Got me Lotus back... Woohoo!! Not running right... Boohoo!!
Got me Lotus back... Woohoo!! Not running right... Boohoo!!
Author
Discussion

Coupe Girl

Original Poster:

431 posts

250 months

Saturday 16th September 2006
quotequote all
Well it's back!!!!

After being rear-ended twice. Once in the spring... lost the car for over a month... new rear clam, etc. Had it back for 2 weeks when it happened again! (must drive faster so no-one can get behind me)

Car gone for 6 weeks this time, new rear clam (again) new exhausts, under-tray thingy, etc

Finally arrived at the dealers to pick it up, well pleased with it, looks like a brand new car from behind, (well, I s'pose it is now) started it up and yikes WTF is that noise???!!!!

The alternator has gone grumpy it definitely wasn't making that noise before the accident. The car was 3 years old in January and has done 18,000 miles, surely it can't have gone that soon? The dealer said it may be because it stood for so long while it was being repaired.

Where do I stand, can anyone advise? The battery went flat over the 6 weeks and they did have trouble getting the car going again, it wouldn't run properly and was hunting badly at idle and eventually they decided it needed a new ECU.

The car was perfect before the accident, DEFINITELY no noise or trouble from the alternator. I've told my insurance company and they're writing to the dealer but the dealer won't say that it's definitely as a result of the accident.

Meanwhile my car sits in my garage at home. I don't want to drive it. I drove it home from the dealer and it was so noisy that I couldn't hear my new sports exhaust over the grinding of dry bearings irked

Not Happy!! banghead

GTRene

22,805 posts

255 months

Saturday 16th September 2006
quotequote all
Sorry to hear that! what a drama! sjeesh not a good restart how much can you handle you almost have the bad luck or get even with gooby...you too should talk maybe...
I would go mad when I had al this sh*t...
My car does not sound good either the last month orso...rattling valve system, first I thought maybe it needed adjustments and yep 4 valve's where to wide so not open far anough...I replaced it myself with new shims everything perfect again but in the end the rattle is still there so it needs to go to the Doctor to see how the valvesprings? are maybe some weak valvesprings or valve's not closing to good that explains the to wide space for shims...aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa thats gona cost me! tonight I don't go out also because of that I don't like the sound and thuesday a specialist is gona take a look! not the bmw dealer though...cause they never have done that on this type S54 engine...

Best of luck Mandy with all stuf hope they come with a good sullution! I say the lotus dealer should have looked at those things and not leave the car for dead that long! they only took care of the work and not taking care anough of your babyyes you thought it was in good hands...so they make it work and give it to you the way it was before the accident...
GTRene

jondude

2,441 posts

248 months

Saturday 16th September 2006
quotequote all
That is annoying for you, to say the least!

Are you using a reputable garage? Reason I am slightly cynical is that if you jump start a motorbike incorrectly, you can fry the equivalent of the ECU and, if you really muck it up, overheat the alternator. Often the two are linked on bikes.

Did they fast charge the battery? It may be fried, too. Or the opposite - still not charged enough so that is the problem. They must make sure the battery is 100% charged and able to hold the charge before changing ECUs or alternators.

Now it may be this just does not happen on cars.( I am very new to cars ) A lot of modern bikes are built with safeguards now ( just removing the battery terminals in the wrong order could do it, and re-connecting wrongly is still a huge risk ).

The reason they gave, that ' the car has been still for a while ' is ridiculous. I mean, it could happen that your ECU packs up as soon as it is handed to a garage, but I dunno....I'm sure some car mechanics can confirm if the Elise is susceptible to this polarity problem or not, but if this was a motorbike and you wrote this I would certainly ask them to be honest about how they wired up the jump leads, disconnected the battery etc. They simply must confirm you have a healthy and fully charged battery too, or this could go on for many dollars more.

From their reason to you for its demise, it is very unlikely they will admit what are, after all, schoolboy errors.


PS: If they did remove the battery, it does take a while for the ECU to re-learn its settings, too, when you re-connect and fire up. Lotus warn you to expect strange/bad running until ' the ECU has learnt its settings'. Haven't removed my battery yet, so I don't know how dramatic or long that period is!

Coupe Girl

Original Poster:

431 posts

250 months

Saturday 16th September 2006
quotequote all
Hey, Rene!!!

How are you my friend? I'm very disappointed about my Lotus, I've been without it for just about the whole summer and now it sits in my garage at home for what's left of the summer It was such a perfect car when I bought it last November... the engine was just soooooo sweet! And immaculate... not a mark on it... why can't people look where they're going? Oh well, it's just a car... there are worst things that happen.

Sorry about your Z3M Coupe, I know you said it was starting to rattle a bit. I had the same problem last year with my Z3M Coupe (S50), the engine started to rattle a little, which is hardly surprising seeing as it's done just over 100k miles now. It got quite noisy, so when I had it serviced next (big service) I got them to do the valve clearances as well. It was like a new car when I picked it up, quiet (apart from my noisy exhaust!) no engine rattle and very smooth to drive. (It cost £900 for the service and the valves though! cough!!) I get mine serviced by a TVR dealer, they do a much better job that BMW)

You'd think it'd only done about 30k miles to drive it, the gearbox is still nice and tight and it's awsomely quick.

What oil do you use? I use Silkolene Pro R 15W-50... nice and thick!!

A strange thing has happened to my Coupe though... about 3 years ago, I had left the car parked and someone drove into it (I think I must attract them!) The local BMW dealer repaired it and the whole front of the car was resprayed. Well, I've noticed that inside the front valance, just below the number plate the black paint has turned slightly yellow and also inside the front wheel arches. I took it back to the dealer a couple of months ago and they said that yes it was their fault and that they would respray it again for me and would contact me to book it in. But now the manager has phoned and asked for me to take the car in again for him to look at it personally. I hope they're not going to start being funny about it.

Let me know how you get on with your valves

Take care

Mandy

x

Coupe Girl

Original Poster:

431 posts

250 months

Saturday 16th September 2006
quotequote all
jondude said:
That is annoying for you, to say the least!...


Hi jondude

Thanks for the reply. I insisted that the car go to a reputable Lotus dealer who have done all the servicing on it previously and I wanted to keep that up. And I'm not knocking them at all, I've always been more that happy with their work and service, we bought a 340R from them recently as well.

I agree with everything you say, I used to have motorbikes (last one was a GSXR 750 Slingshot) and you are spot on about them.

They told me that when they restarted the car, they did run it for quite a while to see if the ECU would re-learn it's settings but it didn't seem to, they say that they then tried an ECU from another car and it was fine, so they ordered a new one for mine. They then told me about the alternator problem and I thought it was odd as I know there was definitely no bad noises before the accident, but when I got in and started it up I couldn't believe the noise!!

I wondered if they had tried to jump the car or something and fried the ECU and I did ask them if it could be the ECU when they first said that they couldn't get it running properly but at that point they said they didn't think it was. I think the ECU and the alternator problem are all connected and I'm also worried that my battery's knackered as it's been flat twice this year now for a good few weeks at a time. I told the insurance company that I'm worried that the battery's knackered and they're looking into it.

I wonder if I can insist that they replace the battery and the alternator at no charge to myself as they were fine before the accident, I personally don't think I should be financially responsible for these.



Edited by Coupe Girl on Saturday 16th September 22:18

GTRene

22,805 posts

255 months

Saturday 16th September 2006
quotequote all
Hey Mandy wavey

I'm fine...wish my car was too...but it will be soon again I know...I think I could not miss it that long as your Lotus though...took both times very very long me thinks! I feel with you...

Lats time I used the Castrol RS 10w 60 Racing, but I just serviced it last week with Catrol TWS 10w 60 a must for the S54 engine...also needed 2 new reartires(where Dunlops but now using a bit cheaper Hankooks) and changed last week from petrol I drove 1.5 year Shell V-power but thats Ron97 here sadly and now I use BP Ultimate Ron 98 the ECU has to learn again..now it drives ok but I'm going back to the faster Shell V-power again next visit
Also a new fuelfilter is what I ordened but they ordened the wrong one aaaaaaaaaaaaa from your car... because I also had 2x 1999 car and that they took! but I have this ride more then 2 years, problem is to less S54 M coupe's so they forget that to often...I sometimes hate their working style and those young boys tooling on my car! at 100 euro per hour thats why most things I do myself...and thats why thuesday its going to a specialist to look with a camera inside...so he can see whats wrong(at least I hope )

I think you realy attracts man? in carshehe but this way its not that nice...
And also a paintjob problem? man...I mean girl what a lot of things you have to go through...
When I know more about the car's haertbeating valve's I let you know...thanks for understanding
Coupe man René hehe
GTReneangel

J2LOT

70 posts

242 months

Sunday 17th September 2006
quotequote all
Hi, I had a similar problem many years ago when my Elan SE was rear ended & was with Lotus dealer for over 3 months waiting for parts !!! Got it back and it died the next day from flat battery. Garage took it back - alternator seized and new battery required. I paid for work so I could get car back quickly & tried to claim from insurance - they would have none of it saying it was not related to the accident. Despite arguing that it ran perfectly before their client ran into me they point blank refused to entertain any further claim. Hope you have better luck. K

tanman

505 posts

266 months

Sunday 17th September 2006
quotequote all
Hi, sorry to hear about your nightmare over the last few months. My old Elise had alternator failure when it was 3 years old, i think it had done about 15k then. Sounds similar story - as mine was stood still for about 4 weeks, tried to turn it over and the battery light came on - diagnosed as alternator failure!
I don't think it would be your garages fault personally, yes they do need to be driven otherwise you do seem to get problems with the Elise but i've also heard of other peoples alternators packing up within 2-3 years.
Its horrible i know, but bite the bullet and get it fixed asap there is nothing worse than looking at it when really you want to be thrashing it.
Hope you get it sorted soon
Tanman

purpleheadedcerb

1,143 posts

253 months

Sunday 17th September 2006
quotequote all
Any garage worth their salt would have your battery on a service charge for the duration of its stay. Its quite obvious that it will not hold its charge if left alone for days on end, only to be depleted even further each time they start the car just to move it around the workshop/yard.

Hope you get it sorted soon. There still seems to be a few days of half decent weather left judging by today.

Scott

TIPPER

2,955 posts

250 months

Sunday 17th September 2006
quotequote all
Sorry to hear about your continuing problems but I think you may just have to bite the bullett on this one.
As you may know my car was involved in quite a serious shunt in July that required a complete rebuild of front and rear offside suspension as well as new rear subframe etc,etc. I got the car back a couple of weeks ago and all was well until Monday last week when the gearbox suddenly started to become quite noisy. I limped home by which time engaging third gear was getting a bit difficult and then noticed lots of oil leaking from the gearbox area. The car was trailered away to a very trusted local garage on Friday (proprietor is a personal friend of brother-in-law and preps race and rally cars) and I'm waiting to hear. Guy that owns the garage reckons its probably linked to the shunt and should have been picked up by repairing garage but not worth asking insurance co as they'll reject it (he used to own a body shop too!). Our experience with our company fleet suggests this too.
Hope you get it all sorted soonest. Remember its still warm all through October now (people sunbathing on Cornish beaches last week of the month last year!).