, it does have a different engine and the interior is different, oh and the body is beautiful. It is basically the same chassis with some lower sills to aid ingress / egress.... Hold on, he doesnt really have a point!

quote]


I am interested in the comment "it is a little more than a VX" It seemed to me from what I have read that it is different to the VX (or the Elise for that matter), just wondered why the poster felt it was "more"?



minimax

11,985 posts

287 months

Monday 11th September 2006
quotequote all
clownfish said:


The thing is, if they had based it on the VX220, it could have been a half decent car.

God knows what they were thinking of when they built this. Oh well, another nail in the coffin for the fantastic Lotus heritage.





another nail? when was the last? I can only think of one other dodgy car in Lotus history and that's the old Excel...care to enlighten me?

and I didn't really get frankels point - people who want a slightly softer Lotus to commute in and drive to their home in france for a hol now have the ideal car. other people who want a soft poseur car that also goes fast buy a Boxster or a Coxster.

...and what's this about saying it's only £175 cheaper than a Boxster, as if Lotus is an inferior brand to Porsche! most people (in my office for example) think Porsche = poseur and Lotus = cool